McCrum's Bakery

- 378 Market St, Elmwood Park, NJ 07407

For residents across Northern New Jersey, finding a reliable bakery that excels in both artistry and flavor can often feel like searching for a hidden treasure. McCrum's Bakery, located in the heart of Elmwood Park, is precisely that—a beloved local gem that has established itself as the premier destination for custom cakes, delectable pastries, and exceptional service. More than just a place to grab a morning treat, McCrum’s Bakery is a true specialty shop, standing out as a trusted wedding and custom celebration cake provider that serves the entire Bergen County area and beyond.

The reputation of McCrum's Bakery rests squarely on its commitment to quality, freshness, and the creative talent of its team, notably cake designer Randy. Customers consistently praise the bakery’s ability to take a vision—from a simple reference photo to a complex wedding theme—and transform it into an edible masterpiece. The focus is on stunning visual appeal combined with an exquisite taste experience, ensuring that every creation is not just a dessert, but a highlight of any special occasion.

McCrum's is a true full-service bakery, offering a wide array of baked goods beyond their celebrated custom cakes. Patrons can indulge in freshly made pies, a variety of pastries, pound cakes, and other daily delicacies. This range of offerings, coupled with a genuine, professional, and friendly approach to customer service, has solidified its position as a highly recommended spot in the New Jersey community. Whether you are celebrating a major life event or simply looking for a quick, delicious treat to enjoy with a cup of coffee, McCrum’s Bakery promises a level of quality and care that keeps local New Jersey customers coming back for years.

McCrum's Bakery is conveniently situated at 378 Market Street, Elmwood Park, NJ 07407, placing it right in the flow of local commerce in Bergen County. This central location makes it highly accessible for customers from surrounding towns who are planning a quick visit to pick up an order or browse the daily selection of freshly baked goods. For a busy New Jersey resident, a quick visit is made easy, offering a seamless experience for those on the go.

Accessibility is a key priority for the bakery, which features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring that all community members can easily access their products and services. While the provided data does not specify parking availability, the Market Street location suggests a typical, easy-to-navigate neighborhood spot, ideal for quick in-and-out visits.

For any inquiries, large custom orders, or simply to place a quick order for pickup, McCrum's Bakery maintains clear communication channels.

Contact Information

Address: 378 Market St, Elmwood Park, NJ 07407, USA

Phone: (201) 797-2470

McCrum's Bakery offers a comprehensive range of services, positioning itself as a versatile establishment capable of fulfilling everyday cravings as well as elaborate event needs. The service model focuses on convenience, quality, and personalized attention.

Services Offered

• Custom Cake Design: Specializing in bespoke cakes for all major celebrations, including birthdays, baby showers, gender reveals, and all other special occasions.
• Wedding Cake Production: A highly-regarded wedding bakery offering consultations to design custom cakes that often become the showstopper of a New Jersey wedding reception.
• Wholesale Bakery Services: Provides a full line of wholesale products, serving local businesses, hotels, banquet halls, restaurants, and caterers.
• Takeout: Offers convenient takeout for all daily pastries, pies, and pre-ordered custom items.
• Delivery: Provides a delivery service option, ensuring large orders, such as wedding and custom cakes, can arrive safely at their destination.
• Daily Pastries and Sweets: A consistent supply of fresh and tasty pastries, pies, muffins, and various delicacies baked fresh daily.
• Beverages: Offers coffee, making it a perfect spot for a quick, delicious start to the day or an afternoon treat.

What truly distinguishes McCrum's Bakery from other local bakeries in New Jersey are the consistent, high-quality features that resonate deeply with their loyal customer base.

Features / Highlights

• Masterful Custom Cake Artistry: The bakery is renowned for its talented cake designer, Randy, who consistently delivers flawless, custom designs that precisely match or exceed customer expectations, demonstrating an unmatched level of care and craftsmanship.
• Exceptional Flavor Profile: Customers rave about the cakes being "insanely delicious," "super moist," and featuring perfectly balanced fillings, with the raspberry mousse flavor being a particularly famous standout.
• Fair and Competitive Pricing: Despite the high quality and custom nature of their work, the bakery is noted for having "the most fair pricing by far" compared to other options in the competitive New Jersey market.
• Wedding Cake Expertise: Possessing proven experience as a successful wedding cake provider for North Jersey couples, maintaining high quality and professional standards over many years.
• Commitment to Freshness: All cakes, pies, and pastries are freshly made daily, ensuring a high-quality and delicious taste in every bite.
• Excellent Customer Service: The team, including designer Randy, is described as "incredibly kind," "super friendly," and "professional," ensuring a positive experience from the initial inquiry through to the final product.
• Dessert Variety: Beyond custom cakes, they offer a wide range of baked goods, including various pies, pound cakes, and other daily treats, catering to all dessert needs.
• Accessibility: Features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, making the business welcoming to all members of the Elmwood Park community.
• Payment Convenience: Accepts major credit cards, debit cards, and is set up for quick visits, perfect for customers in a hurry.

What is worth choosing from McCrum's Bakery?

For any New Jersey resident seeking the absolute best from McCrum's Bakery, there are a few must-try categories that repeatedly earn rave reviews. The undisputed highlight is their range of Custom Celebration Cakes. Whether you need a simple, elegant design or a complex, thematic creation, this is the bakery's specialty. Specifically, when selecting a flavor, the Raspberry Mousse Filling comes highly recommended by long-time patrons. It is consistently praised for being the "perfect balance of sweet and light," paired with a notably moist cake base. Choosing a custom cake from McCrum's guarantees a stunning centerpiece for your event that guests will be talking about long after the party is over.

Beyond the custom cakes, the bakery’s daily offerings are equally essential for a true taste of McCrum's quality. Locals strongly advise trying the Pies, which are made with fresh, homemade fillings and have been a staple of the menu. While specific daily pastry flavors may rotate, the general category of their Fresh Pastries is a must for a morning coffee or an afternoon treat, consistently described as fresh and tasty. The availability of other traditional favorites like various Pound Cakes and Muffins further solidifies McCrum's as the ideal place to satisfy any sweet tooth in Elmwood Park. In short, whether it's a monumental wedding cake or a simple, perfectly baked pie, the combination of Randy's artistic vision and the team's commitment to freshness makes any choice from McCrum's Bakery a worthwhile indulgence.

McCrum's Bakery

378 Market St, Elmwood Park, NJ 07407, USA