Milano Pizza Shop

- 2255 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10029

Milano Pizza Shop is more than just a place to grab a slice; it's a quintessential New York City pizza joint with a heart for authentic Italian flavor. Located in the bustling East Harlem neighborhood, this establishment is a hidden gem that has been serving up classic comfort food to a loyal local following. With a menu that spans from traditional pizza pies and slices to hearty pasta dishes and hot hero sandwiches, Milano Pizza Shop provides a taste of Italy right here in the city. The atmosphere is casual and trendy, making it a comfortable spot for a quick bite or a relaxed meal.

The restaurant's core identity as a pizza shop is evident in its comprehensive menu, which includes everything from a "Regular" slice to a "Special" pizza with multiple toppings. However, its offerings extend far beyond just pizza. The menu features a variety of classic Italian dishes, such as "Lasagna," "Spaghetti W/ Meatballs," and "Baked Ziti W/ Ricotta," showcasing a commitment to a broader culinary tradition. As one customer noted, the pizza and the "giant sandwich" they ordered were "hot, fresh, and with the perfect balance of crisp crust, flavorful sauce, and gooey cheese," adding that you can "tell they use good ingredients." This positive feedback highlights the quality and care that go into their food, despite a contrasting review about a specific delivery experience.

Milano Pizza Shop is a popular spot for various diners, including college students and tourists, which points to its widespread appeal. Its reputation for "delicious menu choices" and fast, polite service has made it a reliable option for lunch and dinner. The fact that it offers "good for kids" options makes it a family-friendly choice, while its counter service and quick-bite options cater to those on the go. The blend of a welcoming environment and a diverse menu solidifies Milano Pizza Shop's status as a genuine East Harlem treasure.

Milano Pizza Shop is located at 2255 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10029, USA. This address places it in a prime spot in East Harlem, a neighborhood known for its lively culture and vibrant community. The location on 2nd Avenue makes it highly accessible for both pedestrians and those using public transportation. The area is well-served by bus routes and is within a reasonable distance of subway stations, ensuring that customers can easily get to the shop from different parts of the city.

For those with mobility needs, the restaurant features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, which is an important amenity that shows the business is committed to serving all members of the community. The atmosphere, described as casual and trendy, adds to its appeal as a welcoming and comfortable place to dine. While a customer review mentioned a delivery issue, the restaurant also offers takeout and dine-in services, providing alternative options for enjoying their food. The accessibility of the location, combined with these flexible service options, makes Milano Pizza Shop a practical and easy choice for a satisfying meal in East Harlem.

Services Offered

• Delivery: Provides the convenience of having food brought directly to your location, a key service in New York City.
• Takeout: Offers a quick and easy way to pick up food to enjoy at home or on the go.
• Dine-in: A casual setting for customers to sit and enjoy their meal in the shop.
• Catering: The menu includes "Catering Trays" for various pasta and specialty dishes, providing an excellent option for parties, events, or large group gatherings.
• Payment options: Accepts cash-only. This is a crucial detail for customers to know beforehand to ensure a smooth transaction.

Features / Highlights

• Classic Pizza and Slices: The menu features a wide variety of pizza pies and slices, including classic options like "Pepperoni" and "Sicilian Slice."
• Extensive Italian Menu: Beyond pizza, the restaurant offers a comprehensive selection of pasta dishes, hot hero sandwiches, and Italian specialties like "Veal Parmigiana" and "Eggplant Parmigiana."
• Family-Friendly: Noted as being "good for kids," the restaurant provides a comfortable and welcoming environment for families.
• Catering Services: The availability of catering trays makes it a go-to spot for large orders for parties or office events.
• Casual and Trendy Atmosphere: The ambiance is relaxed and stylish, attracting a diverse crowd, including college students and tourists.
• Quick Service: A customer review highlights the fast and polite service, indicating an efficient and customer-friendly experience.

Contact Information

Address: 2255 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10029, USA

Phone: (212) 996-5141

What is worth choosing

Choosing Milano Pizza Shop is a decision to experience authentic, high-quality Italian-American comfort food in a genuine New York setting. What makes this restaurant truly worth choosing is its dual focus on classic pizza and a comprehensive Italian menu. While the pizza itself is a major draw, the menu extends far beyond, with dishes that evoke the feeling of a home-cooked Italian meal. The "Baked Ziti" and "Lasagna" catering trays, in particular, are a testament to their ability to handle large-scale orders with the same care as a single slice. The availability of both hot and cold sandwiches, as well as a variety of salads, ensures that there is a satisfying option for every palate and appetite.

The fact that the restaurant is a "hidden gem" that "absolutely delivers on flavor and service" is a powerful reason to visit. The positive review from a customer who ordered multiple items and was impressed by the quality of the ingredients and the friendly service speaks volumes about the business's capabilities. While a single negative review about a delivery experience exists, it is important to note the counterpoint of the in-person experience, which highlights a welcoming atmosphere and a professional staff. The cash-only policy, while a bit old-school, adds to the authentic New York vibe of a classic neighborhood spot. For anyone in New York looking for a reliable, delicious, and versatile Italian-American restaurant, Milano Pizza Shop offers a fantastic combination of quality, variety, and a casual, friendly experience.

Milano Pizza Shop

2255 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10029, USA