My Grandmother’s Kitchen

- 169 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735

For New York residents searching for a truly authentic, heartwarming American dining experience on Long Island, look no further than My Grandmother’s Kitchen. Located in the bustling community of Farmingdale, this restaurant lives up to its name by offering a cozy, nostalgic atmosphere paired with scratch-made comfort food classics. It's the perfect spot to slow down and enjoy a meal that feels like it came straight from a family recipe book.

The entire concept centers around providing not just food, but a welcoming feeling—a retreat that captures the essence of home cooking and familiar warmth. The décor, often noted by patrons, is filled with thoughtful, homey touches like old photos and charming quotes, creating a comforting ambiance that is both casual and inviting. This sense of nostalgia, combined with a commitment to fresh, flavorful food, makes it a standout choice for breakfast, lunch, and dinner in the Long Island region.

My Grandmother’s Kitchen provides a versatile menu focused on traditional American fare, catering to every craving, from a quick coffee and egg sandwich to a full, hearty dinner. Their extensive offerings ensure that whether you're a local seeking a reliable morning stop or a visitor looking for a memorable, satisfying meal, you'll find something delicious and comforting here. The restaurant is popular among families, groups, and even solo diners, underscoring its broad appeal as a community favorite.

Location and Accessibility

My Grandmother’s Kitchen is conveniently situated at 169 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735, placing it right in the heart of Farmingdale’s vibrant downtown area. Its Main Street location makes it easily accessible for those living in or traveling through the Long Island area of New York. The restaurant's accessibility is a key feature, making it a welcoming choice for all patrons.

In terms of physical accessibility, the establishment has proactively ensured that all guests can enjoy their visit comfortably. They offer a wheelchair accessible entrance, a wheelchair accessible parking lot, a wheelchair accessible restroom, and wheelchair accessible seating. Parking is also stress-free, as both a free parking lot and free street parking are available nearby.

Services Offered

The restaurant is dedicated to accommodating various dining preferences and schedules, offering a full range of services throughout the day. This flexibility, combined with fast service and table service, ensures a seamless and pleasant experience for all guests.

• Dine-in: Traditional table service in their casual, cozy, and quiet atmosphere.
• Takeout: Meals are available for convenient pick-up.
• Delivery: For those who prefer to enjoy the comfort food at home or at the office.
• Outdoor Seating: A delightful option for enjoying a meal on pleasant days.
• Catering: Available for events, bringing the restaurant’s home-style cooking to your special occasion.
• Dining Options: Serves Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert.

Features / Highlights

My Grandmother’s Kitchen has earned a reputation for several outstanding highlights that set it apart as a premier American restaurant in the New York region. These features focus on quality, speed, and menu variety, all delivered within a unique, warm setting.

• Fast Service: Known for efficiency, making it an excellent choice for a quick, quality meal.
• Great Coffee: Praised by customers for its quality, perfect for pairing with breakfast or for an afternoon pick-me-up.
• Diverse and Comforting Menu: A wide selection that includes classic comfort food alongside healthy and vegetarian options. Popular menu items include the homemade Corned Beef Hash (a definite favorite), specialty omelettes like the 'Grandmother Omelette' (egg white, fresh spinach, oven gold turkey, sauteed onion, and muenster cheese), and indulgent French Toast varieties, such as the Cannoli French Toast topped with strawberries. Lunch options like the 'Grandparent Sandwich' (grilled chicken, roasted peppers, eggplant, fresh mozzarella, and balsamic glaze on a grilled panini bread) and a variety of Cheeseburgers are also available. For a full American experience, you might even try a Rib Eye Steak or Penne Alla Vodka for dinner.
• Beverage Offerings: Beyond the praised coffee, the menu includes soft drinks, iced coffee, homemade iced tea, juice, milkshakes, and a full selection of alcohol, beer, and cocktails.
• Family-Friendly Environment: The restaurant welcomes children with a dedicated Kids Menu (featuring items like silver dollar pancakes and chicken nuggets) and provides high chairs.
• Atmosphere: Described as casual, cozy, and quiet, providing a relaxing dining experience that feels like a trip down memory lane.

Contact Information

For making reservations (where applicable), checking hours, or inquiring about catering, you can reach My Grandmother's Kitchen directly at the following:

Address: 169 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735

Phone: (516) 586-4289 or +1 516-586-4289

What Is Worth Choosing

What truly makes My Grandmother’s Kitchen a must-visit American restaurant in the New York area is its unwavering focus on a holistic, home-like experience. It’s more than just a place to eat; it's a destination where the quality of the food meets the warmth of the setting. The restaurant’s extensive menu means you can rely on it for any meal—from a quick morning stop to a full, relaxed dinner. The fact that the food is 'Pretty delicious' and 'worth the stop,' as one customer noted, speaks volumes, especially when considering signature items like their fantastic pancakes and the highly-rated, homemade corned beef hash.

For those living in or visiting New York, particularly Long Island, My Grandmother’s Kitchen offers exceptional value. You receive generous portions of quality, flavorful food—the kind ‘made with care’—in an environment that truly makes you feel 'like you’ve stepped into your grandmother’s home.' The combination of a wide, appealing menu, excellent accessibility features, fast and friendly service, and a genuinely cozy atmosphere makes it an unparalleled choice for American comfort food. Whether you are craving the full 'Grandmother Egg Combo' (two eggs any style, one sausage and two strips of bacon with a choice of two pancakes or French toast) for brunch, a hearty cheeseburger for lunch, or a satisfying dinner, this Farmingdale staple delivers a consistent, high-quality, and deeply comforting dining experience.

My Grandmother’s Kitchen

169 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA