My Little Pizzeria

- 114 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Introduction / Overview

In the heart of the historic and highly desirable Brooklyn Heights neighborhood, New Yorkers can find a staple of local dining: My Little Pizzeria. Situated on the iconic Court Street, this classic establishment is a quintessential slice of the city’s culinary tradition. It's the kind of place that many locals have grown up with, a true testament to the enduring appeal of quality, no-fuss New York-style pizza. Known for its quick service, incredibly accessible prices, and a menu built around comforting, familiar favorites, My Little Pizzeria has long served as a go-to spot for everyone from busy professionals and college students to local families and tourists seeking an authentic taste of Brooklyn.

The atmosphere at My Little Pizzeria is casual and welcoming, focusing entirely on the food and speed of service. It’s perfect for a quick lunch, a satisfying dinner, or grabbing that essential late-night bite. The restaurant offers a traditional pizzeria experience, specializing in both Round Pies (classic Neapolitan style) and Square Pies (often likened to Sicilian or Grandma-style), available as full pizzas or, crucially, by the slice. This method of service is, after all, the backbone of true New York pizza culture. Their commitment to offering staples like the classic cheese slice alongside unique options like the Supreme Slice and various specialty rolls ensures there’s a perfect option for any craving.

Beyond the savory, the restaurant extends its menu to include fresh salads, specialty baked Italian items like calzones and rolls, and a complete cafe selection featuring espresso and beloved Italian desserts like Gelato and Spumoni. My Little Pizzeria is a reliable pillar in the Brooklyn Heights food scene, consistently providing a necessary taste of comfort food in a fast-paced city.

Location and Accessibility

My Little Pizzeria is ideally located at 114 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA, placing it firmly in the heart of the vibrant Downtown Brooklyn / Brooklyn Heights area. This location is one of the most transit-rich in the entire borough, making it exceptionally easy for New Yorkers from across the city to visit. The restaurant is perfectly positioned to capture foot traffic from the surrounding residential streets, businesses, and municipal buildings.

Public transportation access is excellent, with multiple subway stations providing service just minutes away:

• The Borough Hall / Court Street station complex is the closest hub, located approximately 0.17 miles away. This station is served by a massive network of lines: the 2, 3, 4, 5, N, R, and W trains (with the 3 and W trains having limited hours). This level of connectivity means a quick pizza fix is never far, whether you are coming from Manhattan or deeper into Brooklyn.
• The Bergen Street station, which hosts the F and G trains, is also a short walk away, about 0.25 miles from the pizzeria, providing excellent coverage for riders coming from areas like Park Slope and Astoria.
• The Jay Street–MetroTech station complex, offering access to the A, C, F, and R trains, is also within a very accessible range, about 0.29 miles away.

For those arriving by vehicle, the location offers the increasingly rare amenity of free street parking, although finding a space in this busy area of Brooklyn can sometimes be a challenge. The restaurant is also wheelchair accessible with an accessible entrance and seating, ensuring it welcomes all members of the community. Its central spot on Court Street, near major thoroughfares and transit lines, makes it a convenient stop for lunch, dinner, and late-night food runs.

Services Offered

My Little Pizzeria provides a comprehensive range of dining and service options designed to accommodate the varied needs and schedules of New York City residents.

• Dine-in: Enjoy a casual dining experience with ample seating, including high chairs for families, and accessible seating for all patrons.
• Outdoor Seating: When the weather permits, customers can enjoy their meals outside, with dogs allowed in the outdoor dining area.
• Takeout: Fast and efficient service for grabbing slices or whole pies to go, ideal for office workers and locals.
• Delivery & No-Contact Delivery: Full delivery services are offered, with the option for no-contact delivery, making it easy to enjoy their menu from the comfort of home or work.
• Curbside Pickup: A convenient option for quick collection without needing to enter the establishment.
• Catering: Provides catering services, perfect for groups, office parties, and local events in the Brooklyn area.
• Payment Flexibility: Accepts modern payment methods including Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments for a seamless transaction experience.

Features / Highlights

My Little Pizzeria has cemented its place in Brooklyn Heights by offering several standout features that resonate strongly with the local community, emphasizing value and genuine New York pizza authenticity.

• Authentic New York Pizza Experience: The pizzeria is praised for serving classic NY-style pizza, described by long-time customers as "what a NY pizza should be," featuring a thin, pliable crust and flavorful sauce.
• Fresh Mozzarella Specialties: A major highlight is their Supreme Pizza line, which features fresh, homemade mozzarella, fresh tomato, fresh basil, and romano cheese, offering a premium and authentic Italian taste.
• By The Slice Variety: Offers a wide selection of slices for a quick bite, including Round Slice ($2.25), Square Slice ($2.25), the popular Supreme Slice ($2.50), and even Vegetable Slice ($4.00).
• Extensive Topping Options: Customers can fully customize their pies with a choice of meat toppings (sausage, pepperoni, meatballs, anchovies) and a wide array of fresh vegetables (peppers, onions, spinach, eggplant, broccoli, etc.).
• Comfort Food Beyond Pizza: In addition to pizza, the shop offers delicious comfort food like Calzones, Sausage Rolls, and various savory vegetable rolls (Eggplant, Spinach, Broccoli), along with complimentary Garlic Knots.
• Dessert and Coffee Bar: Features a dedicated cafe menu with items like Cappuccino / Latte, Espresso, and beloved Italian desserts such as Gelato ($2.00), Spumoni ($3.00), and Italian Ices ($2.00), making it a complete lunch or dinner stop.
• Open for Late-Night Food: Known for offering food late into the evening, catering to the dinner and post-dinner crowds, including groups and college students in the area.

Contact Information

If you are planning a visit, looking to place an order, or need to inquire about catering, here is the necessary contact information for My Little Pizzeria.

Address:

114 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

Phone:

(718) 643-6120

+1 718-643-6120 (Mobile)

Hours of Operation (General, may vary by day; please call to confirm late-night service):

Monday - Friday: Generally open from 10:00 am to 9:15 pm (with some sources indicating later closing times, up to 11:30 pm or 12:30 am on select nights).

Saturday - Sunday: Generally open from 11:00 am to 9:15 pm (with some sources indicating later closing times).

What is Worth Choosing

For New Yorkers who demand a classic, reliable, and authentic pizza experience, My Little Pizzeria is an essential choice, particularly given its prime Brooklyn Heights location and accessible pricing. What makes this establishment stand out is its mastery of the basics, paired with value and variety.

The Supreme Experience: The single most compelling reason to choose My Little Pizzeria is the quality of its Fresh Mozzarella pies. The Supreme Round Pie ($17.00) and Supreme Square Pie (pricing varies) are made daily with fresh, homemade mozzarella, fresh tomato, and basil. This dedication to fresh, high-quality cheese elevates the pizza from a standard slice shop offering to something truly special and reminiscent of authentic Italian-American cooking. If you are ordering a full pie, this should be your first choice.

The Slice Selection: For a quick, affordable, and filling lunch—a cornerstone of the NYC experience—the By The Slice menu is unbeatable. At just $2.25 for a Round or Square Slice, or $2.50 for the Supreme Slice, the value is exceptional. This accessibility makes it a magnet for the college students, busy lunch crowds, and solo diners that frequent the area. Adding a topping is only an extra $0.50 per slice, allowing for customization without breaking the bank.

Beyond the Pizza: Don't overlook the specialties and desserts. The **Calzone ($4.50)** is a hearty, filling option, and the various rolls, particularly the Chicken Rolls ($4.50), make for excellent comfort food alternatives. To finish the meal, the affordable dessert options like Gelato ($2.00) and Italian Ices ($2.00) are a delightful nod to Italian confectionery and perfect for a warm day, proving My Little Pizzeria is a one-stop-shop for a complete, satisfying meal in Brooklyn Heights.

My Little Pizzeria

114 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA