Nagle’s Bagels Introduce
Introduction / Overview
For New Yorkers—especially those in Brooklyn—the quest for the perfect bagel is a serious endeavor, and
Nagle’s Bagels
on Tompkins Avenue has firmly established itself as a must-visit destination in the Bed-Stuy neighborhood. Operating as both a dedicated **Bagel shop** and a cozy **Cafe**, Nagle’s Bagels is much more than just a quick morning stop; it’s a local **Small business** dedicated to delivering exceptional quality and innovative flavor combinations. The shop offers a wide array of authentic New York-style bagels, from the classic **Everything** and **Plain** to more specific choices like **Egg Everything**, **Pumpernickel Everything**, and **Blueberry**. Customers consistently rave about the product, describing the bagels as "amazing," "perfectly warm and lightly toasted," and so good they inspire repeat visits from across state lines.What sets Nagle’s Bagels apart is their creative and extensive menu of **Delicious Sandwiches**. These aren't just standard deli creations; they are gourmet, signature items with names that invoke New York pride, such as the famous **Classic Nagle** (a premium Lox sandwich) and the popular **New Yorker** and **Nagles Sunrise** breakfast sandwiches, which feature fresh griddled eggs and your choice of exciting house-made condiments like Sweet Chili Jam or Chipotle Mayo. Even their unique and sometimes controversial creations, like **The Blue Velvet**—which daringly combines blueberry cream cheese with bacon and sweet chili jam—showcase a commitment to flavor innovation. Beyond the bagels, the shop features a full range of high-quality **Coffee** and a selection of teas (like **EARL GREY** and **GREEN TEA**), various pastries including a delicious **Chocolate Babka**, and ready-to-go options like the **Lox Box** for groups. The inclusive spirit of the establishment is another highlight, as Nagle’s Bagels is proud to be both **LGBTQ+ friendly** and a **Transgender safespace**, fostering a welcoming environment for the entire community.
Location and Accessibility
Nagle’s Bagels is conveniently located at
378 Tompkins Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216, USA
. This prime location places it in the heart of Bed-Stuy's central Tompkins Avenue corridor, making it an easy and familiar stop for local residents. The area is well-connected by public transport, providing accessibility for customers coming from other parts of Brooklyn and beyond. For those driving, the availability of **Free street parking** is a notable convenience in a city where parking is often a challenge.The shop is designed for the high-pace flow of a New York morning, catering to all needs, whether you are planning a **Quick visit** or have time to sit down. Customers can choose from multiple service options, including **Dine-in** for a more relaxed experience, as well as easy **Takeout**, fast **In-store pickup**, and **Delivery** options to bring the fresh bagels right to your home or office. Nagle’s Bagels ensures seamless transactions by accepting both **Credit cards** and **Debit cards**, streamlining the process to keep lines moving efficiently, a must for the morning rush.
Services Offered
- Multiple Service Formats: Offers **Dine-in**, **Takeout**, **Delivery**, **In-store pickup**, and **In-store shopping** for maximum convenience.
- Full **Breakfast** Menu: Serves a complete morning fare, specializing in fresh bagels and a wide selection of signature, gourmet bagel sandwiches.
- Wholesale/Bulk Bagels: Provides options for buying in quantity, including **Half Dozen Bagels**, **Dozen Bagels** and discounted **Day Olds** (6, Assorted).
- Catering/Group Packs: Features the ready-made **The Lox Box** which includes bagels, cream cheese, and sliced salmon, perfect for small gatherings.
- Extensive Cream Cheese Offerings: A variety of portion sizes and flavors, including **Plain Cream Cheese**, **Scallion**, **Blueberry**, and even **Tofu** options.
- Beverage Program: A full **Cafe** menu including **Coffee** (hot and iced), multiple tea varieties (like **ENGLISH BREAKFAST** and **HONEYBUSH & ROOIBOS**), and a selection of specialty bottled drinks like **Boylan Soda** and **Loop Mission - Cold Pressed Juices**.
Features / Highlights
- Signature Sandwiches: The menu boasts inventive and beloved creations such as the **Classic Nagle** (Lox), **Nagles Sunrise** (Egg/Sausage), and the bold **The Blue Velvet**.
- Authentic New York Bagels: Offers a wide selection of high-quality, perfectly prepared bagels, noted for being "perfectly warm and lightly toasted."
- Gourmet Ingredients: Features high-end fillings like **ACME Whitefish Salad** and **8oz. Sliced Salmon**, ensuring a premium experience.
- Inclusive Community Space: Proudly identified as **LGBTQ+ friendly** and a **Transgender safespace**, promoting a welcoming atmosphere for everyone.
- Retail Provisions: Sells house-branded items like the **Nagles Mug** and **Partners Whole Bean** coffee, allowing customers to take the experience home.
- Innovative Condiments: Provides unique spreads and jams (like Sweet Chili Jam and Chipotle Mayo on their sandwiches) that elevate the breakfast experience.
Contact Information
Address:
378 Tompkins Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216, USAPhone:
Publicly listed contact phone number is(347) 305-3007
.What is Worth Choosing
Nagle’s Bagels is absolutely worth choosing for any New Yorker prioritizing an authentic, high-quality bagel experience blended with creative, modern flavor profiles. You should choose Nagle's not just for the excellent texture and freshness of their classic **Everything** or **Egg Everything** bagels, but for the full, inventive menu of **Delicious Sandwiches**. The **Classic Nagle** is a must for Lox enthusiasts, and the **Nagles Sunrise** is celebrated as one of the best breakfast sandwiches in the area, often enhanced by the shop's signature Sweet Chili Jam. Furthermore, choosing this **Small business** means supporting an establishment that actively cultivates an **LGBTQ+ friendly** and inclusive neighborhood environment. Whether you are stocking up with a **Dozen Bagels**, grabbing a **Quick visit** coffee, or settling in for a satisfying **Breakfast** using their **Dine-in** service, Nagle’s Bagels on Tompkins Ave offers a truly exceptional and representative piece of Brooklyn’s vibrant bagel culture. Their vast selection of bagels, gourmet fillings, and commitment to fresh, quality ingredients solidify its reputation as a premier **Bagel shop** in NYC.
Nagle’s Bagels Food & drink
Nagle's Bagels - Bagel Choices
- Everything $2.50
- Egg Everything $2.50
- Multigrain $2.50
- Sesame $2.50
- Poppyseed $2.50
- Onion $2.50
- Egg $2.50
- Pumpernickel $2.35
- Salt $2.50
- Pumpernickel Everything $2.50
- Cinnamon Raisin $2.50
- Blueberry $2.50
- Whole Wheat Everything $0.00
Nagle's Bagels - Choose One Of Our Delicious Sandwiches
- Nagles Sunrise $9.00
- New Yorker $9.00
- Nagles Special $10.00
- The Blue Velvet $11.00
- Veggie Nagle $10.00
- Egg & Cheese Plus $8.00
- Classic Nagle $15.50
- East Side $16.50
- The B. A. T. $11.75
- Brooklyner $14.00
- Gotham $14.00
- Whitefish Sandwich $13.50
- Jerusalem $7.00
- Spicy Nagle $8.00
- The Governor $11.00
- The Nellie $9.00
Nagle's Bagels - Choice Of Pastries
- Chocolate Babka $3.50
- Chocolate Chip Cookie $4.00
Nagle's Bagels - Choose Hot Coffee Size
- 12oz. HOT $3.25
- 16oz. HOT $4.25
Nagle's Bagels - Choose A Size
- 20oz. Iced $5.50
Nagle's Bagels - Choice Of Drink
- Boylan Soda $3.50
- Natalies $4.75
- Bottled Water $1.00
- Red Jacket $4.50
- Spindrift $2.75
- Topo Chico $3.50
- Ciao Bella Coconut Water $3.95
- Loop Mission - Cold Pressed Juices $6.65
Nagle's Bagels - Choose Flavor
- EARL GREY $3.50
- ENGLISH BREAKFAST $3.50
- GREEN TEA $3.50
- HONEYBUSH & ROOIBOS $3.50
Nagle's Bagels - Choose Quantity
- Day Olds (6, Assorted) $6.00
- Dozen Bagels $27.00
- Half Dozen Bagels $14.00
- The Lox Box $45.00
Nagle's Bagels - 4Oz. Cream Cheese
- 4oz Blueberry $3.75
- 4oz Garlic & Herb $3.25
- 4oz Jalapeno $3.25
- 4oz Plain Cream Cheese $3.00
- 4oz Strawberry $3.25
- 4oz. Tofu $3.25
- 4oz Veggie $3.25
Nagle's Bagels - 8Oz. Cream Cheese
- 8oz Blueberry $7.00
- 8oz Garlic & Herb $6.50
- 8oz Plain Cream Cheese $6.00
- 8oz Scallion $6.50
- 8oz Strawberry $6.50
- 8oz Tofu $7.00
- 8oz Veggie $6.50
Nagle's Bagels - Fish
- 4oz. Whitefish Salad $7.50
- 8oz. Sliced Salmon $16.00
- 8oz. Tuna Salad $9.50
- 8oz. Whitefish Salad $9.00
Nagle's Bagels - Choose Flavor
- Barbecue Chips $2.50
- Salt & Vinegar Chips $2.50
- Salted Chips $2.50
- Sour Cream & Onion $2.50
Nagle's Bagels - Retail
- Partners Whole Bean $16.99
- Nagles Mug $8.00
Nagle’s Bagels Details
From the business
- Small business
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- In-store shopping
- Onsite services
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Breakfast
Crowd
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Transgender safespace
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- Credit cards
Parking
- Free street parking
Nagle’s Bagels Photos










Nagle’s Bagels Location
Nagle’s Bagels
378 Tompkins Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216, USA
Nagle’s Bagels Reviews
cream cheesebagel sandwicheseverything bagelmorningveggieingredientsbaconthe new yorkerchilli jammusic
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1The bagel I got was amazing! Perfectly warm and lightly toasted and the cheese was just slightly melted. I will be dreaming about this bagel from back home in NC and will make sure to return every time I'm back in the area.*Update* ~ 5 months later, and it's just as good as I remembered. Sooooo good, and I am definitely coming back on this trip
July 31 · Camille AllumsDelicious bagels and interesting flavor combinations but the cream cheese is almost satire-level-skimpy. Compare this actual blue velvet to the press photo. Where’s that big dollop of blueberry CC!? Ended up going to another place and ordering a side of CC for this thing. $11 for two slices of bacon on a bagel, smh.
May 19 · Daniel WeissMy son took me here last year while I was visiting him from Chicago and I had the most amazing bagel. The Gotham City on an everything bagel I came back to visit this past weekend and they did not fail me. The bagels were so good I went Sun and Mon to get more. The customer service is amazing and the atmosphere is welcoming. Always my first stop when I arrive in NY.
August 12 · Dy Jservice is a little slow but the quality of the product and service is why, it’s a bustling and quaint location amongst a bunch of cool little shoppes and the selection/ prices are all great. the bagels are super soft and not too chewy, tuna salad was well seasoned and overall loved this place. they also gave my friend a free gift just cause they inquired if certain things were for sale- love this place!!!
October 08 · o oThe bagels were delicious, but their thickness overpowered the cream cheese, which melted too quickly. A bit more cream cheese would have created a better balance of flavors and texture.
March 25 · sherri anjum
More restaurants near me

104 Marcus Garvey Blvd, Brooklyn, NY 11206, USA

894 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11206, USA

256 Throop Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11206, USA

574 Marcy Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11206, USA

903 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11206, USA

905 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11206, USA

545 Marcy Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11206, USA

114 Sandford St, Brooklyn, NY 11205, USA

110 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11207, USA

731 Park Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11206, USA

366 Stockton St, Brooklyn, NY 11206, USA

1135 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11206, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Dining Insights Posts





