Nautilus Diner

- 1240 W Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers in Westchester County, the classic diner experience is a cherished tradition, and the Nautilus Diner in Mamaroneck stands out as a beloved local landmark. This iconic establishment is more than just a place to grab a meal; it's a versatile dining destination that captures the heart of American and Greek-style comfort food. Celebrating years of service, the Nautilus Diner has earned a reputation for providing an extensive menu, exceptionally large portion sizes, and great service in a welcoming, cozy atmosphere.

The Nautilus Diner successfully caters to every craving at virtually any time of day, making it popular for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and those essential late-night bites. Whether you're in the mood for fluffy pancakes, a hearty burger, an authentic Greek specialty like Souvlaki, or even a sophisticated Broiled Seafood platter, the sheer volume and variety of the menu ensure there's truly something for everyone. This makes it an ideal spot for groups with diverse tastes, families with young children, and solo diners alike.

Beyond the traditional hash browns and endless coffee refills, the Nautilus Diner elevates the standard diner experience. Customers frequently praise the quality of the food—noting that it’s fresh and well-prepared—and the impressive on-site bakery that produces delicious cakes, pies, and pastries, all baked on the premises. As an added feature not typically found in classic diners, the Nautilus Diner boasts a stocked bar, offering everything from beer and wine to specialty cocktails like Espresso Martinis and Bloody Marys made with fresh-squeezed juice. This combination of classic diner convenience with an elevated menu and beverage selection solidifies its status as a must-visit spot in the New York region.

Patrons have consistently recognized the management and staff for striving to serve the most hospitable environment possible, making customer happiness a clear priority. The combination of a fantastic menu, a comfortable atmosphere, and attentive service ensures that the Nautilus Diner remains a favorite for countless locals and is certainly worth the trip to Mamaroneck.

Location and Accessibility

The Nautilus Diner is conveniently situated in Mamaroneck, New York, making it easily accessible for residents across Westchester County. Its location on a major roadway ensures it’s easy to find and reach, regardless of where you're coming from.

Address: 1240 W Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck, NY 10543, USA

A significant convenience for guests is the ease of parking. The diner offers free parking via a large, on-site parking lot and often has free street parking available as well, a notable feature in a bustling area. Customers appreciate the abundance of parking, though it can get busy during peak times.

Accessibility is a core feature of the Nautilus Diner, ensuring a comfortable experience for all guests:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot
• Wheelchair accessible restroom
• Wheelchair accessible seating

This commitment to accommodating all patrons contributes to the welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere that makes the Nautilus Diner a true community staple.

Services Offered

The Nautilus Diner offers a wide array of dining and service options to suit any schedule or preference, reinforcing its status as a highly versatile establishment in the New York area.

• Dine-in: Enjoy your meal in the casual, cozy atmosphere with comfortable seating and table service.
• Curbside Pickup: A convenient option for quick, contactless retrieval of your order.
• Delivery: Order your favorite diner classics from the comfort of your home or office.
• Takeout: Fast and reliable service for picking up meals on the go.
• All-Day Service: Serving breakfast, brunch, lunch, and dinner, ensuring you can satisfy your craving any time.
• Late-Night Food: A crucial offering, especially on weekends, for those looking for a delicious meal after hours.
• Catering: Providing their extensive menu options for group events and special occasions.
• Full Bar Service: Serving alcohol, beer, wine, hard liquor, cocktails, and specialty drinks.
• On-Premises Bakery: All cakes, pies, and pastries are baked in-house, available for dine-in or to take home (including custom cakes for special occasions).

Features / Highlights

What makes the Nautilus Diner a standout choice in Westchester County goes beyond a typical diner. The establishment is celebrated for several key features and highlights:

• Extensive and Diverse Menu: The menu is gigantic, covering everything from classic American comfort food, Greek specialties like Souvlaki, Broiled Seafood dishes (like Jumbo Shrimp Scampi and Norwegian Salmon), Italian dishes, and a vast breakfast selection served all day, including delicious gluten-free pancakes.
• Exceptional Portions and Value: Customers consistently highlight the large portion sizes—often big enough to stretch into multiple meals—and the reasonable prices, offering great value for the Mamaroneck area.
• Outstanding Beverage Program: Unlike many diners, Nautilus features a stocked bar and is praised for its great cocktails, including those made with fresh-squeezed orange juice, as well as a great selection of beer and wine.
• Commitment to Quality Desserts: All baking is done on premises, ensuring fresh, high-quality desserts. The array of homemade items, including various cheesecakes, pies, and pastries, is a major draw for patrons and often highlighted in reviews.
• All-Day and Late-Night Hours: The diner offers late-night food service, with generous business hours: Sunday through Thursday from 7 AM to 11 PM, and Friday and Saturday from 7 AM to 12 AM, making it a reliable spot for midnight cravings or late-night conversations with friends.
• Welcoming Ambiance and Service: The atmosphere is described as casual and cozy, ideal for a diverse crowd including groups, families, and college students. The staff are frequently described as incredibly friendly, professional, and attentive, ensuring fast service and a welcoming experience.
• High-Quality Core Offerings: Highlights also include their great coffee and tea selection, fresh, well-prepared food, and the fact that the diner serves local specialty items, appealing to those seeking an authentic local dining experience.

Contact Information

The Nautilus Diner is ready to welcome you for any meal of the day. You can reach them at the following:

Address: 1240 W Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck, NY 10543, USA

Phone: (914) 833-1320

Mobile Phone: +1 914-833-1320

Business Hours:

Sunday – Thursday: 7 AM – 11 PM

Friday & Saturday: 7 AM – 12 AM

Payments: Accepts Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

What is worth choosing

Choosing what to order at the Nautilus Diner can be overwhelming due to the sheer size of the menu, but a few categories and dishes consistently earn high praise from local customers. When dining at this iconic Westchester establishment, here’s what’s truly worth choosing:

Start with the Soups. The diner features classic options like Manhattan Clam Chowder and Chicken Consomme, alongside a rotating Soup Du Jour and weekday specialties like Beef Barley or Seafood Bisque. A hearty crock of French Onion Soup Au Graian is also a popular starter.

For a more substantial meal, the Broiled Seafood section is a standout, featuring fresh, well-prepared options that exceed typical diner expectations. Consider the Broiled Fresh Norwegian Salmon ($17.99) or the decadent Broiled Fresh Jumbo Shrimp Scampi ($20.99). If you’re feeling particularly indulgent or are sharing a meal, a Nautilus Special like the Broiled Stuffed Combo ($21.79), which includes stuffed filet, shrimp, scallops, and clam, offers a taste of everything. The Surf N Turf ($29.99), pairing broiled lobster with filet mignon, is another impressive choice.

While the menu is vast, customers often recommend the classic diner staples as well, praising how well they are executed. The breakfast dishes—from perfectly cooked egg platters to gluten-free pancakes and light, crispy Belgian Waffles—are on point any time of day. For a classic comfort plate, the Cuban Panini and the Reuben with Pastrami are noted for their heartiness and flavor.

Do not leave without visiting the in-house bakery. The desserts are a must-try, available in large portions that are ideal for sharing or taking home. Highly recommended are the various cheesecakes, including the Creamy Cheese Cake ($3.99) and the indulgent Swiss Chocolate Dipped Cheese Cake ($4.59), which are baked fresh daily on the premises. The epic cole slaw is also frequently highlighted by long-time customers as alone being worth the trip.

Ultimately, the Nautilus Diner provides a memorable dining experience characterized by generous portions, a diverse menu, and the kind of friendly, fast service that defines the best of the New York diner tradition.

Nautilus Diner

1240 W Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck, NY 10543, USA