NY Pizza Suprema: A Classic New York Slice Experience Near Penn Station

NY Pizza Suprema Introduce

For decades, New York City has been synonymous with pizza, and few places embody that iconic reputation quite like NY Pizza Suprema. Located in the bustling heart of Midtown, this isn't just another pizza joint; it’s a time-honored institution serving a true classic New York slice. It’s a place that understands the city's rhythm, providing fast, high-quality food that fits into a busy schedule. The atmosphere is casual and no-frills, which is exactly what a great slice shop should be. The focus is singularly on the pizza itself—from the crisp-yet-chewy crust to the flavorful sauce and perfectly melted cheese. Whether you're a local rushing to catch a train or a tourist looking for an authentic taste of the city, NY Pizza Suprema delivers a quintessential New York experience. It is a place that has built its reputation on consistency and a dedication to the craft, earning a loyal following from college students to tourists and commuters. This overview provides a taste of what makes NY Pizza Suprema a celebrated name in the competitive NYC pizza landscape.

NY Pizza Suprema is strategically located at 413 8th Ave, New York, NY 10001, USA. This address is a significant part of its appeal, as it places the restaurant directly across the street from Madison Square Garden and just a short walk from Penn Station. This makes it an incredibly convenient stop for anyone traveling in or out of the city, attending an event, or simply passing through one of Manhattan's busiest transportation hubs. The location is easily accessible via numerous subway lines, including the 1, 2, 3, A, C, and E trains that all stop at Penn Station. For those driving, paid street parking is available, though finding a spot can be a challenge in this busy area. The proximity to major transit points and landmarks means that NY Pizza Suprema serves as a perfect pre-show meal or a quick bite for commuters. The neighborhood is constantly bustling, and the restaurant's location reflects its role as a fast-paced, high-volume eatery designed to serve a steady stream of customers efficiently. Its central location makes it an easy and obvious choice for anyone in the Midtown area looking for a reliable, delicious meal.

NY Pizza Suprema offers a variety of services to accommodate its diverse clientele. The focus is on providing quick and convenient access to their famed pizza. The services include:

Dine-in and Takeout: The restaurant offers a traditional dine-in experience with casual seating, as well as quick and easy takeout for those on the go. The seating is wheelchair accessible, making it a comfortable spot for everyone.
Delivery and No-Contact Delivery: For customers who prefer to eat at home, NY Pizza Suprema provides delivery services, including a no-contact option, ensuring convenience and safety.
Late-Night Food: As a true New York staple, the restaurant serves late-night food, catering to the city that never sleeps. This is a major plus for those seeking a post-event meal or a late-night snack.
Onsite Services: The establishment serves local specialties, allowing customers to experience authentic New York-style pizza directly from the source. The presence of a restroom and a selection of beverages including beer and wine enhances the dine-in experience.

What makes NY Pizza Suprema a must-visit destination are the specific features and highlights that define its quality and character. These elements are what have earned it a spot on numerous "best pizza" lists.

Authentic New York Style Pizza: The restaurant serves a classic New York-style slice, characterized by a thin, foldable crust that is crispy at the edges and pliable in the middle. The balanced ratio of sauce to cheese is a hallmark of their quality, and the simple cheese or pepperoni slices are often cited as the best way to experience their craft.
Fast Service: With a location catering to commuters and tourists, speed is a priority. The service is consistently fast, allowing customers to get their order quickly without a long wait, making it perfect for a quick bite.
Extensive Pizza Menu: While the plain slice is a classic, the menu extends far beyond that. They offer a variety of signature pies, from the famous NYC Round Cheese to specialty pizzas like Burrata and Hot Honey. There's also a full menu of vegan pizzas, including Vegan Margherita and Vegan Sicilian, catering to a wider range of dietary needs.
Serves Local Specialty: The restaurant is known for serving a local specialty, providing a genuine taste of New York's famous pizza culture. It’s an authentic experience that can’t be easily replicated.

For any inquiries, to place an order, or for general information, you can contact NY Pizza Suprema using the following details:

Address: 413 8th Ave, New York, NY 10001, USA

Phone: (212) 594-8939

The best way to get in touch is by phone for a quick and direct response. The location is very easy to find given its prominent spot near major landmarks. It’s a great idea to call ahead for whole pies, though a quick visit for a slice is always an option given their efficient service. The restaurant is an integral part of the neighborhood, and the staff are knowledgeable and friendly, ready to help you with your order.

Choosing NY Pizza Suprema is about more than just grabbing a bite; it's about experiencing a piece of New York's culinary history. What makes it truly worth choosing is its ability to deliver an authentic, high-quality product in a fast-paced environment. The location is unparalleled for anyone near Penn Station or Madison Square Garden, making it the most convenient option for a classic slice. The pizza itself is consistently lauded for its quality—the perfect crust, a flavorful sauce, and the right balance of cheese. The variety of the menu, from simple cheese slices that highlight their core strengths to more inventive specialty and vegan options, ensures that there is something for everyone. It is a place that understands its identity and sticks to what it does best. For a quick, affordable, and delicious meal that is a genuine reflection of New York pizza culture, NY Pizza Suprema is a top-tier choice that never disappoints. It’s a destination for both a simple, satisfying lunch and a late-night comfort food fix.

NY Pizza Suprema Menu

Our Famous Signature Pizza Pies
NYC Round Cheese Pizza $28.47
8 slices. Award-winning! Famed for receiving the only perfect score by the slice Harvester who sampled over 375 slices in Manhattan. Our famous signature pizza with a light delicious thin crust slightly charred topped with our famous homemade tomato sauce and imported pecorino Romano cheese and finest grande mozzarella.
Margarita Pizza $37.66
A thin hand-tossed crust is topped with a fresh homemade pomodoro sauce. The fresh mozzarella is placed in between and sprinkled on top, is a generous layer of imported pecorino Romano cheese. The pie is finished off with a light drizzling of imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy. Post bake, it’s finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
White Pizza With Garlic $35.82
No red sauce. A thin white slice topped with generous dollops of the finest whipped creamiest ricotta and finished with a sprinkling of imported pecorino Romano, fresh garlic and a drizzle of imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy. Post bake, it’s finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
New York Style Sicilian Pizza $36.74
12 slices. A deep dish crust light and airy with our homemade savory tomato sauce, sprinkled with imported pecorino Romano, fresh basil and imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy covered with our finest grande mozzarella. Post bake, it’s finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Upside Down Pizza $36.74
12 slices. A sauce lover's favorite. The finest grande mozzarella covers light and airy deep-dish square crust. The mozzarella is covered with our homemade cooked onion-based sauce. Then finished with imported pecorino Romano cheese and imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy with a tossing of fresh basil. Post bake, it’s finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Marinara Pizza $26.64
12 slices. Delicious garlic-based marinara sauce, sprinkled with imported pecorino Romano cheese and finished with fresh basil.
Grandma Pizza $35.82
9 slices. On a thin crust, pan baked is a fresh plum tomato sauce, imported pecorino Romano, fresh mozzarella. Post baked, finished off with fresh basil and imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy. Post bake, it's finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.

Our Specialty Pizza Pies
Burrata Specialty Pizza $43.17
Our signature pizza with our slightly charred light delicious thin crust, topped with our homemade tomato sauce, imported pecorino Romano, grande mozzarella, with dollops of burrata cheese, a touch of fresh basil and imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy. Post bake, it’s finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Hot Honey Specialty Pizza $43.17
A round pie with light dollops of fresh ricotta, fresh mushrooms, our finest grande mozzarella. Post-baked, finished with hot pepper-infused honey. Post bake, it's finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Fig Specialty Pizza $43.17
A round pie topped off with the finest grande mozzarella, creamy goat cheese, fig spread, premium bacon, imported pecorino Romano, fresh basil and Imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy. Post bake, it's finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Chicken BBQ Specialty Pizza $36.74
A thin hand-tossed crust is topped with a premium grande mozzarella lightly breaded white meat chicken cutlet, imported pecorino Romano cheese and homemade BBQ sauce, with a touch of fresh minced garlic. Post bake, it's finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Chicken Parmigiana Specialty Pizza $34.90
Our famous round pie topped with lightly breaded white meat chicken cutlet, imported pecorino Romano cheese, and the finest grande mozzarella cheese finished off with fresh basil. Post bake, it's finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Specialty Pizza $43.17
Fresh white meat chicken cutlet, crispy bacon, fresh jalapenos, sauteed onions, and our finest grande mozzarella, with a sprinkling of imported pecorino Romano on a thin crust, finished off with a creamy ranch dressing. Post bake, it's finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Buffalo Chicken Specialty Pizza $36.74
Our famous round pie topped off with a delicious tender white meat Buffalo chicken. Covered with Buffalo chicken sauce. Post bake, it's finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano. No substitutions.
Suprema Specialty Pizza $41.33
Our namesake round pie with our homemade tomato sauce, imported pecorino Romano, grande mozzarella, topped with all the favorites: fine sweet Italian sausage, imported Italian pepperoni sauteed sliced onions, fresh roasted red peppers and fresh mushrooms. Finished with fresh basil. Post bake, it's finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano. No substitutions.
Meat Lover's Specialty Pizza $41.33
Our round pie is topped off with Boar Head's ham, sweet Italian sausage, imported pepperoni and crushed Italian meatballs. Post bake, it's finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano. No substitutions.
Hawaiian Specialty Pizza $41.33
Our round pie topped with our homemade tomato sauce, finest grande mozzarella, fresh pineapples and Boar Head's ham. Post bake, it's finished with Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Pepperoni Fra Diavolo Specialty Pizza $50.52
We start off with a light and airy Sicilian-style crust. Topped with our finest grande mozzarella. Our fresh homemade fra diavolo sauce and finished with our imported spicy pepperoni from Italy.

Vegetable and Vegan Pizza
Veggie Lover's Pizza $41.33
Our round pie is topped with broccoli, spinach, sliced onions, red peppers, fresh mushrooms, post baked, finished off with Imported pecorino Romano, imported Parmesan cheese and imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy.
Veggie Medley - A Vegan Friendly Pizza $41.33
On a light airy Sicilian crust is our homemade onion cooked-based sauce with diced tomatoes, black olives, sliced onions, and fresh sauteed garlic mushrooms. Finished off with imported extra virgin olive oil and fresh basil. No cheese.
The New York Vegan Regular Slice Pizza $38.58
A savory delicious pizza sauce. Topped with a nondairy and soy-free shredded vegan mozzarella cheese. Finished off with imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy and fresh basil. Contains nuts. Vegan.
The Vegan Alfredo Pizza $41.33
A vegan pizza made with our homemade Macadamia Alfredo truffle sauce, vegan mozzarella cheese, spinach and sauteed sliced onions. Contains nuts. Vegan.
Vegan Margarita Pizza $38.58
A thin crust pie with a non dairy and soy-free vegan mozzarella cheese made with natural coconut, topped with generous dollops of fresh plum tomato sauce. Finished off with imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy, oregano and fresh basil. Contains nuts. Vegan.
Vegan Grandma Pizza $41.33
A thin-crust pie with a non dairy and soy-free vegan mozzarella cheese made with natural coconut. Topped with fresh mushrooms, sauteed sliced onions, roasted red peppers. Post baked, finished off with imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy, oregano and fresh basil. Contains nuts. Vegan.
Vegan White - With Garlic And Cashew Ricotta Pizza $41.33
A non dairy and soy-free vegan mozzarella cheese made from natural coconut. Topped with dollops of our homemade creamy cashew ricotta cheese, a sprinkling of fresh garlic. Then we finished off with our imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy. Vegan.
Vegan Upside Down Pizza $41.33
A light and airy deep dish crust topped with vegan mozzarella made from coconut covered with our homemade cooked onion based tomato sauce. Finished with imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy and oregano. Vegan.
Vegan New York Style Sicilian Pizza $41.33
A light and airy deep dish crust with our homemade savory tomato sauce topped with vegan mozzarella made from coconut and finished off with imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy. Vegan.
Spinach Dip Pizza $41.33
A round thin crust topped with grande mozzarella, pecorino Romano and a secret homemade white sauce fresh spinach dip recipe. Post baked, finished off with a imported Parmesan cheese from Italy.
Fresh Baked Eggplant Pizza $41.33
Our thin-crust with a delicious pre-cooked onion base tomato sauce. Topped with thinly sliced home-baked eggplant and a premium grande mozzarella. Finished with a little sprinkling of fresh garlic, imported pecorino Romano, imported Parmigiano-Reggiano and imported extra virgin olive oil from Italy.

Beverages
2 Liter Bottled Soda $5.00

NY Pizza Suprema Details

Service options
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Serves local specialty

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Comfort food
Late-night food
Quick bite
Vegetarian options
Wine

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Table service

Amenities
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd
College students
Groups
Tourists

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Parking
Paid street parking
Parking

Pets
Dogs allowed outside

NY Pizza Suprema Photos

NY Pizza Suprema Location

NY Pizza Suprema

New York New York County New York 8th Avenue

413 8th Ave, New York, NY 10001, USA

NY Pizza Suprema Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 8137 user reviews.

nyc pizzamadison square gardentrainanthony bourdainbest pizzapenn stationfig pizzafra diavolospinach dipslice in the city

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

This is a great spot for a classic New York slice. The location is perfect, right by Hudson Yards and Penn Station, which makes it super convenient. Service is fast, so you can grab a slice and go without waiting long.The pizza itself is very good. The crust has a nice balance of crisp and chew, and the sauce is flavorful without being overwhelming. It really delivers on what you want from a New York style slice. I especially liked the burrata and meat lover options, and the mushroom pizza was excellent too.The ambiance is fine – nothing fancy, but that’s not really the point here. It’s all about the pizza, and they do it well.
September 08 · Massimo
Start with cheese or pepperoni. Simple slice beats the loaded pies here. Cash is easier. Steps from MSG.Visited a week ago 9/2025. I came in because so many pizza lists and creators recommend this spot. First slice was the “Suprema.” Good bake, good texture, solid flavor, but it didn’t blow me away. Round two was a plain pepperoni and that’s where it clicked. The simpler the slice, the more the sauce and cheese shine. The crust folds clean with a light crisp and lets the sauce do the talking. If it’s your first time, start with a plain cheese or pepperoni, then branch out.Slices were about $7 when I went. They add a small fee for cards, so cash is easier. Seating is basic, which fits the grab-a-slice pace. For a quick stop near Madison Square Garden or Penn Station, this is an easy yes. I’d come back for the simple slice and a cold drink.
September 18 · GregxPerez
Yummy in my tummy! Epic hot honey, then sausage pizza right out of the oven, and a slice of pepperoni. Was in the city for a couple of weeks and this place was right down the street. While it’s a bit pricey for an NYC - walk-in, eat and get out, pizza joint, it’s worth it. Stopped in numerous times and will hit it again the next timeI’m in town.
August 19 · Carlos
A must in New York! definitely if you looking for thin, crust various options for pizza! We were looking for pizza and found this gem has been on the business for over 60 years! Like cmon a MUST! Friendly staff , they were super attentive and gave us “must try options” and they were just BOMB! I’ll be back every time I’m in New York
August 31 · Maria Berrocal
Vegan for 15 years, and NYC born and raised. Highly recommend their vegan pizzas. Since going vegan, one thing I’ve missed is a classic NYC style slice. This place gets it right. I was super satisfied, and filled with NYC nostalgia from their vegan offerings. I recommend the NY Vegan regular slice and the Margherita slice to start. You’ll likely want to try their other vegan options as well. For a classic NYC style vegan slice, this is the place. They’ve made sure to keep the crust and sauce true to NYC tradition. The dairy free cheese is excellent. You can’t get any better than that as a vegan or lactose free person craving a real NYC slice. The staff is very friendly, and the atmosphere is authentic New York. 10/10
August 04 · Robert Vilches