Papa Mikes Brick Oven Pizza

- 7416 20th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11204

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers craving a slice of authentic, old-school Italian flavor mixed with modern culinary flair, Papa Mike's Brick Oven Pizza stands as a true neighborhood cornerstone in Brooklyn. Located in the heart of the vibrant Bensonhurst community, this establishment offers much more than your average pizzeria. It’s a full-service Italian restaurant specializing in everything from traditional pasta favorites and hearty dinner entrées to, most notably, its signature brick oven gourmet pizzas. Papa Mike's has become a beloved local spot for its commitment to extensive menu options, catering to diverse tastes and dietary needs, including an impressive range of vegan and vegetarian selections.

The history of this location is deeply rooted in the Bensonhurst dining scene, with the original 'Mike's Pizza' having a decades-long legacy as a go-to spot for locals. While the business has transitioned to its current iteration as Papa Mike's Brick Oven Pizza, it maintains the spirit of a classic, community-focused establishment where food tastes like home. Customers appreciate the casual, cozy, and trendy atmosphere that makes it ideal for a quick bite, a family dinner, or a comfortable solo meal. With offerings that span comfort food, small plates, and full-course meals, Papa Mike's ensures that whether you’re a college student, a local resident, or a tourist exploring Brooklyn, you’ll find a satisfying and memorable meal.

Papa Mike's excels in providing a truly comprehensive Italian-American dining experience. The centerpiece of their operation is, naturally, the brick oven, which imparts a distinct, high-heat char and flavor to their pizza dough, setting their pies apart. From the deep-dish options to the thin-crust gourmet selections, the focus remains on quality ingredients and time-tested recipes. Beyond pizza, the menu is a celebration of classic Italian cuisine, offering a wide array of appetizers, salads, heroes, full pasta plates, and even seafood. This extensive selection firmly establishes Papa Mike's not just as a pizzeria, but as a full-fledged Italian restaurant ready to serve the entire Brooklyn area.

Location and Accessibility

Papa Mike's Brick Oven Pizza is strategically situated at 7416 20th Ave in Brooklyn, New York, within the well-known and easily accessible Bensonhurst neighborhood. This part of Brooklyn is a hub of cultural life and local businesses, making the restaurant a convenient destination for residents and visitors alike.

Accessibility is a key feature of the establishment. The location is set up to welcome a wide variety of patrons. While the primary service model focuses on counter service and takeout, it also offers seating for those who wish to dine in. Patrons should note that the dining experience is geared towards a casual environment with seating available, though dedicated table service may not be the standard. Importantly, the establishment features a wheelchair accessible restroom and wheelchair accessible seating, demonstrating a commitment to serving all members of the community. For those driving, street parking is typically available in the surrounding Bensonhurst area. For those relying on public transit, 20th Avenue offers straightforward access via local buses and is generally a well-connected part of the borough.

The restaurant's hours cater to both lunch and dinner crowds, and it even offers late-night food options, which is a major convenience in New York City. Operating Tuesday through Sunday from 11:00 AM to 10:30 PM for pick-up, with slightly varying delivery hours, Papa Mike's is a reliable option for a midday meal, an evening gathering, or a late-night craving. The separate section next to the main restaurant that offers coffee and beverages also adds to the neighborhood appeal, providing a quick stop for a hot drink like an espresso or cappuccino.

Services Offered

Papa Mike's Brick Oven Pizza provides a comprehensive set of services to ensure maximum customer convenience, firmly positioning it as a modern, full-service local eatery:

• Delivery and No-Contact Delivery: Fast and efficient service is available for the Brooklyn area, with delivery operating most evenings until 10:00 PM (9:45 PM cut-off).
• Takeout and Pick-Up: Customers can place orders online or by phone and pick them up at the counter.
• Dine-In Seating: Casual indoor and some outdoor seating is available, though dining is primarily counter-service.
• Catering: The establishment offers catering services, making it an excellent choice for local parties and events.
• Lunch and Dinner Service: The menu is robust enough to cover both main meal periods, with quick bites perfect for lunch and full entrées for dinner.
• Payment Flexibility: Accepts credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for easy transactions.
• Children-Friendly: The restaurant is good for kids, with amenities like high chairs and a selection of items that appeal to younger palates, though a formal Kids' Menu is not explicitly listed in the food data.

Features / Highlights

The appeal of Papa Mike's lies in its diverse offerings, quality preparation, and accommodation for various dining preferences. Here are the key highlights that make this Brooklyn spot stand out:

• Authentic Brick Oven Pizza: Specializing in pies cooked in a brick oven, Papa Mike’s offers a signature taste and texture across its pizza offerings, including the classic Round Neapolitan Cheese Pizza, the hearty 16" Square Sicilian Thick Crust Cheese Pizza, and popular gourmet options like the Margherita, Buffalo Chicken, and The New Yorker pizzas.
• Extensive Vegan and Vegetarian Options: A notable feature is the dedicated Vegan menu section, offering options like a Vegan Cheese Pizza and Dr. Prager Chicken Breast. Beyond that, the menu is filled with vegetarian-friendly choices such as the Stuffed Vegetable Delight Deep Dish Pizza, Mozzarella, Tomatoes & Basil, and various meatless pasta dishes, allowing guests with plant-based diets to enjoy authentic Italian flavor.
• Gourmet Pizza Variety: The selection goes far beyond the basic cheese pie, featuring specialty round and square crusts. Highlights include the Capri Basil Pizza (served cold), the rich Pizza Ala Vodka Pizza with homemade vodka sauce, and unique options like the Philly Cheesesteak Pizza and BBQ Chicken Pizza.
• Full Italian-American Menu: Beyond pizza, the menu is robust, featuring classic Italian dishes such as Manicotti, Stuffed Shells, Baked Ziti, Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana, and Veal Cutlet Parmigiana, as well as American comfort food staples like Burgers, Sliders, and Buffalo Wings.
• All-Day Offerings and Late-Night Food: Serving from late morning until late evening, the menu covers all cravings. The 'All Day' menu includes soups like Italian Wedding Soup and Minestrone, fresh salads, and a variety of heroes and wraps, with comfort food and quick bites available for late-night service.
• Freshly Prepared Appetizers and Sides: The appetizer menu is extensive, including classics like Mozzarella Sticks, Garlic Knots with Sauce, and Fried Calamari Basket, ensuring a great start to any meal.
• Dessert and Coffee Bar: Offering a sweet end to the meal with selections like Ice Cream and Cheesecake, plus a variety of hot drinks including Espresso and Cappuccino available from a separate coffee section.

Contact Information

Ready to experience the best of Bensonhurst Italian? Contact Papa Mike's Brick Oven Pizza or stop by their location:

• Address: 7416 20th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11204, USA
• Phone: (718) 513-3696

What is Worth Choosing

When faced with Papa Mike's expansive menu, some dishes truly stand out as a must-try for a first-time visitor or a returning local. For the purist, you cannot go wrong with anything from the brick oven. The Round Crust Brick Oven Gourmet Pizza selection offers the most variety and their signature cooking style. The Margherita Pizza (fresh mozzarella, fresh tomato, olive oil & basil leaves) is an excellent barometer of the restaurant’s quality, offering a light, flavorful pie with perfect brick-oven char. The Capri Basil Pizza, served cold, offers a refreshing twist that is highly recommended during the warmer months, featuring fresh tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil, garlic, and olive oil.

For those seeking a truly hearty meal, the Dinner Entrées and Pasta Favorites sections deliver classic Italian comfort. The Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana is a reliable choice, and the highly praised Chicken Marsala is worth trying, especially when paired with pasta. The menu's dedication to quality is also evident in its side dishes; a customer review specifically highlighted the quality of their brick oven pizza and the Chicken Marsala with pasta as a well-prepared and tasty experience. Furthermore, the commitment to accommodating special diets makes the Vegan Pizza or a custom pie with sautéed broccoli rabe and vegan cheese a top recommendation for those with plant-based preferences—one customer described their vegan creation as a "flavor bomb."

In short, whether you opt for a classic Round Neapolitan Cheese Pizza, a savory Meatball Hero, or a full dinner entrée like Eggplant Parmigiana, Papa Mike's Brick Oven Pizza promises a taste of authentic Brooklyn Italian cuisine, conveniently located in Bensonhurst.

Papa Mikes Brick Oven Pizza

7416 20th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11204, USA