Pete's Pizzeria & Restaurant

- 7522 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209

For any New Yorker seeking an authentic taste of classic Brooklyn Italian-American cuisine, particularly a quintessential New York slice, Pete's Pizzeria & Restaurant stands as an unmissable fixture in Bay Ridge. This establishment is more than just a place to grab a quick meal; it is recognized as a true "old school NYC pizza place," embodying the traditional spirit of neighborhood eateries that have long defined the city’s culinary scene. Pete's masterfully combines three essential local business types under one roof: a top-tier Pizza restaurant, a full-service Italian restaurant, and a comprehensive Sandwich shop.

Located on the highly accessible 3rd Avenue, Pete's Pizzeria is the definitive destination for Comfort food and a Quick bite. While the atmosphere is noted as Casual and Cozy, the focus here is strictly on high-quality, generously portioned food and outstanding value. From perfectly crafted, thin-crust pizza to hearty pasta dishes and an extensive selection of heroes, the menu caters to every imaginable craving. For residents of the 11209 zip code, Pete's Pizzeria & Restaurant is a reliable, high-value option for lunch, dinner, or satisfying that late-night hunger pang.

Location and Accessibility

Pete's Pizzeria & Restaurant is centrally located at 7522 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA. This prime Bay Ridge spot ensures high visibility and ease of access for anyone in the area. 3rd Avenue is a major hub of activity, making it a simple stop whether you are driving or walking.

To ensure a convenient visit, the establishment provides a Wheelchair accessible entrance, making it easy for all patrons to enter and place their order. While the dining experience inside is counter-service—meaning there are "no servers"—several tables are available for dining in, offering a casual and intimate atmosphere. For those driving, Paid street parking is available nearby, which is a key convenience in a bustling neighborhood like Bay Ridge. The restaurant is also designated as Good for kids and provides High chairs, confirming its status as a welcoming, family-friendly local favorite.

Services Offered

Pete's Pizzeria & Restaurant has streamlined its service options to prioritize speed, efficiency, and convenience, fitting the fast-paced life of its New York clientele.

• Delivery and No-contact delivery: Ensuring that piping hot, authentic pizza, heroes, and entrées can be enjoyed from the comfort and safety of home.
• Takeout: The core service for a classic pizza and hero establishment, ideal for quick ordering and pickup.
• Dine-in: Customers can utilize the available seating for a casual, counter-service meal, enjoying the cozy atmosphere of a local favorite.
• Catering: Given the wide range of pizzas, specialty rolls, and large entrées, Pete's is perfectly suited to cater events, office lunches, or large family gatherings.

The restaurant accepts a full array of modern payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, ensuring that patrons can complete their transaction quickly and efficiently, even when taking advantage of the famously great deals. The focus on speed allows customers to get in, get their food, and get back to their busy day with minimal fuss.

Features / Highlights

Pete's Pizzeria & Restaurant is celebrated for a few key features that differentiate it from other local options, notably its authentic pizza and its incredible value proposition.

• Classic Thin-Crust Pizza: Known for serving the definitive classic thin crust NY slice that is "not too greasy," a true sign of quality in New York pizzerias.
• Unique Sauce Flavor: The pizza features a distinct, enhanced flavor profile, noted for a "nice flavor of herbs" and a "hint of oregano or a spice in that family," giving the classic recipe a unique, memorable taste.
• Exceptional Value: Offers one of the best deals in the neighborhood, featuring a popular 2 slice + soda special for $5.99, providing a substantial, filling meal for under seven dollars.
• Massive Menu Variety: The restaurant’s combined identity as a pizzeria, Italian restaurant, and sandwich shop provides an unparalleled menu depth, including Specialty Pizza (e.g., Grandma Pizza, Lasagna Pizza), an enormous selection of Hot Heros (over 15 varieties), and full Seafood entrées.
• Generous Portions: Customers note that meals, such as the Chicken Parmigiana with Ziti, come in "generous portion" sizes, guaranteeing a satisfying meal.
• Comprehensive Dessert Selection: Offers classic Italian-American desserts like New York Style Cheese Cake and Tartufo Gelato, ensuring a complete dining experience.

The atmosphere, while simple and straightforward, contributes to its "old school" charm, emphasizing that the focus is entirely on the quality and authenticity of the food itself.

Contact Information

To place an order for delivery or takeout, or for catering inquiries, please contact Pete's Pizzeria & Restaurant using the following information:

Address: 7522 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

Phone: (718) 745-5442

Mobile Phone: +1 718-745-5442

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Pete's Pizzeria & Restaurant means choosing a quintessential New York dining experience defined by both authenticity and value. For the local New Yorker, the clear choice is the classic Pizza By The Slice ($4.00), especially when combined with the famous 2 slice + soda special for $5.99. This special offers an incredible "better deal around" than most competitors and provides a full, satisfying lunch or dinner. The reputation for the classic thin crust, its non-greasy nature, and the unique, subtly spiced sauce are the primary reasons to visit.

However, the restaurant's extensive menu makes it a worthwhile choice far beyond a quick slice. For those seeking a hearty, traditional Italian meal, the Home Style Pasta section—featuring baked classics like Lasagna ($12.50) and Baked Ziti Siciliana ($12.00)—offers deeply satisfying comfort food. The Entrees section is equally robust, allowing you to choose from classic dishes served with a side, such as Chicken Parmigiana With Side ($16.50) or Veal Marsala With Side ($15.00), with the portions noted to be generous.

The Hot Heros menu is a destination in itself. With over fifteen options, including the Philly Cheese Steak Hero ($11.25), Chicken Cutlet Hero ($10.50), and various meat and egg combinations, it caters to every New York sandwich tradition. Even for groups, Pete's provides value with its Family Special 1 ($28.00) and Family Special 2 ($34.00), making it the perfect choice for feeding a crowd affordably. The combination of authentic, high-quality, classic NYC pizza and a full, generously portioned Italian menu, all available for fast service, firmly establishes Pete's Pizzeria & Restaurant as the indispensable Italian comfort food spot in Bay Ridge.

Pete's Pizzeria & Restaurant

7522 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA