Petee's Café

- 505 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205

In the bustling and creative borough of Brooklyn, where coffee shops and bakeries are plentiful, Petee's Café has carved out a special place for itself. It is a multi-faceted establishment, functioning as a cafe, a bakery, a pie shop, and even a wine bar, all under one cozy roof. This unique combination makes it an ideal spot for a variety of occasions, whether you're looking for a quiet morning coffee, a quick lunch, or a decadent dessert with friends. The reputation of Petee's Café is built on a foundation of high-quality ingredients and an unwavering commitment to the craft of baking, particularly when it comes to their legendary pies.

The core identity of Petee's Café is its pies, which are consistently highlighted in reviews for their "perfect crust" and decadent fillings. The Salty Chocolate Chess pie, for example, is described as "insanely good," "super decadent and creamy," and a treat that would make you want to "eat the whole pie!" This level of passion and praise is common among patrons who have tasted the pie. Beyond the classic flavors, the café is known for using high-quality and ethical ingredients, sourcing from local farms whenever possible. This commitment to fresh, regional products not only elevates the flavor of their pies but also aligns with the values of many New Yorkers who appreciate supporting local businesses.

While the pies are the star of the show, the café and wine bar aspects of the business are equally noteworthy. The coffee is consistently described as "great," providing the perfect accompaniment to a sweet slice of pie. For those who prefer something a bit stronger, the wine bar offers a selection of beer, wine, and cocktails. This thoughtful pairing of a classic café and a more sophisticated bar element makes Petee's a versatile spot that transitions seamlessly from day to night. It’s a place where you can grab a quick bite during a solo outing or settle in for a relaxed evening with a glass of wine and a dessert.

The atmosphere at Petee's Café is a major draw. It's described as "casual," "cozy," and "trendy," creating a welcoming environment that is good for kids and dogs (in the outdoor seating area). The staff is consistently praised for being "super sweet and welcoming," and great at giving recommendations. This friendly and professional service enhances the overall experience, making customers feel right at home. While there may be occasional issues with delivery or portion sizes, the overwhelming majority of feedback centers on the exceptional quality of the food and the pleasant atmosphere. Petee's Café is a true neighborhood gem that has also become a destination for tourists, a testament to its widespread appeal and quality.

Location and Accessibility

Petee's Café is located at 505 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, USA. This address places it in a lively and well-trafficked part of Brooklyn, on a major street known for its diverse selection of shops and eateries. The café is easily accessible by various modes of transportation.

For those traveling by car, paid street parking is available, which is a convenient option in a busy urban area. The location is also well-connected by public transportation, with several bus routes and subway lines running nearby. Its central position on Myrtle Avenue makes it an easy destination for both local residents and those visiting from other parts of the city. The café is also a popular spot for solo dining, a testament to its welcoming and comfortable atmosphere, which is important for individuals who are exploring the area.

Services Offered

• Pies by the Slice and Whole Pies: Petee's is renowned for its selection of pies, available both by the slice for a quick treat and as whole pies for special events.
• Cafe and Bakery Items: In addition to pie, the menu features great coffee, comforting food, and quick bites for breakfast and lunch.
• Wine Bar Offerings: The café serves alcohol, including beer, wine, and cocktails, making it a versatile spot for both daytime and evening visits.
• Seating Options: Customers can choose to enjoy their meal indoors with cozy seating, or outside with outdoor seating, which is also pet-friendly.
• Takeout and Delivery: For those who prefer to enjoy their food at home, Petee's offers convenient takeout and delivery services.

Features / Highlights

• Great Pie and Crust: The most significant highlight is the quality of the pies, particularly the perfect crust and the creative, decadent fillings.
• Fast Service: The café is noted for its fast service, which is ideal for New Yorkers who are often on a tight schedule.
• Quality Beverages: Petee's is celebrated for its great coffee and a solid selection of alcohol, including beer and wine.
• Cozy and Casual Atmosphere: The trendy yet relaxed environment makes it a comfortable and inviting place for solo diners, friends, and families.
• Ethical and Local Ingredients: The business prides itself on using high-quality, ethically-sourced ingredients, from Hudson Valley apples to grass-fed butter.

Contact Information

Address: 505 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, USA

Phone: (646) 494-3630

Mobile Phone: +1 646-494-3630

What is worth choosing

Choosing Petee's Café is a decision to indulge in a truly exceptional culinary experience that goes beyond the ordinary. What makes it worth choosing is its specialization and mastery of pie-making, which has earned it a reputation as a must-visit destination. The commitment to using high-quality, local, and ethical ingredients is evident in every bite and sets them apart in a crowded market. The attention to detail, from the flaky crust to the rich, balanced fillings, is what turns a simple pie into a memorable dessert. This is a place for those who appreciate quality and are willing to pay for an experience that is a cut above the rest.

Beyond the food, the café's inclusive and friendly atmosphere makes it a great spot for a wide range of patrons, including families, solo diners, and even those with pets. The combination of a cozy, casual setting with fast and friendly service makes every visit a pleasant one. The versatility of the menu, which includes not just pie but also great coffee and a wine bar selection, means it can be a part of your morning routine, a lunchtime treat, or a relaxing evening spot. While isolated issues with delivery may occur, the consistent praise for the food and atmosphere demonstrates a business that is doing many things right. For a New Yorker in search of the perfect slice of pie, a great cup of coffee, or just a cozy place to relax, Petee's Café is an easy and excellent choice.

Petee's Café

505 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, USA