Pier 53 Coffee & Sandwich Shop

- 5301 2nd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220

Introduction / Overview

In the expansive and discerning food landscape of New York City, finding that perfect local gem—the place that delivers consistently great food with speed and value—is an ongoing quest. Pier 53 Coffee & Sandwich Shop, situated on 2nd Avenue in Brooklyn, is a celebrated neighborhood fixture that many locals consider the ultimate answer to that search. Categorized simply as a high-quality Sandwich shop, this establishment has quickly become a cornerstone of the community, famed for its substantial portions, friendly atmosphere, and wide-ranging menu that caters to every meal of the day.

The core identity of Pier 53 lies in its ability to master both the essential morning rush and the midday hunger pangs. It functions seamlessly as a coffee spot for your morning pick-me-up, a purveyor of hearty comfort food, and the perfect source for a quick bite that never skimps on flavor or size. It is popular for both Breakfast and Lunch, making it a reliable destination for solo diners and families alike. The atmosphere is deliberately casual, designed to be a relaxing, unpretentious spot where New Yorkers can quickly grab a delicious meal without fuss.

The shop’s menu is a testament to classic American deli and sandwich tradition, featuring not just cold-cut staples but an array of hot sandwiches, inventive wraps, and satisfying burgers. Customers who value great portions and competitive local pricing hold Pier 53 in high regard, often declaring it as the definitive "perfect local NYC sandwich" spot. With its commitment to efficiency and a broad offering, this shop ensures that whether you’re rushing to work or taking a midday break, a great meal is always within reach in Brooklyn.

Location and Accessibility

The Pier 53 Coffee & Sandwich Shop is conveniently located at 5301 2nd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220, making it an extremely accessible spot for local residents and commuters passing through the area. This location places it strategically within a busy, commercial section of Brooklyn, optimizing it for quick service and ease of access.

Recognizing the modern demands of New York life, the shop's operational planning is centered around maximum customer convenience. While specific external accessibility features (like wheelchair ramps or seating) are not specifically detailed, the establishment is set up for high-volume service. The essential services of Delivery and Takeout are readily available, ensuring that the delicious menu can be enjoyed even without stepping foot inside. Furthermore, payments are seamless, with the shop accepting Credit cards, Debit cards, and modern NFC mobile payments, a vital amenity for busy locals who rely on digital transactions. Its popularity for solo dining also speaks to a welcoming, efficient environment where getting in and out quickly with a quality meal is the norm.

Services Offered

Pier 53 Coffee & Sandwich Shop offers a comprehensive menu designed to cover all bases, from early morning sustenance to a satisfying afternoon lunch. The offerings emphasize variety, customization, and hearty fulfillment, all delivered through efficient, customer-focused services.

• All-Day Breakfast: Featuring classic options like Two Egg Any Style served with toast and potatoes, customizable with Bacon, Sausage, or Ham. Lighter choices include 3 Pancakes or 3 French Toast. A variety of Egg Sandwich combinations are also available, ensuring a great start to the day.
• Extensive Sandwich and Wrap Menu: The heart of the offering includes powerful choices like Triple Deckers (Turkey, Grilled Chicken, Tuna Salad) and diverse Combination Sandwiches (American Combo, California Wrap).
• Specialty Hot Chicken Creations: Dedicated section for hot, satisfying meals including the Teriyaki Style and Bbq Style Hot Chicken Sandwiches, the classic Grilled Chicken Wrap, and the distinctive Grilled Chicken Rueben.
• Gourmet Burger Selection: Offers a range of hefty burgers like the signature Pier Special Burger, Spicy Burger, Chicken Burger, Cheese Burger, and the loaded Bacon Cheddar Cheeseburger, perfect for serious appetites.
• Quick Bites and Coffee: Known for its offerings of Coffee and Quick bite items, ensuring that customers can grab a hot drink or a small snack like the One Egg Roll quickly and efficiently.
• Delivery and Takeout: Essential services available to patrons, providing maximum convenience for enjoying the menu at home, work, or anywhere in the local New York delivery radius.

Features / Highlights

What truly makes Pier 53 Coffee & Sandwich Shop a local favorite are the specific elements that enhance the dining experience and solidify its value proposition for New Yorkers.

• Commitment to Comfort Food: The menu is centered on satisfying, feel-good meals, clearly categorized as offering 'Comfort food,' from hearty egg plates to substantial burgers and triple-decker sandwiches.
• High Value and Portions: Highly praised in local reviews for offering "Great prices, great portions," positioning the shop as a superior value choice compared to other local deli options.
• Family-Friendly Environment: The shop is designated as 'Good for kids,' making it a reliable and welcoming choice for parents and families needing a casual, quick meal.
• Technological Payment Options: The acceptance of Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments streamlines the transaction process, catering to the speed and convenience expected by a modern New York clientele.
• Unique Local Status: Holds a reputation as a genuine local spot for New York sandwiches, with one customer noting, "I think about it when I think of a perfect local NYC sandwich," indicating a strong, emotional connection with the community.
• Diverse Menu Range: The ability to easily transition from a morning Bacon 2egg And Cheese sandwich to a mid-day Chicken Finger Wrap Special illustrates the menu's successful adaptability to different craving times.

Contact Information

To reach Pier 53 Coffee & Sandwich Shop for orders, inquiries, or to confirm service details, local patrons can use the following information:

Address: 5301 2nd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220, USA

Phone: (718) 439-3054

Mobile Phone: +1 718-439-3054

What is worth choosing

Choosing Pier 53 Coffee & Sandwich Shop is choosing a high-value, high-flavor experience that perfectly fits the casual but demanding lifestyle of New York. The shop's primary draw is its unique combination of quality and quantity, a factor that is often celebrated by its most loyal patrons. The claim that the place could rival famous establishments, with one customer stating "Katz's could never!", underscores the passionate local belief in the shop’s sandwich quality and overall superior value proposition.

It is important to acknowledge the contrasting feedback. While the shop receives fervent praise for its core sandwich and coffee offerings, one review cited a significant quality issue with a specific salad order, mentioning sogginess, non-traditional ingredients, and weak lettuce. As a professional content writer, it is necessary to present the facts: the business is built on a strong foundation of positive, repeat customer experiences that praise the subs and overall service, suggesting the negative experience, though valid, may be an isolated incident related to a less frequently ordered side item. The management’s consistent reputation for providing "Great prices, great portions" and earning such passionate loyalty is a powerful counterpoint.

Ultimately, Pier 53 is worth choosing for its celebrated Triple Deckers, its specialty Hot Chicken Sandwiches, and its reliable all-day Breakfast service, delivered with the efficiency that New Yorkers require. The commitment to a friendly environment and a feeling of being "hooked up" speaks to a generous service model that builds community goodwill. For a quick, affordable, and incredibly satisfying meal—whether it’s a Pier Special Burger or a classic American Combo—this Brooklyn sandwich shop is a definitive local favorite that consistently proves its worth to the New York public.

The operational hours, which run from early morning (06:00/07:00) until the mid-afternoon (13:30/15:30) during the week and weekend, further solidify its role as the go-to spot for the essential meals of the day, making it an indispensable part of the local dining landscape.

Pier 53 Coffee & Sandwich Shop

5301 2nd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220, USA