Pizza Fenice

- 304 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803

In the vibrant and competitive culinary landscape of the New York metropolitan area, specifically in Westchester County, a true pizza destination has emerged, quickly earning the acclaim of local residents and dedicated food critics alike: Pizza Fenice. Situated in the charming Village of Pelham, this establishment is more than just a local pizza shop; it represents a heartfelt return to the craft for its owner, John Gristina, a Bronx native with a lifelong passion for pizza-making. The name itself, "Fenice," is the Italian word for "phoenix," symbolizing a spectacular rebirth—a nod to Gristina's return to the industry after a 13-year hiatus.

Pizza Fenice is rapidly becoming a local legend, a testament to its commitment to high-quality ingredients, traditional techniques, and innovative flavor combinations. The pizzeria has made waves by offering an exceptional range of styles that appeal to every type of pizza enthusiast, from the classic New York and Grandma styles to the less common, yet highly sought-after, Detroit-style square pies. For locals in the New York region, and specifically Westchester, finding the perfect slice is a serious pursuit, and the rise of Pizza Fenice provides an exciting answer.

Its commitment to excellence has not gone unnoticed. In a significant testament to its quality and popularity, Pizza Fenice was proudly named the Best Pizza in Westchester County in the 2024 Daily Voice Readers' Choice Awards. Voters praised the variety, the exceptional flavors, and the “artistry and love” poured into every pie, with some even exclaiming that the pizzeria's Detroit-style pizza is superior to what you can find in Detroit itself. This level of recognition firmly places Pizza Fenice on the map as a must-visit, or must-order, spot for anyone seeking top-tier pizza in the New York region.

Beyond the accolades, the core of Pizza Fenice's success lies in its diverse and imaginative menu, which caters to both traditional tastes and adventurous palates. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch slice, gathering the family for a delicious dinner, or simply dining solo, this Pelham gem promises a casual, cozy, and trendy atmosphere that is family-friendly and welcoming to all, including visitors and local tourists.

Pizza Fenice is conveniently located in a prime spot in the Village of Pelham, a desirable and accessible community in Westchester County, New York. Its precise location makes it easy for local residents and those traveling from other parts of the New York metro area to visit.

The pizzeria's address is: 304 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803, USA.

This Fifth Avenue location places it in a central part of Pelham, making it a focal point for the local community's dining scene. For those driving, paid street parking is available nearby. The business strives to be welcoming and accessible to all members of the community, offering a wheelchair-accessible entrance for ease of access.

While the restaurant may offer limited indoor seating, which customers note can comfortably accommodate two or three people, the focus on takeout, curbside pickup, and delivery ensures that everyone can enjoy their exceptional food regardless of their dining preference. It’s an ideal spot to swing by for a quick bite or to pick up a fantastic meal to bring home.

Pizza Fenice understands the modern dining needs of its New York customer base and provides a range of flexible services to ensure their award-winning pizza is available to everyone. These services make enjoying their food convenient and simple.

• Dine-in: A casual, cozy, and trendy atmosphere is available for those who prefer to eat on-site, perfect for lunch or dinner.
• Takeout (Pickup): Customers can easily call ahead or order online to pick up their meals directly at the restaurant.
• Curbside Pickup: For maximum convenience, the restaurant offers curbside pickup, allowing you to get your order without having to leave your vehicle.
• Delivery: As a top-tier pizza delivery option, Pizza Fenice brings its delicious pies right to your home or office.
• Online and Mobile Ordering: The use of modern payment and ordering platforms ensures a smooth and quick transaction process.
• Catering Services: Catering is also listed as an offering, indicating the ability to provide larger orders for parties and events.

Pizza Fenice has carved out a unique space for itself by blending high-quality ingredients, variety, and a commitment to customer satisfaction. Its major features and highlights are what truly set it apart in the competitive Westchester market:

• Award-Winning Pizza: Recipient of the 2024 Daily Voice Readers' Choice Award for Best Pizza in Westchester County, a significant local honor.
• The Fenice Story: The restaurant's name and founding are inspired by the "phoenix," symbolizing owner John Gristina's passionate and successful return to the pizza industry after years away.
• Diverse Pizza Styles: They excel at offering a full spectrum of pizza, including authentic 14" and 16" Traditional Pizzas (NY Cheese, Margherita, Marinara), square-cut Grandma’s Pizza and Sicilian Pizza, and their highly-acclaimed Detroit Style Pizzas (like the Detroit Red and Detroit Pulled Pig & Pickle).
• Innovative "Not So Traditional" Pies: The menu features creative and unique specialty pies that go beyond the classics, such as "The Angry Drunk Bird," "Vodka Roni," and "The Pastrami Reuben."
• Commitment to Food Insecurity: The menu includes a "Slice Out Hunger" option, which is a specialty slice and a 16" specialty pie. This partnership with the non-profit Slice Out Hunger demonstrates a commitment to fighting food insecurity through pizza-related campaigns, with 100% of the money raised through SOH's actions going directly to hunger relief initiatives.
• Variety of Offerings: Beyond pizza, the menu includes a generous selection of Rolls/Stromboli (Chicken, Roni, Italian Combo), Calzones, and Panzerotti (stuffed, fried dough pockets), along with comforting appetizers like various Breads, Balls (Arancini, Meatballs), and Sticks (Mozzarella, Provolone).
• Dietary Options: The menu includes Vegetarian Options and has been praised by voters for offering the "Best gluten-free pizza bar none".
• Payment Flexibility: Accepts a wide range of payment methods, including Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments.
• Popularity: A popular choice for both Lunch and Dinner, frequently sought out by people dining Solo due to the quality of their slices and quick bite options.

Ready to try the best pizza in Westchester County? Here is the essential contact information for Pizza Fenice:

• Address: 304 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803, USA
• Phone: (914) 633-3332 (This is also listed as +1 914-633-3332)

For operating hours, it is always recommended to check the most current information, as hours can sometimes be seasonal or subject to change. Based on recent information, the hours generally follow this pattern:

• Monday: Closed
• Tuesday: 1:00 PM – 8:00 PM
• Wednesday: 12:00 PM – 8:00 PM
• Thursday: 12:00 PM – 8:00 PM
• Friday: 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM
• Saturday: 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM
• Sunday: 12:00 PM – 8:00 PM

Note that on certain days, like Saturday, while the store may open, certain specialty items like the popular Detroit pies may take a little time after opening to be ready, so calling ahead for a specific style is a smart move.

For New York pizza lovers, the menu at Pizza Fenice offers a delightful challenge of choice. While a classic Plain Slice or a 16" NY Cheese is always a reliable order to gauge quality, the true genius of Pizza Fenice shines in its specialty offerings. Given the widespread acclaim, we strongly recommend exploring a few signature items:

• The Detroit-Style Pizza: This is a must-try. Reviewers consistently praise the thick, crunchy, and crispy crust, with a great contrast of crisp and airy texture. The Detroit Red or the Detroit It Takes Two (featuring two types of pepperoni) are fan favorites and are considered among the best in the New York area.
• Grandma's Pizza: A perennial favorite among Westchester residents, the Grandma's Pizza, available as a whole pie or a slice, is another testament to their mastery of traditional, square-cut pies.
• The Slice Out Hunger Special: By ordering the $6.00 Slice Out Hunger Slice or the 16" Slice Out Hunger Special ($33.00), you can enjoy phenomenal pizza while also contributing directly to the fight against food insecurity, making your meal a purchase for a good cause.
• Not So Traditional Pizzas: For those looking for an adventurous and memorable meal, specialty creations such as the 14" Vodka Roni ($25.00) or the incredibly unique 14" The Pastrami Reuben ($25.00) provide an exciting, gourmet take on the humble pizza pie.
• Appetizers: Don't overlook the side items. The Arancini ($16.00), the different varieties of Panzerotti (starting at $6.50), and the various Sticks (like the Provolone Sticks at $12.00) are excellent additions to any meal, whether you're dining in or taking out.

From the owner's passion, rising like a phoenix in the pizza world, to the phenomenal crunch of their award-winning crusts, Pizza Fenice offers a high-quality, memorable, and diverse pizza experience that has already captured the heart of Westchester County. It is truly a rising star on the New York pizza scene and well worth the visit or delivery order.

Pizza Fenice

304 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803, USA