Pizza'le Pizzeria

- 560 Central Ave, Cedarhurst, NY 11516

Introduction / Overview

For residents of Long Island and the Five Towns community, when the craving for authentic, quality kosher dairy Italian cuisine hits, there is one name that consistently comes to mind: Pizza'le Pizzeria. Located right in the heart of Cedarhurst, NY, Pizza'le has cemented its reputation over decades as a cornerstone establishment for families, friends, and anyone looking for a satisfying, delicious meal in a comfortable setting. The restaurant, which began its journey as Sabra Pizza, has proudly preserved a beloved and unique pizza recipe while constantly innovating its menu to meet contemporary tastes. This dedication to tradition paired with a drive for new culinary horizons is what makes Pizza'le a truly special local gem.

Pizza'le is not just a pizzeria; it's a comprehensive dining destination blending classic Italian comfort food with a distinctive Mediterranean Israeli flavor. The menu is remarkably diverse, catering to a wide array of preferences and dietary needs. From thick-crust specialty pizzas like the Stuffed Crust or Chicago Pie to lighter fare like fresh salads and a full-service sushi bar—featuring certified Kosher Parve rolls—there is truly something for everyone. This blend of options positions Pizza'le as a versatile choice for any meal, whether you're grabbing a quick lunch, settling in for a family dinner, or looking for catering for a special event. Customers consistently praise the restaurant for its commitment to a strict kashrut policy, its welcoming atmosphere, and, as many local reviewers attest, some of the best pizza and fries in the Five Towns area.

The atmosphere at Pizza'le is casual and inviting, making it an ideal spot for a relaxed outing. It's known for being super child-friendly, even offering a special 'Sunday cut' for pizza sliced into a fine grid for small fingers, underscoring its commitment to the local family crowd. The space is also large and spacious, comfortably accommodating groups and family celebrations. For those seeking kosher excellence combined with a vast and varied menu—all with the warmth of a long-standing community business—Pizza'le Pizzeria in Cedarhurst stands ready to deliver a delightful dining experience.

Location and Accessibility

Pizza'le Pizzeria is conveniently situated on Long Island’s South Shore, making it highly accessible for residents throughout the Five Towns area and beyond. The restaurant's address is 560 Central Ave, Cedarhurst, NY 11516, USA, placing it in a prime, central location in the bustling village of Cedarhurst.

Getting to the restaurant is straightforward, whether you're coming by car or using local public transportation options in the New York region. For those driving, the area offers both paid street parking and a paid parking lot nearby, providing options for customers. In terms of physical accessibility, Pizza'le is designed to be welcoming to all members of the community. It proudly features a range of accessibility amenities, including a wheelchair accessible entrance, wheelchair accessible parking lot, a wheelchair accessible restroom, and wheelchair accessible seating, ensuring that every patron can comfortably enjoy their dining experience.

The Central Avenue location ensures that Pizza'le is perfectly positioned to serve the community throughout the day, whether you are stopping by for a morning coffee and breakfast knish, a midday lunch break, or a full family dinner. Its strategic position in Cedarhurst's commercial hub contributes to its role as a popular and well-known local dining spot.

Services Offered

Pizza'le Pizzeria offers a wide range of services to accommodate various dining needs, events, and customer preferences. These services include:

• Full-Service Dining: Enjoy a casual and family-friendly dining experience with ample seating space.
• Curbside Pickup: Conveniently retrieve your order without having to leave your vehicle.
• Delivery: Fast and reliable delivery service for customers in the local area.
• Takeout: Quick and easy service for grabbing a meal to go.
• Catering Services: Comprehensive catering for various events, including Brit Milahs, Bar/Bat Mitzvahs, engagement parties, birthdays, Sheva Brachot, and more.
• Onsite Event Venue: The large and spacious dining area can be utilized to host private parties and events.
• Breakfast and Brunch Offerings: Starting the day with items like a coffee and a knish, alongside other breakfast and brunch selections.
• Lunch and Dinner Service: Serving hot, fresh food throughout the day, ideal for quick bites or full meals.

Features / Highlights

Pizza'le Pizzeria stands out in the Cedarhurst and Five Towns area due to a unique combination of menu offerings, quality commitments, and community focus. Key features and highlights include:

• Strict Kosher Certification: The restaurant is a Kosher dairy establishment, known for its very strict Kashrut policy, and its sushi bar is certified Kosher Parve, appealing to a wide orthodox clientele.
• Diverse Cuisine Profile: It offers a unique mix of traditional Pizza, Italian dishes (like Baked Ziti, Penne a la Vodka, and Fettuccine Alfredo), Fresh Fish meals (including Baked Salmon and Fish & Chips), and a distinctive Mediterranean Israeli flavor, with items like Falafel Pita and Israeli Salad available.
• Expansive Pizza Menu: Pizza varieties are extensive, ranging from the classic Plain Cheese Pizza and Sicilian to unique options like Mac & Cheese Pizza, French Fry Pizza, Stuffed Crust Pizza, and the thick, circular Chicago Pizza.
• Dedicated Sushi Bar: A prominent feature is the sushi counter offering a wide selection of classic rolls (like Spicy Tuna and California Rolls) and specialty rolls (like the Godzilla Roll and Special Dragon Roll), all prepared by a sushi chef.
• Accommodations for Families and Kids: The restaurant is widely recognized as super child-friendly, offering high chairs, a kids' menu, a changing table, and even a special slicing option—the “Sunday cut”—for young children.
• Historical Local Presence: Originally founded as Sabra Pizza, the establishment has been a beloved fixture in the heart of Cedarhurst for a long time, maintaining the very same unique and delicious pizza recipe that locals have cherished for decades.
• Menu Options for Dietary Needs: The menu features a variety of Whole Wheat, Gluten-Free, and Low-Carb pizza options, as well as cheeseless options, to cater to various dietary preferences.
• Authentic Side Dishes: Customers rave about the quality of the side offerings, with many citing the fries as being among the best in the Five Towns, alongside other favorites like Garlic Knots, Mozzarella Sticks, Onion Rings, and house-made Falafel.
• Welcoming and Casual Atmosphere: The restaurant maintains a casual, comfortable ambiance, suitable for all types of crowds including families, college students, and groups.

Contact Information

To experience the renowned kosher dairy cuisine and certified Parve sushi at Pizza'le Pizzeria, you can find them at the following location and contact details:

Address: 560 Central Ave, Cedarhurst, NY 11516, USA

Phone: (516) 218-2828

Mobile Phone: +1 516-218-2828

What is worth choosing

Choosing Pizza'le Pizzeria means opting for a trusted, decades-old community favorite that truly excels in blending quality, variety, and a superior customer experience right here in Cedarhurst, New York. It’s an easy choice for residents and visitors of the Five Towns because of its uncompromising commitment to kosher standards and its impressively broad menu. Instead of choosing between a classic pizza joint and a specialty restaurant, you get the best of both worlds. The plain cheese slice is hailed as one of the best classic slices on Long Island, with a perfect balance of dough, cheese, and sauce, as noted by long-time patrons. For a more adventurous choice, the specialty pizzas, like the unique Mac & Cheese Pizza or the hearty Grandpa Pizza, are must-try items that demonstrate the kitchen's creativity.

Beyond the famous pizza, the quality extends across the menu. The fresh, hot food is complemented by the dedicated sushi bar, where you can find impeccably fresh and delicious Parve sushi, with customers describing the food, including the sushi, as "perfect." If you're looking for a full meal, the Pasta, Fresh Fish, and More section provides excellent options like Baked Salmon and the popular Fish & Chips. For families, the dedication to a child-friendly environment is a huge draw, making dining out stress-free and enjoyable for all ages. Ultimately, what is truly worth choosing about Pizza'le is the combination of its strong foundation in the local community, its adherence to strict quality and kashrut standards, and a menu vast enough to satisfy virtually any craving. It’s a reliable, delicious, and welcoming place to enjoy a fantastic meal in Long Island.

Pizza'le Pizzeria

560 Central Ave, Cedarhurst, NY 11516, USA