Pleasantville Pizzeria

- 34 Wheeler Ave, Pleasantville, NY 10570

For anyone in the New York region, especially those in Westchester County, finding that perfect, classic pizza slice is a serious matter. Pleasantville Pizzeria, located right in Pleasantville, NY, has earned its reputation as the source of "Always the best pizza in town." It stands as a reliable, high-quality local fixture, delivering exactly what a New York pizza restaurant should: fantastic food, friendly service, and a comfortable, casual atmosphere.

This establishment is more than just a quick pizza joint; it is a full-service pizza restaurant and dedicated delivery restaurant that caters to all your cravings, from a quick comfort food lunch to a family dinner. Customers consistently rave about the quality of the pies, noting the great traditional slice with its "nicely thin crust" – the hallmark of authentic NY style pizza.

Pleasantville Pizzeria serves as a welcoming hub for the community. The atmosphere is casual and cozy, making it popular with various crowds, particularly college students and those looking for a family-friendly meal. The consistent quality, dedication to service (the staff are known as the "nicest people who work there"), and wide-ranging menu options solidify its status as a must-visit in the Pleasantville, NY area. Whether you're in a rush for a quick bite or settling in for dinner, this pizzeria provides a consistently delightful experience.

Pleasantville Pizzeria is ideally situated for easy access in the heart of Pleasantville. The restaurant is located at 34 Wheeler Ave, Pleasantville, NY 10570, USA. Its central location makes it a highly convenient spot for local residents, students, and workers in the area looking for a high-quality meal.

The pizzeria offers flexible options for receiving your order, catering to the busy schedules of New York area residents. While customers note it is "really intended for take-out," the restaurant also provides a relaxed Dine-in option with dedicated Seating. During pleasant weather, patrons can also take advantage of the Outdoor seating available.

• Accessibility: The facility is accommodating, offering a wheelchair accessible parking lot to ensure ease of access for all guests.
• Parking: Finding a spot is simple, as there is free street parking available nearby, removing the typical stress associated with dining out in the region.
• Dining Options: Popular for both Lunch and Dinner, the restaurant caters well to Solo dining as well as groups. The atmosphere is Good for kids, making it a perfect spot for a family meal.
• Payments: For maximum convenience, the pizzeria accepts various modern payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Pleasantville Pizzeria is a versatile food provider, covering all the essential services a local community needs for their favorite Italian-American meals. Their services are designed for efficiency and customer satisfaction.

• Pizza Restaurant: The core service, offering a full range of pies, specialty slices, and mini pizzas that are consistently rated as the best in town.
• Delivery Service: Operating as a dedicated Delivery Restaurant, ensuring hot, fresh food is brought directly to customers' doors in the local area.
• Takeout/Pickup: Highly optimized for Takeout orders, allowing for quick and convenient pickup of meals on the go.
• Dine-In Seating: Providing a Casual, Cozy environment with indoor and Outdoor seating options for guests who wish to enjoy their meal at the restaurant.
• Family and Student-Friendly Meals: The menu offers classic Comfort food that is appealing to all ages and budgets, making it an excellent choice for Family-friendly dining and catering to College students.
• Specialty Menu Items: Serving a wide variety of menu categories beyond just pizza, including soups (Minestrone Soup, Lentil Soup), appetizers (Mozzarella Sticks, Buffalo Wings), and fresh salads (Chef Salad, Cold Antipasto).

The true excellence of Pleasantville Pizzeria lies in the depth and quality of its menu, which features both timeless classics and innovative specialty pies, all contributing to its reputation for serving the best pizza in the area.

• The Classic New York Slice: The foundation of their success, the Regular Slice and the Sicilian Slice are praised for their nicely thin crust and traditional flavor, meeting the high standards of NY style pizza aficionados.
• Extensive Specialty Pizza Pies: The specialty offerings are where the Pizzeria truly shines, all of which are described as "delicious." The variety is staggering, covering meat lovers, vegetarian, and unique combinations, including:
  • Buffalo Chicken and Chicken Parmigiana (classic chicken toppings).
  • The popular Margarita Pizza and unique Fresca.
  • Creative combinations like the Chicken & Bacon Ranch and Kale Gorganzola.
  • Hearty, Italian-American favorites like the Baked Ziti Pizza and Lasagna Pizza.
  • The increasingly popular Cauliflower Pizza and the essential Gluten Free Pizza options, catering to diverse dietary needs in the New York area.
• Calzones & Pizza Rolls: Perfect for a hearty, handheld meal, they offer traditional Calzones (Cheese, Meatball, Spinach, etc.) and delicious Pizza Rolls (Pepperoni Roll, Chicken Roll, Sausage, Peppers & Onion Roll), offering plenty of variety for a quick lunch.
• Full Appetizer Menu: A wide range of Appetizers is available to start the meal, including classics like Mozzarella Sticks, Garlic Knots, and various wings, as well as comforting soups for colder New York days.
• Exceptional Customer Service: Beyond the food, a key highlight is the staff. Customers highlight that the people who work there are the "nicest," and specifically mention the counter staff as "very delightful," ensuring a pleasant, friendly interaction with every order.
• Variety of Sizes: Catering to all needs, they offer small Mini Pizza options for individuals or quick bites, and large Pizza Pies for families or parties.

To place an order for delivery or takeout, or to inquire about their specialty pizza menu, contact Pleasantville Pizzeria using the details below.

Address: 34 Wheeler Ave, Pleasantville, NY 10570, USA

Phone: (914) 769-3391

Mobile Phone: +1 914-769-3391

For anyone in the New York area searching for authentic, high-quality pizza, choosing Pleasantville Pizzeria is a straightforward decision based on consistent quality and variety. The pizzeria perfectly blends the tradition of a great NY style slice—the foundation of their reputation—with the innovation of a vast specialty menu, ensuring there is always something new and delicious to try.

What truly makes them worth choosing is the total package: the assurance of receiving "the best pizza in town," whether you choose a classic Cheese pie or an adventurous Chicken & Bacon Ranch. This is complemented by a customer experience built on kindness and attentiveness. The staff's delightful demeanor makes every visit or call a positive one, reinforcing their status as a true local favorite.

Furthermore, their commitment to providing accessible options like the Gluten Free Pizza and their efficiency as a Delivery Restaurant ensure that every member of the Pleasantville and surrounding Westchester community can enjoy their offerings with ease. When you want excellent comfort food delivered quickly, or a casual, cozy spot for dinner, Pleasantville Pizzeria is the definitive choice for the best slice experience.

Pleasantville Pizzeria

34 Wheeler Ave, Pleasantville, NY 10570, USA