Rosa's Pizzeria and Restaurant

- 170 W Merrick Rd, Valley Stream, NY 11580

Welcome to a comprehensive guide on Rosa's Pizzeria and Restaurant, a beloved fixture in the Valley Stream, Long Island community. For New Yorkers searching for that authentic, dependable Italian-American comfort food experience, Rosa's Pizzeria is a name that frequently comes up. Known for its generous portions, wide variety of menu items, and a commitment to fresh, quality ingredients, this restaurant offers more than just pizza—it provides a true taste of local Long Island dining.

Whether you are a longtime resident or just passing through Nassau County, Rosa's Pizzeria and Restaurant serves as a reliable spot for a casual family meal, a quick lunch slice, or a complete catering package for your next event. The establishment has built a loyal following, with customers praising not only the food but also the genuinely friendly and efficient staff, which adds a much-appreciated personal touch to the dining experience. Given the high volume of business—a testament to its popularity—the food turnover is quick, ensuring that what you receive is always hot and freshly prepared.

Introduction / Overview

Rosa's Pizzeria and Restaurant is a classic Italian-American eatery situated in the heart of Valley Stream, New York. It is a well-established local business recognized for its extensive menu that spans far beyond the typical pizzeria fare. Here, patrons can indulge in everything from large, traditional cheese pies and signature specialty slices to hearty hot heroes, baked pasta dishes, and a variety of Italian specialties. The restaurant maintains a casual dining atmosphere, making it perfect for both solo pickups and group gatherings. Its reputation as a high-volume location often means a quick rotation of fresh slices, a quality many New York pizza lovers prioritize. Customer feedback frequently highlights the authentic taste of the pizza sauce and the freshness of key items, ensuring a consistent and satisfying experience for local diners. The range of options, from a simple yet perfectly executed grilled chicken panini to a rich baked ziti, secures its place as a go-to Italian spot in the area.

The menu balances classic recipes with more inventive offerings, such as their popular specialty pizzas. Reviewers often call out the high quality and generous nature of their non-pizza items, like the "Meatball Parm Hero," which is noted for its ample filling of meat and cheese. This versatility and commitment to traditional, flavorful cooking are key reasons for the restaurant’s strong standing within the Valley Stream community and across Long Island.

Location and Accessibility

Rosa's Pizzeria and Restaurant is conveniently located at 170 W Merrick Rd, Valley Stream, NY 11580, USA. This location places it squarely in Nassau County on Long Island, making it easily accessible for residents and commuters in the Valley Stream area and surrounding towns. Merrick Road is a major thoroughfare, which contributes to the restaurant's visibility and ease of access by car.

For those traveling by car, being on a main road is generally a plus, though potential customers should always consider local traffic patterns, especially during peak dining hours. While specific details on dedicated parking lot size or public transportation connections are not explicitly provided in the snippets, the address on a well-known road like West Merrick Road suggests it is integrated into a commercially active zone. The restaurant is deeply embedded in the local landscape, serving the community for casual dining, takeout, and delivery.

Services Offered

Rosa's Pizzeria and Restaurant provides a comprehensive set of services to accommodate various customer needs, from a quick meal to large events.

The available services include:

• Takeout / Pickup: Customers can place orders for pickup, with operational hours generally running from 10:00 AM to 10:15 PM on most days, and slightly later on Fridays (until 11:00 PM) and a later start on Sundays (11:00 AM). Calling ahead is recommended, especially during busy times.
• Delivery: Delivery services are offered through various third-party platforms such as Grubhub, Seamless, Uber Eats, and DoorDash, allowing local patrons to enjoy their favorite dishes at home.
• Casual Dining: The restaurant operates as a comfortable, local establishment where patrons can enjoy their meal on-site.
• Catering: A full range of catered options is available, including catered appetizers, hot entrees, pasta dishes, salads, side orders, seafood, and stromboli, making it an excellent choice for local parties and corporate events.
• Whole Pizza Pies: An extensive selection of whole pies is available, from traditional Cheese and Sicilian to specialty options like Buffalo Chicken, Lasagna Pizza, and Grandma Pies.
• Pizza by the Slice: A wide array of pizza slices, including regular, specialty, and Grandma style, are available for a quick and satisfying meal.

Features / Highlights

Rosa's Pizzeria and Restaurant is distinguished by several key features and menu highlights that draw a consistent local crowd:

• Extensive Menu Diversity: The offerings go well beyond pizza, including a full menu of appetizers (Garlic Knots, Fried Calamari, Hot Wings), various Italian specialties (Calzones, Rolls, Paninis), Hot Heros, Special Hot Plates (Chicken Parmigiana, Eggplant Parmigiana, Shrimp Parmigiana), and fresh Savory Salads (Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken).
• Specialty Pizza Slices: Customers consistently rave about the unique specialty slices. Favorites mentioned by local users include the Caesar Salad Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Slice (noted for the right balance of blue cheese and heat), and the Salad Slice. The pizza’s freshness is often attributed to the high volume of orders.
• High-Quality Hot Heroes: The Hot Hero menu is a highlight, with the "Meatball Parm Hero" standing out for its generous portions of meat and cheese. Other popular heroes include Chicken Cutlet Parm and Veal Cutlet Parm.
• Freshly Prepared Sandwiches: The Grilled Chicken Panini is singled out as a must-try. It is described as simple yet delicious, with bread toasted to perfection, flavorful, non-dry chicken, and in-house made red peppers.
• Homemade Sauces: The restaurant prepares its own signature sauces, including Vodka Sauce, Marinara Sauce, and Pizza Sauce, which can be purchased separately to use at home.
• Positive Customer Service Environment: Reviewers consistently note the staff as "friendly" and "polite," and the restaurant is frequently described as "always clean," enhancing the overall dining experience.

Contact Information

For those in the New York area looking to contact or visit Rosa's Pizzeria and Restaurant:

Address: 170 W Merrick Rd, Valley Stream, NY 11580, USA

Phone Numbers: (516) 331-5575 (provided in task) and (516) 872-5200 (found in search results)

What is worth choosing

When visiting Rosa's Pizzeria and Restaurant in Valley Stream, the wide range of choices can be a delight. However, based on the popularity and direct customer feedback, a few items truly stand out and are "worth choosing" to get a genuine sense of what makes this establishment a local staple.

First and foremost, the specialty pizza slices are a major highlight. If you are adventurous, the Buffalo Chicken Slice is a celebrated choice, balancing the chicken’s flavor with the perfect amount of blue cheese dressing. The Salad Pizza Slice and Caesar Salad Pizza are also favorites, especially noted for their freshness, which is a rare and welcome characteristic for a slice that's pre-made. Because of the restaurant’s high foot traffic, these unique slices are consistently fresh and ready to eat, a key advantage over places where slices might sit for a long time.

Beyond the pizza, the Hot Heros are an undeniable must-try. The Meatball Parm Hero comes highly recommended, known for its generous filling and satisfying flavor profile. If you're looking for a slightly lighter, yet equally flavorful option, the Grilled Chicken Panini is a great choice. Customers appreciate the care put into this item—the perfectly toasted bread, the tender, non-dry chicken, and the in-house roasted red peppers elevate it from a simple sandwich to a memorable dish.

The pasta dishes also hold a strong appeal, with items like the Baked Ziti Parmigiana frequently ordered and praised for being flavorful and a good value. In short, while the plain cheese slice has received mixed reviews, the consensus points to Rosa's Pizzeria excelling in its specialty and prepared Italian items, where the freshness and generous portions truly shine. If you are in the area and looking for a classic, busy, and dependable Long Island pizzeria experience, Rosa's is an excellent choice for its specialty menu items and friendly service.

Rosa's Pizzeria and Restaurant

170 W Merrick Rd, Valley Stream, NY 11580, USA