Rosticceria Evelina

- 455 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205

In the rich tapestry of New York's culinary scene, some of the most rewarding discoveries are the neighborhood spots that offer both exceptional food and an inviting atmosphere. Rosticceria Evelina, located on Myrtle Avenue in Brooklyn, is precisely one of those places. Described as a "cute little restaurant with great reviews," it's a spot that you can happily stumble upon and be "really glad" you did. This charming Italian restaurant is a sister establishment to the well-loved Evelina in Fort Greene, and it brings a unique focus on roasted dishes and excellent pizzas. The decor and lay-out are "delightful," creating a cozy and welcoming ambiance that makes diners feel relaxed and at home. From the moment you walk in, the warm and inviting vibe is palpable, a key factor that makes people want to "come back to try more dishes." The food itself is a highlight, with every dish being "excellent" and "well above average." The menu strikes a wonderful balance between classic Italian comfort food and more original, creative offerings. While the name suggests a focus on "rosticceria," which translates to "roast," the menu goes far beyond that, offering a diverse selection of appetizers, pizzas, pastas, and main courses. The "Eggs Benedict" and "lasagna" have been specifically called out as "absolutely delicious," while the pizzas are described as "very original and delicious." Beyond the food, the service is consistently "fantastic," with staff members making guests feel like "family." This combination of high-quality food, a warm atmosphere, and stellar service makes Rosticceria Evelina a standout in a neighborhood with plenty of great dining options. It is a very cool and welcoming restaurant that delivers on all fronts, whether you are a local or just passing through for a few days.

Rosticceria Evelina is conveniently situated at 455 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, USA. This prime location places it in the vibrant and accessible heart of the Myrtle Avenue community, making it a great choice for both locals and visitors exploring the area. The restaurant’s accessibility is a key feature, as it offers a wheelchair accessible entrance, ensuring that all guests can enter and enjoy their meal comfortably. For those traveling by car, there is paid street parking available in the vicinity, which is a common feature in a bustling urban environment like Brooklyn. One of the most cherished aspects of Rosticceria Evelina's location is its outdoor seating. Described by a customer as a "cozy covered outdoor seating area," it adds a lovely touch to the dining experience, providing a relaxing space to enjoy a meal regardless of the weather. This feature is particularly valuable in a city where outdoor dining is a treasured experience. The restaurant is easy to reach and serves as a great stop for a variety of occasions. It is a perfect place to "stumble upon" while walking around the neighborhood or a planned destination for a special evening. The fact that dinner reservations are recommended shows its popularity and gives patrons the option to plan their visit to ensure they get a table. The combination of a central location, easy accessibility, and inviting seating options makes Rosticceria Evelina a truly convenient and appealing destination for anyone in Brooklyn seeking a fantastic Italian meal.

Services Offered:

• Outdoor seating: Enjoy your meal in a cozy, covered outdoor seating area.
• Curbside pickup: Order ahead and pick up your food conveniently.
• Delivery: Have your favorite Italian dishes delivered right to your door.
• Takeout: A quick and efficient option for a meal on the go.
• Dine-in: Enjoy the full, warm, and inviting atmosphere of the restaurant.

Features / Highlights:

• Great Cocktails: Known for a great selection of cocktails and a full bar.
• Excellent Food Quality: Dishes are described as "excellent" and "well above average," from appetizers to pizzas and main courses.
• Fast Service: Provides quick and efficient service.
• Extensive Wine List: Offers a wide variety of Italian wines by the bottle and glass.
• Cozy Atmosphere: The restaurant and its outdoor seating are described as casual, cozy, and trendy.
• Accepts Reservations: Accepts and recommends dinner reservations for better planning.
• Diverse Menu: Features a wide range of options including Italian comfort food, pizzas, and roasted dishes, with offerings like small plates, happy hour drinks, and more.
• Accessibility: Wheelchair accessible entrance, ensuring a welcoming environment for all.

Contact Information:

Address: 455 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, USA

Phone: (718) 223-7915

What is worth choosing:

Choosing Rosticceria Evelina for your next Italian meal is an excellent choice, and the reasons are abundant. The most compelling factor is the combination of its high-quality food and a delightful dining experience. As one customer noted, the food is "amazing" and "every dish I tried was excellent." The menu, with its variety of pizzas, pastas, and roasted dishes, offers a taste of authentic Italian homestyle comfort food that is both delicious and satisfying. The cozy and inviting atmosphere is another significant draw. The restaurant’s interior and its "cozy covered outdoor seating area" create a warm and relaxing vibe that makes you feel comfortable from the moment you arrive. This ambiance, combined with the "fantastic" service from a staff that is "super friendly," elevates a simple meal into a memorable occasion. The extensive wine list and great cocktails further enhance the experience, providing the perfect pairing for any dish. The practicality of the restaurant also makes it a great choice. It caters to a variety of needs, whether you're looking for a casual lunch, a romantic dinner, or a quick takeout order. The availability of reservations is a thoughtful touch that allows you to plan your visit with ease, especially during busy times. A customer who dined there three evenings in a row during a short stay is a powerful testament to the restaurant’s appeal and consistent quality. In a neighborhood with many great places to eat, Rosticceria Evelina stands out as a genuine gem that delivers on its promise of delicious food, excellent service, and a truly lovely atmosphere. It is a place that feels special and welcoming, making it a worthy destination for anyone in New York seeking a fantastic Italian meal.

Rosticceria Evelina

455 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, USA