Rothmann's Steakhouse

- 6319 Northern Blvd, East Norwich, NY 11732

For New York residents seeking a quintessential, upscale dining experience steeped in history and luxury, Rothmann's Steakhouse in East Norwich stands as a premier destination. Established by Charles and Franziska Rothmann in 1907, this establishment has been a Long Island landmark for over a century, attracting a distinguished clientele that has included historical figures like President Theodore Roosevelt and celebrities such as Elizabeth Taylor. Today, Rothmann's upholds this tradition of excellence, serving what is recognized as some of the best prime dry-aged steaks in New York, alongside an unexpectedly diverse menu that incorporates creative, fresh sushi and a robust raw bar.

The atmosphere at Rothmann's is one of its most compelling features. It is described as historic, romantic, trendy, and notably upscale, evoking the "elegant style and grace of an authentic Long Island Gold Coast Mansion." Guests are immediately immersed in a classic American steakhouse vibe, which one reviewer likened to a more vibrant version of a 'Classic American Polo bar.' The venue offers far more than just steak; it is a full-service experience that includes a well-appointed bar, an award-winning wine cellar, and impeccable service, making it an ideal choice for special occasions, romantic dinners, or high-end business lunches.

From the moment you enter, the restaurant’s commitment to quality is clear. Patrons can enjoy everything from classic steakhouse apps like Lobster Mac & Cheese and Baked Clams to refined international fare such as Foie Gras and Grilled Octopus. The commitment to a complete dining experience is further emphasized by the availability of fast service, which is a highlight appreciated by many guests.

Location and Accessibility

Rothmann's Steakhouse is prominently located in the affluent and exclusive East Norwich area of Long Island, New York, making it a convenient destination for residents of the North Shore and beyond. The address is:

6319 Northern Blvd, East Norwich, NY 11732

Accessibility is a key priority for the establishment, ensuring a smooth and comfortable experience for all guests:

• Wheelchair Accessible Entrance
• Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot
• Wheelchair Accessible Restroom
• Wheelchair Accessible Seating

For transportation, ample free parking is provided, including a free parking lot and free street parking. This level of convenience for parking is particularly valuable in the New York area. The classic, sophisticated atmosphere attracts a crowd that includes groups and tourists, all seeking a high-end dining experience.

Services Offered

Rothmann's is a comprehensive dining and entertainment venue, offering a wide array of services that cater to various needs and occasions, often requiring advanced planning:

• Dine-in: Enjoy the upscale, cozy, and romantic atmosphere with full table service.
• Delivery and Takeout: Convenient options are available, including no-contact delivery, for enjoying their cuisine at home.
• Reservations: Reservations are highly recommended or required for all dining times, including Brunch, Lunch, and Dinner, reflecting its status as a highly sought-after destination.
• Private Dining Room: Offers a private space for exclusive events, making it an ideal venue for celebrations and professional gatherings.
• Catering: Provides catering services to bring the Rothmann's experience to off-site events.
• Full Bar Service: Features a bar onsite with a great selection of beer, cocktails, hard liquor, and an acclaimed wine list.
• Brunch Service: A newly designed Sunday Brunch is offered, featuring diverse culinary offerings including a seafood bar and carving station.

Features / Highlights

What sets Rothmann's Steakhouse apart are its signature features, which combine classic steakhouse tradition with modern culinary trends:

• Historic Landmark: Operating since 1907, the restaurant boasts a rich history and a classic Gold Coast Mansion style.
• Prime Dry-Aged Steaks: The core of the menu features superior cuts like the New York Strip ($69.90), Filet Mignon ($69.90), Lamb Chops ($69.90), and limited reserve items like the Tomahawk ($159.80).
• Comprehensive Seafood/Raw Bar: Offers an impressive selection including Fresh Oysters, Littleneck Clams ($2.90 each), Shrimp Cocktail ($7.90 each), and an elaborate Seafood Plateau ($43.90 per person).
• Full Sushi Menu: Uniquely for a steakhouse, it features a full sushi offering, including Signature Rolls like the Rothmann's Roll ($39.90) and the Hampton Roll ($36.90).
• Acclaimed Beverage Program: Highlights include a great wine list that has earned a "Wine Spectator" Best of Award of Excellence, as well as great cocktails.
• Atmosphere and Amenities: The ambiance is cozy, romantic, and upscale, complemented by a working Fireplace, a full Bar onsite, and Wi-Fi access.
• Dessert and Coffee: Known for both great coffee and great dessert, ensuring a memorable conclusion to the meal.
• Specialty Dishes: The menu includes 'Chas. Specialities' like Ahi Tuna ($48.90), Swordfish ($46.90), and the Chas. Burger ($28.90).

What is Worth Choosing

For New Yorkers seeking a high-value, memorable dining experience, Rothmann's Steakhouse is an excellent choice that justifies its upscale pricing. The primary reason to choose Rothmann's is the undeniable quality of its prime steaks and chops, which are consistently cooked to perfection, avoiding being 'overly salty' as noted by appreciative patrons. The 'vibe' and historic elegance of the dining room offer an atmosphere that is truly unparalleled in the area—a feeling of dining in a piece of Long Island history.

Beyond the steak, the restaurant excels in offering variety. The inclusion of a robust raw bar and a full sushi menu means that guests who prefer seafood or a lighter start to their meal have world-class options, a rarity in classic steakhouses. The sophisticated bar area, celebrated for its fantastic cocktails and extensive, award-winning wine list, makes it a premier destination for pre- or post-dinner drinks. While brunch may sometimes draw mixed reviews, the quality of the main dining experience, particularly the perfectly prepared main courses and the attentive service, solidifies Rothmann's as a leading choice for celebrating special occasions, impressing business associates, or simply treating oneself to an unforgettable meal in a beautiful, historic setting.

Rothmann's Steakhouse

6319 Northern Blvd, East Norwich, NY 11732, USA