San Juan

- 12 S Main St, New City, NY 10956

Introduction / Overview

For residents and visitors in Rockland County, finding truly authentic, richly flavored Puerto Rican cuisine can be a delight, and San Juan in New City, NY, is a well-regarded local destination that consistently delivers. Operating out of its central location on South Main Street, San Juan stands out as a dedicated Puerto Rican restaurant that captures the heart and soul of island cooking. While the term "American restaurant" is sometimes broadly applied to eateries in the US, San Juan proudly focuses on the distinct, vibrant flavors of Comida Criolla, offering a genuine taste of Puerto Rico right here in the New York region.

The restaurant’s reputation is built on serving comfort food—dishes that are described by patrons as being freshly made with a short wait time and possessing a deeply authentic and richly flavored taste. The menu is a comprehensive tour of traditional island fare, ranging from savory appetizers and robust stews to the signature Mofongos and fresh Seafood preparations. San Juan is a perfect choice for Lunch and Dinner, appealing to both those seeking a Quick bite and groups looking for a substantial, flavorful meal in a Casual and Cozy atmosphere. The staff’s dedication to making every visit the best it can be, alongside the consistent quality of the food, makes San Juan a valuable and essential spot for local Latin Caribbean cuisine.

Location and Accessibility

San Juan is conveniently situated in the heart of New City, NY, making it an accessible spot for the surrounding Rockland County community.

The official address is:

12 S Main St, New City, NY 10956, USA

The location on South Main Street places it in a busy, central area with several convenient options for visitors:

• Parking Options: Visitors have multiple choices for parking, including a readily available Free parking lot nearby. For those parking closer to the main street, Free street parking and Paid street parking options are also available, which is typical for a downtown area.
• Ease of Access: As a major priority for all community members, the restaurant is designed to be highly accessible. It provides a Wheelchair accessible entrance, a Wheelchair accessible parking lot, a Wheelchair accessible restroom, and Wheelchair accessible seating within the dining area.
• Ambiance: The interior is known for its Casual and Cozy atmosphere, creating a welcoming and relaxed dining environment perfect for Solo dining or catching up with Groups.

Services Offered

San Juan provides straightforward and efficient service options focused on customer convenience and comfort:

• Dining Formats:
  • Dine-in: Guests can enjoy the cozy atmosphere with full Table service for lunch, dinner, and dessert.
  • Takeout: Quick and easy service for those who prefer to enjoy their authentic meal at home or at the office.
• Menu Offerings:
  • Lunch, Dinner, Dessert: Full service offered throughout the day and into the evening.
  • Daily Combo Lunch Specials: Dedicated, affordable combo meals, such as Pollo Al Horno and Shreded Beef, are available to provide great value for the local lunch crowd.
  • Beverages: The menu includes a selection of Alcohol, Beer, and Wine (Merlot, Cabernet, Pinot Grigio, Chardonnay), as well as Specialty Drinks like refreshing fruit shakes and traditional Latin drinks like Morir Sonandb (often seen as Morir Soñando).
• Special Features:
  • Fast service: Customers consistently highlight the quick turnaround from order to table, which is ideal for quick lunch breaks.
  • Great coffee: The availability of items like Cafe Con Leche ensures this is a good spot for a morning boost or a traditional post-meal coffee.
• Payments:
  • The restaurant accepts various payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making transactions quick and modern.

Features / Highlights

San Juan is distinguished by several key features that draw customers looking for a quality dining experience in the New City area:

• Authentic Puerto Rican Menu Mastery: The restaurant excels in delivering classic Puerto Rican cuisine. Key offerings that highlight this authenticity include:
  • The variety of Appetizers like crispy Tostones (fried plantains), sweet Maduros, and savory Alcapurrea and Papa Rellena.
  • The impressive array of Mofongos (mashed plantain dish), including the classic Mofongo and versions served with flavorful sauces like Mofongo W/ Shrimp Creole.
  • Hearty stews and meat dishes such as the comforting Chicken Stew W. Rice & Beans and the flavorful Oxtail special.
• Focus on Freshness and Flavor: Customer reviews repeatedly emphasize that the food is freshly made and has an authentic and richly flavored taste. This commitment to quality seasoning and preparation is the foundation of the restaurant's reputation.
• Exceptional Value and Portion Size: The restaurant is noted for offering large, satisfying portions that justify the price, as one reviewer noted, "The price it’s worth the portion size." This focus on value is important for local patrons seeking a filling meal.
• Diverse Beverage and Dessert Selection: Beyond the main courses, San Juan offers an impressive variety of non-alcoholic and alcoholic selections, including freshly prepared Aquas Frescas (Hibiscus, Cucumber Lime, Watermelon, Pineapple) and classic desserts like Flan, Bread Pudding, and Tres Leches.
• Commitment to Comfort: The combination of Comfort food and a Cozy atmosphere makes it an ideal place to unwind. It also offers Healthy options and Small plates alongside the heavier fare, catering to various dietary preferences.

Contact Information

For reservations, inquiries, or placing a takeout order:

Address: 12 S Main St, New City, NY 10956, USA

Phone: (845) 634-2111

What is Worth Choosing

For a new or returning patron at San Juan, the choice should focus on the dishes that truly embody the restaurant’s authentic Puerto Rican identity and customer-praised quality.

The Signature Experience (The Must-Try Dishes):

• Mofongo (The Classic): As a premier Puerto Rican spot, trying one of the Mofongo variations is essential. For the full experience, opt for the Mofongo W/ Shrimp Creole or the Mofongo W/ Beef Stew for a hearty, traditional meal. Alternatively, the Mofongo De Yuca offers a different root vegetable base for plantain purists.
• The Highly Praised Appetizer: Tostones: The reviews specifically highlight the Tostones as "amazing, not dry," and the accompanying mojito (garlic) sauce as "a hit." Ordering a side of Tostones ($3.95) is non-negotiable for a truly authentic start.
• The Hearty Entree: Fried Pork: The Fried Pork W/ Rice & Beans Combo is a great choice, with a reviewer describing their pork chop as "so delicious crispy out and tender inside." This dish is a true representative of hearty Latin comfort food and is offered at a competitive price point.
• The Traditional Lunch Option: Pollo Al Horno: Taking advantage of the Daily Combo Lunch Specials is smart for a mid-day meal. The Pollo Al Horno ($9.95), or baked chicken, with its combination of slow-cooked meat and flavorful sides, provides excellent value and speed, catering directly to the local lunchtime rush.

For the Drink Enthusiast:

Skip the standard sodas and opt for a traditional Latin beverage. The Aquas Frescas like Cucumber Lime or Hibiscus ($5.00) offer a refreshing, natural pairing for the richly spiced food. For a classic sweet treat, the Morir Soñando (literally 'to die dreaming,' a creamy orange juice and milk concoction) or a fruit shake like Papaya or Mango is highly recommended.

San Juan delivers a robust, authentic culinary experience, making it the premier choice in New City, NY, for those craving the genuine taste of Puerto Rican heritage.

San Juan

12 S Main St, New City, NY 10956, USA