Smith Street Pizza

- 311 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers craving a genuine taste of old-school Brooklyn flavor, look no further than Smith Street Pizza. Located right in the heart of the charming Cobble Hill neighborhood, this spot is more than just a typical slice shop; it’s a full-service Italian and pizza restaurant offering a fantastic mix of classic and creative menu items. Smith Street Pizza has established itself as a reliable local favorite, praised by many for its quality, value, and commitment to an authentic New York pizza experience. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick lunch, gathering for a casual dinner, or looking for a great take-out option after a long day, this neighborhood gem provides comfort food with a decidedly local touch.

The atmosphere here is generally described as casual, cozy, and straightforward, perfectly embodying the unpretentious vibe of a true Brooklyn pizza joint. It’s a place where locals, tourists, and families feel equally welcome, with a reputation for a clean venue and a great selection of food. Reviewers frequently highlight the generous variety on the menu and the excellent value for money, making it a reliable choice in a neighborhood known for its high-quality dining options. Beyond just the traditional cheese pie, Smith Street Pizza excels in specialty slices and full Italian entrees, ensuring there is something to satisfy every craving.

The core of their offering is undoubtedly the pizza, which is often noted for its great crust—crispy, with a good chew—and authentic style. Customers consistently give high marks for popular choices like the traditional Traditional Cheese Pizza, the robust Vodka Pie, and the satisfying Buffalo Chicken slice. Yet, the menu doesn't stop there. Smith Street Pizza also offers a full array of Italian-American classics, from hearty pasta dishes to savory heroes and entrees, all made to order. This dedication to variety and consistency is why many in the Cobble Hill and Carroll Gardens area consider it their new go-to pizza spot.

Location and Accessibility

Smith Street Pizza is conveniently situated at 311 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA. This address places it firmly within the popular and well-connected Cobble Hill neighborhood, near the border of Carroll Gardens. Smith Street itself is a bustling thoroughfare, known for its mix of local boutiques, cafes, and eateries, making the restaurant a central and easily accessible destination.

For those traveling via public transport, the location is well-served by several subway lines, making it easy to reach from other parts of Brooklyn and Manhattan. The restaurant’s accessibility features are a notable convenience for all patrons. It boasts a Wheelchair accessible entrance and Wheelchair accessible seating, ensuring a comfortable visit for guests with mobility needs.

Parking options in the area include Free street parking (though this can be typical New York street parking, so plan accordingly) and access to a Paid parking lot nearby. For those bringing their four-legged friends along, the venue is Dogs allowed, with an allowance for Dogs allowed outside, which is perfect for enjoying the lively neighborhood atmosphere at the outdoor seating. The venue is also noted as being Central & Well Connected, which simplifies both local visits and delivery logistics.

Services Offered

Smith Street Pizza is structured to provide flexible service options to meet the needs of its bustling New York clientele.

• Dine-in: Enjoy your meal in the casual, family-friendly, and unpretentious atmosphere with comfortable seating. They are popular for both Lunch and Dinner.
• Delivery and No-Contact Delivery: The restaurant operates as a dedicated Delivery Restaurant, offering convenient service right to your door. Options include standard and No-contact delivery for added safety and convenience.
• Takeout and Curbside Pickup: Grab your food to go with ease. They offer both standard Takeout and Curbside pickup for quick and effortless collection.
• Onsite Services: The restaurant offers standard Onsite services for a traditional dining experience.
• Payment Versatility: Accepting Credit cards, Debit cards, and modern NFC mobile payments for a smooth transaction.
• Beverage Offerings: Available offerings include Alcohol and Beer, alongside standard beverages.

Features / Highlights

What truly sets Smith Street Pizza apart are the many features that enhance the dining experience, making it a standout choice for local residents and visitors alike.

• Authentic Brooklyn Pizza: Many reviews note the restaurant offers a genuine New York pizza experience with quality ingredients and a great, crisp crust, often mentioned as "old school Brooklyn style."
• Speed and Efficiency: Known for its Fast service and ability to be a Quick bite option, it’s ideal for busy New Yorkers on the move.
• Extensive Specialty Menu: Beyond a traditional slice, the restaurant features an impressive selection of specialty pizzas, including the popular Vodka Pie, Grandma Pie, Upside Down Pie, and innovative options like the Caesar Salad Pizza and Ham, Onions, And Burrata pie.
• Full Italian Fare: It functions as a comprehensive Italian restaurant, offering more than just pizza. The menu includes classic entrées like Chicken Parm, Chicken Francese, Eggplant Parm, and Shrimp Parm, all designed to offer satisfying Comfort food.
• Family and Crowd Friendly: With a Casual atmosphere, the restaurant is known to be Family-friendly and is also welcoming to the LGBTQ+ friendly community. It's a great spot for both Locals and Tourists.
• Modern Amenities: Guests can enjoy Wi-Fi access and a Gender-neutral restroom, adding modern convenience to the dining experience.
• Value and Quality: Consistently praised for offering high-quality food at Spot-On Pricing, providing excellent Value for money in the competitive NYC dining scene.

Contact Information

To place an order for delivery or pickup, or for general inquiries, please use the following contact details:

Address: 311 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA

Phone: (347) 457-6471

What is Worth Choosing

With such an expansive menu, deciding what to order at Smith Street Pizza can be a delightful challenge. The restaurant excels across several categories, offering fresh takes on Italian-American staples.

For first-time visitors or those sticking to the essentials, the Traditional Cheese Pizza is a top-ordered item, a true measure of a great pizza spot. Reviewers also frequently recommend the Pepperoni Pizza and the overall selection of pizza is a major highlight.

When it comes to the highly-rated specialty pies, the Vodka Pie is a standout favorite, offering a creamy, rich tomato-cream sauce with fresh mozzarella that New Yorkers love. The Grandma Pie is another must-try, featuring crushed tomatoes, fresh garlic, and mozzarella on a thin Sicilian dough.

For those seeking a hearty, non-pizza meal, the Heroes and Entrées provide the ultimate in Italian comfort food. The Chicken Parm Hero and Meatball Parm Hero are perennial favorites, praised for their satisfying flavors and house-baked bread. The full Chicken Parm entrée is also a customer favorite, served with a side of pasta for a complete dinner. Vegetarian options are also abundant and highly-rated, with the Veggie Pie, Eggplant Parm, and Veggie Hero being popular choices.

Finally, don't overlook the highly praised side items. The Garlic knots are frequently mentioned in reviews as being “delicious” and “amazing,” making them an essential addition to any order. Ultimately, whether you're craving a classic slice, a specialty pie, or a full Italian meal, Smith Street Pizza delivers on its promise of quality, authentic, and well-priced food right here in Brooklyn.

Smith Street Pizza

311 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA