Stellina Ristorante: Your Guide to Exceptional Italian Dining in Oyster Bay, NY

Stellina Ristorante Introduce

For New Yorkers seeking an authentic and refined Italian dining experience right here on Long Island, **Stellina Ristorante** in Oyster Bay stands out as a true local favorite. This establishment offers much more than just a meal; it provides an immersive experience characterized by warm service, a cozy yet upscale atmosphere, and a menu deeply rooted in Italian culinary tradition while offering creative, high-quality selections. Whether you're planning a romantic dinner, a celebratory meal with family and friends, or simply craving exceptional Italian comfort food, Stellina Ristorante promises a memorable occasion. The focus on fresh ingredients and classic preparation, combined with modern flair, makes it a must-visit spot for anyone in the New York region looking for superior Italian cuisine.

Stellina Ristorante is highly regarded by the local community for its consistent excellence across all aspects of the dining experience, from the moment you step through the door until the last bite of their delightful desserts. The restaurant has cultivated a friendly and professional environment where diners feel welcome, whether they are local regulars or first-time visitors from other boroughs or counties. It is the perfect blend of neighborhood comfort and polished, professional dining. This reputation is built on their commitment to delivering not only superb food and drink, but also an atmosphere that encourages connection and relaxation. It’s a place where the attention to detail truly elevates the whole outing. The wide range of menu options ensures there is something for every palate, from exquisite pasta and pizza dishes to robust meat and seafood selections.

Location and Accessibility

Stellina Ristorante is conveniently situated at **76 South St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771**. Oyster Bay is a charming, historic town on the North Shore of Long Island, making it easily accessible for residents across Nassau County and a pleasant destination for those traveling from New York City or other parts of the region. The location is ideal for an evening out, situated in a welcoming part of the town with easy access.

The restaurant goes the extra mile to ensure a comfortable visit for all guests by offering excellent accessibility features, which is a major benefit for local diners and groups. Parking is hassle-free, with both a **free parking lot** and **free street parking** available nearby. For guests requiring mobility assistance, the restaurant is fully equipped with **wheelchair accessible entrance**, **parking lot**, **restroom**, and **seating**. This commitment to accessibility reflects the restaurant's welcoming ethos, ensuring that everyone can enjoy the Stellina experience without concern. The location also makes it a great stop for locals running errands or meeting friends in the area, offering a relaxed environment away from the hustle of city life while still being a short drive from major Long Island hubs.

Services Offered

Stellina Ristorante provides a full range of dining and service options to meet the needs of the Oyster Bay and surrounding New York community. Their flexibility allows patrons to enjoy their outstanding Italian food in whatever way suits them best.

**Dine-in:** Enjoy the full, atmospheric experience with comfortable **table service** during **brunch, lunch, and dinner**.
**Outdoor Seating:** Perfect for enjoying a meal or drinks on a pleasant Long Island day or evening.
**Reservations:** **Dinner reservations are recommended**, and the restaurant **accepts reservations** for planning your visit, especially for larger groups or peak times.
**Takeout and Delivery:** For those nights when you prefer to dine at home, the restaurant offers **takeout** and standard **delivery** service.
**No-contact delivery:** A convenient option for a safer delivery experience.
**Payment Options:** A wide variety of payment methods are accepted for convenience, including **Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments**.

Features / Highlights

The exceptional quality of Stellina Ristorante is defined by several standout features that contribute to its popularity among locals in the New York area. These highlights speak to the overall high standard of the food, drink, and service.

**Great Beverage Program:** The restaurant boasts a spectacular selection of drinks, including **great cocktails** (like the classic *Il Padrino* and various *Mimosas*), an extensive **great wine list** (featuring selections like *Cantina Sylvania Amarone Della Valpolicella* and *Sancerre*), and a selection of local and Italian **beer**. They also offer **hard liquor** and excellent **coffee**.
**Fast and Attentive Service:** Patrons consistently highlight the **fast service** and the staff's dedication to providing a memorable and helpful dining experience, from explaining the menu to anticipating needs.
**Atmosphere and Ambiance:** The setting is described as **Casual, Cozy, Romantic, and Upscale**, making it suitable for a variety of occasions, from a casual lunch to a special date night.
**Exceptional Dessert Menu:** Their desserts, or *Dolci*, are a highlight, including the classic *Tiramisu*, *Hazelnut Gelato Affogato*, and unique items like *Cannolo Destrutturato*, earning them a reputation for **great dessert**.
**Diverse Dining Popularity:** Stellina is **Popular for Lunch, Dinner, and Solo dining**, showing its versatility as a gathering spot for **Groups, Locals**, and being **Family-friendly** with amenities like **High chairs**.
**Specialty Dishes:** The menu features Italian staples and elevated dishes across a variety of categories, including delicious *Pasta* (like *Pappardelle Ragu* and *Lasagna Tradizionale*), *Pizza* (including *Al Tartufo* and *Margherita*), *Carne E Pesce* (such as *Cotoletta Alla Milanese* and *Bistecca Di Manzo*), and *Uova E Salate* for brunch. The availability of **Comfort food** and **Small plates** also adds to the appeal.

Contact Information

For reservations, inquiries, or to place a takeout order, you can easily reach Stellina Ristorante using the information below.

**Address:** 76 South St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771

**Phone:** (516) 757-4989

**Mobile Phone:** +1 516-757-4989

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Stellina Ristorante means opting for a guaranteed excellent Italian culinary journey without having to venture into Manhattan. It is a local gem that provides a level of quality, service, and ambiance that elevates it above the typical neighborhood eatery. The restaurant's dedication to Italian authenticity is evident in their menu, which is both expansive and focused on high-quality preparation. The wide selection of dishes, from the simple perfection of *Penne Al Pomodoro* to the rich flavor of *Agnolotti Di Vitello E Tartufo*, caters to all cravings.

What truly sets Stellina apart is the entire package: the **cozy, romantic atmosphere**, the **attentive and passionate staff**, and the impressive beverage selection. Customers consistently praise the thoughtful wine list and the expertly crafted cocktails, which perfectly complement the meal. Furthermore, the commitment to providing accessible amenities and a welcoming environment for all groups, including families and solo diners, makes it a reliable and inclusive choice for the New York community. If you are a Long Island local or visiting the area, Stellina Ristorante is the premier destination for exceptional Italian food, great service, and a truly delightful dining experience. The ability to cater to various dining times—brunch, lunch, and dinner—with distinct and high-quality menus (such as the incredible *Eggs Benedict With Lobster & Caviar* or the dinner favorite *Bistecca Di Manzo Al Rosmarino*) ensures that Stellina is worth choosing no matter the time of day or the occasion. It is a place where every meal feels like a special event.

Stellina Ristorante Food & drink

Cocktails
Il Padrino $18.00
Blended scotch and amaretto
Vermouth Spritz $18.00
Sweet vermouth and club soda
Bitter Spritz $18.00
Prosecco, Italian bitter liqueur, club soda, and an orange twist

Carne E Pesce
Cotoletta Alla Milanese $59.00
16 oz breaded veal chop with cherry tomatoes.
Porchetta $30.00
Berkshire pork belly porchetta, mesclun, and confit tomatoes.
Pollo Alla Milanese $30.00
Pounded airline chicken breast, breaded, and served with an arugula and cherry tomato salad.
Pollo Alla Parmigiana $39.00
Airline chicken breast, pounded and breaded, baked in our wood fired oven with San Marzano tomato sauce and burrata.
Stellina Burger $29.00
8 oz wagyu beef patty, melted taleggio cheese, sorrel mesclun, apple vinegar grilled onions, and mild lemon herb pink sauce on a toasted brioche bun and served with truffle fries.

Pasta
Bucatini All'Amatriciana $28.00
Bucatini pasta with San Marzano tomato sauce, guanciale, aged pecorino, and a touch of Calabrian chili.
Strozzapreti Al Fume $27.00
Homemade strozzapreti pasta in a San Marzano tomato sauce with smoked pancetta, cream, chili, parmigiano, and smoked provola.
Pappardelle Ragu $29.00
Fresh homemade pappardelle pasta with our traditional meat ragu sauce and topped with parmigiano.
Cacio E Tre Pepe $24.00
Vermicelli pasta with aged pecorino romano and a mix of three peppercorns.
Penne Al Pomodoro $23.00
Penne pasta with San Marzano tomato sauce, EVOO, garlic, basil, and parmigiano.

Pizza
Bianca $15.00
Fior di latte mozzarella, EVOO, and rosemary.
Ricotta Di Buffalo E Tartufo $27.00
Buffalo ricotta, arugula, truffle honey, and freshly shaved black truffles.
Salsiccia E Friarielli $19.00
Fior di latte mozzarella, Italian sweet sausage, broccoli rabe, and EVOO.
Vegetariana $20.00
San Marzano tomato sauce, fior di latte mozzarella, artichokes, spinach, roasted tomatoes, olives, EVOO, garlic, and parsley.
Quattro Formaggi $20.00
Fior di latte mozzarella, provola, gorgonzola, and reggiano.
Calabrese $20.00
San Marzano tomato sauce, fior di latte mozzarella, spicy Calabrian soppressata, and EVOO.
Bresaola Di Wagyu $25.00
San Marzano tomato sauce, fior di latte mozzarella, wagyu bresaola, arugula, EVOO, and balsamic.
Al Tartufo $27.00
Fior di latte mozzarella, black truffle and mushroom cream, spinach, lemon zest, and freshly shaved black truffles.
Stellina Breakfast Pizza $25.00
Fior di latte mozzarella, eggs (regular or scrambled), crispy pancetta, and herbs.
Marinara $15.00
San Marzano tomato sauce, garlic, oregano, and EVOO.
Margherita $16.00
San Marzano tomato sauce, fior di latte mozzarella, EVOO, and basil.

Dolce
Pancakes Ricotta Di Bufala $25.00
Pancakes made with buffalo ricotta and topped with chocolate and amarena cherries.
Frutta E Mascarpone $18.00
Fresh fruit salad with mascarpone cream.
Pancakes Or Waffles $25.00
Pancakes or waffles with your choice of Nutella, pistachio cream, or maple syrup and topped with fresh berries and whipped cream.

Pizza
Pizza Bianca $18.00
Fior di latte mozzarella, evo, rosemary.
Pizza Bresaola Di Wagyu $31.00
San marzano tomato sauce, fior di latte mozzarella, wagyu bresaola, arugula, evo, and balsamic.
Piazza Calabrese $24.00
Spicy. San marzano tomato sauce, fior di latte mozzarella, spicy calabrian sopressata, evos.
Pizza Salsiccia E Friarielli $24.00
Fior di latte mozzarella, Italian sweet sausage, broccoli rabe, and evo.
Pizza Al Tartufo $34.00
Fior di latte mozzarella, black truffle and mushroom cream, spinach, lemon zest, and freshly shaved black winter truffles.
Pizza Ricotta Di Bufala E Tartufo $34.00
Buffalo ricotta, arugula, truffle honey and fresh shaved black winter truffles.
Pizza Marinara $18.00
San marzano tomato sauce, garlic, oregano, and EVOO.
Pizza Quattro Formaggi $25.00
Fior di latte mozzarella, provola, gorgonzola, reggiano.
Pizza Vegetariana $26.00
Vegetarian. San marzano tomato sauce, fior di latte mozzarella, artichokes, spinach, roasted tomatoes, olives, EVOO, garlic, and parsley.
Pizza Margherita $19.00
San marzano tomato sauce, fior di latte mozzarella, evo, basil.

Rosé And Prosecco
Romio Prosecco Extra Dry $47.00
Bottle- Friuli, Italy
Fete De Fleurs Rosé $47.00
Bottle- Cote du Provence, France

Cocktails
Classic Mimosa $18.00
San Marzano Bloody Mary $20.00
Tequila Sunrise Mimosa $18.00
Mimosa Margarita $18.00
Orange Lemon Vodka Punch $18.00

Uova E Salate
Bagel All'Italiana $30.00
Baked pizza dough with garlic and herbs, filled with cream cheese, lox salmon, an olive oil emulsion, and fresh herbs.
Waffles Con Pollo $30.00
Waffles with chicken milanese, maple syrup, and vincotto.
Stellina Toast $30.00
Italian toast with Arctic Char crudo and a poached egg in an avocado-lemon emusion.
Uovi Al Tartufo $27.00
Truffle scrambled eggs and bruschettona.
Uova In Purgatorio $25.00
Poached eggs in a spicy San Marzano tomato sauce with buffalo ricotta, scarpetta bread, and honey.
Frittata Patate E Porchetta $25.00
Potato and porchetta frittata with confit tomatoes and served with pinsa.
Eggs Benedict With Lobster & Caviar $39.00
Eggs benedict made with lobster and caviar in a zesty lemon hollandaise and served on focaccia.

Beer
Birra Follina Giana Doppio Malto $14.00
Moretti Lager $9.00
Birra Follina Sanavalle Bionda $14.00
Menabrea Bionda $9.00
Forst Premium $9.00
Forst Sixtus Doppel Bock $9.00
Birra Nazionale Baladin $12.00
Belgian pale ale style

White Wine
Monte Tondo Pinot Grigio $40.00
Bottle- Venezie, Italy
Back To Basics Verdicchio Dei Castelli Di Jesi $66.00
Bottle- Marche, Italy
Sancerre 2020 $66.00
Bottle- Loire valley, France
Livio Felluga Sauvignon Blanc $66.00
Bottle- Friuli, Italy
Willowbrook Chardonnay $43.00
Bottle- Napa valley, California, USA
Conte Vistarino Ries Riesling $71.00
Bottle- Lombardia, Italy
Jean Marie Reverdy Sauvignon Blanc $47.00
Bottle- Loire valley, France

Fresh Juices
Freshly Squeezed Orange Juice $12.00
Freshly Squeezed Orange & Lemon Juice $12.00

Insalate
Insalata D'Aragosta $35.00
Lobster salad- add description here.
Insalata Di Rucula $17.00
Arugula salad with cherry tomatoes, parmigiano, and balsamic.

Red Wine
Uno Malbec $54.00
Bottle- Mendoza, Argentina
Oak Farm Tievoli Cabernet Sauvignon $50.00
Bottle- Lodi, California, USA
Prunotto Dolcetto D'alba $47.00
Bottle- Piedmonte, Italy
Cantina Sylvania Amarone Della Valpolicella Classico Superiore 2017 $83.00
Bottle- Veneto, Italy
Pull Cabernet Sauvignon $47.00
Bottle- Paso Robles, California, USA
Grattamacco Bolgheri Rosso Superiore 2020 $71.00
Bottle- Tuscany, Italy
Villa La Pagliaia Chianti Classico $58.00
Bottle- Tuscany, Italy
Brigaldara Valpolicella Classico $47.00
Bottle- Veneto, Italy
Elyse Nero Misto Red Blend $108.00
Bottle- Napa valley, California, USA
Mozza I Perazzi Cabernet Sauvignon $47.00
Bottle- Tuscany, Italy
Sostener Pinot Noir $50.00
Bottle- Monterey, California, USA
Contesa Montelpuciano D'abruzzo $54.00
Bottle- Abruzzo, Italy

Dolci
Tiramisu $14.00
Almond dacquoise soaked in coffee and amaretto with airy mascarpone cream and topped cocoa powder.
Hazelnut Gelato Affogato $15.00
Hazelnut gelato with croccante, shaved chocolate, and a shot of espresso.
Strawberry Sorbet $12.00
Strawberry sorbet with freeze-dried strawberries and coulis of strawberry and meringue.
Cannolo Destrutturato $20.00
Deconstructed Cannoli with Sheep Ricotta, Chocolate & Pistachio
Gelato Al Tartufo $18.00
Homemade truffle gelato with hazelnut crumbles and tart crumbs, topped with caramel, and black winter truffles.
Sorbetto Al Limone $12.00
Homemade lemon sorbet with coulis of tomatoes, vincotto, and meringue.
Pizza Fritta Alla Nutella O Pistacchiella $14.00
Fried pizza with Nutella or pistachio cream.

Contorni
Asparagi Al Forno $14.00
Asparagus roasted in our wood-fired oven.
Patate Arrosto $14.00
Roasted potatoes, rosemary and garlic.
Padella Di Funghi $14.00
Saute of black trumpets and chanterelles mushrooms, garlic, parsley and lemon zest.
Rapini Al Forno $14.00
Broccoli rabe roasted in our wood fired oven with lemon, EVOO, and garlic.
Patate Fritte Al Tartufo $17.00
Hand cut French fries with black winter truffles and truffle mayo.

Addizioni
Grilled Shrimp $16.00
Burrata $12.00
Italian Sausage $14.00
Poached Egg $8.00
Rosemary Garlic Roasted Potatoes $12.00
Pancetta $14.00
Truffle Fries $15.00

Primi
Lasagna Tradizionale $40.00
Homemade Fresh Lasagna with Meat Tomato Ragu (Beef-Pork) and Bechamel Sauce, Parmigiano & Mozzarella cooked in Wood Fired Oven
Spaghetti Allo Scoglio $45.00
Spaghetti pasta with mussels, clams, shrimp, and calamari in a light san marzano dop tomato sauce with a touch of calabrian chili.
Pappardelle Ragu $34.00
Fresh house made pappardelle pasta with our traditional meat ragu sauce.
Penne Al Pomodoro $28.00
Penne pasta pastificio dei campi gragnano with san marzano tomato sauce, evo, garlic and basil.
Gnocchi Alla Sorrentina $36.00
Fresh Homemade Potato Gnocchi with San Marzano Tomato Sauce & Basil, Topped with Burrata and baked in Wood Fired Oven
Cacio E Tre Pepe $28.00
Vermicelli pasta pastificio dei campi gragnano, aged pecorino Romano, mix of three peppercorns.
Paccheri Zafferano E Pistacchio $34.00
Paccheri pasta with creamy saffron sauce and pesto of pistachio from Bronte.
Bucatini All'Amatriciana $34.00
Bucatini pasta pastificio dei campi gragnano with san marzano sauce, guanciale, aged pecorino and a touch of calabrian chili.
Mezzi Rigatoni All'arrabbiata $32.00
Mezzi rigatoni pasta in a san marzano tomato sauce with garlic, calabrian chili pepper, parsley, and EVOO.
Strozzapreti Al Fume $33.00
Homemade strozzapreti pasta in a san marzano tomato sauce with smoked pancetta, cream, chili, parmigiano, and smoked provola.
Agnolotti Di Vitello E Tartufo $47.00
Fresh house made stuffed pasta with braised veal and truffles, reggiano cream and truffled veal demi, fresh black winter truffles.

Spuntini
Fior Di Zucchini E Mozzarella $19.00
Stuffed zucchini flowers with mozzarella, battered and fried, served with san marzano tomato, garlic, and basil sauce.
Carciofi Fritti $17.00
Fried and crispy artichokes serve with our herb lemon aioli.
Pinsa Al Rosmarino $14.00
Pinsa romana flatbread topped with garlic, EVOO, rosemary, and sea salt.
Ricotta Di Bufala E Tartufo $19.00
Fresh bufala ricotta with urbani truffles honey, fresh black winter truffle and arugula served with crispy pane carasau.
Polpette Al Sugo $21.00
Our wood fired oven roasted meatballs made of veal, beef, pork and lamb and finished to slow cook in our san marzano dop tomato sauce and topped with reggiano red cow 24 month.

Secondi
Fritto Misto $48.00
Fried seafoods, fishes and vegetables.
Porchetta $36.00
Berkshire pork belly porchetta, mesclun and confit tomatoes.
Cotoletta Alla Milanese $69.00
16 oz veal chop breaded, cherry tomatoes and red onions.
Agnello Al Forno A Legna $69.00
Carre of lamb, roasted in wood oven and smoked with rosemary and thyme.
Bistecca Di Manzo Al Rosmarino $89.00
20 oz bone in wagyu ribeye steak dry aged.
Stellina Burger $34.00
8 oz Wagyu beef patty, melted taleggio cheese, sorrel mesclun, apple vinegar grilled onions, mild lemon herb pink sauce, toasted brioche bun served with truffle fries.
Bistecca Di Manzo $79.00
20 oz bone-in dry-aged wagyu ribeye steak.
Veal Chop Parmigiana $79.00
16 oz breaded veal chop, broiled in our wood-fired oven with san marzano tomato sauce and burrata.
Polletto Arrosto $36.00
Organic young chicken roasted with rosemary, thyme, garlic, lemon.
Cioppino Zuppa Di Pesce $52.00
Seafood Stew with Clams, Mussels, Shrimps, Scallops, Lobsters in a light San Marzano Sauce

Antipasti
Burrata E Pomodorini Affumicati $22.00
Burrata with roasted and confit cherry tomatoes and fennel, smoked with thyme and rosemary, pickled white balsamic red onions.
Gamberi E Calamari Alla Calabrese $24.00
Spicy. Saute of shrimp and calamari in a spicy calabrian tomato sauce.
Cozze E Vongole $22.00
Saute of mussels and manilla clams with sauvignon, garlic, parsley lemon and yellow tomatoes.
Tagliere Di Salumi E Formaggi $34.00
Chef selection of cured meat and cheeses, olives, preserve and honey served with bread selection.
Tartare Di Tonno, Tartufo E Caviale $36.00
Tuna tartare with fresh black winter truffles, caviar, lemon chervil aioli, micro mesclun, lemon caviar and chervil tuile.
Frittura Di Calamari $24.00
Crispy fried fresh calamari with lemon garlic aioli.
Polpo Alla Griglia O Fritto E Patate $31.00
Slow cooked octopus with potatoes and sunchokes cream, parsley garlic lemon sauce choose your prep: octopus finished on the grill or fried.

Insalate
Pinzimonio $21.00
Seasonal shaved vegetables with evo lemon emulsion.
Insalata Di Arance E Finocchio $21.00
Fennel and oranges salad with red onions, olive, evo and a touch of red vinegar.
Insalata Di Rucola $21.00
Arugula salad with cherry tomatoes, 24 months aged reggiano and balsamic emulsion.

Spuntini
Tartare Di Tonno, Tartufo, E Caviale $30.00
Tuna tartare with fresh black truffles, caviar, lemon chervil aioli, micro mesclun, lemon caviar, and chervil tuile.
Frittura Di Calamari $20.00
Fried fresh calamari served with lemon garlic aioli.
Tagliere Di Salumi E Formaggi $28.00
Chef's selection of cured meats, cheeses, olives, preserves, and honey served with a bread selection.
Fior Di Zucchini E Mozzarella $15.00
Stuffed zucchini flowers with mozzarella, battered and fried, served with San Marzano tomato, garlic, and basil sauce.
Ricotta Di Buffala E Tartufo $17.00
Fresh buffalo ricotta with Urbani Truffles honey, fresh black truffle, and arugula, topped with crispy pane carasau.
Carciofi Fritti $14.00
Fried, crispy artichokes served with herb lemon aioli.
Polpette Al Sugo $17.00
Wood-fired, oven roasted meatballs of veal, beef, pork, and lamb, finished to slow cook in San Marzano DOP tomato sauce and topped with Reggiano.

Stellina Ristorante Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great cocktails
Great coffee
Great dessert
Great wine list

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Hard liquor
Small plates
Wine

Dining options
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Romantic
Upscale

Crowd
Family-friendly
Groups
Locals

Planning
Dinner reservations recommended
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
High chairs

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
Parking

Stellina Ristorante Photos

Stellina Ristorante Location

Stellina Ristorante

New York Nassau County Oyster Bay South Street

76 South St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771, USA

Stellina Ristorante Reviews

An average rating of ★4.4 from 126 user reviews.

pastadininggementreepricesvealagnolottipescatarianporchettatartufo

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Plan for a special evening in this amazing restaurant. The service is attentive and helpful, from explaining the menu and anticipating your needs. The regional food was unusual and full of surprises. We tried fennel salad with oranges and pork belly porchetta. It was so good I forgot to take a picture until I ate one of the pieces.
August 28 · eve sarles
Stellina Ristorante is an absolute gem! From the moment you walk in, the warm and inviting atmosphere makes you feel right at home. The food is phenomenal—fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. The pasta dishes are cooked to perfection, and the wine selection pairs wonderfully with every meal. The staff is attentive, friendly, and truly passionate about providing a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just enjoying a night out, Stellina Ristorante delivers excellence on every level.
September 27 · Computer Tech
What a sublime experience of elevated cuisine. What a beautiful way to support local family owned small business. We had a pasta dish and 5 appetizers and they were all different and awesome. We met another local couple and it was so nice to connect with other people from around the area. An out of ordinary menu is a win win esp when the food hits! I am so disappointed to see petty people leaving unwarranted negative reviews not recognizing the impact it has on a small business like this - “it didn’t have enough pescatarian options” what? ✋🏼 go back to the south shore.
June 29 · Marc Moran
This restaurant is extremely small and intimate. The food is simply beyond words for me, they present such a wild array of different flavors for each dish. Everything that touched our table was a treat. I cannot recommend this place enough. If I did have any complaints, they usher you out of there immediately, upon bill payment. Given it's size, I guess that is to be expected.
March 01 · Aaron F.
We visited Stellina Ristorante over Easter weekend, hoping for a pleasant dining experience. Unfortunately, the menu lacked sufficient pescatarian options for my partner, making it difficult for him to find a suitable meal. We had already ordered drinks upon being seated, as prompted by our server. Upon realizing the menu’s limitations, we informed the staff that we wouldn’t be ordering food. The server insisted that we must order food, stating that the establishment is a restaurant, not a bar. Feeling pressured, we ordered the least expensive item on the menu, which turned out to be an unappetizing salad that we did not consume. The waiter actor weird after that. We requested to speak with the manager, but the server claimed to be the manager. In the end, we spent $60 on two drinks and a salad we didn’t eat. This experience left us disappointed, and we hope the restaurant considers accommodating diverse dietary preferences in the future.
April 20 · Queenasia Rosario
A little gem with amazing Italian authentic food. Sometimes you randomly find these little spots that turn out to be a treasure. The ambiance is immaculate, it feels cozy and warm. We tried different plates and everything was tasty, a piece of Italy right here in Oyster Bay.We tried bucatini ala amatriciana, agnolotti with tartufo, meatball, octopus, pizza, the bone-in ribeye, fritto misto, etc.The service was great, the chief greeted us and explained a few of the dishes. I’d recommend Stellina and we’ll definitely come back again.
February 20 · Arbër Shehu