Sunset Coffee Shop

- 5416 2nd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220

Introduction / Overview

Tucked away in the vibrant Sunset Park neighborhood of Brooklyn, Sunset Coffee Shop is a local gem that stands out not just for its name, but for its incredibly diverse and satisfying menu. More than just a spot for a quick coffee, this establishment operates as a full-service, neighborhood-style eatery that expertly blends classic American and New York deli favorites with rich, authentic Dominican and Latin cuisine. If you're looking for a hearty breakfast, a comforting plate of rice and beans, a classic New York slice, or a fulfilling burger and sub, Sunset Coffee Shop aims to be your one-stop destination.

The menu is a testament to the cultural melting pot of the neighborhood, offering everything from traditional American omelets and breakfast sandwiches to specialties like Mangu Breakfast (mashed plantain with salami, eggs, and fried cheese) and slow-cooked Latin food like Baked Chicken Rice and Beans. This extensive selection ensures there's something for every craving at any time of day, cementing its role as a reliable local favorite for Brooklyn residents.

While the majority of customer experiences reflect the satisfaction of a good, diverse menu, and reliable service, it’s important to acknowledge that the business has faced a serious complaint. A customer reported an incident of alleged racial discrimination by a staff member after observing them prioritize a Caucasian customer and stating the reason was due to the original customer's race. This is a very serious matter and customers should be aware of all feedback, both positive and negative, when making their dining choices. Businesses in New York are expected to uphold standards of equitable service for all patrons.

On a lighter note, other patrons highly recommend the dishes, praising the freshness and quality of certain items, such as the White Fish Hero, which one reviewer described as surprisingly great and not dry, unlike similar dishes found elsewhere. The consistently positive feedback on the food’s flavor and the sheer volume of choices highlight why Sunset Coffee Shop remains a frequented spot in the area.

Location and Accessibility

Sunset Coffee Shop is conveniently located at 5416 2nd Ave in the Sunset Park section of Brooklyn, NY 11220. The neighborhood is known for its strong community feel and accessibility to different transportation options, making it relatively easy for locals and visitors to stop by.

The location on 2nd Avenue places it firmly within a bustling commercial strip, offering a natural stop for residents running errands or commuters making their way through the day. For those relying on public transit, the shop is situated in an area of Brooklyn that is well-served by local buses, and it is also within a reasonable walking distance of subway stations on the D, N, and R lines, making it easily reachable from various points in the borough. Whether you are driving, taking the bus, or walking from the subway, accessing this neighborhood eatery is straightforward. The establishment serves as a pillar for quick and comforting meals within this specific corner of Sunset Park.

Services Offered

Sunset Coffee Shop is structured to serve the needs of a busy urban clientele, offering a range of convenient dining and ordering options. The services provided focus on flexibility and accessibility for local customers throughout Brooklyn.

• Dine-In/Take Out: Customers can visit the 2nd Avenue location for a meal inside the shop or place an order for quick pickup to enjoy at home or on the go.
• Delivery Services: The shop partners with popular food delivery platforms like Grubhub and DoorDash, offering delivery to the surrounding Brooklyn area, often with options for contact-free delivery.
• Full Breakfast Menu: They offer an extensive morning menu that includes breakfast sandwiches, omelet platters (served with home fries & toast), and unique Dominican breakfast plates.
• Latin Food Specials: A core offering includes satisfying Latin American staples, primarily rice and bean dishes with various meat options like chicken stew, beef stew, and fried fish.
• Combo Meals: Many menu items, particularly burgers and subs, are available as combo meals that typically include French fries and a can of soda for added value.

Features / Highlights

What makes Sunset Coffee Shop a notable stop in Sunset Park is its deep and diverse menu that caters to a wide array of tastes and times of the day. The highlights emphasize both the comfort and cultural breadth of its offerings.

• Dominican Breakfast Specialties: A true standout, the menu features authentic Dominican breakfast options such as Mangu Breakfast ($11.00+), which is a plate of mashed plantain with salami, two eggs, and fried cheese, and Yuca Breakfast ($10.00+).
• Diverse Breakfast Options: Beyond the Latin choices, they offer a full range of breakfast essentials, from simple Eggs & Cheese Sandwiches ($3.30+) to substantial omelets like the Western Omelette ($10.00) or High Protein Omelette ($10.00).
• Extensive Latin Lunch/Dinner Menu: The menu features numerous rice and bean plates, including Chicken Stew Rice & Beans ($10.00) and Beef Stew Rice & Beans ($11.00), offering affordable and fulfilling meals.
• New York Style Pizza: Customers can choose from a selection of classic and specialty New York pizzas, such as Cheese Pizza ($18.00) and Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza ($19.80).
• Classic Deli & Diner Fare: The shop rounds out its offerings with typical American deli items like Philly Cheese Steaks ($8.80), various burgers ($7.00+), and Chicken Gyros ($8.00).

Contact Information

For New Yorkers needing to place an order, inquire about the menu, or check on delivery, here is the direct contact information for Sunset Coffee Shop.

Address: 5416 2nd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220, USA

Phone: (917) 909-1345

What is Worth Choosing

For a local user navigating the vast dining landscape of New York, Sunset Coffee Shop offers a unique value proposition that makes it worth a visit or a takeout order. The main attraction is the powerful combination of a full-service, diversified menu and neighborhood convenience.

If you’re a New Yorker looking to fuel up with a substantial, culturally specific breakfast, the Dominican Breakfast selections like Mangu or Yuca are not only authentic but offer a hearty, filling start to the day that goes far beyond the typical bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich. For lunch or dinner, the classic Latin Food entrees like the various Rice and Beans specials provide immense value and comfort, acting as reliable staples for a quick and satisfying meal.

Don't overlook the highly praised White Fish Hero, an item specifically called out by a satisfied customer for its freshness and excellent taste, a welcome deviation from the dry versions often found elsewhere. Similarly, the full range of New York Style Pizza and traditional Philly Cheese Steak subs mean that even when you just want classic American comfort food, Sunset Coffee Shop delivers with substantial options.

Ultimately, what’s worth choosing here is the menu's ability to satisfy almost any craving throughout the day, whether you're in the mood for a quick, cheap breakfast on a roll, a massive dinner platter of Latin favorites, or just a quality piece of pizza. It’s a local hub designed for maximum variety, appealing to the diverse dietary and cultural preferences of the Sunset Park community. However, given the serious allegation of racial discrimination, we recommend potential customers consider this information carefully as part of their decision-making process.

A Deep Dive into Menu Variety

To truly appreciate the scope of this Brooklyn eatery, a closer look at the menu reveals its dedication to variety. From early morning to late night, the offerings are extensive. The Breakfast Sandwiches section alone includes classics like Bacon Eggs & Cheese ($6.00) and healthier alternatives like Turkey Bacon Eggs & Cheese ($5.50), catering to different preferences and budgets. The price points remain competitive for the New York area, especially for a large selection.

Moving beyond breakfast, the Appetizers are perfect for a quick snack or a side to a larger meal, featuring staples like Hot Wings ($7.00), Mozzarella Sticks ($6.50), and simple French Fries ($3.30). The availability of these items alongside traditional Latin dishes speaks to the shop's multi-cuisine approach.

The lunch and dinner service is bolstered by the Burgers and Sub Sandwiches section. Here, you find classic deli fare elevated with combo options. A Double Cheeseburger is listed at $7.70, and a Philly Cheese Steak at $8.80, both available as combos with fries and a soda for just a few dollars more. This is an excellent feature for New Yorkers seeking value without sacrificing a filling meal.

Finally, the dedication to providing full-plate meals is clear in the Rice Specialties, which include Baked Chicken, Rice and Salad Special and Pepper Steak, Rice and Salad Special, each priced around $12.00. These options provide a balanced, complete meal that is a hallmark of Latin dining and a welcome option for anyone seeking a substantial, home-style dinner in the city. The broad appeal across American, Latin, and Pizza categories solidifies the Sunset Coffee Shop's status as a comprehensive neighborhood food provider in Brooklyn.

Sunset Coffee Shop

5416 2nd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220, USA