Sweet Treats On the Wharf: Long Island's Award-Winning Dessert Destination

Sweet Treats On the Wharf Introduce

Introduction / Overview

When New Yorkers think of a perfect summer day or a special indulgence, the ideal dessert shop is always part of the picture. On Long Island, and specifically in the charming waterfront community of Port Washington, that establishment is unequivocally

Sweet Treats On the Wharf

. This venue is far more than a simple

Ice cream shop

; it operates as a full-service

Dessert shop

Bakery

, and

Coffee shop

, making it a comprehensive destination for all things sweet and celebratory.

Sweet Treats On the Wharf

holds an impressive distinction in the competitive New York market: it has been named the "Best Ice Cream on Long Island" for six consecutive years, and the "Best Milkshake on Long Island" for five consecutive years, according to the Bethpage Best of LI Awards. This continuous, multi-year recognition is a powerful testament to the superior quality and dedication behind every scoop and shake. Customers are drawn by the promise of genuinely

homemade ice cream

, which is made the "old-fashioned way, one tub at a time," ensuring a dense, creamy, super-premium product.

The appeal of this establishment is dual-layered. First is the extraordinary food quality, praised by a customer who noted that the ice cream is not "too sweet," making flavors like

Heath Bar Crunch

and

Strawberry

particularly delicious. Second is the environment, with its desirable location "near the picturesque waterfront," creating a perfect backdrop for enjoying a treat. The shop is a local institution, formerly known as Douglas & James, and its opening signals the official start of warm weather fun for Port Washington residents. With a massive catalog of more than 50 rotating flavors, including unique concoctions and seasonal specials,

Sweet Treats On the Wharf

is a must-visit for every Long Island resident and visitor.

Location and Accessibility

Sweet Treats On the Wharf

is ideally located at 405 Main St, Port Washington, NY 11050, USA. This Main Street address is crucial, as it places the dessert shop directly at the heart of the community and, most importantly, right near the waterfront. This geographical advantage is a significant feature, allowing patrons to enjoy their award-winning treats while taking in the "perfect place to take a walk afterwards" and enjoying the scenery.

The Port Washington location makes it easily accessible for families and groups across Nassau County. A strong commitment to accessibility ensures that all community members can enjoy the shop. The provided information specifically highlights both a

Wheelchair accessible entrance

and

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

. These essential amenities remove barriers for customers, ensuring that mobility is never an issue when visiting the area’s favorite dessert spot.

Operating hours are particularly appealing for the New York user looking for an evening treat, with the shop open seven days a week from 12:00 to 22:00. This generous schedule caters to everything from an afternoon coffee stop to a late-night ice cream craving after dinner or a local event. The combination of a central, desirable waterfront location, excellent accessibility, and extended operating hours solidifies

Sweet Treats On the Wharf

as a highly convenient and essential local establishment for Long Island.

Services Offered

As a multi-faceted business,

Sweet Treats On the Wharf

delivers a range of services that extend far beyond simply scooping ice cream, catering to a wide variety of customer needs and preferences.

Specialized Ice Cream Retail: Serving super-premium,
homemade ice cream
with a constantly rotating selection from a catalog of over 50 flavors, including classics and innovative creations.
Award-Winning Milkshakes: Providing the celebrated milkshakes that have consistently won "Best of LI" awards, customizable with any of the available ice cream flavors.
Bakery Goods: Offering various
Bakery
items, complementing the ice cream and fulfilling the shop’s identity as a comprehensive
Dessert shop
.
Coffee Service: Functioning as a
Coffee shop
, serving hot beverages perfect for pairing with desserts or simply for an afternoon pick-me-up.
Custom Creations and Tasting: Encouraging customers to
Custom Creations
for sundaes or milkshakes and providing
Free samples are always available
to try new flavors before purchase.
Dietary Options: Committing to serving various dietary needs, including the announced plan to offer
vegan ice cream
made with all dairy-free products.
Extended Operating Hours: Providing service every day from 12:00 to 22:00 (10:00 PM), ensuring accessibility for both daytime and evening visitors.

Features / Highlights

The defining characteristics of

Sweet Treats On the Wharf

are rooted in its dedication to product excellence and its integral role as a community gathering space, particularly around the waterfront.

Consecutive Award Winner: The shop holds prestigious and consistent titles for "Best Ice Cream on Long Island" (six years) and "Best Milkshake on Long Island" (five years), establishing its market leadership.
Super-Premium, Homemade Product: Ice cream is made fresh
every day on site
using the
old-fashioned way
, ensuring a quality and texture that commercial ice creams cannot match. The flavor profile is noted for being less excessively sweet, appealing to a mature palate.
Vast Flavor Library: Maintains a catalog of
more than 50 flavors
, including unique and highly anticipated options like
Chunk Doughboy Delight
,
Coffee Toffee
, and
Wild Maine Blueberry
, guaranteeing variety for repeat visits.
Iconic Waterfront Location: Situated right
on the Wharf
, offering customers a scenic setting to enjoy their treats, enhancing the overall experience with beautiful views and easy access to local walks.
Community and Tradition: Known locally as the spot that marks
the beginning of warm weather fun
, the shop operates with a deep connection to the Port Washington community, with the owners having served customers for over three decades.
Inclusive Accessibility: Provides both a
Wheelchair accessible entrance
and
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
, underscoring its commitment to serving all community members.

Contact Information

For residents and visitors in the Port Washington area looking to indulge in an award-winning dessert experience, the contact information for

Sweet Treats On the Wharf

is listed below.

Address: 405 Main St, Port Washington, NY 11050, USA

Phone: (516) 708-1706

Mobile Phone: +1 516-708-1706

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing

Sweet Treats On the Wharf

is an obvious decision for New York users seeking the best in dessert quality and environment. The primary reason is the objective, verifiable proof of quality: its reign as the continuous winner for Long Island’s best ice cream and milkshakes. When a business consistently earns such high honors in the competitive NYC metro food scene, it reflects an unwavering commitment to excellence that is worth seeking out.

The experience of tasting the super-premium,

homemade ice cream

is the reward. Customers are guaranteed a product made

one tub at a time

on-site, a method that results in a superior, less air-filled, and more intensely flavored dessert. The ability to choose from a vast, rotating catalog of over 50 flavors means every visit can be a new adventure, whether you prefer the classic creaminess of

brownie

and

cookies and cream

or want to try the seasonally inspired and innovative creations.

Furthermore, the value of the location cannot be overstated. Grabbing a treat and enjoying it by the waterfront provides a distinctly Long Island, relaxing experience that elevates a simple dessert run into a pleasant outing. The shop’s dedication to serving the community, including its generous hours (open until 10:00 PM every night) and focus on accessibility, makes it a highly dependable and welcoming institution.

Sweet Treats On the Wharf

is not just an

Ice cream shop

; it is the place where quality, tradition, and community meet, making it the definitive choice for sweets in Port Washington.

Sweet Treats On the Wharf Details

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Sweet Treats On the Wharf Photos

Sweet Treats On the Wharf Location

Sweet Treats On the Wharf

New York Nassau County Port Washington Main Street

405 Main St, Port Washington, NY 11050, USA

Sweet Treats On the Wharf Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 184 user reviews.

flavorscashice cream shopsummerpistachioscoopswatercupshaved iceantiques

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Not every Italian ice cream shop is worth it, but this one definitely is! If you don’t like ice cream that’s too sweet, this place is a must-try. The Heath Bar Crunch and Strawberry flavors are especially delicious. This is now my new favorite to-go spot for ice cream.
August 17 · Cady Y
Great ice cream and view perfect place to take a walk afterwards.
September 13 · Samson S
Awesome place Best ice cream. Creamy lots of flavors. My only place for ice cream
July 31 · Alex the great
I always feel like a kid coming back here. Feels so nostalgic and homey. The ice cream is delicious. Worth the drive.
July 26 · Meni Mor
Love itThe prices is little expensive but really good amount of ice cream3$ for mini cup6$ for small cup .. one scoop but it is a huge scoop like the one in the picThank you
July 31 · Sara Soltan