Taste of Italia - Sandwich Shop & Caterer

- 229 Elm St, Elmwood Park, NJ 07407

For residents across North Jersey and Bergen County, finding a truly authentic, generously portioned Italian hero or a hearty, freshly prepared meal is a local priority. Taste of Italia - Sandwich Shop & Caterer, located right in the heart of Elmwood Park, has established itself as a premier destination that delivers on that expectation. More than just a simple sandwich counter, this local favorite combines the heart of a classic Italian restaurant and deli with the convenience of a modern lunch spot and professional caterer, serving up comfort food and classic Italian flavors to the community.

Taste of Italia is renowned for its commitment to quality and the sheer size of its offerings. Customers consistently praise the "huge sandwiches" and "really fair prices," noting that heroes are "generously stacked with meat and cheese." Since its establishment in 1993 (or 1994, depending on the source), the goal has remained simple: to be a welcoming, "pull-up-a-chair" place that serves food customers will want to order again and again. Their menu showcases an inspiring variety, ensuring that whether you’re a purist craving a classic Italian sub or seeking a unique, inventive specialty, you’ll find something to satisfy your appetite.

The culinary focus here is unequivocally on homemade quality. Many of the ingredients, including their meats, sauces, and dressings, are prepared by hand, ensuring that every bite truly tastes homemade. This dedication to fresh preparation, premium cold cuts, high-quality cheeses, and daily baked bread elevates a simple sandwich into a memorable meal, solidifying the shop’s reputation as a cornerstone of Elmwood Park’s local dining scene.

The popularity of Taste of Italia extends beyond just its delicious subs; it’s also a go-to spot for a full spectrum of Italian-American lunch and dinner classics, including salads, pasta, and specialized local heroes named after Elmwood Park landmarks or traditions. Known locally as simply "Taste," its reputation is built on consistency and friendly, competent service, making every visit a pleasant experience for both regulars and first-time guests.

Taste of Italia is conveniently situated at 229 Elm St, Elmwood Park, NJ 07407, USA. This North Jersey location in Bergen County makes it easily accessible for customers throughout the surrounding towns and neighborhoods. Its placement in a local community setting means it avoids the hassle of major commercial thoroughfare traffic, offering a more relaxed experience.

For those planning a visit, accessibility is straightforward. The shop is noted for being "easy to get to," and parking is readily available. Patrons can take advantage of the free street parking in the immediate vicinity, making quick pickups and dine-in visits hassle-free. The shop offers flexible service options to accommodate all local needs, ensuring that whether you're passing through or stopping in specifically for a meal, the experience is smooth and convenient.

The dining environment at Taste of Italia is characterized by a casual and quiet atmosphere. It’s a family-friendly spot, known to welcome groups and individuals alike. The establishment prides itself on being an inclusive space, identified as both LGBTQ+ friendly and a transgender safe space. Additionally, they accept a variety of modern payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, providing convenience at checkout.

Taste of Italia provides a comprehensive range of dining and professional food services to the local New Jersey community:

• Full-Service Catering: Specializing in catering for events of all sizes, from office lunches and team events to family celebrations and parties, featuring party heroes, hot buffets, and diverse platters.
• Takeout and Dine-in: Offering quick and convenient options for those who prefer to eat on the go or enjoy a casual meal with seating available in a comfortable setting.
• Delivery and No-Contact Delivery: Partnering with various platforms to ensure meals can be brought directly to the customer’s home or office in the local area.
• Complete Meal Service: Open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, catering to all mealtime needs throughout the day.
• Online Ordering: Offering fast and secure online ordering systems for both pickup and delivery, simplifying the process for busy customers.

The menu at Taste of Italia goes far beyond the standard deli fare, featuring a vast selection of specialty items and signature recipes:

• Massive Sandwich Selection: Featuring over 50 classic and reinvented subs, including the "Gianna Supreme," "Mikey Special," "Delo Supreme," and the highly-regarded Italian hero.
• Signature Specialty Subs: Unique hot sandwiches like the "Chicken Ala Vodka" (a top-liked item with homemade vodka sauce), "The Duffy" (with chicken, bacon, melted mozzarella, and brown gravy), and the "Eggplant Supreme."
• Homemade Meatball Creations: A dedicated line of unique meatball heroes, such as the "Disco Ball" (meatball, French fries, American cheese, and brown gravy), "Supreme Ball" (meatballs, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, and marinara), and the "Christian Combo" (meatballs and sweet sausage).
• Elmwood Park Specials: Local favorites like "The Crusader" (sliced steak, potatoes, onion rings, peppers, and cheese) and "The Bomber" (roast beef, American cheese, potatoes, and brown gravy) served on toasted hero rolls.
• Diverse Offerings: A full menu that includes pasta specials (like Penne Pasta Special), fresh salads (Tuna Tossed Salad, Grilled Chicken Salad, Chef Salad), side orders (Mozzarella Sticks, Onion Rings, French Fries), and classic breakfast heroes and platters.
• Health-Conscious Options: Featuring "healthy options" and a full selection of salads for those seeking lighter fare.

To place an order, inquire about catering, or find out more about the daily specials, New Jersey residents can reach out using the following details:

Address: 229 Elm St, Elmwood Park, NJ 07407, USA

Phone: (201) 797-6897

For New Jersey residents, choosing Taste of Italia means opting for an authentic, high-value local dining experience. It is not simply a quick-stop sandwich joint, but an Italian deli dedicated to serving substantial, flavorful, and freshly prepared food. The value proposition is clear: you receive a generously-sized, quality meal at an affordable price point, a fact consistently highlighted in local customer reviews.

Customers looking for quality ingredients will appreciate the use of fresh produce, premium cold cuts, and homemade preparations. Whether you are craving the classic cold cuts of an Italian hero, the warm comfort of a specialty hot sub like the Chicken Ala Vodka, or need reliable, delicious catering for an event, Taste of Italia delivers. The combination of a vast and creative menu, large portions, fair prices, and a commitment to friendly, local service makes this Elmwood Park staple a must-try destination for any sandwich or Italian food lover in the Bergen County area and beyond. It’s a genuine taste of North Jersey Italian comfort food, served up with a smile.

Taste of Italia - Sandwich Shop & Caterer

229 Elm St, Elmwood Park, NJ 07407, USA