Teddy's Restaurant & Bar

- 718 Meacham Ave, Elmont, NY 11003

Welcome to the heart of Long Island's culinary scene, where local tradition and exceptional food come together in a truly unique neighborhood establishment. Teddy's Restaurant & Bar, nestled in Elmont, New York, is much more than just a place to grab a slice—it’s a local institution. Far from the typical bustling Manhattan or Brooklyn spot, Teddy's offers a cozy, friendly, and notably authentic experience that has cemented its status as a hidden gem for Long Island residents and visitors in the know.

Specializing in both beloved Italian-style dishes and classic bar fare, Teddy’s is most famous for one particular item: its legendary bar pie pizza. This style of pizza is celebrated for its thin, crispy crust and perfect balance of cheese and sauce, often described by customers as the best they have ever tasted. The establishment offers a delightful trip back in time, boasting a classic, old-school aesthetic that some customers have affectionately described as a "time capsule." This casual and cozy atmosphere, combined with fast and friendly service, makes Teddy's the go-to destination for a reliably delicious dinner, a late-night snack, or a place to simply relax with a drink.

The combination of a top-tier pizza parlor and a well-stocked local bar creates a versatile space that caters to various occasions, whether it’s a solo dinner, an outing with family, or a night out with friends. From the moment you step inside, the comfortable vibe and dedication to quality comfort food are immediately apparent. Teddy's Restaurant & Bar is a true testament to the enduring appeal of the classic, unpretentious neighborhood spot.

Location and Accessibility

Teddy's Restaurant & Bar is conveniently located in the Nassau County town of Elmont, New York, making it an accessible spot for many Long Islanders and New York City travelers exploring the outer boroughs and beyond. It’s situated just off a major thoroughfare, yet maintains the intimate feel of a local, community-focused establishment.

The full address is: 718 Meacham Ave, Elmont, NY 11003, USA.

For patrons arriving by car, the restaurant offers the convenience of free street parking nearby, a welcome amenity in the greater New York area. Furthermore, Teddy's is committed to ensuring a welcoming environment for all guests, offering several key accessibility features.

Specific accessibility provisions include:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible restroom
• Wheelchair accessible seating

This dedication to accessibility, coupled with the ease of parking, ensures that Teddy's is a viable and stress-free option for a wide range of customers looking for an enjoyable dining and bar experience in Elmont.

Services Offered

Teddy's Restaurant & Bar is designed to be a full-service, all-purpose local hub, providing a variety of service options and amenities to suit nearly any plan. Whether you are seeking a full sit-down meal or a quick bite and drink to go, the establishment has you covered with flexible service modes and a comprehensive menu.

Core services and offerings include:

• Dining options available for dinner with table service.
• A casual, cozy atmosphere that is perfect for families, groups, and solo diners.
• Flexible pickup and delivery with Curbside pickup and Takeout service options.
• A well-appointed Bar onsite serving a wide variety of beverages.
• The crowd is known to be Family-friendly, accommodating Groups, and is LGBTQ+ friendly.
• An extensive beverage list featuring Alcohol, Beer, Cocktails, Hard liquor, and Wine.
• The menu is focused on comfort food, Quick bites, and Small plates, alongside the famed pizza and Italian fare.
• A special provision for late-night food for those craving a snack or a pie after regular hours.
• Fast service, ensuring a quick and efficient experience for all patrons.
• Payment is convenient, though it is a cash-only establishment, so patrons should plan accordingly.
• For those with pets, dogs are allowed inside and outside, adding to the neighborhood-friendly vibe.
• Restrooms are available for customer use.

Features / Highlights

The distinctive appeal of Teddy's Restaurant & Bar stems from its unique blend of traditional charm, specialized food quality, and a welcoming bar culture. It’s the kind of place locals depend on for both a celebratory meal and a relaxing evening.

The primary features and highlights that set Teddy’s apart include:

• Legendary Bar Pie Pizza: A major draw, the thin, crispy, flavorful pizza is consistently praised by reviewers and long-time customers as being among the best in the region. It’s noted for its distinct texture and perfectly balanced ingredients.
• Classic, Cozy Atmosphere: The venue is a genuine 'time capsule' offering an old-school, authentic Long Island neighborhood experience with a casual, comfortable ambiance that makes everyone feel at home.
• Exceptional Bar Program: Teddy's is highlighted for both its Great beer selection and Great cocktails, providing a quality experience for anyone looking to enjoy an alcoholic beverage.
• Fast Service: The staff is known for their efficiency and speed, a key highlight for customers seeking a quick and satisfying meal or drink.
• Sports-Friendly Venue: The bar area is a popular spot for Sports enthusiasts, making it an excellent location to catch a game while enjoying quality drinks and food.
• Perfect for Solo Diners: It is a Popular for Solo dining, indicating a comfortable and unintimidating environment for individuals seeking a meal or drink alone.
• Family-Owned Feel: Customers often praise the feeling of authentic, family-run care and commitment to great food and value.

Contact Information

For those in the New York area planning a visit, wanting to inquire about the menu, or looking to place a takeout order, the contact information for Teddy’s Restaurant & Bar is readily available.

• Address: 718 Meacham Ave, Elmont, NY 11003, USA
• Phone: (516) 825-9827
• Mobile Phone: +1 516-825-9827

What is Worth Choosing

When considering a visit to Teddy's Restaurant & Bar in Elmont, the choice becomes clear for those who value authenticity, quality, and a relaxed atmosphere. The reviews consistently point to the establishment's unwavering commitment to its signature dish and overall customer experience.

The primary item worth choosing is, without a doubt, the pizza. It is the core of the restaurant’s fame, described as "amazing" with an out-of-this-world flavor and a crust that is "thin and crispy." The bar pie is not just food; it is an experience that transports diners back to the "Long Island of the past," where local joints served up consistently great food with a friendly, welcoming spirit. For pizza aficionados, it's considered a "MUST try" and arguably the "best bar pie" they’ve ever had. If you appreciate a traditional, no-frills, high-quality pie with a perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio, this is your destination.

Beyond the pizza, Teddy's offers exceptional value and an overall fun experience. It's a place where life-long memories are made, often described as a great dive with an authentic vibe. The bar is highly recommended for its Great beer selection and Great cocktails, ensuring the beverage pairing for your comfort food is just as satisfying as the meal itself. For those seeking affordable drinks and a full glass, customers are repeatedly satisfied with the "best bang for your buck."

In summary, if you are located in the New York region and searching for a dining experience that combines exceptional, authentic Italian comfort food—especially a top-tier bar pie—with a friendly, cozy, sports-friendly bar atmosphere, Teddy's Restaurant & Bar should be at the top of your list. It's a genuine local treasure that offers great service, great food, and great value, embodying the very best of a classic neighborhood bar and pizza joint. Visiting Teddy's is not just about eating; it’s about discovering one of Long Island's true "hidden gems."

Teddy's Restaurant & Bar

718 Meacham Ave, Elmont, NY 11003, USA