Italian American Bakery Introduce
For residents of the New York metropolitan area, particularly those in Nassau County, the pursuit of truly authentic, high-quality baked goods often leads them to a cherished local institution: Italian American Bakery. Located in Franklin Square, this bakery is more than just a place to buy bread; it’s a living tradition that brings the rich, delicious culinary artistry of Italian-American pastry to Long Island. It serves as a classic
Bakery
that has woven itself into the fabric of the community, catering to everything from daily bread needs to spectacular birthday and holiday celebrations.The establishment offers a comprehensive and impressive array of baked items. From crusty, fragrant
Italian Bread With & Without Seeds
and traditionalSemolina Bread
to an "art gallery of flavor" in its pastry and cake cases, Italian American Bakery is a one-stop shop for sweet and savory cravings. As noted by a long-time customer, the bakery’s commitment to quality ensures that cakes remainsoft, moist, flavor full
even days after purchase, a testament to their dedication to fresh, classic ingredients and expert preparation. This deep-rooted authenticity and commitment to quality make it a trusted source for New Yorkers preparing for any special event or simply seeking a delightful everyday treat.The experience is focused on efficiency and quality, making it ideal for a
Quick visit
for those on a tight New York schedule. The friendly service, as highlighted by multiple patrons, enhances the local, welcoming feel, transforming a simple transaction into a pleasant neighborhood interaction. Whether it's the highly anticipatedCannoli
, a slice of the best-tastingStrawberry Shortcake
, or a selection of traditionalItalian Cookies
, this Franklin Square bakery is a must-visit destination for those who value genuine Italian baked excellence.Italian American Bakery enjoys a prime location on a central avenue in Franklin Square, Long Island, making it an accessible spot for both local residents and those traveling from other parts of Nassau County or Queens. The exact address is
727 Franklin Ave, Franklin Square, NY 11010, USA
.Franklin Avenue is a major commercial corridor, ensuring high visibility and easy navigation for drivers. While parking details are not specified, its location in a suburban business district often implies street parking is available, catering to the common travel method for New York residents outside of the city center. Crucially, the bakery is attentive to physical access, offering a
Wheelchair accessible entrance
, which ensures that all members of the community can enjoy their delicious offerings without hindrance.The central location in Franklin Square makes it a convenient stop for those running errands, commuting, or planning a party, reinforcing its role as a key neighborhood supplier of essential and celebratory baked goods for the entire area.
Italian American Bakery specializes in efficient and quality-focused services, designed to quickly deliver fresh products to its New York customers:
Takeout
Service: The primary service model, focused on quick and efficient acquisition of baked goods for enjoyment elsewhere.- Special Occasion Cakes: Offering a variety of ready-made and presumably custom-order cakes, including specialty items like
7" Cannoli Cream Cake
andTiramisu Cake
. - Party-Sized Desserts: Catering to large New York parties with unique offerings like the
Jumbo Party Cannoli
. - Daily Fresh Bread: A constant supply of essential baked items like
Italian Bread With & Without Seeds
andKaiser Rolls
. - Modern Payments: Accepting convenient
Debit cards
andNFC mobile payments
, streamlining the checkout process for aQuick visit
. - Large and Mini Pastries: Providing flexibility for individual enjoyment (
Large Pastries
) or party platters (Mini Pastries
).
The distinctive features and highlights of Italian American Bakery lie in the quality of its products and the authenticity of its Italian-American heritage:
- Authentic Italian Pastries: Highly praised for classic pastries, including
Cannoli
,Cherry Turnover
, andEclairs
, confirming its reputation as a "Very nice Italian bakery!!!!" - Specialty Italian Cookies: Offering traditional and prized cookies like
Rainbow Cookies
and the expensive, high-qualityPignoli Cookies
. - Diverse Cake Selection: A wide array of specialty cakes, from classic favorites like
7" Strawberry Shortcake
and7" Carrot Cake
to Italian-inspired flavors such as7" Cannoli Cream Cake
. - Cheesecake Variety: Featuring traditional Italian-style
Italian Ricotta Cheesecake
alongside classicPlain Cheesecake
andMarble Cheesecake
. - Fresh Bread Staples: Supplying daily essentials like
Semolina Bread
,Frizelle
, and convenient rawPizza Dough
. - Customer Longevity: The bakery boasts a loyal customer base, with patrons noting they have been returning since childhood, a strong indicator of its consistent quality and local importance.
To place an order for a special occasion cake, check on the daily bread selection, or simply inquire about their current pastry offerings, please use the following contact information:
Address: 727 Franklin Ave, Franklin Square, NY 11010, USA
Phone (Primary): (516) 561-6711
Mobile Phone (Alternative): +1 516-561-6711
For New York users planning a visit to Italian American Bakery, the most worthwhile choices are those that reflect its Italian heritage and the items highly praised by the local community.
First, for special occasions or family gatherings, one of their **Signature Cakes** is a must-choose. The
7" Strawberry Shortcake
received exceptional praise, being described assoft, moist, flavor full
, and the "best ever tasted," even two days after purchase. Similarly, the **Cannoli Cream Cake** and **Tiramisu Cake** represent classic Italian desserts that are essential purchases from an authentic Italian-American bakery.Second, prioritize the **Pastries** and **Cookies**. The **Cannoli** is explicitly mentioned by one excited customer as a future order, indicating its high reputation. The
Mini Pastries
are excellent for creating a stunning, varied dessert platter for any party, while the selection ofItalian Cookies
and specialty **Pignoli Cookies** are perfect for gifting or serving with coffee. One reviewer specifically complimented thecannoli, cherry danish, danish cup with fruit and cream, and an eclair
, providing an excellent starter list for pastry sampling.Finally, do not overlook the **Bread** section. Picking up a loaf of
Semolina Bread With & Without Seeds
or the essentialItalian Bread With & Without Seeds
ensures you bring home a piece of their daily fresh baking tradition. For the busy host, even the ready-to-usePizza Dough
is a convenient, high-quality option for a quick Italian dinner at home. Italian American Bakery’s focus on genuine flavors and community-endorsed quality guarantees a worthwhile purchase every time.Italian American Bakery Food & drink
Bread
- Small Round Bread $4.50
- Kaiser Rolls $1.00
- Large Round Bread $5.99
- Breadsticks $9.99
Long stick shaped baked bread.
- Pizza Dough $2.99
Whole wheat, semolina or regular.
- Breadcrumbs $2.99
- Semolina Bread With & Without Seeds $3.99
- Frizelle $9.99
Per lb.
- Italian Bread With & Without Seeds $3.99
Cakes
- 7" Strawberry Shortcake $35.00
- Tiramisu Cake $45.00
Coffee soaked cake with chocolate and mascarpone cheese.
- 7" Red Velvet Cake $39.99
- 7" Rainbow Cookie Cake $35.00
- 7" Vanilla Buttercream $35.00
- 7" Chocolate Mousse $39.99
- Pretzel Cake $25.00
- 7" Carrot Cake $39.99
Sweet and moist spice cake.
- 7" Cannoli Cream Cake $35.00
Fried pastry with a sweet creamy filling.
Cheesecake & Fruit Tarts
- 7" Plain Cheesecake $32.99
- 7" Plain Cheesecake With Fruit $39.99
- 7” Marble Cheesecake $35.99
- 7” Italian Ricotta Cheesecake $35.99
Special Items
- Jumbo Party Cannoli $109.99
For more information, please call us the restaurant.
Pastries
- Large Pastries $7.99
- Mini Pastries $23.99
Per lb.
- Cupcakes $5.99
Cookies
- Rainbow Cookies $24.99
- Italian Cookies $17.99
- Butter Cookies $20.99
- Pignoli Cookies $39.99
Pies
- Pies $26.99
- 7" Fruit Custard Pie $35.99
Blueberry, strawberry, and kiwi.
Danishes & Turnovers
- Apple Turnover $4.99
Folded and stuffed pastry dough..
- Brownies $5.99
- Cherry Turnover $4.99
Folded and stuffed pastry dough.
- Chocolate Cigars $5.99
- Linzer Tarts $5.99
- Raspberry Cigars $5.99
- Blueberry Turnover $4.99
Folded and stuffed pastry dough.
- Danishes $4.99
Flaky pastry with a sweet filling.
- Sugar Free Turnover $4.49
Folded and stuffed pastry dough.
- Crumb Cakes $3.99
- Coffee Rings $16.99
Italian American Bakery Details
Service options
- Takeout
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Italian American Bakery Photos










Italian American Bakery Location
Italian American Bakery
727 Franklin Ave, Franklin Square, NY 11010, USA
Italian American Bakery Reviews
pricescannolicookiessquareslobstervanillaholidayfrostingchocolate chipschristmas
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1First, I have to say that I have been going to this bakery since I was a kid. It was good, for a while, it wasn’t so good, But it has always been my go to every time I come into town. And this time, it was great! An art gallery of flavor. I bought my Ma’s favorite cake for her birthday, Strawberry Shortcake. I bought it Friday with intention to present it that evening to her but our day of fun got away from us and we completely forgot it in the fridge. We brought it to my brother’s house for Father’s Day Sunday and much to our delight it was still soft, moist, flavor full and Mom said it is the best she ever tasted, it was a big hit at the party. Thank you to the Lady and gentlemen who helped me. They both were extremely nice, friendly, pleasant and happy. I look forward to going back for the Cannoli and Tiramisu. Great, thank you, keep it up.
June 18 · Christopher Scoma, DC, NMTAmato Sweet Home BakeryFranklin SquareLong Island, New YorkDelicious pastries hands down!!!! I usually order a cannoli, cherry danish, danish cup with fruit and cream, an eclair, a little cheesecake topped with red berries, and it all was very good and well baked! Very nice Italian bakery!!!!My photos are below from today. 11/14/21.
June 28 · Tayler FisherAmato Sweet Home BakeryLayout/atmosphere*Small bakery; tables on sidewalk; parking lotFood/drink*Cannoli (with chocolate chips) - quite good; large amount of cream; good crunch on the shell; hint of sweetness in both the cream and shell itself*Raspberry crumb cake - above average; not much filling
September 29 · Daniel PinoI always come here for the rainbow cookie cake !!! Perfect for the person that likes rainbow cookies.
May 26 · Cindy B.The worst bakery I ever came across. The red velvet cake taste like cough syrup and old.My kids who loves cake gave up on cake after trying cake from this bakery lol. Even the lady have a bad attitude.. I’ll give them a negative 10 if I could.
May 30 · Shehara Gunasekara
More restaurants near me

727 Franklin Ave U, Franklin Square, NY 11010, USA

700 A Franklin Ave Suite A, Franklin Square, NY 11010, USA

1591 Dutch Broadway, Valley Stream, NY 11580, USA

1591 Dutch Broadway, Valley Stream, NY 11580, USA

1625 Dutch Broadway, Elmont, NY 11003, USA

1629 Dutch Broadway, Elmont, NY 11003, USA

1627 Dutch Broadway, Elmont, NY 11003, USA

434 Dogwood Ave #3349, Franklin Square, NY 11010, USA

902 Niagara St, Elmont, NY 11003, USA

258 Rockaway Pkwy, Valley Stream, NY 11580, USA

254 Rockaway Pkwy, Valley Stream, NY 11580, USA

1767 Dutch Broadway, Elmont, NY 11003, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Dining Insights Posts





