The Otter

- 58 Thompson St, New York, NY 10012

Introduction / Overview

New York City's dining scene is a world unto itself, and finding a restaurant that feels like a quiet, coastal retreat in the middle of Manhattan is a rare treat. The Otter, a seafood and American restaurant located on Thompson Street, is one of those unique finds. More than just a place to eat, it offers a magical and serene dining experience that feels like an escape from the city's frantic pace. Situated on a tree-lined street and offering a charming outdoor dining area, it brings a fresh, coastal-inspired vibe to the heart of SoHo. It’s an ideal spot for a leisurely meal, whether you're a local looking for a new favorite or a tourist seeking a tranquil, high-quality dining experience.

The restaurant’s concept is straightforward and elegant: a focus on simply prepared seafood using the freshest ingredients. The menu is a testament to this philosophy, featuring a raw bar with impeccably fresh offerings like oysters and tuna tartare, as well as a selection of "Simply Prepared" fish and classic American dishes. The ambiance is a major part of its appeal. The interior has a trendy, polished feel, while the outdoor seating area has a cozy, "secret garden" charm, complete with string lights and comfortable seating. The Otter also stands out for its well-curated drink program, boasting a great wine list and creative cocktails that complement the food beautifully. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply looking for a quality meal in a relaxed setting, The Otter's combination of a warm atmosphere, friendly service, and delicious, no-gimmicks food makes it a standout destination in downtown New York.

Location and Accessibility

The Otter is perfectly nestled at 58 Thompson St, New York, NY 10012, USA, placing it in one of Manhattan's most desirable and vibrant neighborhoods: SoHo. Thompson Street is known for its charming, quieter atmosphere compared to the main thoroughfares of SoHo, which adds to the restaurant's intimate and relaxed feel. The location is easily accessible for both locals and visitors. It's just a short walk from several major subway stations, including the C and E trains at Spring Street and the N, Q, R, W, and 6 trains at Prince Street and Spring Street, respectively. This makes it a convenient and straightforward destination for anyone using public transportation.

The restaurant is also committed to providing an accessible experience for all patrons. It features both a wheelchair-accessible entrance and wheelchair-accessible seating, ensuring that everyone can comfortably enjoy their meal. The flexible service options, including dine-in and a highly-praised outdoor seating area, cater to different preferences and occasions. The outdoor dining space, in particular, is a highlight and has been described as "magic" and "a breath of fresh air," offering a European cafe vibe right in the middle of Manhattan. The Otter also accepts and recommends dinner reservations, which is a great feature for planning a special night out and ensuring you have a spot at this popular establishment. Its central yet tucked-away location, combined with its accessibility and versatile dining options, makes it a true gem in the neighborhood.

Services Offered

• Dine-in service with both indoor and magical outdoor seating options.
• Accepts reservations, which are recommended for dinner, to ensure a spot.
• Offers brunch, dinner, and dessert with a full menu that includes vegetarian options.
• Provides table service with a friendly and attentive staff.
• Features a full bar onsite, serving cocktails, beer, hard liquor, and wine.

Features / Highlights

• A great selection of creative cocktails and a curated wine list.
• Specializes in fresh seafood with a focus on a raw bar and simply prepared dishes.
• Offers a cozy and trendy atmosphere that is ideal for groups and solo diners alike.
• Known for its warm hospitality and fast, professional service.
• Features live music and live performances, adding to the vibrant atmosphere.
• Provides amenities such as a bar onsite, restrooms, and Wi-Fi.
• A popular spot for dinner and solo dining.
• A welcoming venue for a variety of crowds, including locals and tourists.

Contact Information

Address: 58 Thompson St, New York, NY 10012, USA

Phone: (929) 651-5330

What is worth choosing

When you visit The Otter, the menu offers a range of compelling options, but what truly makes it worth choosing are its specialties and core offerings. The seafood is a definite highlight, with the raw bar being a popular starting point. Customers rave about the freshness of the oysters and the quality of dishes like the "Tuna Tartare" and "Scallop Crudo." The "Simply Prepared" section is where the restaurant's philosophy truly shines, offering dishes like the "Faroe Islands Salmon" and "Whole Spanish Branzino," which are prepared with an emphasis on clean, pure flavors. For a heartier meal, the "Whole Lobster" is a classic choice, and the "Fish & Chips," made with beer-battered Spanish mackerel, is also a highly recommended and satisfying dish.

Beyond the seafood, The Otter’s "American restaurant" side of the menu is equally impressive. The "Double Cheeseburger" with a buttery brioche bun and the "Lobster Roll" with its saffron coleslaw are both standouts that have earned high praise. For those looking for something a bit different, the "Parsley Root Agnolotti with Buttered Crab Meat" is a unique and creative dish that showcases the chef's expertise. The drink menu is also a must-explore, with a great wine list and cocktails that are creative and perfectly executed. As one review noted, the drinks are where the restaurant truly shines, offering innovative takes on classics. The fact that the restaurant offers a happy hour with specials on drinks and small bites from 3-6 PM daily makes it an excellent choice for an after-work unwind. The combination of excellent food, a fantastic drink program, and a warm, inviting atmosphere makes The Otter a place to visit for a truly memorable dining experience in SoHo.

The Otter

58 Thompson St, New York, NY 10012, USA