Tilly's Table: Upscale Farm-to-Table Dining and Historic Venue in Brewster, NY

Tilly's Table Introduce

Tilly's Table is a distinguished American restaurant nestled in the picturesque and historic Tilly Foster Farm in Brewster, NY, offering a true farm-to-table dining experience that beautifully blends rustic charm with upscale sophistication. For local New York residents in the Hudson Valley area and those seeking a memorable escape, this venue stands out not just as a place to eat, but as a destination for celebrating life's moments.

The core philosophy of Tilly's Table is showcased through its focus on fresh, local culinary talents and ingredients, many of which are sourced from the Hudson Valley region itself—a key local specialty that patrons can enjoy. The menu features classic American fare elevated with a contemporary, farm-fresh approach. Dishes are prepared to be both flavorful and satisfying, with patrons often praising the generous portion sizes, noting that they get great value from options ranging from expertly cooked prime rib to fresh seafood like Dijon crusted salmon and crab cakes.

The dining options are expansive, covering every part of the day, making it an ideal choice for various occasions. Customers can start their day with a hearty Breakfast, enjoy a relaxed Lunch, or indulge in a highly recommended Brunch on Sundays, which often includes a variety of delicious options and features like bottomless mimosas. The dinner service, available Thursday through Saturday, is particularly popular, offering a more romantic and upscale atmosphere perfect for a date night or celebratory gathering. The restaurant is also known for its specialty nights, such as the Thursday Night Prime Rib and Wine Special.

The ambience of the space is a major highlight, described as a unique combination of Historic and Trendy. The post and beam construction of the building creates a cozy and charming farmhouse aesthetic, while the full transformation of the Tilly Foster Farm into a premier destination adds a layer of rustic elegance. The atmosphere is generally considered Casual yet Upscale, making it appropriate for everything from a quiet solo meal to a large group celebration. The venue is also renowned as a spectacular event space, particularly for weddings, with the newly renovated barn and beautiful outdoor grounds providing a stunning backdrop.

While the overall experience is overwhelmingly positive—especially concerning the beautiful venue and professional staff for events—it is worth noting feedback regarding general dining service. Some customers have reported difficulty getting through by phone to make reservations for a la carte dining, and a review of a concert night mentioned having to eat at the bar as a result. Additionally, while the food is generally good, some dishes have received mixed feedback, such as scallops being "drenched in butter" and wings having an unwelcome batter, while other items like the beet salad were deemed "excellent."

Location and Accessibility

Tilly's Table is conveniently situated in the lower Hudson Valley, making it easily accessible for residents across Putnam, Westchester, and Dutchess Counties, and even for those traveling from New York City via the nearby Metro-North line.

The address is:

100 NY-312, Brewster, NY 10509, USA

The location on the historic Tilly Foster Farm contributes significantly to its atmosphere and accessibility features:

The venue offers ample On-site parking, including a dedicated Free parking lot and free street parking.
It boasts comprehensive accessibility for all guests, including a Wheelchair accessible entrance, Wheelchair accessible parking lot, Wheelchair accessible restroom, and Wheelchair accessible seating.
Its proximity to major routes and the quaint charm of Brewster make it a well-known landmark and an easy-to-find spot for both local groups and tourists.

Services Offered

Tilly's Table provides a robust array of services focused on maximizing convenience and dining flexibility:

Full Dining Options: Available for Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert with professional table service.
Reservations Management: Accepts reservations, with Dinner reservations recommended and Brunch reservations recommended, often requiring reservations due to high popularity.
Private Events & Catering: Functions as a unique event venue, with Catering services for weddings, corporate affairs, graduations, and smaller gatherings in spaces like The Loft or the newly renovated Barn.
Flexible Service Modes: Offers Dine-in, Takeout, and Outdoor seating options.
Onsite Farm Activities: Located on a working farm, guests can enjoy the scenery and sometimes interact with farm animals like horses and alpacas.

Features / Highlights

The unique features of Tilly's Table are numerous, establishing its place as a premier destination in the Hudson Valley:

Farm-to-Table Focus: It Serves local specialty by featuring ingredients grown on-site at Tilly Foster Farm and sourced from the wider Hudson Valley, ensuring fresh and seasonal offerings.
Exceptional Beverage Program: Known for a Great wine list, Great beer selection, and expertly mixed Great cocktails, along with a full bar onsite.
Atmosphere and Ambiance: Features a warm Fireplace, contributing to the Cozy and Romantic setting, and is considered one of the most Upscale dining options in the area.
Entertainment: Frequently hosts Live music and other entertainment, such as comedy nights, enhancing the evening dining experience.
Versatile Venue: The property is an incredibly popular wedding and special event venue, offering beautiful outdoor ceremony sites and a grand barn reception space.
Menu Variety: Caters to diverse dietary needs with Healthy options, Vegetarian options, and the ability to serve comfort food and small plates.

Contact Information

For dining reservations, event inquiries, or other information, please use the following contact details:

Address: 100 NY-312, Brewster, NY 10509, USA
Phone: (845) 808-1840

What is Worth Choosing

Tilly's Table is unequivocally worth choosing for New Yorkers seeking a dining experience that combines exceptional cuisine with an unmatched aesthetic. The primary draw is the authentic farm-to-table American cuisine, which promises freshness and a local connection rarely found in other restaurants. This commitment to local sourcing is reflected across the menu, from hearty comfort food to sophisticated dinner plates.

Beyond the plate, the atmosphere is the reason guests return and recommend. Whether you are looking for a Romantic dinner by the Fireplace or an Upscale Sunday Brunch, the setting on the historic Tilly Foster Farm provides a beautiful and tranquil backdrop. The restaurant’s status as a top-tier event venue—particularly for barn weddings—speaks volumes about the beauty of the property and the professionalism of the staff, who are highly praised for their attentiveness and kindness during large events.

The impressive beverage program, featuring a Great wine list and excellent cocktails, ensures a perfect pairing for any meal. The overall package of accessible luxury, historic charm, genuine hospitality, and commitment to fresh, regional ingredients makes Tilly's Table a premier destination for any meal or celebration in the New York region.

Tilly's Table Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights
Fast service
Fireplace
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Great coffee
Great dessert
Great wine list
Live music
Serves local specialty

Popular for
Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Happy hour food
Hard liquor
Healthy options
Small plates
Vegetarian options
Wine

Dining options
Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Historic
Romantic
Trendy
Upscale

Crowd
Groups
Tourists

Planning
Brunch reservations recommended
Reservations required
Dinner reservations recommended
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
High chairs

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
On-site parking
Parking

Tilly's Table Photos

Tilly's Table Location

Tilly's Table

New York Putnam County Brewster New York 312

100 NY-312, Brewster, NY 10509, USA

Tilly's Table Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 369 user reviews.

brunchbuffetentreesfarmweddingbarnmimosaseveningconcertcrab cakes

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

As life long Hudson Valley locals we have always known about Tillys Foster Farm, we decided to get married here on August 2nd 2025 and had truly the best day ever. From the beginning Maegan was amazing to work with. She was clam, answered our questions- and was genuinely excited for us. She even set up our DIY decor. When the day of came, we worked with Colleen and Nick and they were just as incredible. They ensured our day ran smoothly and that we had everything we needed. We took our photos on the beautiful property, and they came out stunning. There is no shortage of outdoor spots for pictures. Especially if you're looking to capture the true beauty that is this genuine working farm and open outdoor space. Our ceremony was outside in the field and was absolutely flawless. To make my entrance as the bride a surprise I was driven up in a little golf cart with my dad and it was so fun and special. Our cocktail hour was in the restaurant - the food was delicious and the bar and staff were attentivene, kind and fun. The reception was in the barn with again delicious food, incredible staff and the most beautiful space. We had about 120 people and it was perfect. I can't recommend Tillys enough for your big day.
August 09 · Riley
Attended a concert at Tilly's Table. I called REPEATEDLY trying to make a reservation but nobody ever answered the phones. Arrived and had to eat at the bar. Food was good. Wings had a batter on them which brought down the experience. Scallops were drenched in butter. Bar service was very good. Prices were good. Beet salad was excellent.
October 14 · Anthony DelVecchio
This place is beautiful, and the service was exceptional. However, it’s not truly ‘farm-to-table’ in the way you’d experience at the Rockefeller Estate. The ‘market price’ menu for roasted chicken feels odd—MP is usually reserved for 3lb lobsters. Parking is sensational when there’s no major event going on, and I love how pulling in gives off a ‘Yellowstone’ vibe.All in all, it’s absolutely worth a visit. I’d rate it 4.5 stars, but I’m holding back on handing out too many 5-star reviews these days. LOL!But on a serious note - charging for each coffee and seltzer refill is tasteless. That sort of nickel and dime’n doesn’t bring people back. Just a little FYI to the team.
January 11 · Harry Otto
One of the best restaurants in the Hudson Valley. The atmosphere inside is beautiful and the waitstaff is so friendly. The waitresses, bussers, and food runners are always the same each and every weekend we go, and each still is so friendly, knowledgeable, and has wonderful energy as they talk to not just us, but I’ve noticed the other people dining, too. It’s quite refreshing.I always love looking out the windows and enjoying the views of the farmland, animals, and more as I dine. No matter where you sit, you should still be able to get a glimpse out the windows. If you’re a party of two, you get sat along the windows—which I am normally—and truly enjoy my experience so much more because of it. Quite calming to see the horses, if you ask me. Honestly, this and the food is possibly why it’s my fav!Making a reservation is easy, you can do it online though Open Table (when you press to make a reservation on their website, it should send you there). Just make sure to do it well in advance, as this place fills up quite fast. On non-busy weekends, we have gotten last minute tables, but during the busy season, holidays, and summer (because of outdoor seating and the gorgeous views), it’s more difficult!They have a huge gravel parking lot. It’s only a 1-3 minute walk to the entrance, depending on how far back you park. On busy weekends, and especially if someone is having a party, wedding, etc, the parking lot does fill up, but there’s a lot of space to even make more rows. I recommend getting there a few minutes early just to ensure you find a parking spot you’re comfortable with! We’ve never had any issues finding a spot, just sometimes it’ll be alllll the way in the back—even a few times on the grass! But that goes to show just how great and popular this place is.My boyfriend, his family, and I all love Kayleigh (apologies if spelt incorrectly). She’s a true sweetheart who cares so deeply about the people she’s serving! We’ve come so many times that she knows our drinks, starters, and entrees from the start! She works hard, so make sure you tip her good!! 😆Food wise, it’s always such a treat. Each time I go, we always get the giant hot pretzel and fried calamari to start. If I could have the pretzel everyday, I seriously would. It’s the best pretzel I’ve ever had!!! For entree’s, I highly recommend the Rughetta salad, chicken Milanese, Kobe beef burger, filet mignon, penne vodka, homemade Mac and cheese, and so much more!! These are all things I’ve personally tried and have loved. However, my go-to tends to be the rughetta salad (I’d swim in the dressing and tomatoes) just because I always fill up on the calamari and pretzel (it is GIANT)!!They also have a bar. I haven’t sat at it, but it seems lively on the weekend and people seem to enjoy it! The drinks I get (typically coke/pepsi) are always good. The bussers offer pitchers of water for the table in glass vases (in farm to table style) which is nice, or they fill up your glasses as the evening goes on.Cleanliness wise, everything is clean, smells good, organized, not dusty, no water spots on the cutlery/plates, no leftover food on dishes, etc. The bathrooms (located right behind the bar), are always clean and well-kept.Only negative? This place isn’t open m-w, and isn’t open for dinner on Sundays! I’m sure there’s a reason, after all it is a farm, they host events, and more, but I love this place so much and sometimes I just am not available th-sa for dinner, and too busy for lunch on Sunday. But, it makes coming here that much more special knowing that they’re only open a few short days, so make the experience—the pretzel—count!Overall, can’t stress enough how much I loveeeeeee this place! If you’ve read this far, I hope you found it helpful.
June 24 · Paige Ferrier
Tilly's table is a cozy rustic restaurant situated on a farm which I was told is owned and operated by Putnam County. Location is conveniently located within a couple miles from Interstate 84. We had dinner and ordered the crispy calamari with homemade marinara sauce for appetizer and linguini with manilla clams in a white wine and garlic sauce. The service and food were outstanding. Portions are large enough to share and absolutely delicious. Major compliments to the Chef.There are signs posted on the farm that pets are not allowed but we were allowed to bring our dog and sit at a high-top table in bar area of the restaurant which is a major plus for us. Thank you for being a dog friendly establishment and supporting the growing trend of dog lovers. We will definitely be back to visit soon.
November 06 · Scott Floughton