Tony's Pizza

- 1412 St Johns Pl, Brooklyn, NY 11213

Introduction / Overview

Tony's Pizza, a true Brooklyn institution, stands out as a quintessential neighborhood spot for authentic New York-style pizza. Located at 1412 St Johns Pl, this casual and welcoming pizza place has become a favorite among locals for its classic pies and unique menu offerings. More than just a pizzeria, Tony's Pizza has carved out a special niche by blending traditional Italian-American fare with a vibrant touch of Caribbean-inspired flavors, most notably with its Jerk Chicken and Jamaican Beef Patties. The inviting atmosphere and focus on quality make it the perfect destination for a quick lunch, a casual dinner, or a satisfying solo meal. It’s the kind of place where the community gathers, and the simple, flavorful food speaks for itself.

What sets Tony's Pizza apart is its commitment to serving up comfort food that's both delicious and a great value. The menu caters to a wide range of tastes, from classic cheese pizzas that transport you back to the golden age of pizzerias to specialty pies that offer a creative twist on the familiar. The focus is on straightforward, well-executed dishes that satisfy the soul. Many customers rave about the quality of the ingredients, highlighting the flavorful sauce and perfectly crispy crust that defines a truly great New York slice. Beyond the pizza, the menu offers a diverse selection of appetizers, heroes, and specialty rolls, all reflecting the same dedication to good food. Whether you’re grabbing a single slice on the go or settling in for a full meal, Tony’s Pizza delivers a consistently satisfying experience that has earned it a loyal following in the Crown Heights neighborhood.

Location and Accessibility

Tony's Pizza is conveniently located in the vibrant Crown Heights neighborhood of Brooklyn, New York. You can find this local gem at 1412 St Johns Pl, Brooklyn, NY 11213. The area is known for its strong community feel and accessibility, making Tony’s a simple stop for both residents and visitors exploring the area. The restaurant’s location makes it a central hub for those seeking a delicious and reliable meal, whether they're walking from a nearby apartment or driving through the neighborhood. Its proximity to other local businesses and residential streets contributes to its casual and easy-to-reach atmosphere.

When it comes to accessibility, Tony's Pizza makes an effort to accommodate all of its patrons. The establishment features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring that everyone can easily come in and enjoy a meal. The physical layout is designed to be welcoming and functional, allowing for a comfortable experience for all diners. The location on St. Johns Place is well-integrated into the city's infrastructure, which means it’s easily accessible via public transportation and on foot. For those arriving by car, the neighborhood offers various street parking options, although as with any urban area, it’s always a good idea to plan ahead. The welcoming vibe extends to its physical space, making it a stress-free and enjoyable place to visit.

Services Offered

Tony's Pizza provides a variety of services designed to meet the needs of its diverse clientele, whether they prefer to dine in or enjoy their meal at home. The restaurant is committed to convenience and flexibility, offering multiple ways to order and receive your food.

• Curbside Pickup: Customers can place an order and have their food brought out to them at the curb, providing a quick and efficient way to grab a meal without having to leave their vehicle.
• No-Contact Delivery: For those who prefer to stay at home, Tony’s offers a no-contact delivery service through various platforms. This ensures a safe and convenient delivery experience, with the food left at your door.
• Takeout: A traditional and reliable option, customers can call ahead or order in person to pick up their food at their convenience. This is a great choice for a quick, fresh meal on the go.
• Delivery: Beyond no-contact options, the restaurant provides standard delivery services, bringing hot and fresh pizza and other menu items directly to your home or office.
• Dine-in: The casual dining area provides a relaxed and comfortable space for patrons to sit down and enjoy their meal. It's a great option for a break from a busy day or a relaxed dinner with friends and family.
• Outdoor Seating: When the weather permits, Tony’s provides outdoor seating, allowing customers to enjoy their food in the open air, a perfect choice during a nice New York day.
• Accepts Reservations: While it maintains a casual atmosphere, the restaurant is prepared to accept reservations, which can be particularly useful for larger groups or during peak dining hours.

Features / Highlights

Tony’s Pizza stands out for several key features that contribute to its status as a beloved local spot. It’s more than just a pizza shop; it’s a place with a distinct character and a focus on what matters most: good food and a friendly environment.

• Classic and Specialty Pizza: The menu is anchored by a selection of timeless pizzas, including the ever-popular Cheese Pizza. In addition, there are several specialty options like the Tony's Special Vegetarian Pizza, topped with broccoli, spinach, onions, and mushrooms, and the Tony's Meat Lovers Pizza, which is piled high with pepperoni, beef sausage, and meatball. For those who love a bold flavor, the Tony's Garlic Pizza is a must-try.
• Unique Menu Items: In a city filled with pizzerias, Tony’s distinguishes itself with unique offerings. The Jamaican Beef Patties are a fan favorite, providing a flavorful and authentic snack. They also feature a variety of rolls, such as the Pinwheel Pepperoni Roll, which is perfect for a quick bite or an appetizer.
• Value-Driven Specials: Tony's Pizza understands the importance of providing great value. They often have specials, such as the "2 Large Cheese Pizzas Special," which is a fantastic deal for feeding a family or a group of friends. This focus on affordability makes it a go-to choice for a satisfying meal without breaking the bank.
• Family-Friendly Atmosphere: The casual vibe and welcoming environment make it a great place for families. It is known to be a good spot for kids, making it a reliable choice for a fun and easy meal out.
• Local Favorite: Tony's Pizza is popular among locals, which is a testament to its consistent quality and community presence. It's the kind of place where you’ll see neighborhood regulars, and the staff often knows customers by name. This local connection gives it an authentic charm that larger chains can’t replicate.
• Flexible Payment Options: For customer convenience, Tony's Pizza accepts a range of payment methods, including major credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making transactions quick and easy.

Contact Information

For those looking to get in touch with Tony's Pizza, whether to place an order or simply inquire about the menu, the following contact details are available:

Address: 1412 St Johns Pl, Brooklyn, NY 11213, USA

Phone: (718) 804-0966

What is worth choosing

When you visit Tony's Pizza, there are a few items that are absolutely worth choosing, representing the best of what this Brooklyn institution has to offer. The heart of the menu is, of course, the pizza. The classic Cheese Pizza is a staple for a reason; its sauce is often described by customers as being very flavorful, and the overall pie provides that perfect, crispy bite that everyone looks for in a New York slice. It’s a foundational choice that won’t disappoint. Similarly, the Tony's Meat Lovers Pizza is an excellent choice for those with a big appetite, featuring a generous combination of pepperoni, beef sausage, and meatball. For those seeking something with a bit of a twist, the Tony's Special Vegetarian Pizza is highly recommended for its fresh and flavorful vegetable toppings, including broccoli, spinach, onions, and mushrooms, which come together in a delicious and satisfying combination. These core pizza options are a reliable and worthwhile choice for any visit.

Beyond the pizza pies, a number of other menu items are worth a special mention. The garlic knots, for example, have a stellar reputation, with one customer even exclaiming that they are "very, very, very, very good." This level of praise for a side dish speaks volumes about the quality of the food across the board. The Jamaican Beef Pattie is another highlight, offering a spicy and savory treat that showcases the restaurant's unique blend of Italian-American and Caribbean flavors. This is a must-try for anyone looking for something a little different. For a lighter meal or a snack, the Pinwheel Pepperoni Rolls are a great choice, offering a delicious and easy-to-eat option. And finally, for those looking for a great deal, the "2 Large Cheese Pizzas Special" is a practical and economical option that has made Tony's a go-to for many in the neighborhood. Whether you're a first-time visitor or a regular, these selections are sure to provide a great taste of what makes Tony's Pizza a beloved local spot.

Tony's Pizza

1412 St Johns Pl, Brooklyn, NY 11213, USA