Tony's Pizza

- 312 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11213

Tony's Pizza on Utica Avenue stands out in the bustling Brooklyn food scene as much more than a traditional pizzeria. It is a true local institution that has masterfully blended the beloved New York-style pizza experience with vibrant Caribbean flavors, creating a menu that delights both lifelong residents and new visitors alike. For many in the community, as customer reviews attest, this establishment is a generations-old tradition, with patrons recalling coming here since childhood. The combination of classic Italian-American comfort food and the distinct, savory taste of Jamaican cuisine is what defines this local gem and establishes its unique identity in New York City.

This unique culinary fusion is a major draw. Where else can you find a perfectly crisp slice of New York pizza alongside a perfectly seasoned Jerk Chicken Dinner or a Fried Whiting Fish filet? This commitment to serving up diverse and deeply satisfying comfort food is a testament to the restaurant's role as a neighborhood hub. Whether you're in the mood for a quick, affordable slice, a hearty hero, or a flavorful Caribbean dinner, Tony's Pizza provides an exceptional and memorable dining experience that keeps locals coming back for more. It is a place where quality ingredients, generous portions, and friendly service converge to create a truly unmissable Brooklyn food destination.

Tony's Pizza operates with a clear commitment to convenience and accessibility, ensuring that everyone in the community can easily enjoy their extensive offerings. They pride themselves on providing fast service, making it an ideal choice for a quick bite during a busy workday lunch or a hassle-free family dinner. The atmosphere is consistently described as casual and trendy, fostering a welcoming environment suitable for all types of patrons, including college students and families looking for good value. They are well-equipped for the modern dining experience, accepting credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for seamless transactions. The establishment is also designed to be accessible to everyone, featuring a wheelchair-accessible entrance.

Location and Accessibility

Tony's Pizza is conveniently situated at 312 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11213, USA. This location in the heart of Brooklyn makes it a central and easily reachable spot for neighborhood residents and those traveling from nearby areas. Utica Avenue is a major thoroughfare, and the restaurant’s presence there establishes it as a familiar and reliable place for local takeout, delivery, and casual dining. Being rooted in a vibrant community like Brooklyn contributes to its authentic and long-standing local appeal, making it more than just a restaurant—it's a neighborhood fixture. The accessibility of the location is further enhanced by its multiple service options that cater to New York's fast-paced lifestyle.

Services Offered

Tony's Pizza offers a comprehensive range of services to accommodate the diverse needs of its New York City clientele, focusing heavily on convenience and efficiency.

• Dine-in: Customers can enjoy the casual and family-friendly atmosphere for a relaxed meal.
• Takeout: The traditional option for grabbing food to enjoy at home or on the go.
• Delivery: Fast and reliable delivery service is available, bringing comfort food directly to your door.
• No-contact delivery: A safe and convenient option for those who prefer minimal interaction.
• Curbside pickup: An efficient service that allows customers to quickly pick up pre-ordered food without leaving their vehicle.
• Catering to various dining options: Available for both lunch and dinner service.
• Payments: Accepts Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for quick transactions.
• Kids' Menu: Offerings are family-friendly and include a dedicated kids' menu.

Features / Highlights

What truly sets Tony's Pizza apart are its distinctive features and highlights, which are the main reasons why this Brooklyn spot has such a devoted following. The dual-concept menu is arguably the most remarkable feature, but several other service elements and menu items contribute to its high local standing.

• Fusion Menu: Uniquely combines authentic New York-style pizza with popular Jamaican dishes such as Jerk Chicken and Fried Whiting Fish, providing a rare and appealing culinary experience in one location.
• Fast Service: Highly recommended by patrons for its quick preparation and service, ensuring a minimal wait time, which is essential for busy New Yorkers.
• Serves Local Specialty: The menu features specialties that are deeply appreciated by the local Brooklyn community, particularly the unique Caribbean comfort food.
• Variety of Offerings: Provides a wide selection, including comfort food classics, quick bites, and small plates, ensuring a satisfying option for any craving or meal size.
• Affordable Family Deals: The Tony's Family Deal, which includes a large pie, medium jerk chicken, and garlic knots, is available for an excellent value, making it a popular choice for families and gatherings.
• Signature Items: Must-try items include the Jerk Chicken Pizza With BBQ Sauce and Jerk Chicken Pizza Roll, innovative items that beautifully marry the Italian and Jamaican elements of the menu.
• Beverage Selection: Offers refreshing Jamaican Soda, a perfect complement to the spicy and savory Caribbean items on the menu.
• Community Staple: Has been operating as a local favorite for years, with a casual, family-friendly, and trendy atmosphere that appeals to a diverse crowd.

Contact Information

For orders, inquiries, or to find out more about their current specials, customers can easily reach Tony's Pizza using the following contact details:

Address: 312 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11213, USA

Phone: (718) 774-4440

Mobile Phone: +1 718-774-4440

What is Worth Choosing

When visiting Tony's Pizza, the most worthwhile choices are the ones that celebrate its unique fusion identity and deep local roots. The sheer variety of the menu ensures that there's something for everyone, whether you're craving a classic slice or a culinary adventure.

For Pizza Purists and Adventurers: Start with the classic Cheese Pizza for an authentic Brooklyn experience, which has been hailed as some of the "best pizza in Brooklyn." However, to experience the true spirit of Tony's, you absolutely must try the Jerk Chicken Pizza With BBQ Sauce. This specialty item is a local favorite that combines the tangy, sweet, and spicy flavors of jerk chicken with melted mozzarella and pizza crust. If you're looking for a handheld option, the Jerk Chicken Pizza Roll is a perfect, savory, and satisfying choice at a great price.

For Caribbean Comfort Food Lovers: The Jerk Chicken Dinner is a standout, widely praised for its flavor and a testament to the restaurant's commitment to authentic Caribbean cuisine. Another highly recommended item is the Fried Whiting Filet Fish, especially when ordered with Coco Bread, which creates a satisfying and flavorful sandwich. The Jamaican Beef Pattie, available plain or with cheese and different types of bread, is another popular small plate that offers a quick, delicious taste of the islands.

For a Great Value: The Tony's Family Deal is an outstanding value, combining a large pie, a medium jerk chicken portion, and garlic knots, making it the perfect choice for feeding a family or a group without breaking the bank. Additionally, many of the appetizers, like the 4 Garlic Knots and the various pinwheels, offer excellent quick bites at super affordable prices.

In essence, Tony's Pizza provides a delicious answer to one of New York's perennial questions: what's for dinner? By offering the best of two worlds—classic Italian-American heroes and pizza alongside flavorful Jamaican fare—it has secured its position as a cherished and vital food destination on Utica Avenue.

Tony's Pizza

312 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11213, USA