Wild Bagels Brooklyn: Fresh Bagels, Huge Heroes, and All-Day Eats on Stillwell Ave

Wild Bagels Introduce

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers in the Gravesend and Bensonhurst sections of Brooklyn, finding an authentic, top-tier bagel shop that goes beyond the basics is a cherished local tradition. That tradition is perfectly embodied by Wild Bagels, located prominently at 1901 Stillwell Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11223. More than just a morning pit stop, Wild Bagels is a full-service deli and eatery that proudly offers its customers a vast menu centered around its foundational product: the classic New York bagel.

Wild Bagels has earned its stripes in the competitive Brooklyn food scene, even having been voted "Best Bagels" in Brooklyn in 2022. The secret to its success lies in its commitment to being "old-fashioned," with all of its bagels reportedly made fresh daily and hand-rolled on the premises. This dedication ensures that every bagel, from a simple Plain to a densely-topped Whole Wheat Everything, is guaranteed to be fresh and delicious, living up to the high standards of a Brooklyn-born creation.

Beyond the perfect bagel and a schmear, Wild Bagels operates as a comprehensive breakfast and lunch destination. Its extensive menu covers everything from hearty Eggs Sandwiches and Omelettes to an incredible selection of giant Specialty Heroes and grilled Paninis. Customers consistently praise the friendly service and the quality of the food, establishing Wild Bagels as a true community staple for a quick visit, a satisfying breakfast, or a catered event. It is the quintessential local spot where fast, efficient service meets great, fresh-daily food.

Location and Accessibility

Wild Bagels is strategically situated at 1901 Stillwell Ave in the heart of Gravesend, Brooklyn, right on the border of Bensonhurst. This location is easily accessible for residents across the surrounding neighborhoods, including Midwood, Coney Island, and Bath Beach. As a high-traffic intersection, Stillwell Avenue ensures that the shop is convenient for both foot traffic and commuters.

In a busy urban setting like Brooklyn, accessibility is paramount. Wild Bagels is noted for featuring a Wheelchair accessible entrance, making it a welcoming destination for all members of the community. For ordering convenience, the shop offers a full spectrum of service options, ensuring that customers can grab their food in the manner that best suits their busy schedules. The shop's service model is perfectly suited for a Quick visit, catering to those who need to get their bagel, coffee, or sandwich promptly. Furthermore, the establishment accepts modern payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, streamlining the transaction process for a speedy and hassle-free experience.

Services Offered

Wild Bagels has diversified its service offerings to be a one-stop-shop for breakfast, lunch, and catering needs for the local Brooklyn community:

Multi-Platform Ordering: Services include Delivery, In-store pickup, In-store shopping, and Takeout, providing ultimate flexibility for local patrons.
All-Day Breakfast: Offers a robust menu of hot items including Eggs Sandwiches, Omelettes, Pancakes, French Toast, and Hot Oatmeal available throughout their operating hours.
Catering Services: Specializes in catering for events, featuring various options such as Cream Cheese Platters, Bakery Platters, Cold Cut Platters, and massive Bagel Wheels in American, Italian, Tuna, and Chicken Salad styles.
Full Deli/Sandwich Bar: Serves an extensive list of Deli Basics, Specialty Heros, Paninis, and Lunch Wraps, solidifying its role as a full-meal destination, not just a bagel spot.
Beverage Variety: Features classic New York beverages, including fresh-brewed Coffee & Tea, Fresh Squeezed OJ, and local favorites like Manhattan Special.
Accommodating Orders: The staff is known for being friendly, efficient, and often follows complex directions "to the T," ensuring order accuracy even during busy times.

Features / Highlights

The true allure of Wild Bagels lies in its commitment to quality and the sheer variety of its menu, which caters to every possible craving:

Authentic, Old-Fashioned Bagels: All bagels are hand-rolled and baked fresh daily on the premises, providing the fresh, high-quality New York texture and flavor that earned them the "Best Bagels in Brooklyn" title in 2022.
The Stillwell Special Hero: A customer favorite, this specialty hero features a classic Philly Cheese Steak with sauteed onions and peppers and melted cheese of choice, showcasing the shop’s deep deli roots.
Massive Sandwich Selection: The menu boasts over twenty different Specialty Heros and Paninis, offering options like the 'Cheese Lover’s Hero' (with chicken cutlet, cheddar, American, and mozzarella) and the 'Lox, Cream Cheese, Onions & Tomatoes Panini.'
Comprehensive Breakfast Menu: Far exceeding a typical bagel shop, the eatery offers full breakfast meals, including The Wild Deluxe Eggs & Meat, Golden Brown Pancakes, and a variety of freshly prepared omelettes like the 'Greek Omelette' or 'Western Omelette.'
Excellent Tuna Salad: A specific highlight noted by a customer review is the "very good" Tuna Salad, available in a sandwich, as a wrap, on a bagel, or as part of a cold salad platter.
Fresh Lox and Cream Cheese: The Bagel with Fresh Lox & Cream Cheese is a delicious, fresh, and highly popular classic New York offering, a testament to the quality of their appetizing ingredients.

What is Worth Choosing

When visiting Wild Bagels in Brooklyn, a first-timer should focus on the core strengths that have made this establishment a local favorite. The number one choice must be a classic bagel with a schmear. Opt for the highly praised Whole Wheat Everything Bagel or a simple Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese, a best seller that perfectly highlights the freshness and quality of the bagel itself. Customers consistently rave about the bagels being "always fresh and packed with flavor."

For a more substantial meal, consider one of the legendary Specialty Heros. The Stillwell Special Hero (Philly Cheesesteak) or The Classic Hero (Chicken cutlet, American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, and mayo) are massive, fulfilling, and represent the best of their deli offerings. If you're visiting for breakfast, the Turkey Bacon, Egg & Cheese Sandwich is a perfect choice, often described as always being "packed and hot," or for the ambitious, the four-egg Wild Breakfast Hero Sandwich.

Finally, pair your selection with a beverage. Their Iced Coffee is frequently highlighted by regulars as being among the best and the perfect way to kick off a busy New York day. Wild Bagels is a high-volume, quality-driven shop where you can confidently order almost anything, knowing it will be made fresh with generous portions.

Contact Information

For delivery, catering inquiries, or a simple takeout order, you can contact Wild Bagels using the information below:

Address: 1901 Stillwell Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11223, USA

Phone: (718) 333-9453

Wild Bagels Food & drink

Finger Foods & Sides
Waffle Fries $5.95
Tater Tots $5.95
Full Order Of Home Fries $5.95
Fresh Fruit Bowl $5.95
Buffalo Wings (1/2 Dozen) $8.75
Chicken Fingers With Fries $9.95
Pizza Bagels $4.95
French Fries $4.95
1/2 Dozen Buffalo Wings With Fries $9.95
Chicken Fingers $8.49
Side Of Turkey Bacon $4.95
Onion Rings $4.95
Grilled Cheese $4.95
Mozzarella Sticks $7.50

Cold Salads
Tortellini Salad $3.49
Grilled Veggies Salad $3.49
Broccoli carrots walnuts craisins and apples.
Tomato Salad $3.49
Cold Antipasto Salad $4.49
Egg Salad $4.99
Tuna Salad $5.99
Chicken Salad $5.99
Fresh Mozzarella Salad $4.49

Classic Burgers
Turkey Burger $8.75
Swiss cheese avocado and roasted bell peppers.
Hamburger $7.50
Veggie Burger $7.50
Cheeseburger $8.50
Bacon Cheeseburger $10.00

Paninis
Addison Special (Bacon Cheeseburger Panini) $11.95
Turkey, Provolone, Tomatoes, Lettuce & Mayo Panini $11.95
Grilled Chicken, Sun-Dried Tomatoes & Swiss Panini $11.95
Roast Beef, Mozzarella & Brown Gravy Panini $11.95
Grilled Chicken, Roasted Peppers, Arugula & Pesto Panini $11.95
Ham, Swiss, Tomatoes, Lettuce, Mayo & Melted American Panini $11.95
Lox, Cream Cheese, Onions & Tomatoes Panini $11.95
Grilled Chicken, Mozzarella & Sautéed Broccoli Rabe Panini $11.95
Maple Turkey, Bacon, Provolone & Ranch Dressing Panini $11.95
Grilled Chicken & Mozzarella Panini $11.95
Grilled Chicken, Avocado & Bacon Panini $11.95
Comes with mozzarella, peppers, and honey mustard.
Tuna Melt With Tomatoes Panini $11.95
Grilled Chicken, Avocado & Mozzarella Panini $11.95
Comes with tomatoes and balsamic glaze.
Grilled Chicken, Roasted Peppers & Mozzarella Panini $11.95
Pastrami, Swiss Cheese, Pickles, Mustard & Coleslaw Panini $11.95
Grilled Veggies, Mozzarella & Roasted Red Peppers Panini $11.95

Breakfast Drinks
Manhattan Special $2.50
Cold espresso.
Fresh Squeezed OJ $4.95
Starbucks Frappuccino $2.50
Made with the signature espresso coffee.
Yoo-Hoo $2.25
Tropicana $2.25
14 ounces carton.
Nesquick $2.25

Beverages
Sport Water $1.50
Soda $2.25
Hal's Seltzer $2.25
Snapple $2.25
Poland Spring Water (16 Oz) $1.00

Lunch Wraps
Grilled Chicken & Spinach Wrap $10.49
Served with melted mozzarella cheese.
Baby Wrap $10.49
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella and roasted red peppers with balsamic vinegar.
Grilled Chicken & Broccoli Rabe Wrap $11.95
Grilled chicken, broccoli, and melted mozzarella.
Wild’s Famous Tuna Melt Wrap $10.49
Tuna salad with melted swiss cheese and tomato.
Philly Cheesesteak Wrap $10.49
Thinly sliced steak, onions, peppers, and American cheese.
Grilled Veggie Wrap $10.49
Eggplant, peppers, zucchini, squash, mushrooms, and red onion.
Tuna Wrap $10.49
Tuna, lettuce, and American cheese.
Chicken BLT Wrap $10.49
Grilled chicken, turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mozzarella.
Chicken Fajita Wrap $10.49
Grilled chicken, cheese, red and green peppers, onions, and salsa.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap $10.49
Buffalo chicken, cold cut, hot sauce, melted American cheese, lettuce, and tomatoes.
Wild Sampler Wrap $10.49
Grilled chicken or chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, romaine lettuce, and Caesar dressing with home fries.
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap $10.49
Grilled chicken with croutons, romaine lettuce, and Caesar dressing.
Grilled Chicken Jalapeño Wrap $10.49
Onions, guacamole, lettuce, tomato, and pepper jack cheese.
Roast Beef & Provolone Wrap $10.49
Lettuce, tomato, and red onion.
Grilled Chicken Wrap $10.49
Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomatoes, avocado, roasted red peppers, and honey mustard.
Turkey BLT Wrap $10.49
Turkey, bacon, lettuce, and tomato.
Grilled Chicken Mozzarella Wrap $10.49
Mozzarella, guacamole, and chipotle sauce.

Omelettes & Breakfast Wraps
Broccoli & Cheese Omelette $6.95
Three eggs, broccoli, and cheese.
Western Omelette $8.50
Three eggs, onions, peppers, and ham.
My Three Sons $7.50
Ham, egg, and cheese in a wrap, then dipped in egg and fried.
Turkey Bacon Wrap $7.00
Three Eggs Omelette With Home Fries $8.50
American Cheese Omelette $5.95
Everyday Special $9.50
Two eggs any style and with choice of meat.
Mushroom Omelette $6.95
Three eggs, onions, mozzarella, and mushrooms.
Green Omelette $7.95
Three eggs omelette with spinach and mozzarella.
Caliente Mexican Wrap $7.50
Two eggs onions, tomatoes, jalapeños, pepper jack cheese, and salsa.
Diva D-Lite Wrap $8.25
Cream cheese, avocado, bacon, and tomatoes.
Greek Omelette $9.50
Three eggs, feta cheese, tomatoes, onion, and olives.
Vegetable Omelette $7.95
Three eggs, vegetables, and cheese.
Salami & Egg Wrap $7.50
Two Eggs Ham & Cheese Omelette With Home Fries $7.50
Three Eggs Omelette With Smoked Turkey & Spinach $7.95

Muffins & Pastries
Black & White Cookie $2.50
Flavored Croissant $2.50
Muffin With Butter & Jelly $4.00
Brownie $2.50
Muffin With Jelly $3.25
Crumb Cake $2.50
Apple Turnover $2.50
Regular Muffin $2.50
Muffin Buttered $3.25
Croissant $2.50

Build Your Own Salad
Build Your Own Salad 3 Toppings $8.25
Build Your Own Salad 2 Toppings $5.25
Build Your Own Salad 1 Topping $5.00

Specialty Burgers
Philly Cheese Steak Burger $11.50
Sautéed onions, bell peppers, and American cheese.
Veggie Burger Supreme $10.75
Avocado, swiss cheese, red onion, lettuce, and tomatoes.
Buffalo Burger $13.95
Blue cheese, tangy sauce, and pepper jack cheese.
Turkey Burger $11.50
Swiss cheese, avocado, and roasted bell peppers.
Breakfast Burger $11.50
Cheese, bacon, and eggs.
Tex Mex Burger $13.95
Jalapeños, avocados, cheddar cheese, lettuce, and chipotle mayo.
Heavy “D” Burger $13.95
Bacon cheeseburger with fries, pickles, lettuce, onions, and coleslaw.

Deli Basics
Ham Sandwich $8.99
Egg Salad Sandwich $7.99
Roast Beef Sandwich $10.99
Fresh Mozzarella Sandwich $7.50
Bologna Sandwich $7.49
Chicken Buffalo Sandwich $8.99
Pastrami Sandwich $10.99
Chicken Salad Sandwich $8.99
BLT Sandwich $8.49
Chicken Everroast Sandwich $8.99
Salami $8.49
Tuna Salad Sandwich $8.99
Turkey Sandwich $8.99

Specialty Salads
Wild L.D. Salad $10.95
Fried chicken, hard-boiled egg, olives, cheddar cheese, bacon, tomatoes, and blue cheese dressing.
Wild Boyz Salad $9.50
Avocado, grape tomatoes, pickled, jalapeños, tortilla chips, and corn.
Caesar Salad $7.50
Croutons, cucumbers, peppers, red onion, tomatoes, shredded pecorino, and Caesar.
Veggie Salad $9.50
Broccoli, carrots, walnuts, craisins, and apples.
House Salad $7.50
Carrots, cucumbers, peppers, red onion, tomatoes, and choice of dressing.
Greek Salad $9.50
Grape tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, red onions, feta cheese, and balsamic vinaigrette dressing.

Hot Oatmeal
Small Hot Oatmeal $4.95
Large Hot Oatmeal $8.95

Coffee & Tea
Hot Tea $2.25
Iced Coffee $3.00
Hot Coffee $2.25

Bagels
Bagel With Flavored Cream Cheese $7.35
Bagel (1) $1.50
Bagel With Jelly $3.60
Bagel With Lox Spread $7.80
Bagel With Butter & Jelly $4.80
Bagel With Peanut Butter & Jelly $6.90
Bagel With Fresh Lox & Cream Cheese $16.80
Bagels (1/2 Dozen) $9.00
One free.
Bagel With Plain Cream Cheese & Jelly $6.00
Cream Cheese By Weight $4.25
Bagel With Nutella $6.00
Bagel With Peanut Butter $6.00
Bagel With Butter $3.60
Bagel With Plain Cream Cheese $4.80

Pancakes & French Toast
Golden Brown Pancakes $5.50
French Toast Dipped In Rich Egg Batter $5.50
The Wild Deluxe Eggs & Meat $10.75

Specialty Heros
Turkey Club Hero $12.95
Bacon, swiss cheese, turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, and ranch.
French Dip Hero $12.95
Roast beef, freshly melted mozzarella, au jus brown gravy, and sautéed onions.
T.T.S Fave Hero $11.95
Buffalo chicken cold cut, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo, and hot sauce.
Spice It Up Hero $12.95
Spicy grilled chicken, blue cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, and hot sauce jalapeños.
Tuna Melt Hero $11.95
Tuna, melted American cheese, and tomato.
Chicken Cutlet Americana Hero $10.95
Fried cutlet, American cheese, and brown gravy.
Luke’s B.L.A.T. Hero $9.95
Bacon, lettuce, avocado, and tomato.
Big Dave Hero $10.95
Turkey and extra fresh mozzarella.
Cheese Lover’s Hero $12.95
Chicken cutlet, melted cheddar, American and mozzarella with lettuce, tomatoes, and bacon.
Tommy’s Turkey Club Hero $11.95
Turkey, bacon, swiss cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, and ranch dressing.
Reuben Hero $12.95
Corned beef, coleslaw, melted swiss, and Russian dressing.
Lil’ Dave Fave Hero $10.95
Turkey, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo, salt and pepper, and Doritos on a sandwich.
Honey Honey Hero $11.95
Maple glazed honey turkey, white American cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and honey mustard.
Pa’s Pastrami Melt Hero $12.95
Hot pastrami, melted swiss cheese, coleslaw, mustard, and sliced pickles on rye bread.
The Classic Hero $12.95
Chicken cutlet, American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, and mayo.
Sausage, Peppers & Onions Hero $12.95
Stillwell Special Hero $12.95
Philly cheesesteak with sautéed onions and peppers and melted cheese of choice.
Chicken Parm Hero $12.95
Meatball Parm Hero $11.95
Old Fashioned Hero $10.95
Chicken salad, melted American cheese, and craisins.
Brooklyn Boyz Hero $12.95
Ham, pepperoni, salami, capicola, provolone cheese, and mustard.
Wild Child Hero $12.95
Ham, cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on a bagel, dipped in batter and fried.

Eggs Sandwiches
Turkey Bacon, Egg & Cheese Sandwich $8.75
Two Eggs Sandwich $4.75
Add cheese, meat, ham, bacon, or sausage for an additional charge.
Wild Breakfast Hero Sandwich $12.45
Four eggs, ham, bacon, sausage, and cheese on a hero.
Three Eggs Sandwich $6.00

Wild Bagels Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
In-store shopping
Takeout

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Wild Bagels Photos

Wild Bagels Location

Wild Bagels

New York Kings County Gravesend Stillwell Avenue

1901 Stillwell Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11223, USA

Wild Bagels Reviews

An average rating of ★4 from 433 user reviews.

priceeverything bagelbacon egg and cheesedeliverycashorderwheatphoneselectiontoast

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

The store is located in the Bensonhurst section of Brooklyn. They sell bagels, muffins, breakfast sandwiches, paninis, wraps, burgers, salads, cold cuts and beverages. The tuna salad is very good. The whole wheat everything bagel was a generous size.
April 25 · Steven Nechamkin
Wild Bagels never disappoints! The bagels are always fresh and packed with flavor. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic or something a bit more adventurous, they’ve got you covered. The staff is super friendly, and the vibe of the place makes it a perfect stop for breakfast or a snack. Highly recommend for anyone craving an amazing bagel!
September 19 · Alyxandr Sergo
They have some of the best tasting bagels, but they always get my order wrong. How did you guys give me regular toasted bread when I asked for an everything bagel with bacon egg and cheese? Seriously? Regular bread? The person ringing me up also loves to try to pull a fast one by charging more than what the actual cost of the order is. I let this slide twice now, but now I won’t come back. The third time is too much to the point where I think you guys are deliberately giving me bad service.
April 26 · Kurt Lee
Ive been coming here for 15 years. I live down the block and honestly its not worth it anymore. The food is just "okay", some of the bagel options are flat as hell with a HUGE hole in the middle, and theyre charging things like we're in Manhattan.Manager has an attitude problem. I get things can get busy and theirs a bunch of stuff going on but there's no reason to lash out about it. Actual man-child behavior. When asked about the prices ($22.65 for two BE&C and a medium coffee mind you) he made a snarky comment saying theyre still the cheapest option around the area. 😂 Okay so now we're lying to people. Oddly defensive over a place as if it came out of their paycheck.Over the years sometimes my order would be wrong or get a badly burnt BE&C but I'd let it slide. Its a nostalgic place for me, I'd go nearly every day in elementary school.But now?? Manager was a real piece of work. I've actually had really good service by other staff, very nice and not part of my reason of never coming back. Overestimate the food quality doesn't match up with the price. Don't go.
September 19 · Alex Orozco
Great price paired with great bagels. There was a bit of a misunderstanding at the first time ordering, but we got what we needed and the misunderstood order too, in no time.Great place! One thing we miss are the chairs and the tables.
August 16 · Péter Katona