Wish Upon a Pastry: Bringing Custom Cakes and Disney Magic to Midland Park, NJ

wish upon a pastry Introduce

For New Jersey residents seeking a bakery experience that transcends the ordinary,

Wish Upon a Pastry

in Midland Park, NJ, offers a truly unique and delightful destination. This local Bergen County gem is not just a place to grab a baked good; it’s a boutique bakery where culinary skill meets whimsical imagination, specializing in creating custom, often Disney-inspired, confectionery masterpieces. It serves as a creative outlet for professional chefs who have successfully channeled their passion for pastries and a well-known theme into a thriving local business.

This article is tailored for our New Jersey users, offering a detailed look at what makes

Wish Upon a Pastry

a standout choice for custom orders and quick treats. We will explore its accessible location, the convenient services available for busy customers, and the specific highlights—from stunning sugar cookies to an inclusive menu featuring vegan and gluten-free options. Based on factual public data and enthusiastic local reviews, this is the go-to guide for those ready to turn their dessert dreams into delicious reality.

Introduction / Overview

Wish Upon a Pastry

began as a dedicated cookie company and has since blossomed into a full-fledged boutique bakery in Midland Park, NJ. Its foundation is built upon the expertise of its owners and operators, professional chefs Michelle and Torre, who are also self-taught artists and self-proclaimed huge fans of Disney. This dual passion is the essence of the bakery, which aims to give every customer the opportunity to make their order one-of-a-kind, turning any "pastry dream into something edible for any event."

The bakery is famous throughout Bergen County for its specialty in custom cookies, cakes, and confections. Its retail area offers a variety of grab-and-go treats for quick visits, but the heart of the business lies in its custom creations. Customer testimonials consistently praise the experience, noting the visually stunning and delicious nature of the treats. One local shared their joy, saying, "They satisfy the urge for a Disney baked treat without leaving New Jersey," and specifically highlighted the "perfect texture" of the homemade marshmallows and the fact that the beautifully decorated sugar cookies "taste too yummy to just look at!" Another customer’s experience for a dog birthday party highlighted the warm, personal service and the beauty and deliciousness of their funfetti cake. The atmosphere, complete with store-made scented candles reminiscent of Disney World aromas, truly captivates visitors.

Location and Accessibility

Conveniently located in Bergen County,

Wish Upon a Pastry

is situated at 26 Goffle Rd, Suite 6, Midland Park, NJ 07432, USA. Midland Park is a central hub, making the bakery easily reachable for customers across Northern New Jersey.

For New Jersey patrons, the facility prioritizes ease of access, especially for those who need a quick stop to pick up a custom order or a retail treat. Key accessibility features include:

Free Parking Lot: In the often-crowded North Jersey area, the provision of a free parking lot is a significant convenience for all customers.
Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot: The bakery ensures easy access for all members of the community by providing a designated wheelchair accessible car park.
Quick Visit Planning: The setup is conducive to a quick visit, whether you are running in for a grab-and-go item or swiftly picking up a pre-ordered custom creation.

The bakery's standard retail hours are structured to accommodate local schedules: Tuesday to Friday from 11:00 AM to 6:00 PM, and Saturday from 10:00 AM to 2:00 PM. The bakery is closed on Sundays and Mondays.

Services Offered

Wish Upon a Pastry

focuses on a hybrid model that expertly balances highly custom services with the convenience of retail treats. Their primary offerings are centered around providing an exceptional dessert experience for any occasion.

Custom Cake and Confection Ordering: The business is primarily a custom bakery. They specialize in creating tailored desserts, including complex, multi-tiered cakes, number/letter cakes, and custom cupcakes. To ensure an accurate quote, customers are required to fill out a detailed order form to discuss design complexity, flavors, and ingredients.
Custom Sugar Cookies: Highly intricate and themed decorated sugar cookies are a specialty, with pricing tiered based on the complexity of design, colors, and details like hand-painted metallics and florals. A minimum of one dozen is required for custom cookies.
Retail Grab-and-Go Treats: The in-store retail area offers a variety of treats that customers can quickly purchase without a custom order, perfect for satisfying an immediate sweet craving.
Specialty Desserts and Confections: The custom menu extends to a variety of specialty treats, including French Macarons (with a two-dozen minimum order), Cakesicles, Chocolate Covered Pretzel Rods, Rice Krispie Treats, Chocolate Covered Oreos (including a gluten-free option), Chocolate Covered Strawberries, Dessert Shooters, and Mini Cake Doughnuts.
Inclusive Dietary Options: The bakery is committed to catering to diverse dietary needs, offering gluten-free desserts and a selection of dairy-free and vegan ice creams.
Takeout and In-Store Pickup: All retail purchases are typically takeout, and custom orders are handled through efficient in-store pickup, streamlining the process for the customer.

Features / Highlights

Several distinctive features make

Wish Upon a Pastry

a celebrated local business in Midland Park, setting it apart from other bakeries in the New Jersey area.

Themed Dessert Expertise: The bakery's unique, whimsical, often Disney-inspired theme is a major draw, providing a distinct and magical atmosphere and product line that appeals to all ages.
Professional Chef Ownership: The owners are professional chefs, which ensures a high standard of culinary execution and attention to detail in every product.
Extensive Custom Menu: The wide array of custom options, from large tiered cakes to specialized French macarons and chocolate-dipped treats, means the bakery can cater to virtually any special event in Bergen County.
Dietary Flexibility: The provision of gluten-free desserts and dairy-free/vegan ice cream options demonstrates an important commitment to inclusivity, ensuring customers with restrictions can still enjoy delicious treats.
Atmospheric Experience: Customers report that the "aromas are intoxicating" and that the in-store experience, enhanced by their own scented candles, creates a pleasant and memorable sensory visit.
Convenient Payment Options: The bakery accepts a variety of modern payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making transactions quick and easy.
High-Quality Ingredients: Customer feedback suggests a focus on quality, particularly noting the homemade items like marshmallows, which are described as having a "perfect texture."

Contact Information

New Jersey customers wishing to connect with the bakery for custom orders, quotes, or retail hours can use the following information.

Address: 26 Goffle Rd Suite 6, Midland Park, NJ 07432, USA

Phone: (201) 428-9456

Mobile Phone: +1 201-428-9456

Note on Custom Orders: For a proper quote on custom orders, the bakery directs customers to fill out the order form available on their official website, as pricing is dependent on the complexity and detail of the design.

What is Worth Choosing

For New Jersey users,

Wish Upon a Pastry

is the ideal choice when a simple, mass-produced dessert just won't do. What is worth choosing here is the combination of highly professional culinary skill and the dedicated art of customization.

The biggest draw is the unique ability to turn a specific theme or dream—whether Disney-inspired or completely original—into a beautiful and delicious edible creation. Bergen County residents no longer have to settle for standard bakery offerings; instead, they can work with professional chefs who are excited to brainstorm and execute creative, personalized ideas, as evidenced by the testimonial regarding the custom dog birthday cake. This level of personalized service, combined with genuine enthusiasm for the customer's event, creates an experience far superior to conventional bakeries.

Furthermore, the inclusion of dietary-restricted items like gluten-free baked goods and vegan ice cream shows a thoughtful approach to serving the entire New Jersey community. Patrons with specific needs can trust that they, too, can enjoy a magical treat without compromise. When coupled with the practical conveniences—easy and accessible parking, quick service options, and flexible digital payment methods—

Wish Upon a Pastry

simplifies the process of ordering a sophisticated, specialty dessert.

In short, if you are planning a special event in New Jersey and seek a dessert that is not only highly visual and delicious but also backed by professional expertise and a commitment to customer satisfaction,

Wish Upon a Pastry

in Midland Park provides a truly exceptional, one-of-a-kind experience. It is where your dessert wishes come true.

wish upon a pastry Details

Service options
In-store pickup
Takeout
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free parking lot

wish upon a pastry Photos

wish upon a pastry Location

wish upon a pastry

New Jersey Bergen County Midland Park Goffle Road

26 Goffle Rd Suite 6, Midland Park, NJ 07432, USA

wish upon a pastry Reviews

An average rating of ★5 from 161 user reviews.

designcandlespartycake popsmacaroonsice creamsugar cookiesgluten freecupcakesganache

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Wish Upon a Pastry is so good! They satisfy the urge for a Disney baked treat without leaving New Jersey. Their homemade marshmallows have the perfect texture. The decorated sugar cookies are almost too beautiful too eat, but they taste too yummy to just look at! The smells in the store made it hard to choose just one treat. And speaking of smells, their store-made scented candles make me feel like I'm walking through Disney World. We will be back to try their vegan, dairy-free ice cream!
August 22 · Jackie D.
My experience from start to finish was incredible. I was greeted as soon as I entered the bakery. When I explained what I was looking for, creative ideas were immediately shared. I told Michelle that the cake was for a dog birthday party and we talked about rescue dogs for a bit. The funfetti cake with buttercream was beautiful and delicious! Everyone said how good it was! :)Bottom line: dog people + cute Disney inspired bakery = amazing combination
August 04 · Kristen Graham
Fantastic designs and fabulous flavors! What a delicious spread of desserts. The Disney flavor macarons were a huge hit. The mini donuts were such a tiny treat. The designs in the cookies were so creative...and delicious! The cookies had just the right balance of flavor and weren't overly sweet, which can happen with iced cookies. Wish upon a pastry is THE place to get your special desserts, or just a fun cookie, cakesicle or macaroni.
May 17 · Ellen Hillman
I cannot express how overjoyed we were with the cake we ordered for my daughter’s birthday! As a huge Billie Eilish fan, she had a vision for her special cake that perfectly combined her love for Billie with a charming coquette theme. The dynamic duo, Michelle and Torre brought her dream to life with stunning precision. From the moment we placed the order, their attention to detail was like no other. The cake not only looked incredible—complete with the signature Billie lyrics font and delicate coquette touches—but it also tasted absolutely delicious! Each layer was moist and flavorful. Thank you from the bottom of my heart, for making my daughter’s birthday unforgettable and for creating the cake she truly wished for! We couldn’t have asked for a better experience, her smile says it all!
May 16 · Daisy Castro Ramos
I cannot say enough wonderful things about this place! Worth the trip on a Saturday morning, we leave with more than what we initially went in for but it's so worth it! It's a taste of Disney World when we're not able to go as much as we'd like to. And if you're a pin trader, they have a pin board there and freshen it up too so it's not the same pins all the time - we saw a different set today than we did last month. Michelle and Torre are so lovely and they truly do bring Disney magic when you step in the shop.
April 05 · Marie LaPilla