Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

- 2101 Promenade Blvd, Fair Lawn, NJ 07410

Introduction / Overview

For New Jersey residents in search of authentic Italian flavors and a truly unique pizza experience, Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Fair Lawn stands out as a must-visit dining destination. Located conveniently in the Fair Lawn Promenade, this local favorite has carved a niche for itself by embracing an old-school cooking method: the high-heat, coal-fired oven. This technique, with the pizzas cooked at an intense 900 degrees, is what imparts a distinctive, perfectly charred, and crisp crust—the "well done" taste that has become the restaurant's signature. It's an atmosphere that is both casual and trendy, making it an ideal spot for locals, families, and groups alike. While the core focus is on their acclaimed coal-fired pizzas and jumbo, never-frozen chicken wings, the menu is an expansive celebration of Italian comfort food, all prepared with fresh, high-quality ingredients.

Anthony's commitment to quality extends beyond the cooking method. They use hand-picked Italian tomatoes for their sauces, vine-ripened plum tomatoes for salads, and fresh, homemade dough. This dedication creates a vibrant destination for those seeking an elevated yet family-friendly dining experience. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch, a relaxed dinner, or planning a major catered event, Anthony’s is ready to deliver a flavorful and authentic taste of Italy right here in Bergen County. The restaurant is popular for lunch, dinner, and even solo dining, ensuring a welcoming environment regardless of the time or occasion.

Location and Accessibility

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings is perfectly situated at 2101 Promenade Blvd in Fair Lawn, NJ 07410, making it a highly accessible location for residents across northern New Jersey. The restaurant's placement in the Fair Lawn Promenade provides convenience and ample space for dining. For visitors arriving by car, the location boasts excellent parking amenities, including a free parking lot and on-site parking, with the added benefit of free street parking available in the vicinity. This makes spontaneous visits or planned gatherings effortless.

The establishment is committed to accommodating all guests, with robust accessibility features in place. The location includes a wheelchair accessible entrance, a wheelchair accessible parking lot, a wheelchair accessible restroom, and wheelchair accessible seating, ensuring a comfortable visit for every member of the New Jersey community.

Contact Information

• Address: 2101 Promenade Blvd, Fair Lawn, NJ 07410, USA
• Phone: (201) 796-2625

Services Offered

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings provides an extensive array of dining and service options to suit every need, positioning them as a versatile choice for a pizza restaurant, Italian restaurant, chicken wings specialist, and caterer in New Jersey.

• Dining Services: Dine-in, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Counter service, Dessert, Seating, and Table service are all available.
• Takeout and Delivery: The restaurant offers convenient Takeout, Delivery, Curbside pickup, and even No-contact delivery options for those who prefer to enjoy their meal at home.
• Catering: Comprehensive Catering services are a major offering, perfect for hosting business lunches, birthday parties, or any game-day gathering, with large trays of pizza, wings, and pasta.
• Reservations: Anthony's accepts reservations, a useful amenity for planning group dinners or ensuring a table during peak hours.
• Bar Service: A Bar onsite offers a great beer selection, cocktails, hard liquor, and wine, complementing the dining experience.
• Payment Options: For ease of transaction, the restaurant accepts Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Features / Highlights

The unique features of Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings are what truly set it apart in the competitive New Jersey dining scene.

• Coal-Fired Cooking: All signature pizzas and jumbo chicken wings are cooked in a 900-degree coal oven, providing a uniquely crisp, perfectly charred crust and a smoky, robust flavor that cannot be replicated by traditional ovens.
• Signature Wings: The Coal Fired Chicken Wings are a major highlight, consistently praised by customers for their juicy, oven-roasted preparation, often served with caramelized onions and focaccia bread, an excellent choice for wing aficionados.
• Full Bar & Drinks: The presence of a Bar onsite and a menu featuring a Great beer selection and Great cocktails, including unique offerings like the Aperol Spritz and Italian Margarita, enhances the dining experience, making it a perfect casual spot for adults.
• Family and Group Amenities: The restaurant is very Family-friendly, offering a Kids' menu and High chairs. Furthermore, with an atmosphere noted as Casual and Trendy, and catering to groups, it’s a popular spot for locals, College students, and families.
• Outdoor Dining: The availability of Outdoor seating with a friendly policy that allows Dogs outside adds a pleasant, relaxed dimension to the dining experience, especially during warmer months.
• Dietary Inclusivity: They provide various Offerings to meet different needs, including Vegetarian options, Coffee, Comfort food, and Small plates, ensuring there is something for everyone.

What is worth choosing

For those new to Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings or looking for the restaurant's best, the menu highlights provide a clear path to a memorable meal. The entire concept of the restaurant is built around the signature "coal fired" flavor, a distinctive taste that elevates every item it touches.

Undoubtedly, the Coal Fired Chicken Wings are a must-try. Their preparation in the 900-degree oven leaves them uniquely crispy, juicy, and flavorful—a significant departure from typical deep-fried wings. They are often mentioned as a local favorite and are truly a "game-changer" for wing lovers.

On the pizza side, while the Create Your Own/Traditional Pizza allows for full customization, several specialty pies stand out. The Paulie's Pie, featuring baby meatballs, Italian sausage, long hot finger peppers, and ricotta cheese, is a robust and highly recommended specialty. The Meatball & Ricotta Pizza is another beloved option that brings together two house favorites. For a vegetarian option with a unique twist, the Roasted Cauliflower Pizza receives high praise, topped with garlic-roasted cauliflower, Romano, and breadcrumbs for a delicious texture. Finally, for an appetizer or side, the large, homemade Maria's Meatballs with Ricotta and the warm, garlicky Garlic Knots are excellent choices that embody the heart of Italian comfort food.

While some past customer feedback has noted occasional inconsistencies regarding crust thickness and topping distribution on certain pizzas, the overall enthusiasm, especially for the unique coal-fired wings and the specialty pies, highlights the potential for a fantastic Italian meal. Anthony’s in Fair Lawn offers a compelling blend of tradition, quality ingredients, and unique flavor profiles that make it a standout for anyone in North Jersey seeking a premium pizza and Italian dining experience.

The environment is also part of the appeal. With a casual atmosphere, a full bar for enjoying happy hour drinks, and the convenience of being a transgender safespace and LGBTQ+ friendly, Anthony's actively cultivates a welcoming space for all segments of the New Jersey community.

Final thoughts: If you're in the Fair Lawn area and craving authentic, high-quality Italian food with a unique, smoky twist, Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings should be at the top of your list. From the signature pies to the famous coal-fired wings, it’s a local gem ready to serve you.

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

2101 Promenade Blvd, Fair Lawn, NJ 07410, USA