Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

- 3430 Sunrise Hwy, Wantagh, NY 11793

For Long Islanders seeking a pizza experience that breaks the mold of the traditional slice shop, Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Wantagh, NY, presents a distinctly fiery alternative. This restaurant specializes in authentic Italian-American classics, all prepared with the intense, dry heat of a 900-degree coal-fired oven. This cooking method is the heart of their unique flavor profile, delivering a signature crispy, slightly charred crust on their pizzas and an unparalleled succulence to their famous chicken wings.

More than just a pizza place, Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings operates as a full-service Italian restaurant, a caterer, and a dynamic spot for a casual yet trendy night out. Located conveniently on Sunrise Highway, the establishment caters equally well to families looking for a delicious dinner, friends gathering to watch a game—thanks to its "Sports" highlight—or commuters grabbing a quick, high-quality takeout meal. The atmosphere is consistently described as casual, trendy, and fun, even if it can be "a bit noisy" on a busy Saturday night, a common sign of a well-loved local favorite. The overall commitment to using fresh, high-quality ingredients, from vine-ripened plum tomatoes to in-house grated Pecorino Romano, underscores their dedication to authentic Italian soul food.

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings is ideally located for Long Island residents at 3430 Sunrise Hwy, Wantagh, NY 11793, USA. This prominent location on Sunrise Highway makes it easily reachable by car for those living in or traveling through the South Shore area, and is conveniently close to major local landmarks like Wantagh Park and the LIRR.

The restaurant places a strong emphasis on accessibility and convenience, making it welcoming for all New York patrons. The location offers a comprehensive set of accessibility features, ensuring that all guests can enjoy their meal comfortably:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot
• Wheelchair accessible restroom
• Wheelchair accessible seating

Parking is readily available and stress-free, which is a major benefit in a high-traffic area. Customers can utilize the Free parking lot, On-site parking, or find Free street parking nearby. Furthermore, the dining environment is inclusive, being explicitly listed as LGBTQ+ friendly and a Transgender safespace, while also being popular for families and groups.

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings provides an exhaustive list of dining and takeout options designed to fit any lifestyle or occasion in the New York metropolitan area:

• Dine-in and Table Service: Guests can enjoy the full experience with ample seating, table service, and a casual, trendy atmosphere.
• Outdoor Seating: A fantastic option for beautiful Long Island weather, with Dogs allowed outside for pet owners.
• Takeout & Curbside Pickup: Perfect for a quick meal at home, with the added convenience of Curbside pickup.
• Delivery & No-Contact Delivery: Reliable options are available for those who prefer to have their hot meal delivered directly to their door, including No-contact delivery.
• Full Bar Service: The Bar onsite offers a great beer selection, great cocktails, and a great wine list, with happy hour specials for both drinks and food.
• Catering Services: The restaurant specializes in catering large orders for local events, office lunches, or parties, featuring signature items like pizzas, wings, salads, and baked pasta trays.
• Family-Friendly Amenities: The spot is Good for kids and offers High chairs and a dedicated Kids' menu.
• Reservations Accepted: Guests can plan ahead by calling the restaurant to secure a table, especially valuable during peak dinner hours.
• Payment Flexibility: Accepts all major payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

The defining characteristic of Anthony's is its coal-fired cooking method, which infuses all the items with a unique flavor and texture. This method, along with a commitment to quality ingredients, leads to several key highlights:

• The Coal Fired Flavor: Pizzas and wings are cooked at 900 degrees, resulting in a distinct, lightly charred, crispy crust and tender, succulent wings that are frequently cited as a major draw.
• The Legendary Wings: The Coal Fired Chicken Wings are a mandatory starter for many regulars. They are always fresh, never frozen, and served with caramelized onions and focaccia bread, coming in several varieties like Original, Dry Rub No 2, and Mike's Hot Honey®.
• Signature Specialty Pizzas: The menu features creative and highly-praised pies, including the fan-favorite "Paulie's Pie" (featuring baby meatballs, Italian sausage, hot or sweet peppers, and ricotta cheese), "Eggplant Marino Pizza," and the popular "Meatball & Ricotta Pizza."
• Authentic Italian Soul Food: Beyond pizza and wings, the restaurant excels with Italian-American comfort food such as "Maria's Meatballs with Ricotta" and the "Eggplant Marino" starter, which is thinly sliced and served with their signature Italian plum tomato sauce.
• Full Bar and Sports Atmosphere: With a bar onsite offering a great selection of beers, cocktails, and wine, and a "Sports" highlight, Anthony's is an excellent destination for catching a game in a vibrant setting.
• Great Salad Options: The salads are a highlight, especially the "Anthony's Classic Italian Salad" and "Chopped Salad," made with fresh, vine-ripened tomatoes and homemade Italian dressing.

To place an order for delivery or takeout, make a reservation, or inquire about catering services in the Wantagh, NY, area, please use the following contact information:

Address: 3430 Sunrise Hwy, Wantagh, NY 11793, USA

Phone: (516) 679-2625 or Mobile Phone: +1 516-679-2625

Operating hours typically run from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM Sunday through Thursday, and 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM on Fridays and Saturdays, but it is always best to confirm with the restaurant directly for the most current schedule.

For Long Islanders, Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Wantagh is worth choosing for its genuinely unique, coal-fired cooking process that guarantees an authentic, delicious result. The restaurant offers a high-quality Italian meal that appeals to a diverse crowd—from families to solo diners and sports enthusiasts.

The standout combination of the famously tender and flavorful Coal Fired Chicken Wings and the signature pizzas, like the "Paulie's Pie" or "Meatball & Ricotta," creates an unforgettable dining experience. Furthermore, the extensive service options—including outdoor seating, seamless delivery, full bar service, and robust accessibility—ensure comfort and convenience. While like any busy spot, it can get loud or experience occasional operational issues, the overwhelming consensus points to friendly, attentive service and consistently great food. If you are looking for an energized atmosphere and a distinctive, charred crust that defines Long Island's contemporary pizza scene, Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings is the perfect destination on Sunrise Highway.

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

3430 Sunrise Hwy, Wantagh, NY 11793, USA