Barney Brown: Your Go-To Custom Sandwich Shop in Midtown

Barney Brown Introduce

In the relentless pace of New York City life, finding a lunch spot that is both fast and offers high-quality, fresh food can feel like a genuine challenge. Thankfully, Barney Brown is here to solve that problem. Located in the heart of Midtown, this sandwich shop has quickly become a local favorite, celebrated for its commitment to using fresh ingredients and providing a truly customizable dining experience. Unlike generic delis, Barney Brown puts the power in your hands, allowing you to craft the perfect sandwich exactly to your liking. The concept is straightforward: you can build your dream meal from a vast selection of fresh meats, cheeses, vegetables, and spreads. This interactive and efficient approach, aided by easy-to-use kiosks, makes it a perfect stop for busy professionals and anyone who appreciates a meal tailored precisely to their taste. The ambiance is casual and welcoming, creating a comfortable space to grab a quick, satisfying bite, whether you are dining alone or with a group.

The core of Barney Brown's appeal lies in its centerpiece offering: the Custom Sandwich. This isn't just a simple build-your-own model; it's a gourmet experience. With a wide variety of breads, proteins, cheeses, and an impressive array of toppings and condiments, the possibilities are virtually endless. Customers rave about the quality, noting that the ingredients are always fresh and the portions are generous. One reviewer praised the quality of the food and highlighted the great way to customize your meal exactly how you like it. While the focus is on sandwiches, the menu also offers an excellent selection of fresh salads, including the vibrant **Kale Caesar** and the unique **Asian Crisp**, providing healthy and delicious alternatives. For those looking for smaller bites, the menu features a variety of snacks, from classic **Kettle Cooked Chips** to fresh fruit like **Clementine** and **Granny Smith Apple**, as well as delicious sweet treats like **Brownies** and **Chocolate Chip Cookies**. This diverse menu ensures that every visitor, no matter their preference, can find a satisfying and flavorful option.

Barney Brown's success is built on more than just its food; it's also about its efficiency and customer-focused service. The use of ordering screens streamlines the process, ensuring that your custom creation is prepared and served promptly. This quick and efficient service is a huge plus in a neighborhood where time is of the essence. While the interior is optimized for a quick transaction, with counter service and no dedicated seating, it’s a setup that perfectly suits the grab-and-go culture of Midtown. The restaurant also has a friendly and inclusive atmosphere, being described as family-friendly, LGBTQ+ friendly, and a transgender safe space. This welcoming environment, combined with their offering of vegan and vegetarian options, shows a commitment to serving the diverse community of New York City. The restaurant's popularity for both lunch and solo dining speaks to its reliable, no-fuss appeal for individuals who need a trustworthy spot for a quick and high-quality meal.

Barney Brown is located at 1410 Broadway, New York, NY 10018. This prime address places it squarely in the bustling Garment District, a high-traffic area teeming with office buildings, showrooms, and is just a short walk from Times Square and Bryant Park. Its central location makes it an extremely convenient choice for professionals working in the surrounding offices, as well as for tourists exploring the iconic sights of Midtown. The restaurant is easily accessible by public transportation, with numerous subway lines and bus routes stopping nearby, making a visit seamless for anyone in the city. The wheelchair-accessible entrance ensures that the restaurant is welcoming to all. For those who can't make it to the shop, Barney Brown offers robust delivery and no-contact delivery options, bringing their fresh, custom creations directly to you. This combination of a strategic location and comprehensive service options makes Barney Brown a truly accessible and convenient choice for a fantastic meal.

Services Offered:

No-contact Delivery & Delivery: Get your favorite sandwiches and salads delivered safely to your home or office.
Takeout: Order and pick up your meal at the counter for a quick and easy experience.
Catering: Barney Brown also offers catering services, perfect for office lunches and events.

Features / Highlights:

Custom Sandwich: The main feature is the ability to build your own sandwich with a vast selection of fresh ingredients.
High-Quality Ingredients: Customers consistently praise the freshness and quality of the food.
Efficient Service: The use of kiosks and a streamlined process ensures quick and prompt service.
Dietary Options: Offers a variety of vegan and vegetarian options, catering to different dietary needs.
Inclusive Atmosphere: A friendly and welcoming environment that is LGBTQ+ friendly and a transgender safe space.

Contact Information:

Address: 1410 Broadway, New York, NY 10018

Phone: (212) 634-9114

What is worth choosing?

What makes Barney Brown truly worth choosing is its unparalleled dedication to customization and quality. While some customers have noted minor issues like a soggy bread from a delivery order or a bland side, the overwhelming consensus is that the core product—the sandwich—is excellent. Reviewers consistently use words like fresh, delicious, and great quality to describe their meals, and many consider it their **favorite sandwich place.** The standout feature is undoubtedly the build-your-own-sandwich model. In a city of pre-made options, Barney Brown gives you the creative control to make a sandwich that perfectly matches your cravings, whether it's a simple turkey and provolone or a complex creation with multiple peppers and sauces. The screens make the process intuitive and fun, turning a simple lunch order into an engaging experience.

Beyond the food, the service and efficiency are key factors. The fast service is a huge asset, especially during the busy lunch rush. This speed, combined with the convenience of delivery and takeout options, makes Barney Brown a practical and reliable choice. It's the kind of place you can count on for a consistently good meal, even when you're in a hurry. The added offerings of fresh salads and a variety of snacks also make it a versatile option, so you’re not limited to just sandwiches. For anyone in Midtown who has grown tired of the same old lunch routine and is looking for a place that offers both quality and the freedom to create something truly personal, Barney Brown is the obvious choice. It is a fantastic example of a modern sandwich shop that understands its customers and delivers an experience that is fresh, satisfying, and uniquely New York.

Barney Brown Sandwich

Sandwiches
Custom Sandwich $9.95

Salads
Kale Caesar $12.00
Kale and romaine lettuce, grated parmesan cheese, croutons, and caesar dressing.
Mediterranean $12.00
Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, red onions, feta cheese, dried oregano, basil, and a housemade tahini dressing.
Cherry Pistachio $12.00
Arugula, dried cherries, shaved manchego cheese, crushed pistachio nuts, and balsamic dressing.
Asian Crisp $12.00
Mixed greens, cabbage, mandarin orange, crispy wonton, shredded carrot, edamame, sesame seeds, and thai peanut dressing.

Snacks
Brownie $3.75
Scoop Of Tuna Salad $3.75
Clementine $1.75
Scoop Of Chicken Salad $3.75
Chocolate Chip Cookie $3.75
Kettle Cooked Chips $2.50
Granny Smith Apple $2.50
Scoop Of Egg Salad $3.75
Scoop Of Coleslaw $3.00
Sour Pickle $1.50

Drinks
Snapple Peach $3.50
Dr. Brown's Diet Black Cherry $2.50
Dr. Brown's Diet Cream $2.50
Sprite $2.50
La Croix Lime $2.50
Bottled Still Water $2.50
Sprite Zero $2.50
La Croix Grapefruit $2.50
La Croix Tangerine $2.50
Dr. Brown's Cream $2.50
Diet Coke $2.50
Snapple Lemon $3.50
Snapple Diet Lemon $3.50
Coca Cola $2.50
Bottled Sparkling Water $2.50
La Croix Passionfruit $2.50
Snapple Diet Peach $3.50

Barney Brown Details

Service options
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout

Popular for
Lunch
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee
Comfort food
Quick bite
Vegan options
Vegetarian options

Dining options
Lunch
Catering
Counter service

Atmosphere
Casual

Crowd
Family-friendly
LGBTQ+ friendly
Transgender safespace

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments

Children
Good for kids

Barney Brown Photos

Barney Brown Location

Barney Brown

New York New York County New York Broadway

1410 Broadway, New York, NY 10018, USA

Barney Brown Reviews

An average rating of ★4.1 from 37 user reviews.

lunchingredientspriceipadwrapmayolettucechoices

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

‏ I was impressed by the quality of the food.The sandwiches were fresh, and the ingredients tasted great. One feature I really loved is how you can build your own sandwich—it’s such a great way to customize your meal exactly how you like it. The screens in the shop make the process easy and efficient, which adds to the overall experience. The staff was friendly, and everything was served promptly. My only suggestion would be to expand the menu a little to offer more variety, but overall, it’s a fantastic option if you’re in the area and need a quick, satisfying meal. Would definitely recommend!
October 16 · Mr. Ant
First time trying this sandwich shop. I ordered on their website for pick up. You customize your sandwich or select from their long list of sandwich options. I chose to customize my sandwich (semolina bread, turkey, provolone, mayo/dijon mustard, lettuce, tomato, roasted peppers, banana peppers, jalapeño peppers, onions, oregano, and coleslaw) along with a scoop of egg salad, 2 sour pickles and a diet dr brown’s cream soda. The sandwich was tasty but wasn’t too happy that the bread was soggy and messy to eat. Wasn’t a huge fan of the egg salad (bland) and sour pickle wasn’t the greatest. The quality of the ingredients were fresh though but they def packed in the meat. There’s no tables inside to sit and eat, and you order on a kiosk then someone is there to hand you your order once ready. I’d be back to try another sandwich.
February 18 · Nicole Kim
It’s a really good sandwich, but you’re gonna hit close to the $15 mark, Gyna.Their app is by far the most user friendly and ascetically pleasing visually to order a sandwich. At least for the first time you do it.The ordering process via the app is what separates them from the competition as well as quality & unique ingredients plus unlimited toppings. There’s options for half, full or extra in terms of quantity.The sandwiches themselves are above average, compared to the deli options in the area. However, the prosciutto is not Italian and inferior. The pastrami was lifeless. Bread options are superior, ditto cheese and toppings, so winner winner- lechon dinner.You can order via iPads at the location, but why when the app is faster ? It’s strictly take out, no tables, just an awkwardly long bench where I suppose you could sit down and eat your sandwich like a weirdo.To summarize: You’ll spend about 11-15$. The meats are bland. The toppings and bread make the sandwich, which isn’t what a sandwich should be. The search continues for a better sangwhicha
February 29 · Yür MůmzŶ
I ordered a lettuce wrap sandwich and this is what I received. Horrible. Would never recommend or reorder.
June 14 · Information Desk
I was so excited to go here based on a tiktok recc however my wrap had way too much mayo it was inedible bummed as I was excited!
June 15 · jennathompson