Benny's Brick Oven Pizza

- 1802 Avenue M, Brooklyn, NY 11230

Welcome to Benny’s Brick Oven Pizza, a cherished local institution for authentic and high-quality Kosher Italian cuisine right here in the heart of Brooklyn. For New Yorkers in the know, especially those in the Midwood and Flatbush areas, Benny's on Avenue M has long been a go-to spot for a reliable, delicious, and satisfying meal. Known for expertly crafted pies emerging from a traditional brick oven, this restaurant offers more than just your average slice—it delivers a true New York pizza experience with the added assurance of K’hal Chizuk Hadas of Flatbush supervision, making it a staple in the local Kosher community.

Benny's Brick Oven Pizza isn't just another pizzeria; it's a dairy-based Italian-Kosher eatery that caters to a diverse clientele, from families and college students to large groups and tourists seeking a taste of classic Brooklyn fare. The atmosphere is generally described as casual, cozy, and trendy, providing a welcoming environment whether you're grabbing a quick bite during lunch or settling in for a satisfying dinner. As a long-standing establishment, Benny's has built a reputation on serving delicious, affordable, and fresh food, solidifying its place as a popular choice among Brooklynites.

The menu is impressively varied, extending far beyond the traditional cheese pie to include an array of Italian, Israeli, and Mediterranean-inspired dishes. From specialty pizza slices to hearty pasta plates, fresh salads, and even fish and Impossible Burgers, there is truly something for every craving and dietary preference. The commitment to fresh ingredients and accommodating special dietary needs, such as offering a dedicated selection of Gluten Free pies and Low Carb pizzas, speaks volumes about the restaurant’s dedication to its community.

Benny's Brick Oven Pizza consistently ranks among the most talked-about Kosher pizza spots in New York City, a testament to its commitment to quality. Local customers often praise the fantastic New York-style pizza, noting its excellent crust and overall superior taste that stands out, even in a borough with countless pizzerias. If you’re in Brooklyn and looking for a classic pie, a comforting plate of pasta, or a fresh meal, Benny’s Brick Oven Pizza on Avenue M is a destination you shouldn't miss.

Location and Accessibility

Benny's Brick Oven Pizza is conveniently situated at 1802 Avenue M, in the bustling Midwood neighborhood of Brooklyn, New York, 11230. This prime location makes it highly accessible for residents and visitors throughout Brooklyn, serving as a reliable and central culinary anchor.

Accessibility is a key priority at Benny's, ensuring all members of the community can comfortably enjoy their dining experience. The premises offer:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance.
• Wheelchair accessible restroom.
• Wheelchair accessible seating.

For those traveling by car, both paid and free street parking options are available in the vicinity. The central Avenue M address is easily reachable via public transportation as well, connecting it seamlessly to the rest of the borough and NYC.

Services Offered

Benny's Brick Oven Pizza provides a full range of services to accommodate all dining preferences, making it an excellent choice for any occasion:

• Dine-in service with comfortable seating options.
• Takeout for quick and convenient meals.
• Delivery service to bring fresh, hot food right to your door.
• Catering services for large events, parties, and gatherings, featuring large trays of pasta and other specialties.
• Dining options available for Brunch, Lunch, and Dinner.
• Accepts major Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC mobile payments for hassle-free transactions.
• Family-friendly dining environment, including high chairs and a kid’s menu.
• Offerings that include late-night food options for those late cravings.

Features / Highlights

What truly sets Benny's Brick Oven Pizza apart are its unique features and its deep connection to the local New York food scene:

• Authentic Kosher Dairy Cuisine: The restaurant specializes in delicious Italian and Kosher dairy dishes, certified under K'hal Chizuk Hadas of Flatbush supervision, making it a reliable choice for the Orthodox Jewish community.
• Brick Oven Preparation: Many of the signature pies are cooked in a traditional brick oven, lending an unparalleled flavor, crisp crust, and authentic Italian texture to the pizza.
• Extensive Pizza Variety: Beyond the classic Regular Pie ($30.95), the menu boasts specialty options like Penne Alla Vodka Pizza ($39.00), Grandma Pizza ($36.99), Deep Dish Pizza ($35.99), and Whole Wheat Spinach Tomato Pizza ($37.99), plus a wide selection of specialty slices and Calzones.
• Accommodating Dietary Needs: A dedicated menu section is available for specialty diets, including Gluten Free Pies (like Regular Gf 12 Inch for $19.99) and Low Carb Pizzas (such as Regular Pizza for $13.00), ensuring everyone can find a delicious meal.
• Comfort Food and Vegetarian Options: The menu is packed with comforting favorites like Macaroni And Cheese ($15.00), Stacked Eggplant Florentine ($16.50), and various hearty pasta dishes ($20.50 each for most types), alongside a wealth of vegetarian-friendly choices.
• Innovative Menu Items: Catering to modern tastes, Benny's offers unique items like the Impossible Burger ($15.50) and several vegan pizza options, including the Vegan Pepperoni Pie ($37.00) and Vegan Sausage Pie ($42.00).
• Highly Praised NY-Style Slice: Customers frequently praise the fantastic quality of the New York-style slices, noting the fresh ingredients and great value, which is a significant compliment in a city famous for its pizza.

Contact Information (Address, Phone)

To plan your visit or place an order, you can contact Benny's Brick Oven Pizza using the following information:

• Address: 1802 Avenue M, Brooklyn, NY 11230, USA
• Phone: (718) 787-0050

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing a single item at Benny's Brick Oven Pizza can be tough given the expansive menu, but several options consistently rise to the top as must-tries for any first-time visitor or regular patron.

Firstly, you absolutely must try a classic New York-style Regular Slice ($5.50) or the Regular Pie ($30.95). As highlighted by customer reviews, the quality of their plain slice is a cornerstone of their reputation, providing the perfect balance of crispy crust, rich sauce, and melted cheese that is essential to a great New York pizza experience.

For those looking to explore the menu's creative depth, the specialty pies are a highlight. The Alla Vodka Pizza ($35.99) is a perennial favorite, marrying a creamy vodka sauce with their excellent crust. If you are in the mood for something truly unique, the Malawach Pizza ($13.99) offers a new twist, while the Grandma Pizza ($36.99) delivers a satisfying, square pie with fresh mozzarella and a hearty tomato sauce.

Beyond pizza, the extensive pasta menu is worth considering. The Baked Penne Pasta ($20.50) and the Alla Vodka Pasta ($20.50) are incredibly popular comfort food choices. For a full-service experience, the Family Style Meal, which includes a Regular Pie and a choice of appetizers for $39.95, offers fantastic value for feeding a small group.

For those with dietary considerations, Benny's provides excellent selections: the Gluten Free Pies (starting at $19.99) and the Low Carb Pizzas (starting at $13.00) are thoughtfully crafted alternatives that ensure no one has to miss out on the quality and flavor that Benny's is known for. Whether you are a local Midwood resident or just visiting Brooklyn, Benny's Brick Oven Pizza provides a delicious, diverse, and authentic Kosher dining experience that continues to earn its place as a New York favorite.

Benny's Brick Oven Pizza

1802 Avenue M, Brooklyn, NY 11230, USA