Benny's Famous Pizzeria

- 3517 White Plains Rd, Bronx, NY 10467

For long-time residents and new neighbors in the Bronx, especially around the 10467 zip code, finding a reliable spot that covers everything from a classic Italian dinner to a late-night quick bite is essential. Benny's Famous Pizzeria, located on White Plains Road, positions itself as a highly versatile establishment aiming to serve a broad range of community needs. Categorized as a Pizza restaurant, an Italian restaurant, and a Delivery Restaurant, the venue’s operational model is built around accessibility and an expansive menu that far exceeds standard pizzeria fare.

Benny's Famous Pizzeria is designed to be a local go-to, catering to various dining scenarios. It is popular for both lunch and dinner, making it a viable option for daily meals. Furthermore, its stated popularity for "Solo dining" and its accommodation of "Groups" and "Family-friendly" crowds suggests a flexible dining environment. The overall atmosphere is described as casual, fitting the neighborhood feel and making it a comfortable place for locals to stop by. Crucially, the menu’s offerings extend into "Comfort food," "Late-night food," "Quick bite," and "Small plates," indicating a commitment to serving the community beyond standard meal times.

The unique aspect of Benny's Famous Pizzeria is its surprisingly diverse culinary offering. While the name highlights pizza, the menu features a significant mix of traditional Italian dishes, like Lasagna and various Parmigiana options, alongside American staples such as Hamburgers and French Fries, and even popular Mexican items like Burritos, Enchiladas, and various meat fillings (Pollo, Carnitas, Chorizo, Pastor). This expansive selection means that a family or group with diverse cravings can often find something for everyone, a key practical advantage in a local dining spot.

As with any high-traffic, local establishment, experiences can be varied. Customer feedback has been highly polarized, with several reports citing significant dissatisfaction regarding food quality, sanitary conditions, and pricing perceived as high for the product received. For instance, one customer noted paying $10 for two slices and another mentioned a price of $11.96 for two slices and a soda. Conversely, another customer did note that "at least the place looked clean," offering a piece of contradictory information. Prospective patrons should be aware of this range of experiences and weigh the reported convenience of the location and extensive service options against the critical comments concerning food quality and pricing.

However, the facts about the services offered, such as the numerous delivery and pickup options, remain concrete. These features are vital for New Yorkers who prioritize convenience above all else. The commitment to accepting major payment methods like Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments further streamlines the transaction process, facilitating quick and easy service for those on a tight schedule.

The restaurant also actively attempts to engage with customers through promotions, such as offering a free garlic knot if patrons follow them on Instagram, a tactic common among local businesses trying to build an online community.

***

Location and Accessibility

Benny's Famous Pizzeria is strategically situated at 3517 White Plains Rd, Bronx, NY 10467, USA. White Plains Road is a major commercial corridor in the Bronx, known for its high foot traffic and excellent connectivity via public transportation, including the subway and local bus lines. This prime location contributes significantly to its popularity as a quick-stop destination for commuters and residents in the surrounding neighborhood. The visibility and easy access from the street are assets for a business heavily involved in takeout and delivery services.

Regarding physical accessibility, specific information about wheelchair ramps or accessible restrooms is not publicly available in the provided data. However, the venue offers multiple non-physical access services, including Curbside pickup, No-contact delivery, and a Drive-through option, which enhance convenience for nearly all patrons, regardless of their physical mobility. These services demonstrate a dedication to facilitating ease of transaction in a dense urban environment.

***

Services Offered

The range of service options at Benny's Famous Pizzeria is one of its most compelling operational features, offering flexibility that caters to the fast-paced lifestyle of New York City residents. The available services include:

• Curbside pickup
• No-contact delivery
• Delivery (general)
• Drive-through
• Takeout
• Dine-in (with available Seating)
• Catering (for larger events or corporate needs)

This comprehensive suite of services ensures that patrons can access their food in almost any way they prefer, whether they are home-bound, on a quick lunch break, or hosting an event.

***

Features / Highlights

Benny's Famous Pizzeria is highlighted by several features that appeal directly to the needs of the local Bronx customer base:

• Extensive and Diverse Menu: Offers a unique blend of Italian (Lasagna, Manicotti), Mexican (Tacos, Burritos, Enchiladas), and American items (Hamburgers, Fries), ensuring wide appeal.
• Late-Night Food Availability: A critical service in the city, providing options for those working late or seeking a meal after hours.
• Full Dining Options: Serving Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert, with seating available for dine-in patrons.
• Planning & Payment Flexibility: The restaurant accepts reservations and supports all major modern payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
• Family and Group Accommodations: The venue is explicitly "Good for kids," family-friendly, and capable of accommodating groups.

***

Contact Information

Local users can reach Benny's Famous Pizzeria using the following contact details for orders, reservations, or general inquiries:

Address: 3517 White Plains Rd, Bronx, NY 10467, USA

Phone: (718) 231-8746 or +1 718-231-8746

***

What is Worth Choosing

When considering Benny's Famous Pizzeria, the primary reasons for choosing this establishment revolve around its practical operational advantages and the sheer variety it offers, especially for the high-demand environment of the Bronx.

First and foremost, the unparalleled convenience and service depth are what set it apart. The ability to choose from Curbside pickup, Drive-through, No-contact delivery, and traditional Takeout/Dine-in means the restaurant is equipped to serve customers under almost any circumstance. This level of transactional flexibility is a massive time-saver and a key feature for a busy New Yorker.

Second, the late-night and comfort food offerings fulfill a crucial need. Knowing there is a place offering quick bites and substantial comfort meals, available late, provides significant value and reliability to the local community.

Third, the uniquely diverse menu is a defining strength. For locals often deciding on a meal for multiple people, the ability to order Italian staples like Baked Ziti, classic Heroes, and even Mexican street food like Tacos and Enchiladas from a single location simplifies the ordering process considerably. This massive range, from $3 tacos to $18 pasta dishes, caters to a wide spectrum of tastes and budgets within a group setting.

It is a factual reality that customer experiences, particularly concerning food quality and value perception, have been sharply criticized in some reviews. However, the decision to choose Benny's is often driven by the practical necessity of its location, its extensive hours, and its wide variety of food items served through every available modern service channel. For the local resident prioritizing speed, accessibility, and the convenience of a diverse menu in a single spot on White Plains Road, Benny's Famous Pizzeria remains an option worth investigating, especially given the operational facts that confirm its ability to deliver and accommodate groups and families efficiently.

Benny's Famous Pizzeria

3517 White Plains Rd, Bronx, NY 10467, USA