Buttermilk Bakeshop

- 530 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215

Buttermilk Bakeshop: Your Brooklyn Destination for Custom Cakes and Delicious Treats

For New Yorkers in Brooklyn and beyond, finding a reliable, high-quality bakery that can handle everything from a quick morning treat to a magnificent custom wedding cake is essential. Buttermilk Bakeshop has cemented its reputation as one of the borough’s premier destinations for delectable baked goods. Blending homestyle baking traditions with an eye for stunning, modern design, this bakery is a true local treasure, specializing in a wide range of desserts that cater to every taste and dietary need. Whether you're planning a grand celebration or simply craving a perfectly baked cookie, Buttermilk Bakeshop delivers on both flavor and artistry.

The bakery prides itself on its "bake from scratch" philosophy, ensuring that every cookie, bar, and cake is made with fresh, quality ingredients. They are particularly well-known for their expertise in custom cakes—from whimsical birthday designs to elegant, multi-tiered wedding creations. The commitment to crafting beautiful, delicious sweets, coupled with attentive customer service, makes Buttermilk Bakeshop a standout choice for those special New York moments that deserve a truly exceptional dessert.

Location and Accessibility

Buttermilk Bakeshop is conveniently situated in the vibrant borough of Brooklyn, making it easily accessible for residents across New York City. The primary location is nestled at:

530 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA

This address places the bakeshop within a lively and accessible area, perfect for quick visits or planned pickups. For New Yorkers relying on public transit, the location is well-served by the neighborhood’s transportation network.

Accessibility and payment are designed for customer convenience. The establishment accepts major payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, allowing for quick and seamless transactions. The service options are also designed to accommodate the fast-paced lives of local patrons, making it easy to grab a treat, even on a quick visit.

Services Offered

Buttermilk Bakeshop is a full-service bakery that offers a comprehensive array of products and ordering options to meet the needs of any New York event, large or small. Their expertise extends across multiple dessert types, from their famous custom cakes to individual treats.

A detailed look at the services and offerings includes:

• Custom Cake Creation: Specializing in bespoke cakes for all major celebrations, including weddings, birthdays, baby showers, and corporate events. Customers can upload reference pictures and add customization details to ensure a perfect design, even requesting personal inscriptions. Popular flavors include Classic Birthday (vanilla cake, raspberry jam, vanilla buttercream), Wedding Cake Slice (almond cake, lemon curd, raspberry jam, meringue buttercream), Red Velvet, Double Chocolate, and Cookies and Milk.
• Everyday Cakes and Mini Cakes: Offering ready-to-order cakes for smaller gatherings, such as the 6-inch Classic Birthday Cake, 6-inch Double Chocolate Cake, and the colorful 6-inch Rainbow Cake, as well as mini cakes perfect for serving 3-4 people.
• Catering and Dessert Tables: Providing an assortment of goodies for large events, including sweet tables composed of cupcakes, cookies, brownies, and more, all beautifully presented.
• Variety of Baked Goods: A wide selection of individual treats is available daily, including cookies (Chocolate Chunk, Sprinkle, Chai Spice Snickerdoodle, Salted Nutella), brownies, and dessert bars (Tangy Lemon Bar, Fudge Brownie, the popular "Brookie" - half brownie, half cookie).
• Cupcakes and Cake Pops: Offering classic flavors like Vanilla, Chocolate, and Red Velvet cupcakes, often available in assorted packs, as well as vanilla and chocolate cake pops.
• Dietary Accommodations: A significant focus on catering to specific dietary needs with dedicated selections, including delicious gluten-free and vegan options for cakes and other desserts.
• Pies: Offering seasonal and classic pies, such as the Buttermilk Pie and the Nutella Pecan Pie.
• Ordering Options: Providing convenient ways to order, including in-store pickup, onsite services for events, and standard takeout for quick service.
• Cake Tasting Kits: Available for pre-order, these kits allow customers to sample eight of the most popular flavors, including specialized gluten-free and vegan options, which is particularly useful for wedding planning.

Features / Highlights

Buttermilk Bakeshop has earned its excellent reputation in the competitive New York bakery scene through several key features that set it apart.

• Specialization in Custom Creations: The bakeshop is highly praised for its ability to create stunning, artistically designed custom cakes, transforming customer visions—from elegant wedding styles to whimsical unicorn or character themes—into delicious realities.
• Exceptional Taste and Texture: A consistent highlight in customer reviews is the outstanding quality and taste of the products, often noting the cakes are moist, the flavors are rich, and the special-diet options (like gluten-free) are equally soft and delicious, a rare find.
• Accommodating Dietary Needs: The bakery excels at providing impressive vegan and gluten-free alternatives for cakes and cupcakes, ensuring that guests with allergies or dietary restrictions do not have to compromise on flavor or artistry. The availability of gluten-free tasting kits further showcases this commitment.
• Attentive Customer Communication: Customers frequently commend the Bakeshop's staff for their smooth, empathetic, and responsive communication throughout the entire ordering and delivery process, which is critical for high-stakes events like weddings and birthdays.
• Homestyle, Scratch-Made Quality: All items are baked from scratch, maintaining a comforting, high-quality, homestyle flavor profile that appeals to those seeking authentic, unpretentious baking.
• Diverse Dessert Menu: Beyond cakes, the wide variety of cookies, bars, macarons, and pies ensures that everyone can find a favorite treat for any occasion.

Contact Information

For New York customers interested in placing a custom order, picking up a daily treat, or discussing catering options, here is the key contact information for the 3rd Avenue location:

Address: 530 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA

Phone: +1 (347) 987-3941

What is Worth Choosing

Buttermilk Bakeshop is undeniably a top choice for New Yorkers seeking high-quality, custom-made baked goods, particularly for milestone events. The main reason to choose this Brooklyn bakery is the peace of mind that comes from combining artistic excellence with a dedication to superior flavor. Customers consistently rave about the results, with one patron noting their unicorn birthday cake was "stellar" and guests are "still talking about it," while another, who ordered a gluten-free bridal shower cake, was relieved that the cake was "so good and soft" and loved by everyone, including guests without allergies.

From the moment you begin communication—whether it's for a detailed wedding cake consultation or a simple cookie pickup—the team provides an empathetic and professional service that takes the stress out of ordering dessert for any occasion. The ability to cater beautifully and deliciously to dietary restrictions, coupled with a menu of indulgent classics like the Pistachio Honey cake and The Rocher, means Buttermilk Bakeshop is a dependable and celebrated choice for making any occasion in New York just a little bit sweeter. For an important event, their combination of artistry, quality ingredients, and excellent customer handling makes them highly recommendable.

Buttermilk Bakeshop

530 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA