Cait's Key Lime

- Willoughby Street & Jay Street, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Welcome to the sweet and tangy world of Cait's Key Lime, a Brooklyn-born business that has quickly cemented its status as the premier destination for Key Lime Pie enthusiasts across New York City. Operating as a specialty bakery, Cait's Key Lime focuses on perfecting a single, iconic dessert: the Key Lime Pie. Far more than just a simple treat, the pies from Cait's are a passion project brought to life by founder Caitlin Hubner, a professional chef who set out to fill what she saw as a major void in the NYC dessert landscape—a truly exceptional Key Lime Pie.

Since its founding in 2020, born from a craving during the early days of the pandemic, Cait's Key Lime has garnered a loyal following for its commitment to quality and the perfect balance of flavors. The business proudly identifies as women-owned, contributing to the vibrant and diverse small business community in the city. Cait’s mission is simple: to share her perfectly developed, sweet-tart Key Lime Pie recipe with everyone in NYC, ultimately aiming to make her pie a readily accessible, year-round staple. If you’re a New Yorker with a love for sunshine-in-a-slice, keep reading to learn how you can get your hands on one of these legendary pies.

Location and Accessibility

As a contemporary, specialty bakery, Cait's Key Lime primarily operates without a traditional brick-and-mortar storefront for direct walk-in sales. Instead, it utilizes a modern, customer-convenient model centered around pop-ups, strategic collaborations, and scheduled local pickups, often referred to as 'drops.' The business maintains a core base in Brooklyn, with a primary organizational and contact address associated with a bustling area, making it a true staple of the borough’s dynamic food scene.

The reference address for Cait’s Key Lime is Willoughby Street & Jay Street, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA. This location places the business squarely in the heart of Downtown Brooklyn, an area easily accessible via several major NYC subway lines, including the A, C, F, R, 2, 3, 4, and 5 trains, as well as numerous bus routes.

For New Yorkers looking to grab a pie, accessibility is key. Cait has made it a point to cater to customers across different schedules and neighborhoods by offering a variety of scheduled pickup locations and times. This flexible approach ensures that the "People's Pie" can reach pie lovers far beyond its Brooklyn home base. Customers can stay informed about the latest pickup locations, special pop-ups, and availability by following Cait's Key Lime on social media or checking the business website, which is the primary portal for ordering. This approach supports a quick visit experience for those who have pre-ordered their dessert.

Services Offered

Cait’s Key Lime offers a focused set of services designed to deliver their world-famous pie to customers with maximum freshness and convenience. The business model emphasizes pre-ordering and distribution over a traditional retail setup.

UL

LI

Delivery: For ultimate convenience, customers throughout the NYC area can have a pie delivered directly to their door.

LI

Takeout/Pickup: The primary method for collecting orders, this often involves scheduled "pie drops" at various locations across different neighborhoods in Brooklyn and Manhattan, making the product accessible to a wide audience.

LI

Specialty Pies: The core offering is the signature Key Lime Pie, which is available in various sizes, including the popular 3.5-inch "Mini Key Lime" pie, perfect for individual or two-person enjoyment.

LI

Local Collaborations: Cait’s Key Lime frequently partners with other local New York businesses—including ice cream shops, restaurants like Sweet Chick, and other specialty food and lifestyle brands—to create unique, limited-edition desserts and pop-up experiences.

UL

Features / Highlights

The success of Cait’s Key Lime lies not just in its excellent product, but also in its distinct business ethos and engaging presence in the local NYC food scene.

UL

LI

The Best Key Lime Pie in NYC: Customer reviews consistently praise the pie's exceptional quality, highlighting the "perfectly dense yet soft crust," the ideal "sweet/tart balance" of the key lime filling, and the generous layer of fresh, light homemade whipped cream.

LI

Women-Owned Small Business: Cait's Key Lime is proudly a women-owned business, reflecting the entrepreneurship and dedication of its Brooklyn-based founder, Caitlin Hubner, a private chef by trade.

LI

Small-Batch Care: Customers appreciate the care and attention that comes with a small-batch operation, which ensures high quality and consistent flavor in every single pie.

LI

Convenient and Organized Ordering: The business is praised for being organized and easy to order from, offering flexible pickup logistics that cater to busy New Yorkers with different schedules.

LI

Exclusive Collaborations: Cait's is known for high-profile partnerships with other beloved NYC brands, creating buzz and offering novel Key Lime-inspired items, such as a Coconut Key Lime Pie ice cream pint or limited-run event-specific desserts.

LI

The 'Tropical Obsession': Founder Caitlin Hubner's passion for tropical flavors drives the business's quality, bringing a much-needed slice of Florida sunshine to the New York City dessert scene.

UL

Contact Information

To connect with Cait's Key Lime and secure one of their highly sought-after pies, you can use the following details. Note that as a specialty business primarily focused on delivery and scheduled pickups, the best way to place an order and inquire about the latest drop locations is through their official website and social media channels.

P

Address (Organizational): Willoughby Street & Jay Street, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

P

While a public-facing phone number is not consistently published for direct orders, the business's primary interaction is facilitated through online ordering and direct messaging on social media, where they maintain a responsive and organized presence. Check their official website for the most current ordering procedures.

P

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Cait's Key Lime is an endorsement of local craftsmanship and a choice for what many New Yorkers consider the absolute best Key Lime Pie the city has to offer. The pie itself is the standout star, masterfully crafted to be perfectly balanced: the zesty tartness of the key lime filling cuts through the sweetness, all resting on a "perfectly" constructed graham cracker crust. The pie is crowned with a light, non-overly sweet whipped cream topping and a sprinkle of fresh lime zest, creating a refreshing dessert that truly captures the essence of a tropical treat.

Beyond the taste, customers choose Cait's for the overall experience of supporting a passionate, local, women-owned business. Cait herself is celebrated for being "so easy to order from" and "organized," making the pre-order and pickup process surprisingly smooth for the typically hectic schedules of New Yorkers. The constant search for the next collaborative venture—whether it's with a beauty brand in Flatiron or a local ice cream purveyor—adds an element of excitement and novelty for loyal customers who enjoy following the brand's evolution. For New York dessert lovers craving an authentic, tangy, and expertly made pie, Cait's Key Lime offers a small-batch dessert experience that delivers a true taste of sunshine with every bite. The community around the pie is strong, making every purchase feel like a treat and an act of local support.

Cait's Key Lime

Willoughby Street & Jay Street, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA