Caledonia Bar Introduce
Tucked away on the Upper East Side at 1609 2nd Ave, Caledonia Bar stands out as a true neighborhood gem. This isn't just another local watering hole; it's an upscale pub that manages to be both trendy and incredibly cozy. With a distinct focus on quality spirits, a wide selection of draught beers, and expertly crafted cocktails, Caledonia Bar offers a refined experience without any of the pretense. It's the kind of place where locals feel at home, and newcomers are welcomed like old friends. The pub has quickly become a go-to spot for those who appreciate a fine drink and a relaxed, friendly atmosphere. Its warm and inviting decor, combined with a stellar selection of beverages, makes it a perfect escape from the fast-paced New York lifestyle.
The true star of the show at Caledonia Bar is its unparalleled selection of whiskey. The bar boasts an impressive collection of Scotch, with an extensive list that includes Japanese, Islay, Highlands, Campbeltown, and Islands varieties. For the whiskey enthusiast, this is a paradise. The menu is thoughtfully curated, and patrons can explore different regions and flavor profiles, from the smoky notes of an Ardbeg Corryvrecken to the intricate flavors of a Springbank 12 Cask Strength. For those looking to try a variety of whiskies, the whiskey flights like "The Confectionist" or "Up In Smoke" provide a guided tasting experience that is both educational and delicious.
But Caledonia Bar is more than just a whiskey haven. It also offers a fantastic range of other drinks to suit every taste. The draught beer list features a mix of local favorites and international classics like Guinness and Belhaven Ale. The cocktail menu is creative and impressive, with unique concoctions like the "Adventures of Dave and Elly" and the "White Mezcal Negroni." In addition, the bar serves a selection of red, white, and sparkling wines, ensuring that every patron can find a drink they love. The staff, known for being super friendly and knowledgeable, adds to the welcoming atmosphere, making this a great spot for a casual drink or a more sophisticated night out.
## Location and Accessibility
Located at 1609 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028, Caledonia Bar is perfectly positioned in a vibrant and bustling part of the Upper East Side. Its prime location on a main avenue makes it easily accessible to both residents and visitors. Public transportation options are abundant in the area, with nearby subway and bus stops making it a convenient destination for a night out. For those who choose to drive, paid street parking is available, which is a common amenity in this part of the city.
The bar’s address on 2nd Avenue places it in the heart of a lively neighborhood known for its mix of residential buildings, restaurants, and shops. This setting contributes to the pub's genuine local feel, attracting a crowd of regulars who frequent the establishment. The easily identifiable storefront makes it a simple and straightforward stop for a spontaneous drink or a pre-planned get-together. The combination of a central location and accessibility makes Caledonia Bar a desirable and practical choice for anyone looking for a quality pub experience in New York.
## Services Offered
Dine-in: The primary service offered, allowing patrons to enjoy their drinks and food in the cozy atmosphere.
Onsite services: Friendly and fast service is provided by a knowledgeable team.
Happy hour: A great way to enjoy discounted beer and wine on weekdays, perfect for an after-work unwind.
Food at bar: Enjoy a menu of delicious pub fare while seated at the bar.
Caledonia Bar focuses on providing a top-notch in-person experience. The dine-in service is at the core of their offerings, inviting patrons to take a seat and relax in the comfortable setting. The staff's friendly attitude and fast service are consistently praised by customers, creating a welcoming environment that encourages repeat visits. The availability of food at the bar means you don't have to be seated at a table to enjoy a meal, making it a great option for solo diners or those just popping in for a quick bite.
The happy hour is a major draw for locals, offering discounts on beer and wine during the week. This is an excellent way to sample the extensive drink list at a more affordable price. The bar's commitment to creating a great experience is evident in its efficient service and welcoming attitude. Whether you’re a whiskey connoisseur looking for a rare pour or just want a casual drink with friends, Caledonia Bar's service model is designed to cater to your needs and ensure a pleasant visit.
## Features / Highlights
Great cocktails: The bar is known for its inventive and delicious cocktail creations, with options like the "High Priestess Cocktail" being a customer favorite.
Fast service: The staff is quick and efficient, ensuring you get your drinks without a long wait.
Cozy and trendy atmosphere: The interior is nicely decorated and feels both intimate and modern.
Vast whiskey selection: An endless selection of Scotch, bourbon, and other whiskies is a major highlight for enthusiasts.
Locals crowd: The pub has a strong local following, creating a warm and authentic neighborhood feel.
NFC mobile payments: The bar accepts various payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, and mobile payments for added convenience.
Food at bar: Serves a menu of food items that perfectly complement the drink selection.
Restroom: Convenient and well-maintained amenities are available for all guests.
Caledonia Bar's features are what truly set it apart. The star attraction is its incredible whiskey selection, which is a rare find in a casual pub setting. The staff's expertise on the subject makes it a great place to explore new flavors and learn about different spirits. The atmosphere is a perfect blend of cozy and trendy, making it suitable for a quiet drink or a lively social gathering. The "locals" crowd contributes to a welcoming and authentic neighborhood vibe that can be hard to find in a city as large as New York.
The fast and friendly service is another key highlight that is consistently praised by patrons. This efficiency allows for a seamless and enjoyable experience, even during peak hours. The bar's commitment to convenience is further demonstrated by its acceptance of various payment methods, including modern NFC mobile payments. These features, combined with the bar’s excellent drink menu and comfortable setting, make Caledonia Bar a premier destination in the Upper East Side.
## Contact Information
Address: 1609 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028
Phone: (917) 763-3487
## What is worth choosing
When you visit Caledonia Bar, the most worthwhile choice is to dive into their exceptional whiskey selection. This pub is a mecca for whiskey lovers, and the vast menu, organized by region, makes it a perfect opportunity to sample something new and exciting. The whiskey flights are an especially great value, offering a curated tasting experience that showcases the bar’s expertise. Beyond the whiskey, the creative and well-balanced cocktails are a must-try. The "High Priestess Cocktail" is a customer favorite and a perfect example of the bar’s mixology skills. The draught beer list is also worth exploring, featuring a nice mix of craft and international brews.
What truly makes Caledonia Bar worth choosing is the overall experience. It's a place where you can get a world-class drink in a relaxed and unpretentious setting. The staff is knowledgeable and passionate about their craft, and their fast, friendly service makes you feel right at home. It's the ideal spot for a sophisticated yet casual night out, whether you're a connoisseur of fine spirits or just looking for a good time with friends. The cozy atmosphere and genuine local feel make it a standout destination in New York, and a place you’ll want to return to again and again. It's a testament to the fact that you can have an upscale experience in a down-to-earth environment.
Caledonia Bar Food & drink
Japanese Whiskey
- Yamazaki Distiller’s Reserve $24.00
A beautifully crafted single malt with notes of red berries, honey, and soft spice, aged in a mix of American, Spanish, and Mizunara oak.
- Hibiki Harmony $25.00
A delicate and well-balanced blend of malt and grain whiskies, featuring flavors of orange peel, honey, and subtle oak spice.
- Kaiyo Cask Strength $23.00
A bold and intense Japanese whisky aged in Mizunara oak, delivering deep notes of vanilla, coconut, and rich oak spice.
Islay Scotch
- Kilchoman Sauternes Cask $28.00
A rare Islay release finished in Sauternes wine casks, creating a unique balance of peat smoke, honeyed fruit, and spice.
- Lagavulin Distiller’s Edition $27.00
A rich and complex single malt, double-matured in Pedro Ximénez sherry casks, offering deep smoke, dried fruit, and dark chocolate notes.
- Ardbeg Corryvrecken $25.00
A powerful and intense peated whisky, bursting with black pepper, dark chocolate, and sea salt, named after the legendary whirlpool off Islay’s coast.
- Octomore 15.1 $54.00
One of the most heavily peated whiskies in the world, featuring smoky depth, citrus zest, and maritime salinity with an elegant oak influence.
- Laphroaig 10 Sherry Cask $23.00
The classic Laphroaig peat smoke meets rich Oloroso sherry sweetness, adding layers of dried fruit, spice, and dark chocolate.
Highlands Scotch
- Valinch & Mallet Ardmore $17.00
A bold Highland whisky with smoky richness, caramelized fruit, and earthy spice from an independent bottling.
- Deanston Virgin Oak Cask Strength $23.00
An unfiltered cask-strength Highland single malt, offering intense vanilla, toasted oak, and spiced honey.
- Dalmore 14 $26.00
A luxurious and elegant dram, matured in Oloroso and Pedro Ximénez sherry casks, delivering toffee, orange zest, and nutty spice.
- Nc'Nean Organic $21.00
A smooth, organic-certified Highland whisky, featuring notes of baked apple, creamy vanilla, and soft spice.
Campbeltown Scotch
- Springbank 12 Cask Strength $27.00
A complex and full-bodied whisky, offering rich oak, spice, and maritime smoke, bottled at natural strength.
- Springbank 10 $25.00
A beautifully balanced Campbeltown classic, featuring citrus, vanilla, and a hint of smoke, making it a go-to for whisky enthusiasts.
- Kilkerran 12 Year $28.00
A Campbeltown single malt with light peat smoke, dried fruit, and a malty backbone, showcasing a true old-style character.
- Campbeltown Loch $18.00
A rare blended malt featuring whiskies from Springbank, Glen Scotia, and Kilkerran, bringing together flavors of salted caramel, citrus, and toasted oak.
Islands Scotch
- Isle of Raasay While We Wait $16.00
A lightly peated Islands whisky, matured in Tuscan red wine casks, offering layers of berries, vanilla, and coastal smoke.
- Tobermory 12 $28.00
A beautifully balanced non-peated Islands whisky, featuring notes of ripe fruit, creamy vanilla, and warm spice.
- Ledaig 18 Sherry Cask $39.00
A rich and peaty single malt from Tobermory Distillery, matured in sherry casks for deep flavors of smoke, dried fruit, and dark chocolate.
American Bourbon & Rye
- E.H. Taylor Single Barrel $25.00
A top-shelf bourbon with rich vanilla, toasted oak, and caramelized sugar, delivering a long, warming finish.
- Weller Full Proof $30.00
A wheated bourbon bottled at full proof, showcasing bold flavors of baking spice, honey, and buttery oak.
- Hard Truth Bourbon $22.00
A craft bourbon with a high-rye mashbill, offering notes of dark fruit, toffee, and black pepper spice.
- Kentucky Owl 'The Wiseman' $25.00
A high-proof bourbon with a deep caramel core, spiced oak, and a velvety mouthfeel.
- Makers Mark 46 $15.00
A smooth, wheated bourbon, finished with French oak staves to enhance notes of toasted vanilla, cinnamon, and caramel.
- Whistlepig Piggyback 6 Year Bourbon $15.00
A bold high-rye bourbon with layers of spice, caramel, and dried fruit, perfect for sipping or cocktails.
- Whistlepig Piggyback 6 Year Rye $15.00
A classic aged rye whiskey with notes of clove, nutmeg, and sweet vanilla, offering a spicy and smooth finish.
Draught Beers
- Allagash White (Maine, 5.1%) $9.00
A refreshing Belgian-style wheat beer with notes of orange peel, coriander, and light spice, offering a crisp and smooth finish.
- Belhaven Ale (Scotland, 5.2%) $9.00
A traditional Scottish ale with a malty sweetness, hints of toffee, and a smooth, creamy body.
- Guinness (Ireland, 4.4%) $9.00
The iconic Irish stout, known for its smooth, velvety texture, roasted malt character, and creamy head.
- Lagunitas Daytime IPA (California, 4%) $9.00
A low-ABV session IPA, bursting with citrusy and piney hop aromas, balanced by a crisp, clean finish.
- Narragansett (Rhode Island, 4.4%) $9.00
A classic New England lager, crisp and light-bodied, perfect for easy drinking.
- Sierra Nevada Hazy Little Thing (California, 6.7%) $9.00
A juicy and hazy New England-style IPA with tropical fruit flavors and a pillowy mouthfeel.
- Victory Prima Pils (Pennsylvania, 5.3%) $9.00
A German-style Pilsner with bright floral hops, a crisp malt backbone, and a dry, refreshing finish.
Cans & Bottles
- Athletic Run Wild IPA (Non-Alcoholic) $8.00
A full-bodied, hoppy non-alcoholic IPA, brewed with an abundance of citrus and piney hops for a flavorful experience.
Sparkling Wine
- Pol Clemente "Blanc de Blanc" (Brut, France) $12.00
A dry and elegant sparkling wine, featuring bright citrus, green apple, and delicate floral notes.
Rose Wine
- J. Bogle Rosé (California) $12.00
A crisp and refreshing California rosé, with flavors of strawberry, watermelon, and hints of citrus.
White Wines
- La Fiera Pinot Grigio (Veneto, Italy, 2014) $11.00
A light and zesty Italian Pinot Grigio, offering notes of pear, green apple, and fresh minerality.
- Withering Hills Sauvignon Blanc (New Zealand, 2019) $13.00
A bright and tropical Sauvignon Blanc, bursting with passion fruit, citrus, and crisp acidity.
Red Wines
- Broquel Malbec (Mendoza, Argentina, 2012) $12.00
A bold and rich Malbec, with dark berry flavors, hints of cocoa, and smooth tannins.
- Gravelly Ford Pinot Noir (California, 2015) $11.00
A smooth and silky Pinot Noir, featuring red berry flavors, subtle spice, and a soft finish.
Cocktails
- Espresso Martini $16.00
A rich and energizing blend of vodka, espresso, and Kahlua, delivering the perfect balance of coffee and sweetness.
- Kink is Karma $16.00
A vibrant and aromatic cocktail featuring vodka, oleo saccharum, cranberry, lime, rosemary, and an absinthe rinse for a bold, citrusy finish.
- Bee's Knees $16.00
A classic gin cocktail with bright lemon juice, honey, and lavender bitters, creating a smooth and floral sip.
- Adventures of Dave and Elly $21.00
A milk-washed El Dorado 5-year rum cocktail, infused with caramelized pineapple syrup, Darjeeling tea, lemon, and nutmeg for a complex and velvety experience.
- Penicillin $16.00
A bold and smoky mix of blended Scotch, lemon, honey, and ginger, finished with a Bowmore 12 float for extra depth.
- Rhubarbara Ann $16.00
A spicy and fruity creation with habanero-infused tequila, Dola Dira, strawberry & rhubarb syrup, lemon, and carbonation for a refreshing kick.
- White Mezcal Negroni $16.00
A smoky and herbal variation on the Negroni, featuring mezcal, reposado tequila, Bitter Bianco, Suze, and orange bitters for a layered and bittersweet finish.
- Earl of "Your Mom" $16.00
A smooth and sophisticated bourbon cocktail, featuring Earl Grey-infused bourbon, Pedro Ximénez sherry, demerara sugar, and black walnut bitters for a rich, nutty depth.
Whiskey Flights
- The Confectionist $39.00
A rich and dessert-like flight featuring GlenDronach 12, Glen Moray Port Cask, and Balvenie 14, perfect for those who love sweet, sherried, and port-finished whiskies.
- Up In Smoke $33.00
A peat lover’s dream, featuring three smoky icons: Laphroaig Select, Ardbeg Wee Beastie, and Bowmore 12, showcasing Islay’s signature maritime smoke and depth.
- The One Percenter $100.00
A luxury whisky flight with Dalmore 18, Balvenie 21, and Bowmore 18, offering deep complexity, sherry influence, and refined elegance.
- Barrel Matters $45.00
A barrel-aged whisky experience, featuring Tamnavulin Red Wine, Brenne, and GlenFarclas 10, each showcasing unique cask finishes.
Caledonia Bar Details
Service options
- Dine-in
- Delivery
Highlights
- Fast service
- Great cocktails
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Offerings
- Alcohol
- Beer
- Cocktails
- Food
- Food at bar
- Happy hour drinks
- Hard liquor
- Wine
Dining options
- Table service
Amenities
- Restroom
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cozy
- Trendy
Crowd
- Locals
Planning
- Accepts reservations
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Paid street parking
Caledonia Bar Photos










Caledonia Bar Location
Caledonia Bar Reviews
bartenderscotchatmospheremenuselectionpricessittingbourbonmanhattanevening
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1This place is a great upscale neighborhood bar! 🍻 Caledonia Bar on the UES serves am endless selection of whiskey 🥃, beer 🍺, and cocktails 🍸 - definitely get the High Priestess Cocktail!🍹 Staff 👨🍳 is super friendly and the service is quick! ⏲️ The place is nicely decorated 🛋️, and the ambience 🎶 is great! I wish I came here earlier!
May 26 · Alon GrinshpoonThis restaurant creates food memories!! The team combines a friendly attitude with speed. Their meals are delicious without being expensive. The nice employees really add to the good food here. Stop by when possible – it's a good choice.
September 06 · Jennie RiveraEvery meal here feels like a special treat. The staff showed good manners. The plating showed skill, but the seasoning showed excess. The price point fits the experience perfectly. I look forward to returning to try different selections.
August 04 · Ignace Manouryone of the best whiskey cocktails. easy to have a conversation without loud music.p.s. once rhe bartender refused to give us more drinks because he thought we had too many 😊
February 20 · C SaurabhNo food but they let you order/bring your own food. Dark cozy wood setting with extensive whiskey menu. Hot Toddy & Dave Elly milk punch were 10/10
December 21 · James
More restaurants near me

304 W 34th St., New York, NY 10001, USA

411 W 35th St, New York, NY 10001, USA

316 W 34th St., New York, NY 10001, USA

316 W 34th St., New York, NY 10001, USA

441 9th Ave, New York, NY 10001, USA

330 W 34th St., New York, NY 10001, USA

330 W 34th St., New York, NY 10001, USA

371 W 34th St., New York, NY 10001, USA

325 W 33rd St, New York, NY 10001, USA

445 W 35th St, New York, NY 10001, USA

383 W 31st St, New York, NY 10001, USA

Moynihan Train Hall, 421 8th Ave, New York, NY 10001, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Dining Insights Posts





