Cosimo & Johnny's Pizzeria

- 330 White Plains Rd, Eastchester, NY 10709

For residents of Westchester County and the wider New York region seeking an authentic taste of classic, high-quality pizza, Cosimo & Johnny's Pizzeria is a beloved neighborhood destination. Located in Eastchester, this casual gem is highly regarded for bringing genuine Bronx-style pizza to the area. It is a dedicated pizza restaurant that prides itself on crafting inviting dishes with a commitment to both quality and tradition, catering to all who appreciate classic New York comfort food.

The pizzeria is frequently described by local patrons as the "best around," a reputation built on its delicious food and exceptional hospitality. Customers consistently praise the staff, noting they are "the nicest people you’ll ever meet," which contributes significantly to the warm, friendly, and welcoming atmosphere. This is a cozy, no-frills spot where the focus is firmly on fresh, expertly crafted food, served with genuine neighborhood charm.

Cosimo & Johnny's offers a diverse menu that goes beyond the standard slice, specializing in signature Pies, Pizza By The Slice, and a wide array of savory Calzones. It is a popular choice for both Lunch and Dinner and is particularly well-suited for Solo dining when a craving for a quick, high-quality bite strikes. The menu’s offerings are built around the idea of a quick, satisfying meal that utilizes fresh ingredients, ensuring that whether you grab a slice or a whole pie, you are getting the true taste of a classic New York pizzeria.

While the overall feedback is overwhelmingly positive, with an emphasis on the great taste and friendly service, the management also shows a dedication to quality by addressing customer feedback, such as past critiques on the dough, illustrating a commitment to continuous improvement for their loyal customer base.

## Location and Accessibility

Cosimo & Johnny's Pizzeria is conveniently situated at 330 White Plains Rd, Eastchester, NY 10709, USA. This address places the restaurant in a readily accessible area of Westchester County, making it a simple stop for both local residents and those driving through the region. Its location on White Plains Road ensures good visibility and ease of access.

The location is set up for maximum convenience, providing excellent amenities for a seamless visit:

• Parking: Customers benefit from both a Free parking lot and Free street parking, eliminating the hassle often associated with parking in the New York metropolitan area.
• Accessibility: The restaurant offers Wheelchair accessible seating, ensuring that all patrons can dine comfortably inside the casual space.
• Pet-Friendly Feature: For those with pets, the pizzeria allows Dogs allowed outside in the outdoor seating area, a great feature for a casual lunch or dinner stop.

The casual atmosphere of the dining space, complete with comfortable seating and a restroom, makes it an inviting spot for families and groups, while the various service options ensure the food can be enjoyed both on-site and at home.

## Services Offered

Cosimo & Johnny's Pizzeria is committed to providing flexibility and convenience in how their customers can enjoy their acclaimed pizza and calzones. They offer a full range of service options designed to fit any schedule or preference:

• Dine-in: Guests can enjoy the casual and cozy atmosphere with comfortable Seating inside the pizzeria.
• Takeout: Fast and easy pickup is available for those who wish to enjoy their order at home.
• Delivery: The restaurant offers a reliable Delivery service, bringing hot, fresh pizza and calzones directly to your door.
• No-contact delivery: For safety and peace of mind, a No-contact delivery option is available.
• Curbside pickup: Patrons can utilize the convenient Curbside pickup service by calling ahead, perfect for a fast stop when time is limited.
• Outdoor seating: When the weather is nice, customers can take advantage of the available Outdoor seating.
• Payment Options: The pizzeria accepts modern forms of payment, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments (such as Apple Pay).

## Features / Highlights

The menu at Cosimo & Johnny's is a true celebration of traditional pizza and Italian bakery items, with several stand-out specialties that have earned the pizzeria its dedicated following:

• Authentic Bronx-Style Pizza: The signature offering is their Bronx-style pizza, noted for having a consistently delicious, sometimes crispy and firm crust. Their Plain Cheese Pizza is a top-seller and most-liked item.
• Specialty Pies and Slices: Beyond the Plain Cheese, they offer specialty full pies, including the classic square Sicilian Pizza ($32.00), the rich White Pizza with ricotta ($26.00), and the Neapolitan-inspired Margherita with fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, and fresh basil ($29.00). Slices of all popular varieties are available for a quick bite, including the beloved Fresh Mozzarella And Fresh Tomatoes Pizza Slice ($6.00).
• Exceptional Calzones: The restaurant is highly noted for its impressive calzone selection, offered in both Family Style and Personal sizes. Personal calzone favorites include the Deep-Fried Cheese Calzone ($9.50) and the popular Chicken Parmigiana Calzone ($9.50), while the hearty Sausage, Peppers, & Onions calzone is frequently singled out as being "absolutely out of this world."
• Unique Frozen Pizza Option: A truly convenient offering for busy New Yorkers is the selection of personal-sized Frozen Pizza options, allowing customers to take home a Plain, Pepperoni, or Sausage pie for baking later.
• Take-Home Fresh Pizza Dough: For those who enjoy making their own pizza at home, they sell Fresh Pizza Dough ($5.00), a sign of their commitment to fresh ingredients and accommodating home cooks.
• Classic Beverages: The drink selection features classic New York favorites, notably the hard-to-find Manhattan Special Coffee Soda ($4.00), alongside Snapple and traditional soda options. They also offer simple Coffee.
• Good for Kids: The establishment is designated as Good for kids and provides High chairs, confirming its status as a comfortable spot for families.

## Contact Information

To place an order, inquire about catering, or learn more about the menu offerings from this top-rated Eastchester pizzeria, please use the following contact details:

Address: 330 White Plains Rd, Eastchester, NY 10709, USA
Phone: (914) 787-8808
Mobile Phone (Direct Line): +1 914-787-8808

## What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Cosimo & Johnny's Pizzeria is all about securing a dependable, high-quality, and friendly experience that embodies the best of a New York neighborhood pizza spot. For anyone in the New York region, particularly in Westchester, this pizzeria is worth choosing for several key reasons:

Firstly, the quality and variety of the core offerings are exceptional. Whether you are in the mood for a whole pie, a quick $4.50 slice of Plain Cheese, or the more indulgent White Pizza, the food is consistently described as "delicious." The menu is thoughtfully structured to offer genuine comfort food, from the Bronx-style pizza to the outstanding calzones, which allow patrons to enjoy savory Italian ingredients like Chicken Parmigiana or the locally-loved Sausage, Peppers, & Onions encased in a perfect crust.

Secondly, the superior customer experience truly sets this pizzeria apart. The owners and staff are consistently praised for being "the nicest people," going "above and beyond" to provide fresh food and great service. This personal, welcoming touch is invaluable in a local business and creates a truly friendly and loyal customer base. The convenience is also a major draw: with free parking, curbside pickup, and the unique option to purchase fresh pizza dough to bake at home, Cosimo & Johnny's seamlessly integrates into the busy New Yorker’s lifestyle. It's the perfect choice for an outstanding pizza experience that feels like coming home.

Cosimo & Johnny's Pizzeria

330 White Plains Rd, Eastchester, NY 10709, USA