Dine Droop
Dine DroopDining Insightsrestaurants near me
ConnecticutNew JerseyNew York

Dine Drooprestaurants near meNew YorkNassau CountyHewlettrestaurants in BroadwayDa Nicola
Da Nicola ico

Da Nicola
- 1203 Broadway, Hewlett, NY 11557

Italian restaurant, Caterer ★4.0·$$

1203 Broadway, Hewlett, NY 11557, USA

4.0
Hubby took me here for Valentine’s Day. I’m giving them a little grace on this review due to this.Since it was an extremely busy night for them I’m certain this could be the reason it didn’t live up to the previous reviews. We had a reservation and still had to wait over 20 mins to be seated. It was Vday so I get it, they were packed to capacity so I tried not to let it annoy me too much.Service was also pretty slow and not very attentive, our table barely got checked on. Again, extremely busy night so I get it.Finally, the food and drinks were just ok. The best item we had for the night was their crab cake. Everything else we had left us underwhelmed. Again, I’m sure the kitchen was super busy and burnt out and it probably wasn’t their best work.Not sure if I’ll be back, but if do return I’ll be sure to go on a less busy night to see if I have a better experience. - Nissa Milfort
Da Nicola Overview Intro Vibe Detail Photos Location Reviews

Da Nicola Introduce

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers seeking an exceptional and diverse dining experience right in Nassau County, look no further than Da Nicola in Hewlett. This establishment transcends the traditional 'Italian restaurant' label, operating also as a premier fine dining destination that masterfully blends the rich traditions of Italian cuisine with high-quality seafood and steakhouse offerings. Since its establishment, Da Nicola has earned a reputation for serving up fresh, authentic Italian classics and new favorites daily, all within a welcoming, cozy, and casual atmosphere.

Da Nicola is recognized for its commitment to a varied, top-tier menu that appeals to a wide range of palates. From handcrafted pastas like the rich Pappardelle Bolognese to substantial cuts from their Steaks and Chops section, there is a dish for every craving. The restaurant is consistently noted for its fast service and is particularly popular for dinner service and those dining solo, making it a reliable choice whether you are planning a romantic evening or a quick, high-quality meal after a long day.

With a focus on customer experience, this Hewlett gem prides itself on providing an inviting ambiance perfect for groups and a friendly, attentive staff. Patrons often highlight the quality of the beverage program, featuring a great wine list, excellent cocktails, and delicious coffee and dessert to round out the meal. It’s a complete dining package that brings a taste of refined Italian-American culinary tradition to the Long Island community.

Location and Accessibility

Da Nicola is conveniently situated at 1203 Broadway, Hewlett, NY 11557, USA, positioning it as an easily accessible location for residents and visitors across Nassau County and surrounding New York areas. Hewlett provides a pleasant suburban setting that is readily reachable by road, making it a practical choice for your next fine dining experience.

The restaurant is committed to ensuring a comfortable experience for all guests, offering comprehensive accessibility features. These include a Wheelchair accessible entrance, a dedicated Wheelchair accessible parking lot, a Wheelchair accessible restroom, and Wheelchair accessible seating. Parking is made easy with options for a Free parking lot, Free street parking, and Valet parking, addressing a common concern for dining in the area and allowing guests to focus entirely on their meal.

Services Offered

Da Nicola provides a full suite of dining and event-related services designed for convenience and a superior experience:

  • Dine-in: Enjoy dinner in the casual, cozy atmosphere with full Table service.
  • Takeout: Conveniently place an order and pick up your meal to enjoy at home.
  • Delivery: Have the full fine dining experience delivered right to your door.
  • Catering: Specialized menu options are available to cater for various events and gatherings.
  • Outdoor Seating: Offers a chance to enjoy the weather while dining (seasonal availability may apply).
  • Reservations: Accepts and recommends dinner reservations to secure your preferred table, especially for groups or during peak hours.
  • NFC Mobile Payments: Accepts modern payment methods for a quick and seamless checkout process, in addition to standard Credit cards and Debit cards.

Features / Highlights

The experience at Da Nicola is defined by several key highlights that distinguish it in the local New York fine dining landscape:

  • Diverse Culinary Profile: Functions as a true hybrid, excelling as an Italian restaurant, Caterer, Fine dining restaurant, Salad shop, Seafood restaurant, and Steak house.
  • Exceptional Beverage Program: Boasts a great Wine list, alongside a full Bar onsite offering Beer, Cocktails, Hard liquor, and Coffee.
  • Menu Variety: The menu is extensive and includes Appetizers like Baked Clams Oreganata, a dedicated Salad section with options like the Wedge Salad, numerous Pastas (including gluten-free options and whole wheat choices), hearty Entrees, and a comprehensive selection of Steaks and Chops (such as the Grilled Ribeye and Skirt Steak).
  • Speed and Efficiency: Known for Fast service, a significant highlight often appreciated by diners.
  • Atmosphere and Comfort: The setting is described as Casual and Cozy, making it suitable for both special occasions and regular dining, with amenities like a Restroom available.
  • Signature Classics: The menu features a full range of Italian Classics, offering dishes prepared in the Francese, Marsala, and the popular Parmigiano styles.
  • Dessert Focus: Praised for its Great dessert options, ensuring a satisfying conclusion to your meal.

Contact Information

To plan your visit or inquire about services, Da Nicola can be reached using the following information:

Address: 1203 Broadway, Hewlett, NY 11557, USA

Phone: (516) 812-5155 or +1 516-812-5155

What is Worth Choosing

For New York diners, Da Nicola offers a compelling argument for being your next choice for Italian and contemporary American cuisine. The sheer breadth of the menu, encompassing high-quality Italian food, fresh seafood preparations, and excellent steakhouse cuts, ensures that any group can find something to savor. Unlike single-focus venues, Da Nicola provides the Comfort food of classic Italian dishes like Penne Alla Vodka and the refined experience of Fine dining with options like Halibut or a prime cut steak, served with attentive and Fast service.

The atmosphere is a key selling point; it is a Cozy environment, perfect for a relaxing dinner but with enough polish to make any outing feel special. Customer feedback often singles out menu standouts such as the Baked Clams Oreganata and the signature Pappardelle Bolognese. The dual recognition for a Great wine list and Great coffee also means that whether you are starting with a glass of red or finishing with an espresso, the quality is maintained throughout your experience.

Ultimately, Da Nicola is worth choosing because it delivers a comprehensive, high-value experience: a diverse, high-quality menu in a comfortable, accessible setting, supported by professional service. It stands out as a reliable, highly-rated local establishment that consistently meets the expectations of the discerning New York diner, whether you are seeking a traditional Parmigiano Italian Classic or exploring their popular seafood selections.

Da Nicola Vibe

  • Appetizers

  • Baked Clams Oreganata $13.95
  • Sauteed Artichoke Hearts Oreganata $13.95
  • Fried Calamari $16.95
  • Fried Calamari Arabiatta $17.95

    Crispy calamari sautéed in a spicy tomato sauce with hot cherry peppers and onions

  • Fried Zucchini $10.95
  • Mozzarella, Tomato, Roasted Peppers $14.95

    Drizzled in balsamic vinaigrette

  • Malcom's Bar Pie $10.95

    Thin crust Margherita pizza

  • Shrimp Cocktail $15.95
  • Shrimp, Bacon & Gorgonzola $16.95

    Shrimp sautéed in a white wine sauce topped with bacon and gorgonzola and served with asparagus

  • Salads

  • House Salad $8.95

    Iceberg lettuce, tomato, cucumber, pimento, balsamic vinaigrette

  • Caesar Salad $11.95

    Hearts of romaine, Parmesan, croutons, creamy homemade Caesar dressing

  • Shaved Vegetable Salad $13.75

    Heirloom carrots, cucumbers, red onions, red peppers, shaved fennel, cauliflower, shaved radishes, lemon olive oil, and pumpkin seed with shaved Parmesan

  • Wedge Salad $14.95

    Iceberg wedge, fresh tomatoes, crispy bacon, creamy gorgonzola dressing

  • Goat Cheese Salad $12.95

    Mixed greens, craisins, candied walnuts, goat cheese, creamy honey balsamic

  • Avocado Salad $15.95

    Hass avocados, English cucumber, red onions, almonds, imported feta cheese, tomatoes, olive oil, and balsamic

  • Arugula Salad $11.95

    Fresh arugula, shaved Parmesan, lemon vinaigrette

  • Pastas

    Ask about our gluten-free options

  • Whole Wheat Penne and Chicken Meatballs $23.95

    Served in a tomato sauce

  • Gnocchi Alla Jay $25.95

    Fresh gnocchi served with shrimp in a pesto vodka sauce

  • Trofie with Lump Crab, Shrimp & Panko Marechiaro $29.95
  • Handmade Fusilli with Braised Short Rib $25.95
  • Pappardelle Bolognese $23.95

    Homemade pappardelle pasta in a veal meat sauce

  • Seafood Linguini $32.95

    Shrimp, clams, calamari with a plum tomato sauce

  • Penne Alla Vodka $21.95
  • Whole Wheat Penne Primavera $18.95

    Whole wheat penne tossed with sautéed seasonal vegetables served in a marinara or white wine sauce

  • Craig's Grilled Chicken Arabiatta with Whole Wheat Penne $23.95

    Seasoned grilled chicken served over whole wheat penne in a spicy tomato sauce with hot cherry peppers and onions

  • Penne, Tomato & Basil $18.95
  • Penne, Tomato & Basil with Fresh Mozzarella $21.95
  • Zucchini Noodles with Shrimp Marinara $27.95
  • Orecchiette with Broccoli Rabe and Sausage $24.95
  • Entrees

  • Half Roasted Chicken $23.95

    Crispy, oven-roasted chicken served with sautéed seasonal vegetables

  • Chicken Scarcella $29.95

    Broiled chicken on the bone with roasted peppers, potatoes, garlic, and sausage, also available off the bone with white meat but must be specified.

  • Chicken Calabrese $24.95

    Sautéed, topped with baked eggplant, melted mozzarella, and tomato in a sherry wine sauce with mushrooms

  • Chicken & Shrimp Italiano $28.95

    Served with sundried tomatoes, mushrooms, and onions in a sherry wine sauce

  • Spicy Garlic Shrimp $29.95

    Jumbo shrimp sautéed with garlic and spinach in a hot garlic and chili oil sauce

  • Italian Classics

  • Francese Italian Classic $24.95

    Egg battered and sautéed in a lemon wine sauce

  • Montecassino Italian Classic $24.95

    Sautéed, topped with baked eggplant and melted mozzarella, served in a sherry wine sauce with mushrooms

  • Parmigiano Italian Classic $24.95

    Golden fried, topped with tomato sauce and melted mozzarella

  • Marsala Italian Classic $24.95

    Sautéed in a Marsala wine sauce with mushrooms

  • Pizziola Italian Classic $24.95

    Medallions of veal or chicken sautéed in red plum tomato sauce with mushrooms, peppers, and onions

  • Bruschetta Italian Classic $24.95

    Pounded and breaded, topped with fresh arugula, chopped tomato, and onion salad

  • Uncle Hal's Italian Classic $24.95

    With prosciutto and shoestring potato fries, in a wine sauce

  • Steaks and Chops

    Steaks served with roasted or mashed potatoes or French fries

  • Skirt Steak $45.95

    16 oz. grilled, marinated skirt steak

  • Grilled Ribeye $68.95

    24 oz. black Angus bone-in ribeye

  • 16 Oz. Prime Sirloin $62.95
  • Porkchops $29.95

    Grilled pork chops served with hot cherry peppers and sautéed onions

  • 10 Oz. Burger $20.95

    Served with French fries. (Main Streets 1946 blend)

  • Seafood

    Some options are seasonal. Additional charges apply for substitutions

  • Halibut $37.95

    In a lemon caper sauce over mashed potatoes

  • Francese Seafood $28.95

    Sautéed in a lemon, butter sauce

  • Arturo Seafood $28.95

    Sautéed with fresh tomatoes, mushrooms, and onions

  • Broiled Seafood $28.95

    In white wine and garlic butter

  • Oreganata Seafood $28.95

    Broiled and topped with seasoned breadcrumbs

  • Livornese Seafood $28.95

    Plum tomato sauce with olives, capers, and onions

  • Marechiaro Seafood $33.90

    Light tomato sauce served with whole clams

  • Soups

  • Pasta Fagioli Soup $8.95

    White beans and pasta in a light, plum tomato broth

  • Stracciatella Soup $8.95

    Spinach and egg drop soup

  • Sides

  • Mixed Seasonal Vegetables $7.95
  • Roasted Potatoes $7.95
  • Mashed Potatoes $7.95
  • French Fries $5.95
  • Chicken Meatballs $9.95
  • Sautéed Spinach $7.95
  • Sautéed Broccoli $7.95
  • Sautéed Broccoli Rabe $9.95
  • Grilled Burnt Broccoli $9.95
  • Asparagus $9.95

Da Nicola Details

  • Service options

  • Outdoor seating
  • Delivery
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in
  • Highlights

  • Fast service
  • Great coffee
  • Great dessert
  • Great wine list
  • Popular for

  • Dinner
  • Solo dining
  • Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Wheelchair accessible seating
  • Offerings

  • Alcohol
  • Beer
  • Cocktails
  • Coffee
  • Comfort food
  • Hard liquor
  • Wine
  • Dining options

  • Dinner
  • Catering
  • Dessert
  • Seating
  • Table service
  • Amenities

  • Bar onsite
  • Restroom
  • Atmosphere

  • Casual
  • Cozy
  • Crowd

  • Groups
  • Planning

  • Dinner reservations recommended
  • Accepts reservations
  • Payments

  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments
  • Credit cards
  • Parking

  • Free parking lot
  • Free street parking
  • Parking
  • Valet parking

Da Nicola Photos

Da Nicola Picture 1Da Nicola Picture 2Da Nicola Picture 3Da Nicola Picture 4Da Nicola Picture 5Da Nicola Picture 6Da Nicola Picture 7Da Nicola Picture 8Da Nicola Picture 9Da Nicola Picture 10

Da Nicola Location

Da Nicola

1203 Broadway, Hewlett, NY 11557, USA

Da Nicola Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 194 user reviews.

pricesseafoodchicken parmchicken meatballsvaletgraduationshort ribpenne alla vodkahere againlive music

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

More restaurants near me

  • Xaga Sushi & Asian FusionXaga Sushi & Asian Fusion4.0 (349 reviews)

    1330 Broadway, Hewlett, NY 11557, USA

  • CarvelCarvel4.0 (58 reviews)

    1344 Peninsula Blvd, Hewlett, NY 11557, USA

  • Lucy By Marina BakeryLucy By Marina Bakery3.0 (89 reviews)

    503 Dubois Ave, Valley Stream, NY 11581, USA

  • Marina's Dominican CakesMarina's Dominican Cakes3.0 (204 reviews)

    503 Dubois Ave, Valley Stream, NY 11581, USA

  • Cold Cut ExpressCold Cut Express4.0 (55 reviews)

    507 Dubois Ave, Valley Stream, NY 11581, USA

  • Scottio's PizzaScottio's Pizza4.0 (39 reviews)

    171 Dubois Ave, Valley Stream, NY 11580, USA

  • Pizza AmorePizza Amore4.0 (48 reviews)

    171 Dubois Ave, Valley Stream, NY 11581, USA

  • Gibson DelicatessenGibson Delicatessen4.0 (79 reviews)

    161 Dubois Ave, Valley Stream, NY 11581, USA

  • Wah SangWah Sang4.0 (124 reviews)

    159 Dubois Ave, Valley Stream, NY 11581, USA

  • Ralphs Italian IcesRalphs Italian Ices4.0 (371 reviews)

    1091 Rockaway Ave, Valley Stream, NY 11581, USA

  • Smash House 5 TownsSmash House 5 Towns4.0 (269 reviews)

    594 Central Ave, Cedarhurst, NY 11516, USA

  • Inatome Japanese Steak + SushiInatome Japanese Steak + Sushi4.0 (768 reviews)

    6 5th St, Valley Stream, NY 11581, USA

  • Categories

    Top Visited Sites

    Top Searches

    Trending Dining Insights Posts