Emmett's on Grove: A Taste of Chicago Tavern Pizza in NYC

Emmett's on Grove Introduce

Introduction / Overview

In a city famous for its pizza, standing out is no easy feat. Yet, Emmett's on Grove has done just that by bringing a unique and beloved style to the New York dining scene: Chicago tavern-style thin crust pizza. This is not the deep-dish pizza you might associate with the Windy City. Instead, it's a crispy, cracker-thin crust, cut into shareable squares, perfect for a casual and fun dining experience. Following the success of his original Soho location, owner Emmett Burke set out to create a space exclusively dedicated to this lesser-known but equally cherished Chicago classic. The result is a West Village gem that feels like a modern throwback, a "Midwest-inspired supper club" with a distinctly New York flair. The restaurant effortlessly blends a trendy, vibrant atmosphere with the warmth and comfort of a classic American tavern, making it a favorite for both locals and tourists.

Beyond its signature pizza, Emmett's on Grove offers a full menu of Italian-American comfort food favorites, from delectable meatballs to perfectly prepared pastas and even a standout burger. This variety ensures that there's something for every palate, whether you're craving a slice or a full dinner. The restaurant's commitment to quality is evident in every dish, from the perfectly cooked mains to the carefully curated drink list. The bar is a highlight, boasting a great selection of beer, a thoughtful wine list, and a menu of well-crafted cocktails. The overall experience is elevated by the staff's genuine hospitality and attention to detail, creating an environment that feels welcoming and special. Emmett's on Grove is more than a pizza place; it's a lively and sophisticated dining destination that offers a truly unique culinary experience in the heart of New York City.

Location and Accessibility

Located at 39 Grove St, New York, NY 10014, Emmett's on Grove is nestled on a charming, tree-lined street in the historic West Village. This address places it in one of Manhattan's most desirable and picturesque neighborhoods, known for its quaint streets and lively dining scene. The restaurant's prime location makes it a destination in itself, perfect for a meal after a day of exploring the area's boutiques and brownstones. The accessibility is excellent, with multiple subway stations, including Christopher Street-Sheridan Square and West 4th Street, within easy walking distance. This ensures that whether you're coming from another borough or just across town, getting to Emmett's is a breeze. The restaurant is also committed to being accessible to everyone, with a wheelchair-accessible entrance, restroom, and seating, ensuring a comfortable dining experience for all guests. The classic New York facade and trendy interior invite you to step in and discover what makes this spot a neighborhood favorite and a must-visit for anyone in the city.

Services Offered

Dine-in: Enjoy the trendy and cozy atmosphere with full table service for a relaxed and enjoyable meal. Reservations are accepted and recommended, especially for dinner.
Delivery: For those who prefer to dine at home, Emmett's on Grove offers a convenient delivery service.
Takeout: You can place an order for takeout, perfect for a quick and delicious meal on the go.
Brunch: The restaurant serves a popular brunch, offering a variety of morning favorites in addition to its regular menu.
Happy Hour: Enjoy special pricing on select drinks and food items during happy hour.
Private Events: The restaurant can accommodate private events and groups, providing a great space for celebrations or large gatherings.

Features / Highlights

Authentic Chicago Tavern-Style Pizza: The main draw is the unique pizza, featuring a thin, crispy crust cut into squares. This style is perfect for sharing and offers a delicious departure from the standard New York slice.
Exceptional Food Beyond Pizza: While the pizza is a star, the rest of the menu is equally impressive. The meatballs are praised for being perfectly cooked and flavorful, and other dishes like the Baby Back Ribs and Chicken Parmesan are also highly recommended.
Outstanding Drink Selection: Emmett's on Grove is known for its well-curated bar. The "Great beer selection," "Great cocktails," and "Great wine list" are all major highlights, with a variety of options to complement any meal.
Trendy and Inviting Atmosphere: The interior is thoughtfully designed, with a mix of great art and vintage memorabilia that creates a lively yet cozy vibe. It's a perfect setting for both a casual bite and a special occasion.
Top-Tier Service: The staff is consistently praised for being attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable. The service is described as "next level," making the entire dining experience feel special and welcoming.
Accessibility: The restaurant is fully wheelchair accessible, from the entrance to the restrooms and seating areas, demonstrating a commitment to serving all patrons.

Contact Information

Address: 39 Grove St, New York, NY 10014, USA

Phone: (646) 370-3858

What is worth choosing

When you visit Emmett's on Grove, the abundance of delicious options can be overwhelming, but a few items stand out as essential choices. The undisputed star of the show is the "Hot Girl" pizza. This pie has earned a reputation for a reason: it's a perfect blend of spicy and sweet, featuring pepperoni, jalapeños, and Mike's Hot Honey. The combination is a fiery yet harmonious flavor explosion that is both addictive and unforgettable. As one reviewer noted, it's a legitimate hit and a must-try for anyone who loves a little heat.

Beyond the pizza, you absolutely must try the Emmett's Meatballs. These are not your average meatballs; they are perfectly cooked, tender, and served in a sauce that enhances the flavor without overwhelming the meat. They are a beloved appetizer that are great for sharing and have surprised many first-time visitors with their quality. For a side, the Arugula Salad is a refreshing and flavorful choice to balance out the richness of the pizza and other dishes. And for a truly memorable finale, the Key Lime Pie is a standout dessert with a strong, authentic lime flavor and a perfect texture that provides a light and satisfying end to the meal. Whether you're in the mood for the signature pizza, a comforting pasta like the Pappardelle Bolognese, or a combination of their stellar appetizers, Emmett's on Grove offers a dining experience that consistently exceeds expectations, ensuring you'll leave a fan.

Emmett's on Grove Menu

Snacks
House Chips $6.00
Crispy Olives $6.00

Apps
Arugula Salad $13.00
Caesar Salad $14.00
Emmett's Meatballs $14.00
Classic Shrimp Cocktail $14.00
Burrata $14.00
House Focaccia $6.00

Pastas
Spaghetti & Meatballs $25.00
Pappardelle Bolognese $25.00

Sides
Hand Cut Fries $7.00
Pan Fried Broccoli $8.00
Sauteed Escarole $8.00
Twice Baked Potato $10.00

Pizzas
Hot Papi $28.00
Hot Girl $27.00

Mains
Baby Back Ribs with Sides $27.00
Chicken Parmesan $28.00
Chicken Milanese $23.00
House Burger & Fries $21.00

Cocktails
Classic Martini $16.00
Classic Negroni $16.00
Mezclado $16.00
La Cura $15.00
Mai Tai $16.00
Grapefruit Spritz $14.00

Emmett's on Grove Details

Service options
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Great wine list

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Happy hour drinks
Happy hour food
Hard liquor
Late-night food
Small plates
Wine

Dining options
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Trendy

Crowd
Groups
Tourists

Planning
Dinner reservations recommended
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
High chairs

Emmett's on Grove Photos

Emmett's on Grove Location

Emmett's on Grove

New York New York County New York Grove Street

39 Grove St, New York, NY 10014, USA

Emmett's on Grove Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 301 user reviews.

martinichicken parmmeatballscaesar saladbartenderdeep dishbrunchtavern stylepigs in a blankethappy hour

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

The hostess, Hannah, was fantastic and made our whole visit something beyond our expectations. She greeted us warmly as we all walked in and made sure our table was ready, since we already had a reservation. She made sure our server was also attentive and came right to our table. She is the coolest hostess I've ever met.We had two servers who were also both truly attentive, friendly, prompt, and accurate. The pacing of the meal was relaxed, not rushed, and not delayed.The service and staff here make the experience "next level."We ordered the pigs in a blanket, Greek salad, and meatballs for appetizers. Each was outstanding and perfect for sharing. The pigs in a blanket are larger than what you would expect and the wrap was flaky and seeded. Dipped in the mustard, it was better than any wedding I've ever attended (and that's no joke as they are always the first thing to deplete at weddings for a good reason). The meatballs were an unexpected hit. They were very well cooked, but not dry at all. The sauce was flavorful and not overwhelming, so the meatball itself was the focus of the bite. The Greek salad didn't actually include salad, which was perfect, so the fresh tomato, the ideal "baby bear" feta - not too hard, not too soft, the onion, and the cucumber were the focus. The dressing was lightly applied so as to not be overwhelming.The pizza came out before the pasta. The pizza is Chicago-style, so it is thin crust and cut into single-bite squares, and excellent for sharing. The "Hot girl" pizza was the hit. I can tolerate a lot of spice, and this was spicy. I loved it. Pepperoni, jalapeño, and Mike's Hot Honey. It was legit. The other half was Mona Lisa, which was nice, but not in the class of "Hot Girl."The pappardelle bolognese had the right amount of sauce and was prepared perfectly al dente. The noodles were super long and it was like a pasta clown car when you try to serve it. The noddle just kept on coming and eventually had to be cut. The Cacio e Pepe also was a hit with the group, but not my thing. It's more like an "al fredo."The surprise at the end was the key lime pie which had a very strong lime flavor and ridiculously crumbly and chewy crust, topped with a light whipped cream that didn't drown the pie like some do. The pie center had a perfect texture that was creamy and thick, but not viscous at all.The atmosphere was very trendy with great art strewn throughout and 20th century memorabilia also scattered around, like an old 7-up sign or the rotating Schlitz globe. The Globe is apropos as it is mounted outside the restrooms - just in case you need to take a "Schlitz," I guess. There is great natural light in the rear dining room from a skylight and a display of wine racks in the wall. The bar had a well-curated selection for all levels of palates.I had an IPA on tap with the meal and it was a perfect pairing with the spicy pizza.Overall, this is one of my favorite restaurants now, between the service, the ambiance, and the food, Emmet's on Grove is a "must-see" if you're anywhere in NYC.
June 15 · Cory Notrica
Hands down, the best pizza and burgers in town! The service was amazing, and the food was out of this world. If you visit New York, make sure to have lunch or dinner here. This is the best pizza I’ve ever had!
August 17 · Aaron Goldsmith
Quality and unique presentation of the pizza, pasta and chicken parm. Great service. Celebrated my wife’s birthday and the staff made it special.
July 28 · Peter Tse
Was able to walk in Saturday 3pm still pretty crowded! Vibes were good, back room was super loud. Took about 35 minutes to get one pizza which was annoying because the pizza was only tepid. everyone in the room was waiting for their pizzas so maybe they had a backlog or change in shift. Pizza was good though, could’ve been warmer and crunchier.
May 10 · H L
The pepperoni and jalapeño pizza hits so hard. Also don’t sleep on their salad. The pizzas with a lot of veggies or sausage can sag a bit too fast and makes it not-as-good as the other ones. Great service but space is a bit too crowded.
May 24 · Francisco F