Fisherman's Cove

- 2137 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11210

Welcome to the heart of Flatbush, Brooklyn, a vibrant neighborhood renowned for its rich cultural tapestry and, most importantly, its phenomenal food. For those seeking a truly authentic taste of the Caribbean, there is one destination that stands out: Fisherman's Cove. Located at 2137 Nostrand Ave, this Jamaican restaurant has become a beloved local institution for New Yorkers craving the distinctive, bold flavors of the island. Fisherman's Cove offers more than just a meal; it provides a bustling, casual, and satisfying culinary experience rooted in traditional Jamaican cooking.

Since opening its doors, Fisherman's Cove has cemented its reputation by consistently serving hearty portions of popular Jamaican staples. It’s a go-to spot for locals, university students, and groups looking for comfort food that is both flavorful and filling. The atmosphere is generally described as casual and trendy, reflecting the energetic pulse of the Flatbush community it serves. Whether you're a long-time resident or just passing through, stepping into Fisherman's Cove means preparing for a feast of authentic tastes.

The restaurant is celebrated for its commitment to delivering a taste that reminds many patrons of home-cooked Jamaican meals. From the signature Jerk Chicken to the succulent Oxtail and flavorful Curry Goat, the menu is a deep dive into the best of Caribbean culinary tradition. It caters to a diverse clientele throughout the day, being a popular spot for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, and is well-equipped to handle various dining needs, from a quick solo bite to catering for large groups.

Location and Accessibility

Fisherman's Cove is strategically situated in the bustling Flatbush neighborhood of Brooklyn, making it a highly accessible spot for many New Yorkers. The exact address is 2137 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11210, USA. This location places it right in the flow of daily commerce and public transit, which is essential for a high-traffic urban eatery. The neighborhood itself is vibrant and diverse, contributing to the restaurant's bustling and popular atmosphere.

For those traveling by public transportation, the Nostrand Avenue location is conveniently located near various subway and bus routes serving the Flatbush area, ensuring that getting to this Caribbean food haven is relatively easy from any borough. For patrons requiring specific accommodations, the restaurant is noted for having a wheelchair-accessible entrance, demonstrating a commitment to serving the wider community.

The restaurant’s core hours of operation generally reflect its popularity throughout the day, though it's always wise for patrons to check for the latest times, especially for weekend visits. Based on available information, the operating hours typically run from 10:00 AM to 10:00 PM, Monday through Saturday, with the venue being closed on Sundays. However, some online sources suggest varying opening hours as early as 7:00 AM to midnight, so calling ahead for the most accurate current schedule is recommended, particularly for late-night food or early morning breakfast. The fact that they are open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner solidifies its role as an all-day dining destination in the neighborhood.

Services Offered

Fisherman's Cove provides a comprehensive range of services to accommodate the diverse needs and preferences of its New York customer base:

• Dine-in Service: Patrons can enjoy their meal on-site in a casual, comfortable, and trendy atmosphere, with seating available.
• Delivery: For the ultimate convenience, the full menu is often available for delivery, allowing customers to enjoy authentic Jamaican cuisine from the comfort of their home or office.
• Takeout / Takeaway: Perfect for New Yorkers on the go, the takeout option ensures a quick bite of Caribbean flavor is never far away.
• Catering: The restaurant offers catering services, making it an excellent choice for events, meetings, and parties looking to bring authentic Jamaican flavors to their guests.
• All-Day Dining: Serving an extensive menu throughout the day, Fisherman's Cove is popular for breakfast, brunch, lunch, and dinner.
• Payment Flexibility: The establishment accepts a variety of payment methods, including Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC mobile payments for a seamless transaction experience.

Features / Highlights

Fisherman's Cove’s enduring popularity in the New York food scene can be attributed to several distinguishing features:

• Authentic Jamaican Cuisine: The primary highlight is the genuinely authentic and flavorful Jamaican dishes, which many customers praise for their consistent quality and taste.
• Signature Dish Popularity: Favorites like the Jerk Chicken, Oxtail, and Escovitch Fish are frequently cited as must-try items, embodying the rich spices and cooking traditions of the Caribbean.
• Generous Portions and Value: A recurring theme in customer feedback is the satisfaction with generous portion sizes, often noted to be affordable and providing excellent value for money.
• Extensive Lunch Specials: The menu features a wide array of lunch specials, including options like Jerk Chicken Lunch Special, Stew Chicken Lunch Special, and Oxtail Lunch Special, catering to the daytime crowd looking for a quick, filling, and cost-effective meal.
• Comfort Food Options: The offerings lean heavily on comfort food, providing hearty, satisfying meals, though they also include healthy options and smaller plates for lighter appetites.
• Late-Night Availability: The restaurant is known to offer late-night food options, a valuable service in a busy city like New York.
• Family-Friendly Environment: With the listing noting it as "Good for kids," the restaurant is a welcoming environment for families, with high chairs available.
• Crowd Diversity: The restaurant attracts a diverse and lively crowd, including groups, tourists, and college students, contributing to its bustling and energetic ambiance.

Contact Information

For those planning a visit, seeking catering information, or simply wanting to inquire about the daily specials, here is the essential contact information for Fisherman's Cove in Brooklyn:

Address: 2137 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11210, USA

Phone: (347) 295-2892

What is Worth Choosing

When exploring the extensive menu at Fisherman's Cove, the choice is abundant, but several categories and specific dishes are consistently worth selecting for a true taste of this Brooklyn gem.

The Lunch Specials are arguably the best way to experience a variety of their most popular items at excellent value. Options frequently listed and highly sought after include the Jerk Chicken Lunch Special, the Oxtail Lunch Special, and the various Curry Goat Lunch Specials. These represent the core of Jamaican comfort food and are perfectly portioned for a satisfying midday meal. Given the potential for a wait during peak hours, ordering a lunch special for takeout can be a highly efficient way to enjoy the food quickly.

For those looking for a full meal beyond the lunch hour, the main Meals section is where the kitchen truly shines. The Jerk Chicken Meal and the Oxtail Meal are legendary among regulars. The Jerk Chicken is described by some as nicely cooked, tender, and falling off the bone. The Escovitch Fish Meal is another excellent choice for seafood lovers, though its availability can sometimes vary. Diners should note that the snapper is specified as a Snapper Dinner Meal and is typically Available Only On Wed-Sat, making it a great weekend treat.

Don’t overlook the Soups section, which includes the classic Chicken Soup and the Friday-only Red Bean Soup. Soup is a cornerstone of Caribbean cuisine, and despite occasional inconsistencies noted in some reviews, many long-time patrons consider the soups to be top-tier when prepared correctly. A warm bowl of soup can be the perfect complement to the main course.

Finally, to complete the authentic experience, consider one of the house-made Drinks, particularly the Limeade or the Special Juice, which offer a refreshing, sweet-tart balance to the spicy and savory main courses.

It is important for patrons to set proper expectations when visiting any bustling neighborhood favorite. While the quality and flavor of the food—the true heart of Fisherman's Cove—is widely praised, the busy nature of the establishment, especially during peak hours, means there may occasionally be a wait, or minor service inconsistencies, as noted in some community feedback. However, the loyal customer base, and the overall praise for dishes like the jerk chicken and generous portions, confirm that for a truly authentic, hearty, and flavorful Jamaican meal in Brooklyn, Fisherman's Cove remains a top choice.

Fisherman's Cove

2137 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11210, USA