Four & Twenty Blackbird Commissary Bakery

- 597 Sackett St, Brooklyn, NY 11217

Four & Twenty Blackbirds: The Brooklyn Bakery That Perfected the Pie

## Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers who believe a perfect pie is the pinnacle of dessert, **Four & Twenty Blackbirds** is a name that commands reverence. More than just a local **Bakery**, this Gowanus institution, founded by sisters Melissa and Emily Elsen, has been lauded as one of the best pie shops in the entire United States. Drawing inspiration from their grandmother's pie-making traditions in South Dakota, the sisters have modernized the craft by focusing on handmade, all-butter crusts and inventive, seasonal flavor combinations.

Four & Twenty Blackbirds has transcended the typical neighborhood bakery status, becoming a culinary landmark in Brooklyn. The bakery is renowned for its commitment to high-quality ingredients, often sourcing local fruits from New York's Hudson Valley. Their signature pies—the addictive **Salty Honey®** and the universally loved **Salted Caramel Apple**—have achieved 'cult favorite' status and are often preordered by the hundreds, especially during the holidays.

While the business has a primary retail location, the **Commissary Bakery** operation is integral to their ability to produce these renowned whole pies and other baked goods for the demanding New York market, including supplying major partners like Shake Shack. Whether you’re stopping by for a planned whole pie pickup or seeking a quick treat, Four & Twenty Blackbirds guarantees a pastry experience that is authentic, artisanal, and deeply satisfying.

## Location and Accessibility

The **Four & Twenty Blackbird Commissary Bakery** is strategically located in Brooklyn, though often associated with the neighboring Gowanus retail space. The specific address for the commissary mentioned is: **597 Sackett St, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA**. This area of Brooklyn is known for its blend of industrial history and burgeoning creative and culinary enterprises, making it a fitting home for a high-production, artisanal bakery.

While often serving as the production heart, the bakery is accessible to customers and equipped for convenient service. For local patrons, the essential feature is the **Wheelchair accessible entrance**, ensuring accessibility for everyone. Given the nature of a commissary and dedicated bakery space, it’s designed for a **Quick visit**, making it efficient for New Yorkers on the go who are picking up pre-ordered items or grabbing a treat.

The Gowanus neighborhood is well-connected via public transportation, making the location a manageable trip for those traveling from other parts of Brooklyn or Manhattan. Payments are made easy with the acceptance of major **Credit cards** and **Debit cards**, streamlining the transaction process for a quick and seamless pickup.

## Services Offered

The Four & Twenty Blackbirds operation is centered around artisanal baking, specializing in whole pie production and a variety of other high-quality sweet and savory goods. Services are primarily geared toward product acquisition, ensuring maximum freshness and convenience for the customer:

• **Takeout:** The primary service option, allowing customers to easily pick up whole pies, hand pies, and other baked goods.
• **Whole Pie Orders:** The core offering, with 10-inch pies that typically serve 8-10 people, perfect for parties, holidays, or simply treating the family.
• **Online Ordering and Pickup:** Customers can conveniently place orders via their website for next-day pickup or delivery, though a 48-hour lead time may be required for certain days.
• **Merchandise and Cookbook Sales:** The bakery sells The Four & Twenty Blackbirds Pie Book, offering New Yorkers a chance to recreate their celebrated recipes at home.
• **Custom Cake Orders:** Offering a selection of cakes and cupcakes, including the 8-inch Chocolate Victory Cake and Carrot Cake, with options for both standard and vegan frosting/cake.
• **Vegan Options:** Menu includes vegan alternatives for cakes and a variety of cookies and bars, catering to diverse dietary preferences.

## Features / Highlights

Four & Twenty Blackbirds' reputation in the NYC food scene is built upon a foundation of quality, tradition, and inventive flavor:

• **The Salty Honey® Pie:** A signature, original creation and a "cult favorite," known for its perfect balance of sweet, fragrant honey custard and a light touch of flake sea salt.
• **The Salted Caramel Apple Pie:** Voted one of the best apple pies in New York, featuring a mix of sweet and tart NY apples, house-made caramel, and a sprinkle of flake sea salt.
• **Handmade All-Butter Crusts:** Unlike older, lard-based recipes, the sisters insist on using a hand-rolled, all-butter crust for a richer flavor and perfectly flaky texture, a key differentiator that New Yorkers appreciate.
• **Seasonal and Local Ingredients:** A strong commitment to using local fruits, often sourced from the Hudson Valley, ensuring peak freshness and supporting New York farmers.
• **Innovative Flavor Combinations:** Beyond the classics, the menu features unique creations such as **Matcha Custard Pie**, **Black Bottom Oat Pie** (a brown sugar custard with dark chocolate ganache and toasty oats), and the seasonal **Bourbon Pear Crumble**.
• **Variety of Baked Goods:** In addition to their famous pies, they offer a range of treats, including various cookies (**Chocolate Chip, Congo Cookie**), muffins, scones, and brownies.
• **Acclaimed and Award-Winning:** The bakery has been named “Artisans of the Year” by Time Out New York and has been featured by The New York Times, Food Network, and other major media outlets, solidifying its place as a top NYC bakery.

## Contact Information

For general inquiries, whole pie orders, or to confirm pickup details for the Commissary Bakery, please use the following information (note: the most publicly available contact information for the Four & Twenty Blackbirds operation often directs to their primary Gowanus retail location, which handles most customer communication):

• **Address (Commissary):** 597 Sackett St, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA
• **Phone (Gowanus Retail):** (718) 499-2917 (This is typically the best number for customer service and pre-order management.)

## What is Worth Choosing

For New York locals, choosing Four & Twenty Blackbirds means selecting a product that is not just a dessert, but a piece of Brooklyn’s refined culinary landscape. What makes this bakery an essential choice, even with the slightly premium price point, is the uncompromising dedication to artisanal quality and unique flavor profiles that have earned it the title of "The Absolute Best Pie in New York" by publications like New York Magazine.

The decision to choose this bakery comes down to two signature creations: the **Salty Honey® Pie** and the **Salted Caramel Apple Pie**. The Salty Honey® is a truly original flavor that represents the creative spirit of New York baking—a sweet custard elevated by a simple yet perfect pinch of sea salt, resulting in an unforgettable, complex taste that is their trademark. The Salted Caramel Apple Pie is a masterful take on a classic; the use of high-quality, locally sourced apples and house-made caramel, coupled with their famous flaky, all-butter crust, makes it the standard by which all other apple pies are judged in the city. The fact that the entire pie operation is run by two sisters who have put pie-making on the international map adds a compelling layer of authenticity and dedication.

Furthermore, Four & Twenty Blackbirds is the perfect choice for New Yorkers planning for **holidays** or **group gatherings**. Their pies are renowned for their stability and excellence, often selling out during peak seasons, which speaks to their overwhelming popularity and quality. While one can occasionally find a slice at their retail location, ordering a **Whole Pie** from the commissary is the most reliable way to secure your favorite for a dinner party or family event. The convenience of their online pre-order system and the quick, efficient **Takeout** service from their Brooklyn base makes it a seamless experience, ensuring you bring home a celebrated, handmade treat that will undoubtedly impress any New York dining crowd. Simply put, when you want pie perfection, you choose Four & Twenty Blackbirds.

Four & Twenty Blackbird Commissary Bakery

597 Sackett St, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA