Gotham Pizza

- 1443 York Ave, New York, NY 10075

### Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers, a good pizza place is more than just a restaurant—it's a staple of daily life. Gotham Pizza, a classic establishment on the Upper East Side, has earned its place as a reliable and affordable go-to spot for a slice or an entire pie. As a traditional **pizza restaurant** and **Italian restaurant**, Gotham Pizza specializes in the kind of honest, classic thin-crust cheese pizza that the city is famous for. But their menu extends far beyond the basic slice, offering a variety of pies, from Grandma and Sicilian to specialty options like Buffalo Chicken and White Pizza. This range ensures that whether you’re a purist or looking for something more adventurous, you'll find a pie that fits your taste.

Gotham Pizza is known for its incredible value, particularly its lunch special, which has long been a neighborhood favorite. While prices have adjusted with inflation, the value remains excellent, guaranteeing that you can get a fresh, delicious, and affordable meal. Because of its popularity, especially for the lunch special, the pizza is constantly being made, which means you're almost always guaranteed to get a fresh-from-the-oven slice. This commitment to freshness and value is a major reason for its strong local following. The atmosphere is **casual** and welcoming, making it an ideal place for a **quick bite**, a solo meal, or a laid-back dinner with friends and family.

While the business has received some mixed feedback, with one review mentioning an issue with a specific pie, the overall sentiment points to a solid, reliable pizza joint. The majority of customers are happy with the quality and taste of the classic pizzas, as well as the generous portion sizes and fair pricing. The menu is also great for groups with diverse preferences, offering salads, garlic knots, and various pie sizes. Whether you want a large 16" pie for a gathering or a quick slice for a lunch break, Gotham Pizza can accommodate. It's the kind of place that embodies the spirit of a true neighborhood pizzeria, delivering on comfort food and consistency.

---

### Location and Accessibility

Gotham Pizza is located at 1443 York Ave, New York, NY 10075. This address places it in a prime residential area of the Upper East Side, making it a convenient spot for local residents and those working in the vicinity. York Avenue is a major thoroughfare, and the restaurant's location is easily accessible by public transportation and for those walking through the neighborhood. Its presence as a staple in the area solidifies its role as a key part of the local dining scene. The convenience of its location is a significant factor in its popularity, as it provides a quick and accessible option for a meal at any time.

The restaurant is designed to be accessible to a wide range of customers, featuring a **wheelchair accessible entrance**. This ensures that everyone can easily come in and enjoy their food. Gotham Pizza also offers a variety of service options to cater to a modern, fast-paced lifestyle. In addition to **dine-in** seating, they provide **takeout**, **delivery**, and even **no-contact delivery**. This flexibility makes it easy for customers to get their pizza fix whether they're at home, at the office, or want to enjoy a quick meal at the restaurant itself. The acceptance of **credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments** further streamlines the ordering process, making it a hassle-free experience.

The casual atmosphere and seating options make it a comfortable spot for lunch or dinner. It is also noted as being **good for kids** and provides **high chairs**, making it an excellent choice for a family outing. The overall planning of the establishment seems to be centered on catering to a diverse crowd efficiently and conveniently. From its easily accessible location to its various service and payment options, Gotham Pizza is set up to be a simple, reliable, and convenient choice for anyone in the neighborhood looking for a great slice of pizza.

---

### Services Offered

• Pizza Slices and Pies: Offers a wide variety of pizza, available both as individual slices and as full pies in 12" and 16" sizes. Options include classic regular and pepperoni slices, as well as specialty slices like Grandma, Sicilian, Buffalo Chicken, and White Pizza.

• Dine-in and Takeout: Provides both a casual dining area for customers who want to eat in, as well as quick and easy takeout service for those who prefer to eat at home.

• Delivery Services: Offers both standard and **no-contact delivery**, providing a convenient way to get a hot pizza delivered right to your door.

• Lunch and Dinner: Caters to both lunch and dinner crowds with a menu that includes a popular lunch special and a full range of pies suitable for dinner gatherings.

• Beverages: A selection of bottled water, canned soda, and 2-liter bottles of soda are available to complement your meal.

• Sides: The menu includes classic side options like Garlic Knots and a variety of salads, including Caesar and House Salads, available in both individual and party sizes.

---

### Features / Highlights

• Great Value: The restaurant is known for its excellent value, particularly its popular lunch special, which provides a satisfying and affordable meal. The pricing on slices and pies is also very competitive for the area.

• Classic Thin-Crust Pizza: Customers praise the classic thin-crust cheese pizza, noting that it is a well-made, traditional New York style pizza. The quality and freshness are consistent due to high demand.

• Variety of Pies and Slices: The menu offers a huge selection of pizzas, from traditional pies to specialty options like Sicilian and Grandma pizzas, as well as a variety of slices for a quick and easy choice.

• Late-Night Food: As a casual spot offering comfort food, it is an excellent choice for a late-night bite, catering to the needs of New Yorkers who are out late.

• Family-Friendly: With a casual atmosphere, seating, and high chairs, the restaurant is a great spot for families with kids looking for a no-fuss meal.

• Efficient and Flexible Payment Options: The acceptance of major credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments makes the checkout process fast and convenient for all customers.

---

### Contact Information

• Address: 1443 York Ave, New York, NY 10075

• Phone: (212) 288-8085

---

### What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Gotham Pizza means opting for a classic, reliable, and value-driven New York pizza experience. What makes this restaurant a worthwhile choice is its commitment to the fundamentals of what makes a great slice. The classic thin-crust cheese pizza is consistently praised for being a true New York staple, a testament to their dedication to quality and tradition. The variety of slices and pies, including specialty options like Grandma and Sicilian, means there is always something new to try, while also catering to those who prefer the familiar classics. This versatility makes it a great spot for a quick lunch or a dinner for the whole family.

The value offered by Gotham Pizza is another compelling reason to choose it. The popular lunch special provides an unbeatable deal, and the overall pricing on their menu is highly competitive for the Upper East Side. This affordability, combined with the assurance that your pizza is likely to be freshly made due to high demand, makes for a truly satisfying and cost-effective meal. While a single negative review about a specific order exists, the overwhelming feedback on its value and the quality of its classic pies is a more reliable indicator of its overall reputation. This is a place that understands the local demand for a good, honest slice without any pretension.

Furthermore, the convenience and service options add to the overall appeal. Whether you want to dine in, grab a quick takeout order, or have your pizza delivered, Gotham Pizza provides a seamless experience. The restaurant is also family-friendly, making it a perfect spot for parents with children. The availability of **late-night food** is a significant advantage in a city that never sleeps, providing a reliable source of comfort food at any hour. In summary, Gotham Pizza is worth choosing for its authentic New York-style pizza, great value, reliable service, and its role as a dependable, no-frills neighborhood classic.

Gotham Pizza

1443 York Ave, New York, NY 10075, USA