Holey Cream

- 1460 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10128

Introduction / Overview

Located in the heart of the Upper East Side, Holey Cream is a vibrant ice cream shop that has carved out a distinct and celebrated niche in New York City’s bustling dessert scene. Situated at 1460 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10128, this local favorite is best known as the home of the Famous Original Holey Cream Donut Ice Cream Sandwich, a genius creation they have been proudly serving since 2009. Holey Cream is not just a place to grab a scoop; it is a destination for the imaginative, over-the-top indulgence that epitomizes the best of NYC street food culture in a casual, family-friendly environment.

The concept is simple: take a freshly made, warm gourmet donut, slice it in half, fill it with a generous scoop of ice cream, and finish it with an array of delectable toppings and glazes. This customizable masterpiece has become an iconic New York treat. Beyond their signature item, Holey Cream offers a comprehensive menu catering to every kind of sweet tooth. From classic Sundaes like the Famous Hot Fudge Sundae and Nutella Extravaganza Sundae to simple scoops, Milkshakes, and a variety of Brownies and Cookies, the selection ensures there is something for everyone.

Importantly, Holey Cream is mindful of diverse dietary needs, offering a dedicated selection of VEGAN ICE CREAM flavors such as Vegan Vanilla Bean and Vegan Cherry Chunk, as well as certified GLUTEN FREE BAKED GOODS. This commitment to inclusivity, combined with a fun atmosphere and the novelty of their flagship dessert, makes Holey Cream a must-visit spot for a Quick visit or a fun family outing on the Upper East Side.

Location and Accessibility

Holey Cream is strategically positioned on Lexington Avenue in the Upper East Side, offering high visibility and easy access for local residents and passersby. The address, 1460 Lexington Ave, places the shop in the busy, family-oriented neighborhood near the 96th Street area.

Accessibility via New York's transit system is excellent. The shop is a short walk from the 86th Street subway station, a major hub for the 4, 5, and 6 express and local lines, and is also convenient to the 96th Street station for the 6 line. Multiple bus lines run along Lexington Avenue, providing extensive connectivity. For customers traveling by car, there is Paid street parking available in the vicinity. Moreover, Holey Cream prioritizes physical accessibility, featuring a Wheelchair accessible entrance, ensuring that the entire community can easily enjoy their treats. This convenient and accessible location makes it a perfect spontaneous stop for Solo dining or for families looking for an after-school or weekend dessert.

Services Offered

Holey Cream operates as a highly specialized dessert shop focused on providing immediate, high-quality, and creative sweet treats:

• Onsite Services: The shop offers a welcoming Casual atmosphere for customers to enjoy their treats immediately after creation.
• Takeout Service: All menu items, including custom donut sandwiches, scoops, and baked goods, are available for Takeout.
• Custom Donut Orders: Offers fresh, customizable donuts for individual sale (1 Donut) or in bulk packages (4 Donuts, 8 Donuts, 12 Donuts) perfect for parties or office treats.
• Ice Cream Sales: Sells ice cream and sorbet in various sizes from SMALL ($7.50) to QUART ($22.50) for consumption at home.
• Specialty Drinks: Provides classic parlor drinks including MILKSHAKE, MALTED SHAKE, and FLOATS like the Root Beer Float, alongside Coffee and various sodas and water.
• Dietary Alternatives: Maintains a dedicated menu of VEGAN ICE CREAM and GLUTEN FREE BAKED GOODS (Gluten Free Brookie, Gluten Free Chocolate Chip Cookies) to accommodate customers with specific needs.
• Seasonal Items: Features revolving options like the DUBAI CHOCOLATE DONUTS and WEEKLY SPECIALS to keep the menu exciting and fresh for regulars.

Features / Highlights

Holey Cream’s appeal is driven by its innovative and indulgent dessert offerings, making it a unique stop in the city:

• The Original Donut Ice Cream Sandwich: Their signature item, the Famous Original Holey Cream Donut Ice Cream Sandwich (Since 2009), is the primary highlight, offering a highly customizable, warm donut filled with any flavor of ice cream and choice of toppings.
• Gourmet Donut Selection: Features a wide array of freshly made HOLEY CREAM DONUTS with various glazes and toppings, ensuring the donut component of their famous sandwich is always fresh and delicious.
• Diverse Sundae Menu: Beyond the donut sandwich, the shop excels at over-the-top, classic sundaes, including the rich Brownie Explosion Sundae and the holiday-favorite Smores Sundae.
• Vegan and Gluten-Free Focus: A crucial highlight is the dedicated inclusion of several Vegan Ice Cream flavors and a selection of high-quality Gluten Free Baked Goods, demonstrating a commitment to being Good for kids and inclusive for various dietary restrictions.
• Perfect Quick Visit Spot: The whole atmosphere and menu are tailored for a fun, Casual, and speedy stop, whether for a midday treat or a post-dinner indulgence, facilitating a Quick visit.
• Sweetness and Variety: The sheer variety of classic and unique options, from rich ice cream and sorbet to chewy brownies and cookies, ensures that every visit allows for a new, exciting creation.

Contact Information

To learn more about Holey Cream's offerings, check on weekly specials, or place a takeout order, please use the following details:

• Address: 1460 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10128
• Phone: (212) 470-1020

What is worth choosing

Holey Cream is unequivocally worth choosing for any New Yorker looking for a dessert that is not merely a treat, but an unforgettable, customizable experience. In a city of countless dessert spots, Holey Cream stands out because of its commitment to one revolutionary idea and its dedication to an inclusive menu.

The primary reason to visit is to experience the Famous Original Holey Cream Donut Ice Cream Sandwich. This concept combines two beloved comfort foods into one perfect, highly personalizable dessert. The warmth of the freshly made donut perfectly contrasts with the cold, smooth scoop of ice cream, creating a textural and temperature sensation that you cannot find at a traditional ice cream shop.

Furthermore, the shop’s menu provides essential options for modern urban living. The robust inclusion of three different Vegan Ice Cream flavors (Vegan Vanilla Bean, Vegan Cherry Chunk, Vegan Mint Chip) and a selection of high-quality Gluten Free Baked Goods means that groups and families with mixed dietary needs can all enjoy an indulgent experience together. For a truly fun, unique, and sweetly satisfying New York dessert experience on the Upper East Side—one that caters to all—Holey Cream is the standout destination.

Holey Cream

1460 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10128, USA