La Casa del Molcajete

- 635 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10304

For New Yorkers seeking a genuine taste of Mexico right here in the city, La Casa del Molcajete stands out as a premier destination on Staten Island. Located in the vibrant Stapleton neighborhood, this Mexican restaurant delivers a culinary experience rooted in authentic flavors and a lively, welcoming atmosphere. The name itself, referencing the traditional volcanic stone mortar used to grind spices and prepare salsas, signals the restaurant's dedication to foundational, rich Mexican cookery. The atmosphere is best described as a perfect blend of Casual and Cozy, creating a comfortable yet exciting setting for any meal, whether it’s a quick solo lunch or a group dinner celebration.

La Casa del Molcajete's menu is an expansive and impressive showcase of both land and sea specialties, moving far beyond typical Mexican fare. While classics like Tacos ($12.60) and Green Enchiladas ($18.90) are expertly prepared, the restaurant truly distinguishes itself with its signature dishes and generous portions. The variety of offerings ensures that every craving is met, from rich comfort food to fresh seafood preparations.

The true heart of the menu is the specialty "Molcajete" offerings, a traditional presentation that serves as a communal feast of grilled meats, seafood, and vegetables, all simmering in a hot, flavorful sauce within the stone bowl. The restaurant features the indulgent Seafood Molcajete ($36.75), a flavor-packed experience for seafood lovers, and the hearty Molcajete Ranchero ($31.50). For those who want the best of both worlds, the signature Surf N Turf Molcajete ($29.40) is an absolute must-try. Reviewers frequently highlight the high quality of the food, noting the amazing flavors of dishes like the Shrimp Molcajete and the excellent NY Strip Steak meal, served in truly generous portions.

Beyond the signature dishes, the menu offers numerous other highlights. Meat-eaters can enjoy the authentic Pollo A La Mexicana / Mexican Style Chicken ($23.10) or the tender Fajitas De Bistec / Steak Fajitas ($23.10), with the option to upgrade to the Steak And Shrimp Fajita ($27.30). Seafood is also celebrated in dishes like Camarones Al Ajillo / Al Ajillo Shrimp ($25.20), the rich Jarocho Salmon ($29.40), and the extensive Seafood Broth ($29.40) and 7 Seas Pasta ($31.50). Starters are satisfying, featuring the crisp House Fried Calamari ($18.90) and classic Nachos Rancheros ($18.90). The dedication to authentic Mexican cuisine is clearly felt, even in the staff’s attentive service and the quality of the ingredients used.

Location and Accessibility

La Casa del Molcajete is centrally located at 635 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10304. Situated conveniently in a bustling area, the restaurant is easily reachable for local residents and visitors traversing the borough.

While specific details about accessible features like ramps are not explicitly stated, the business operates as a full-service dining establishment committed to serving the New York community. Customers with specific accessibility needs are encouraged to call ahead to ensure their visit is as comfortable as possible, particularly as the restaurant is known for Table service and is popular with large Groups and Family-friendly crowds, suggesting an accommodating layout.

Services Offered

The service structure at La Casa del Molcajete is comprehensive, focusing on flexibility, speed, and a full-service experience.

• Dining and To-Go Options: Customers can enjoy a relaxing meal with Dine-in table service or utilize the convenient Takeout option.
• Bar and Beverage Menu: The restaurant features a full Bar onsite, offering an extensive selection that includes Alcohol, Beer, specialty Cocktails, Hard liquor, and Wine. Coffee is also available for a post-meal digestif.
• All-Day and Late-Night Availability: The restaurant serves Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert. Operating hours are generous, running late into the evening (generally until 12:00 am most days), making it an excellent late-night dining option. Note that the restaurant is typically Closed on Thursdays.
• Planning and Payment: La Casa del Molcajete Accepts reservations, which is highly recommended for weekend evenings when the Live music is featured. Debit cards are accepted for payment convenience.

Features and Highlights

La Casa del Molcajete is defined by several key features that enhance the dining experience, making it more than just a place to eat.

• Lively Weekend Entertainment: A major draw is the exceptional Live music program. Furthermore, the restaurant hosts exciting karaoke nights on weekends, creating a festive and social atmosphere. The presence of excellent security staff on the weekends ensures a safe and comfortable environment for all patrons enjoying the late-night fun.
• Outstanding Service and Attentiveness: Customers consistently praise the Great service and mention that the staff is very attentive and helpful to the customers, contributing to a positive experience. The commitment to Fast service also makes it efficient for lunch or a quick dinner.
• Authentic Seafood Focus: Beyond the standard Mexican fare, the restaurant's strong emphasis on fresh seafood dishes, such as the various Plato Del Mar / Sea Dish ($27.30) options, the signature Molcajetes, and the Seafood Asado ($29.40), highlights a specialized, authentic regional approach.
• Versatile Dining for All: The venue is Popular for various needs, including a fun night out with Groups, a satisfying meal with the Family-friendly crowd, or a comfortable option for Solo dining.

Contact Information

To make a reservation, inquire about group dining, or check the schedule for Live music and karaoke nights, please use the following contact details:

• Address: 635 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10304
• Phone: (646) 833-5170

What is Worth Choosing: The Molcajete Experience and Community Vibe

Choosing La Casa del Molcajete offers New Yorkers an escape to an authentic, energetic, and flavor-forward Mexican dining experience. It is worth selecting this restaurant for several compelling reasons. Firstly, the dedicated focus on the eponymous Molcajete—served hot and bubbling with a combination of grilled meats and seafood—is a culinary spectacle and a delicious representation of traditional Mexican hospitality that is hard to find elsewhere in the city. The comprehensive menu, with its array of authentic dishes like Pozole ($21.00), Pancita / Belly ($23.10), and the variety of Fajitas, offers depth and quality that appeal to every palate.

Secondly, the restaurant provides a superior social experience. The combination of a Cozy dining space with the major highlight of Live music and karaoke nights on weekends transforms a standard meal into a fun, memorable outing. The staff’s attentive service and the welcoming atmosphere for Groups and families are consistently praised, ensuring guests feel well-cared for. Lastly, the robust bar program, offering everything from Cocktails to Hard liquor alongside an extensive Wine and Beer list, makes it a perfect late-night spot for celebrating or unwinding after a long day in New York. For authentic food, fast and friendly service, and a lively community vibe, La Casa del Molcajete is Staten Island's premier choice for Mexican cuisine.

La Casa del Molcajete

635 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10304, USA