Lenny's Bagels

- 4662 Boston Post Rd, Pelham, NY 10803

Lenny's Bagels has firmly established itself as a cornerstone of the Westchester County breakfast and lunch scene, offering a true taste of New York's quintessential bagel culture right in Pelham. More than just a simple bagel shop, this location operates as a full-service cafe and deli, serving up an expansive menu that extends well beyond the classic bagel with a schmear. For locals and commuters alike, Lenny's is the reliable spot for high-quality, generously portioned meals served in a fast and friendly environment.

This establishment has garnered a strong reputation, particularly among local New Yorkers, for its commitment to classic, delicious food. Whether you are craving a traditional breakfast or a hearty lunch sandwich, Lenny's Bagels provides a bustling, clean, and efficient setting where the focus remains squarely on the quality of the food. It's a key local gem for those who appreciate the genuine New York bagel experience without having to venture into Manhattan.

Location and Accessibility: The Pelham Hub

Strategically situated at 4662 Boston Post Rd, Pelham, NY 10803, USA, Lenny's Bagels is positioned to serve the busy Pelham community and those traveling through the area. The location on the Boston Post Road makes it highly accessible for quick stops, grab-and-go orders, and daily commutes. For patrons arriving by car, the shop provides key accessibility features, including a wheelchair-accessible entrance and a convenient free parking lot. Free street parking is also available, making a quick visit straightforward and hassle-free, a major benefit in the often-congested New York area.

While the atmosphere is geared toward efficiency and quick service—reflecting the true local New York style—the store ensures everyone can access its delicious offerings. The focus on takeout, delivery, and in-store pickup caters perfectly to the pace of life in Westchester, ensuring that a quality breakfast or lunch is always within reach. The quick visit dining option underscores their commitment to fast, reliable service for people on the move.

Services Offered

Lenny's Bagels offers a comprehensive range of food and convenience services, positioning it as an all-day dining option, primarily focused on breakfast and lunch.

• In-House Dining: Limited seating is available for a quick dine-in experience, although the shop is largely optimized for quick, efficient service.

• Full-Service Bagel Shop: Offering individual bagels ($2.99), half dozens, or a full Bag of 12 Bagels ($27.99), along with a variety of spreads including Plain, Vegetable, Scallion, Strawberry, Olives, Walnut Raisin, and Lox Cream Cheese. Vegan-friendly options are also available with Plain, Scallion, and Vegetable Tofutti Cream Cheese.

• Breakfast Service: An expansive morning menu featuring their famous Create Your Own Egg Sandwich ($6.99), Specialty Breakfast Specials like the Chorizo, Cheddar & Hash Brown Burrito ($12.99), and a range of three-egg Omelettes, such as the Feta, Spinach, & Tomato Omelette ($13.99).

• Gourmet Coffee and Beverages: A selection of Hot Coffee, Hot Tea, Hot Chocolate, Iced Coffee, Iced Tea, and a dedicated Espresso Bar serving Cafe Latte and Cappuccino. For a stronger kick, they offer Cold Brew On Tap and Nitro Brew On Tap ($6.99). They also stock a variety of soft drinks, juices, and specialty waters.

• Lunch and Deli Services: Serving an extensive line of specialty sandwiches, classic deli sandwiches using Boar's Head cold cuts, Paninis, and customizable Philly Cheese Steaks.

• Salads and Sides: A fresh Salad Bar ($12.99), various homemade salads by the pound (Macaroni Salad, Tuna Salad, Whitefish Salad), and a selection of sides including French Fries ($4.99), Onion Rings ($4.99), and Chicken Tenders ($10.99).

• Takeout, Delivery, and Pickup: Convenient service options including delivery, in-store pickup, and takeout, perfect for busy schedules.

• Catering: They offer platter options such as Bagels | Dozen On Platter ($34.99) and Assorted Pastry Platters, ideal for office meetings or family gatherings.

• Desserts: Classic treats like Black & White Cookie ($4.99) and Tate's Chocolate Chip Cookies ($8.99).

Features and Highlights

Lenny's Bagels stands out in the competitive New York food landscape due to several key features that appeal directly to local tastes and demands.

• Authentic New York Bagels: The foundation of their business is the exceptional quality of their bagels—widely praised by customers for being top-notch, with the perfect chewy texture that New Yorkers expect. They also offer speciality options like Flats Bagel ($2.99) and Assorted Gluten-Free Bagel ($3.99).

• Famous Specialty Sandwiches: The menu features local-area tributes such as The Pelham Sandwich (Grilled or breaded chicken, fresh mozzarella, tomato, and basil) and The Westchester Sandwich (Chicken cutlet, bacon, melted cheddar, and BBQ sauce), both priced at $13.99, along with The Reuben ($16.99) and The Brooklyn Sandwich (Sliced Nova, cream cheese, tomato, and onion) at $16.99.

• Premium Lox and Smoked Salmon: The quality of the Nova Scotia smoked salmon is a significant draw, often cited in customer feedback as a major highlight, perfectly paired with their house-made lox cream cheese. The Sliced Nova & Cream Cheese Sandwich is available for $15.99.

• Diverse and Hearty Breakfast Bowls: For those seeking a substantial morning meal, the All Day Menu includes eight unique Breakfast Bowls ($13.99 each), such as the Flatline (Double bacon, mozzarella, potatoes, and onions) and the Nice-n-Spicy (Chorizo, pepper jack, jalapeños, bacon, and hot sauce).

• Commitment to Cleanliness and Service: Customer feedback frequently highlights the "spotless cleanliness" of the store and the "fast service" provided by the friendly staff, indicating a highly professional and well-managed operation focused on quick turnaround.

• All-Day Options: They are more than just a breakfast spot, with a robust lunch menu including Paninis, seven varieties of Philly Cheese Steaks ($15.99 each), and classic Boar's Head deli sandwiches, ensuring quality food is available throughout the day.

• Vegan/Dairy-Free Alternatives: The inclusion of Tofutti Cream Cheese options (Plain, Vegetable, Scallion) ensures that customers with dietary restrictions can still enjoy a classic bagel experience.

Contact Information

For all inquiries, orders, and information, Lenny's Bagels in Pelham can be reached at the following contact points:

Address: 4662 Boston Post Rd, Pelham, NY 10803, USA

Phone: (914) 355-5445

What is Worth Choosing: Menu Highlights for New Yorkers

For a true taste of New York, several items on the Lenny's Bagels menu stand out and are highly recommended.

The core offering, the Bagel with Lox and Cream Cheese (or the pre-made Sliced Nova & Cream Cheese Sandwich for $15.99), is a non-negotiable choice for first-time visitors or lox aficionados. The combination of their exceptional, fresh-baked bagel, the quality Nova Scotia salmon, and their house-made lox cream cheese represents the peak of the classic bagel experience.

For a power breakfast that captures the local love for hearty morning fare, the Breakfast Bowls are a must-try. Specifically, the Flatline Breakfast Bowl ($13.99) with double bacon, mozzarella, potatoes, and onions, or the spicy kick of the Nice-n-Spicy Breakfast Bowl ($13.99), are customer favorites that guarantee a filling start to the day.

When it comes to sandwiches, locals often lean into the creatively named Specialty Sandwiches. The Brooklyn Sandwich ($16.99), which is the Nova and cream cheese on a bagel with tomato and onion, perfectly encapsulates the classic deli experience. For a hot, savory lunch, the Chicken Cutlet and Muenster Panini ($13.99) or any of the Philly Cheese Steaks ($15.99) offer a comforting and generously portioned meal that showcases the deli's full range.

Finally, the customizability of the Create Your Own Egg Sandwich ($6.99 base price) allows every customer to build their perfect New York breakfast on a freshly baked bagel, a simple yet essential local ritual that Lenny's Bagels executes flawlessly. This blend of classic items and inventive, high-quality deli fare makes Lenny's Bagels a continuously popular and highly recommended local business in the Pelham area.

Lenny's Bagels

4662 Boston Post Rd, Pelham, NY 10803, USA