Little Sugar Shop

- 157 Rockaway Ave, Valley Stream, NY 11580

Introduction / Overview

For residents of Long Island and the broader New York area, finding a truly exceptional bakery can turn any special occasion—or even a simple Tuesday afternoon—into a moment of pure delight.

The Little Sugar Shop

More than just a place to buy sweets, The Little Sugar Shop is a creative hub where fresh, high-quality ingredients meet artistic vision. Their reputation is built on a commitment to flavor and detail, ensuring that every cake, cupcake, or cookie is a masterpiece. Whether you're seeking a simple, decadent slice to satisfy a spontaneous craving, or a multi-tiered custom cake designed specifically for a milestone celebration, The Little Sugar Shop promises a product that is not only visually stunning but also "amazingly delicious," as one satisfied customer enthusiastically noted. They pride themselves on using only the finest and freshest ingredients, baking their delicacies in small batches every day, which truly elevates the quality and taste of their offerings. Their unique specialization in Dominican cakes brings an authentic and moist texture that New Yorkers seeking an exquisite treat will absolutely cherish.

Location and Accessibility

The Little Sugar Shop is conveniently situated in a central Long Island location, making it easily reachable for New York patrons across Nassau County and beyond. You can find this delightful bakery at

157 Rockaway Ave, Valley Stream, NY 11580, USA

The bakery operates six days a week, keeping hours that are convenient for both morning rush and afternoon treats, though New Yorkers should note the seasonal adjustments. The hours are as follows:

Tuesday - Friday: 11:00 AM - 6:00 PM

Saturday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM

Sunday: 10:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Monday: Closed

Note for summer: The shop is closed on Sundays during July and August, and also observes closures for major holidays like Christmas Day and New Year’s Day.

Services Offered

The Little Sugar Shop offers a comprehensive suite of services centered around baked goods, catering to both everyday desires and grand celebrations:

• In-Store Sales: Offering freshly baked cupcakes, brownies, cookies, and a variety of 8-inch classic cakes for immediate purchase in their display cases.
• Custom Cake Orders: Specializing in bespoke cakes for all occasions, including weddings, birthdays (Adult, Kids, Number/Letter Cakes), baby showers, graduations, and religious events. They require full payment upon order placement.
• Signature & Classic Cakes: Available in popular flavors like Chocolate Hazelnut, Coconut with mango & pineapple, Red Velvet, and their specialty Dominican cakes.
• Gourmet Cupcakes: A daily rotating selection of flavored cupcakes, such as Coconut with custard, Strawberry, and Cinnamon Apple.
• Holiday & Seasonal Treats: Offering themed desserts for major holidays, including Halloween, Thanksgiving (like Thanksgiving Vintage Heart and Decorated Bundt Cakes), Christmas, and Easter.
• Online Ordering and Pickup: Customers can browse and order classic cakes and other items directly through their online store, with an option to select a preferred pickup date.
• Delivery: Delivery is available via third-party services, with the cost based on distance and tolls, providing convenience for events across Long Island.
• Consultation for Custom Orders: Working closely with clients to create unique designs for specialty cakes, often requiring 2–3 weeks' notice for complex custom creations.

Features / Highlights

What makes The Little Sugar Shop a must-visit bakery for New Yorkers? It’s a combination of heritage, artistry, and customer-focused practices:

• Specialization in Dominican Cakes: This is a major highlight, setting them apart from many local bakeries. Dominican cake is celebrated for its moist texture and rich, unique flavor, an offering customers consistently seek out.
• Highly-Praised Signature Flavors: Customer reviews often call out the Red Velvet cake and Tres Leches cake as "absolutely heavenly," indicating excellence in traditional and Latin-inspired desserts.
• Commitment to Custom Detail: They excel at creating highly detailed, photo-perfect custom cakes for birthdays and other events. One testimonial specifically praised how "all attention to detail was incorporated" from a submitted photo to the final product.
• Fresh, Small-Batch Baking: Their commitment to using the "finest and freshest ingredients" and baking daily in small batches guarantees superior quality and taste in all their cookies, brownies, and cupcakes.
• Wide Range of Cake Styles: From simple, elegant Classic Cakes and Standard Birthday Cakes to elaborate Drip Cakes, Heart Cakes, and beautiful Tiered Wedding Cakes, they cover virtually every celebratory need.
• Family-Owned Warmth: Since 2011, the family-owned nature of the business translates into personalized customer service and a dedication to the local community.
• Proactive Ordering Process: They recommend ordering at least 48 hours in advance for classic cakes, and 2-3 weeks for custom designs, ensuring every order is planned and executed to perfection.

Contact Information

To secure your next custom cake or inquire about their daily selection, please use the following contact details:

Address: 157 Rockaway Ave, Valley Stream, NY 11580, USA

Phone: (516) 612-2697

Email (Custom Orders): cakes@littlesugarshop.com

What is Worth Choosing

For New York customers, particularly those on Long Island, choosing The Little Sugar Shop means opting for a guaranteed blend of spectacular flavor and stunning artistry. It is worth choosing this bakery for several key reasons that elevate it beyond the standard fare.

Firstly, their mastery of specialty flavors is undeniable. Their Red Velvet cake and the incredibly moist, flavorful Tres Leches are frequently described as must-try items. But perhaps the single most compelling reason to choose The Little Sugar Shop is their expertise in bespoke cake design, especially their Dominican cakes. When an occasion calls for a showstopper—whether it’s a detailed birthday cake for a child or a sophisticated wedding cake—you want a baker you can trust to deliver on a vision. Testimonials confirm that The Little Sugar Shop takes the creative brief seriously, incorporating every detail to produce an "impressive" and "delicious" final product. This reliability in custom work is invaluable for event planning in the New York metropolitan area.

Furthermore, the convenience of modern service options, including online ordering, reliable delivery, and clear notice requirements, takes the stress out of securing high-end desserts. Whether you are looking for a quick, freshly baked treat from their daily small-batch production, or you are planning a grand event and need a cake that will impress every guest, The Little Sugar Shop in Valley Stream is the professional, trusted choice that promises quality, creativity, and a little slice of heaven.

Little Sugar Shop

157 Rockaway Ave, Valley Stream, NY 11580, USA