Lorenzo's Pizza of New York

- 1910 Hylan Blvd Suite B, Staten Island, NY 10305

When New Yorkers talk about great pizza, the conversation inevitably turns to local favorites that embody quality, tradition, and an authentic taste of the city. On Staten Island, Lorenzo's Pizza of New York at 1910 Hylan Blvd has firmly established itself as a must-visit destination for those craving genuine New York-style pies and classic Italian-American comfort food. Far more than just a slice shop, Lorenzo's is a full-service pizzeria and takeout restaurant that has earned a reputation among locals for its commitment to making everything in-house, ensuring a fresh and delicious meal every time.

This family-owned and operated establishment excels by offering a remarkably diverse and inventive menu built around the classic pizza foundation. Customers can choose from traditional options like the 16" Round Pie and the Sicilian Pie, but the real excitement lies in their Lorenzo's Specialty Pies. These creative pizzas include the highly-praised Vodka Sauce pie, the savory Chicken Parm pizza, and the unique Philly Cheese Steak pie, showcasing their willingness to push the boundaries while maintaining high-quality ingredients.

Beyond the pies, Lorenzo's is celebrated for its huge variety of Rolls and Fried Calzones, which serve as the perfect quick bite or substantial lunch. Rolls like the Grilled Chicken & Broccoli Rabe or the classic Meatball Parm are popular choices, alongside heroes, appetizers like Buffalo Wings and Garlic Knots, and full pasta dinners. What often resonates most with New York customers, however, is the genuine, high level of customer service. One local review highlights a moment of "kindness, compassion, and dedication to quality" where staff made a customer a fresh pie late near closing, insisting on charging only for two slices—a testament to the community-focused ethos that defines this Staten Island gem. This commitment to both excellent food and "genuine kindness" is what transforms a simple pizza place into a truly valuable local business.

Location and Accessibility for the New York Local

Lorenzo's Pizza of New York is located at 1910 Hylan Blvd Suite B, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA, placing it squarely in the Dongan Hills neighborhood on the East Shore of Staten Island. Hylan Boulevard is one of the borough's most significant and heavily traveled thoroughfares, making the location easily identifiable and accessible by car.

For New York residents who travel by vehicle, particularly for large orders or family meals, the accessibility is excellent. The restaurant provides both a Free parking lot and Free street parking, eliminating the common city hassle of finding a spot. This makes it a practical choice for both quick pickups and longer dine-in experiences. Furthermore, the establishment features a Wheelchair accessible entrance, ensuring that it is welcoming and available to all members of the community. While detailed bus routes are not provided, Hylan Boulevard is a central bus corridor, connecting this location via public transit to many parts of Staten Island, including the ferry. Offering options for Dine-in, Takeout, and Delivery, Lorenzo's ensures their amazing pizza is available regardless of a customer's preferred mode of access.

Services Offered

• Dine-in Service: Casual seating available for enjoying lunch or dinner.
• Takeout Service: Quick and efficient order pickup for food on the go.
• Delivery Service: Convenient home delivery to the surrounding Staten Island area.
• Catering: Dedicated Party Box options and trays for large events, parties, and family gatherings.
• Lunch and Dinner Options: Full menu available for both mid-day and evening dining.
• Family-Friendly Atmosphere: Good for kids with the availability of High chairs.
• Full Accessibility: Includes a Wheelchair accessible entrance.
• Flexible Payment: Accepts Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Features / Highlights

• Authentic New York-Style Pizza: Serves traditional Round Pie and Sicilian Pie varieties, living up to its "of New York" name.
• Famous Specialty Pies: Known for its innovative and highly-rated specialty pizzas, including the Vodka Sauce pie, Calamari pie, and Buffalo Chicken pie.
• Extensive Roll and Calzone Selection: Offers nearly a dozen different varieties of savory Rolls (e.g., Chicken Parm, Philly Cheese Steak) and Fried Calzones.
• Genuine Customer Care: Praised by customers for "genuine kindness" and a dedication to making fresh food, even near closing time.
• Dedicated Catering Options: Provides pre-set Party Box options for easy party planning.
• Comprehensive Comfort Food Menu: Beyond pizza, the menu includes Heros, Pasta dishes (like Ravioli), Appetizers, and Salads (including Caesar Salad With Shrimp).
• Convenient Parking: Offers both a Free parking lot and Free street parking, making the location highly convenient for Staten Island drivers.

Contact Information

Address: 1910 Hylan Blvd Suite B, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA

Phone: (718) 979-4700

Mobile Phone: +1 718-979-4700

What is Worth Choosing Lorenzo's Pizza of New York

For Staten Island residents, choosing Lorenzo's Pizza of New York is choosing a business that delivers on its promise of quality and community commitment. The primary reason to frequent this establishment is the combination of authentic, high-quality New York-style pizza and a menu depth that offers much more than a typical slice shop. The specialty pies, particularly the Vodka Sauce Pizza and the diverse range of Rolls and Heros (like the Sausage & Broccoli Rabe Roll), provide compelling reasons for repeat visits and satisfy virtually any craving for Italian-American comfort food.

While, as with any high-volume New York pizzeria, a customer may occasionally encounter an off-experience (as noted by a review regarding the garlic knots or the "Upside Down" pie), the overwhelming local consensus and specific testimonials emphasize that the management’s dedication to quality, freshness, and outstanding customer service is what truly sets them apart. When a business makes a fresh pie after closing and charges only for slices, it demonstrates a rare and genuine care for its New York patrons. This family-friendly, community-focused approach, combined with highly convenient access via free parking on Hylan Blvd and full Catering options, cements Lorenzo's Pizza of New York as a must-support, reliable, and delicious local pizzeria on Staten Island.

Lorenzo's Pizza of New York

1910 Hylan Blvd Suite B, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA